The certainty of God's existence.

I will check it out, thanks for the heads up. I have often wondered why there wasn't a lot of atheist aid groups. If I were an wealthy atheist I would found one.
; {>

That's a good question. For starters, there aren't a lot of atheists, and we've been pretty isolated until recently, I went my first forty years knowingly meeting only three atheists. Thanks to Meetup groups I now know about a hundred. We haven't formed a charity, but we raise money for the local food bank now and then. Anyway, the point is, it really hasn't been practical for atheists to organize to do much of anything except try to protect our rights until recently. There are about forty times as many Christians as atheists in America, why would you not expect atheist aid groups to be a tiny percentage of Christian aid groups?

For seconders, wealthy atheists have an excellent record for starting charities, they just don't use them to evangelize atheism. I have reservations myself about starting a charity with atheism in the name. Sure, I'm an outspoken atheist, but if my cause is to, say, assist in resettling refugees from Third World countries in America, I would be short-changing the refugees if I took the opportunity to say 'look how charitable atheists are!' by naming it 'Atheists for Smooth Resettlement of Refugees'. As you've pointed out, atheists aren't much-liked, this name is likely to reduce donations-especially from Christians and Muslims. Some of the people at Harvest Hope food bank know that Godless Columbia is one of their donors, that will have to be it for our advertising of atheist charity for now. Possibly a charity to benefit victims of religous violence could have atheist in the title without undermining the cause too much, but even then I'm not sure I'm comfortable with a title that would contribute to interested religous people feeling excluded. It's a good cause, and most religous folk I know don't condone any religously-motivated violence, so it isn't that atheistic.

I've meandered, was this any help at all?
 
Kurt Godel was the greatest mind secondly only to Einstein in my book. He and Einstein were walking buddies at Princeton and he helped Einstein flesh out his theories of GR. He formulated the his famous incompleteness theorem, and which rocked the world of mathematics.

BTW Godel ontological argument is modal in nature,

You are correct of course. But I did not have his in mind, instead I was more thinking along the lines of a very bare modal ontological arguments that is exclusively geared towards necessary being and leaves aside and additionals, like omnipotence or Godel's positive attributes.

And some such is the best you can do, IMO, if and only if you use it merely as a definitional basis.



but its weak compared to the cosmological argument that modern philosophers like Craig and Koon present.

If I say that a bare OA is the best you can do this implies of course that I think less of these cosmological arguments. To my mind they are borderline idiotic syllogisms.

However ... the discussions over their validity and soundness handily serve you the illusion that you are really discussing anything of substance, that there really is some sort of question. You get page over page of talk about causation, events, the big bang, and maybe other scientific things and the word "God" is somewhere amonst the fray as well.

It makes for gorgeous red herrings, no?
 
Soundness is a property of an argument, RevD, not of a premise. A premise is a statement of fact. Your premises are false.

Are you sure that soundness does not apply to premises? I see it constantly used like that, and have used soundness as applicable to premises as well, even in this thread.
 
My knowledge breaks down at this point, but from what I do know, you're right. If only there were an astrophysicist in the house. ;)


It is even weirder than that. Hawking has conceded that information can leak past the event horizon, although Kip Thorne has not.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thorne-Hawking-Preskill_bet

For a better idea of what "goes on" inside a black hole, I would refer you to this book, although it is getting a bit outdated.

http://www.amazon.com/Black-Holes-T...=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1250532595&sr=1-1

I'll tackle a longer reply to RevDisturba after I have had my tea.
 
It is even weirder than that. Hawking has conceded that information can leak past the event horizon, although Kip Thorne has not.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thorne-Hawking-Preskill_bet

For a better idea of what "goes on" inside a black hole, I would refer you to this book, although it is getting a bit outdated.

http://www.amazon.com/Black-Holes-T...=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1250532595&sr=1-1

I'll tackle a longer reply to RevDisturba after I have had my tea.
Who won the bet?

PS - This is a rhetorical question.
 
All due respect for not holding on to the deathbed story, you probably weren't very attached to it, but even so, a lot of people value 'face' over integrity and refuse to admit when they're wrong even when they are convinced of it themselves. Duly noted that you're not that kind of person.

Also, knowing you're not a 'flaming hell' Christian does somewhat mitigate your comment about seeing an atheist punished; however it is still a very horrible thing to say and I am mystified as to why a decent man would refuse to apologize for it. You might be surprised at how easily most of us would forgive you.

First we have made our amends so I don't know what you are talking about. If I just out of the blue insulted someone I would apologize. However, if over the hundreds of posts where in more than a few that I had been taunted, insulted, and needled with off color comments and veiled derogatory suggestive comments, not to mention the same treatment being applied to my God and religion and the same treatment applied to my friends by a few other than said member (Randy who I already have made amends), in not just one but more than one two or three posts, (or ten twenty or thirty posts) maybe Its I that is due the apology(s). One of many. Not a on your knees groveling post, just a sorry if I have offend you or your religion or your friends. So yes that would be nice, yes it would !

But thanks for your kind comments.

Some of the above tongue in cheek but not too much!

; {>
 
Last edited:
First we have made our amends so I don't know what you are talking about. If I just out of the blue insulted someone I would apologize however if I had been taunted insulted, and my God and religion had been insulted and belittled and such maybe Its I that is due the apology. One of many.

But thanks for your kind comments.

; {>

Having your beliefs challenged is not against the MA. Finding them indefensible does not mean it was a personal attack.
 
