The certainty of God's existence.

Its not easy to visualize and that is at least part of the difficulty.
It has nothing to do with visualization. It has to do with the words you are using and logic. Words have meaning and logically they have consequences. Now, I realize that it can be difficult to explain some concepts because the words we have at our disposal might not be adequate to convey the message intended.

But if you are in effect saying that you have a round square then we have a problem. A square by definition isn't round.

A does not equal not A.

I may go out on a limb and speculate that events taking place without time could be events that happen inside an event horizon of a black hole etc.
Define event?

Time does not actually stop (for both parties at least) at the event horizon but would appear to stop if a friend could watch you falling into the black hole from a safe distance. If you could live through the experience you would notice nothing strange, but to your observer it would appear that you were slowing down and eventually stopping 'at' the event horizon. So time would appear to the observer to of stopped. So that may be a bad example.
Yeah, this doesn't at all help.

Anyway the logic of the KCA tells us that the 'cause' is atemporal, which is true if time was created in the big bang along with space energy etc. and the premises are sound. It also tells us that it has to be able to influence this mass and energy to create the universe i.e. to cause it to begin to exist. So to summarize we may not know the mechanism unless it could be similar to 1-2-3-4 example I gave before.
I know that you have a lot to respond to but I've stated on numerous occassions that theoretical physists have theories as to the formation of the universe that do not result in paradoxes of time. See M-Theory.

Also, assuming for the sake of argument that KCA were true it doesn't tell us anything. It has no explanatory power, makes no falsifiable predictions, does not advance or resolve any of the questions of cosmology or physics, is unparsimonious (posits unkown entities and unknown forces).



As to M-Theory. Perhaps it has a way to go before it becomes conventional wisdom however,
  • It IS parsimonious.
  • It does address the issues being worked on by cosmologists and theoretical physicists.
  • It does have explanatory power (WITHOUT appealing to magic or miracles).
Now, I keep telling you these facts and you keep ignoring them. They're not going away.
 
Last edited:
Just a note: I wrote several lines in post 1219 criticising RevDisturba's description of event horizons. I was in error; though RevD is not entirely correct, the point is more subtle than I made out. I've removed those lines from my post.
 
Okay, RevD, a second attempt at correcting your description of event horizons, hopefully this time with fewer errors on my part!

It is true that as an object approaches the event horizon of a black hole, time slows down for it, relative to an observer stationary with respect to the black hole.

As you say, if you could survive the event (which is of course impossible) you would not notice time slowing down as you fell into the black hole. You'd just go fwip! and be gone.

Here's where you come unstuck, though:

to your observer it would appear that you were slowing down and eventually stopping 'at' the event horizon.
In fact, to the observer you would just go fwip! and be gone as well. However, the observer would never see you reaching the event horizon. Instead, what would happen is that as you approach the event horizon, the light from you would become so red-shifted that you would simply disappear from view. In no time flat you'd be one with the cosmic microwave background.
 
One more thing bud your attempt at proselytizing (a direct attempt to convert me) in your earlier post is a violation of this sites tos. Please cease and desist.

Which provision of the Membership Agreement do you claim this violates? If proselytizing was against the rules, people like kurious kathy would have been banned years ago.

I think perhaps you are confusing this with another site.
 
Which provision of the Membership Agreement do you claim this violates? If proselytizing was against the rules, people like kurious kathy would have been banned years ago.

I think perhaps you are confusing this with another site.

Oh its too bad I don't do online conversions. Or to be truthful its very rare. Kurious Kathy... I wondered why she received the hostile comments (I noticed saw excerpts of posts directed towards ms kathy)

However concerning the proselytizing I believe you are correct, it was another site. Anyway I may still be Buddhist. Thanks for the heads up and I apologize if I scared anyone.

; {>
 
Okay, RevD, a second attempt at correcting your description of event horizons, hopefully this time with fewer errors on my part!

It is true that as an object approaches the event horizon of a black hole, time slows down for it, relative to an observer stationary with respect to the black hole.

As you say, if you could survive the event (which is of course impossible) you would not notice time slowing down as you fell into the black hole. You'd just go fwip! and be gone.

Here's where you come unstuck, though:

In fact, to the observer you would just go fwip! and be gone as well. However, the observer would never see you reaching the event horizon. Instead, what would happen is that as you approach the event horizon, the light from you would become so red-shifted that you would simply disappear from view. In no time flat you'd be one with the cosmic microwave background.

I think you are incorrect Pixi because the observer watching his hapless friend accelerate faster and faster to near light speed he would appear to be slowing down (to the observer on earth) due to the effects of time dilation ...then he would eventually appear to stop at the event horizon.....I will look for some validation

Your version would seem to be correct intuitively but time dilation is a strange thing indeed!

; {>.

Here is something close but they are using clocks.....>

"you would not be aware of any slowing down of any clock you carried as you fell in. However, if you could compare the speed of your clock with that of a reference clock kept far away, then then the clock falling into the black hole would appear to slow down relative to the clock far from the hole. The place where the falling in clock would appear to 'stop' is the spherical surface called the event horizon. This is also regarded as the boundary of the black hole, since nothing crossing this surface can escape."

http://imagine.gsfc.nasa.gov/docs/ask_astro/answers/970618a.html

; {>
 
Last edited:
So weak atheism isn't a doctrine then.

Strong atheism is a positive belief, and could be described as having a doctrine. Weak atheism, not so.

I agree that weak atheism wouldn't be supported by that (my) source. However, weak atheism allows that there may be god etc. Whats his name was claiming the strong atheism concept. If I had to rate which form of atheism I respected the most it would be strong atheism.

: {>
 
I think you are incorrect Pixi because the observer watching his hapless friend accelerate faster and faster to near light speed he would appear to be slowing down (to the observer on earth) due to the effects of time dilation ...then he would eventually appear to stop at the event horizon.....I will look for some validation
No, it can't work that way. The closer you are to the event horizon, the more light is red-shifted. At the event horizon, it it infinitely red-shifted.

So the observer cannot see the hapless test subject reaching the event horizon, because at that point, no light can reach the observer from the subject.

And just before the event horizon, light from the subject is red-shifted, not infinitely, but so much that it becomes physically impossible to detect. (Wavelengths measured first in metres, then miles, then in light years...) So rather than being seen to reach the event horizon and disappear, they fade from view as they approach it. I think this would happen very quickly for stellar-mass black holes, but really large black holes could have relatively low gravity at the event horizon - it's the escape velocity that gets you, not the gravity at the horizon - and it could actually become observable.

Your version would seem to be correct intuitively but time dilation is a strange thing indeed!
Not quite that strange, though!
 
I think you are incorrect Pixi because the observer watching his hapless friend accelerate faster and faster to near light speed he would appear to be slowing down (to the observer on earth) due to the effects of time dilation ...then he would eventually appear to stop at the event horizon.....I will look for some validation.
Of course none of this has anything to do with time for the hapless friend from his perspective. Time keeps on going.

I will concede that I can't speak to the atemporal nature of the interior nature of a black hole or how it relates to the disussion.
 
Last edited:
I agree that weak atheism wouldn't be supported by that (my) source. However, weak atheism allows that there may be god etc.
Not quite. More precisely, it correctly places the burden of proof.

Whats his name was claiming the strong atheism concept.
For that case, I agree; strong atheism could be described as having a doctrine. You still have to be careful in comparing that with religious doctrine, though, for it is essentially just a positive statement of the null hypothesis, and is far easier to support than any religion.

If I had to rate which form of atheism I respected the most it would be strong atheism.
I can understand that, and strong atheism is an understandable and reasonable position to take with respect to all known human religions.

Personally, I'm not an atheist at all; I'm an ignostic. (Yes, I spelled that correctly.)
 
Last edited:
After some research it appears that Darwin went to his death an agnostic. Darwin did not recant. Lady Hope claimed to of been by Darwin's bedside and said that he recanted. However his family denied the story along with some other convincing proof.

Even today the Lady Hope story occasionally appears on Christian tracts published and given out by well-meaning people.That is probably why the darwin/christian thing is a dim memory and one that is now abolished. RIP Charles.

; {>

All due respect for not holding on to the deathbed story, you probably weren't very attached to it, but even so, a lot of people value 'face' over integrity and refuse to admit when they're wrong even when they are convinced of it themselves. Duly noted that you're not that kind of person.

Also, knowing you're not a 'flaming hell' Christian does somewhat mitigate your comment about seeing an atheist punished; however it is still a very horrible thing to say and I am mystified as to why a decent man would refuse to apologize for it. You might be surprised at how easily most of us would forgive you.
 
Of course none of this has anything to do with time for the hapless friend from his perspective. Time keeps on going.
Right.

I will concede that I can't speak to the atemporal nature of the inside of a black hole or how it relates to the disussion.
Indeed, no-one can speak to the atemporal nature of the inside of a black hole. Physics breaks down at the event horizon. Nothing about the interior of the black hole - including whether there is one - can be known.
 
Here is something close but they are using clocks.....>

"you would not be aware of any slowing down of any clock you carried as you fell in. However, if you could compare the speed of your clock with that of a reference clock kept far away, then then the clock falling into the black hole would appear to slow down relative to the clock far from the hole. The place where the falling in clock would appear to 'stop' is the spherical surface called the event horizon. This is also regarded as the boundary of the black hole, since nothing crossing this surface can escape."
Right. That's entirely correct.

But if your clock is stopped, your clock is stopped. No information from you can reach an external observer. You've disappeared from the Universe.

It's just that the way you disappear is different from Newtonian physics - instead of zipping across the event horizon and winking out, you fade into causal invisibility just before you reach it.
 
Nothing about the interior of the black hole - including whether there is one - can be known.
Not exactly. We can confidently say that gravity inside the EH is very chaotic. We