You don’t have to walk on eggshells around me Mr Hokulele.The only thing that torques my crank (biker slang) are insults to myself or the God I worship. Even then it takes a few tries to make my head spin around and blood shoot out of my eyes.


Mrs.

Not speaking for Dr Craig, when I say linked time I am specifying space time that was created in the big bang that I mean just after t-0 . Did God create spacetime ? Most theists say yes even Quentin Smith* is now throwing in with theists and accepting time began with the BB. I feel that God created time indirectly.


That doesn't really answer my question. Do you believe that time can exist independently of space?

I will refer you to a page where he discusses this in detail. May I ask, do you work with computers ?


Please provide that reference. What I do for a living and my educational background should be irrelevent to this discussion.

You see this is where it gets confusing. I have stated many times that I am a open theist Christian, with nuances. I believe that God exists in a perfect spiritual realm that is outside this universe, however I feel that God can interact casually (ie most of the time he sends liaisons to the temporal universe.

The burning bush, visions, voices, angels and the most profound of all Jesus Christ.


Did you mean "casually" or "causally"? And how would such an interaction take place? Are these liasons be created ex nihilo?

However the material universe being made from fragile ‘atom based’ matter means that it appears non perfect to us. So yes God as Einstein mused, God does have self imposed limitations in this universe.


Who "us"? Perfection, much like beauty, is in the eye of the beholder. Thank you for the clarification regarding limitations.


It’s a debatable question. Some say time is infinite and stretches in all directions infinitely. Hogwash. I don’t like infinities. The easy way to visualize it is to see events as numbers in linear sequence. The sequence is the arrow of time (without time) and the numbers are events. We know what numbers come before each other or where they should be in the graph and can explain it without having to use space-time.


Wrong. Time is simply a dimension, or a way of measuring something that exists in space-time. As a dimension, it certainly can stretch out to infinity either along the positive or negative axis, exactly as the three spatial dimensions can. Stating it cannot is like stating there must be a limit to integers.

Now, objects that exist in the space-time continuum may be limited along these axes, but the dimensions themselves are not.

Or the event two comes after event three and before event one.


The main problem with your number analogy is that there is no causal link between them. Ordering something along a non-time axis tells us nothing about time. To use another analogy, I can line up a group of people by height, but it tells me nothing about the relationships between those people.


We were doing good until the last sentence! I haven’t said the BB can state why or how the universe began to exist that is the KCA’s job. The BB simply takes us to near t-0.


You are trying to use the Big Bang model as support for the KCA, aren't you? If the Big Bang doesn't work at the "time" required, replacing it with anything, including the KCA, is a complete non sequitur. It simply doesn't follow.


I haven’t claimed that the KCA is based on science. It uses science as in the BB but the KCA is a cosmological argument for the existence of God.


If it isn't based on science, how can you use science to support it? That makes as much sense as using matrix algebra to support literary criticism.

it’s a valid logical argument that relies on deductive logic (its premises) constructing a valid syllogism. However it can and does offer an explanation for those that are not too effected by their own belief system to understand it fully.


Of course it offers an explanation for those who buy into its premises (several of which still have unaddressed issues). That is called circular reasoning.
 
Last edited:
No, it can't work that way. The closer you are to the event horizon, the more light is red-shifted. At the event horizon, it it infinitely red-shifted.

So the observer cannot see the hapless test subject reaching the event horizon, because at that point, no light can reach the observer from the subject.

And just before the event horizon, light from the subject is red-shifted, not infinitely, but so much that it becomes physically impossible to detect. (Wavelengths measured first in metres, then miles, then in light years...) So rather than being seen to reach the event horizon and disappear, they fade from view as they approach it. I think this would happen very quickly for stellar-mass black holes, but really large black holes could have relatively low gravity at the event horizon - it's the escape velocity that gets you, not the gravity at the horizon - and it could actually become observable.


Not quite that strange, though!

Wrong Pixi. The size of a black hole would make no difference as all require enough mass to create one, a million stellar mass black hole or a thousand stellar mass black would be have the same effects on our guy. The observer would see his friend stop at the event horizon. Remember we also said that we were saying his freind could live through it.

You forget that we said we could watch everything. If the observers could see everything it would happen just as I said *and the NASA astrophysicist said. I can pull another link if you like, or better yet why don't you provide the link this time?

; {>
 
Of course none of this has anything to do with time for the hapless friend from his perspective. Time keeps on going.

I will concede that I can't speak to the atemporal nature of the interior nature of a black hole or how it relates to the disussion.

We know that by hawking radiation that information can enter a black hole and not be lost so I was demonstrating that cause and effect can exist where time according to the observed has stopped.
If Pixie would of read my post I already indicated that time would seem to be unchanged to the friend not to the observer. To the observer it would seem that time had stopped for his friend at the event horizon as per me and the NASA astrophysics link.

; {>
 
I did. They said it's not. That's why I'm asking you.

Your assertion is not supported by your sources.

You missed this;

a·the·ism Pronunciation (th-zm)
n.
1. Disbelief in or denial of the existence of God or gods.
2. The doctrine that there is no God or gods.

http://www.thefreedictionary.com/Atheists

mufff

; {>

Read number two again The doctrine that there is no God or gods.

Its items like this that makes debating with you pixi nearly impossible. And not know much of your subject matter, and not admitting when you are wrong even in the face of outside evidence.

; {>
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom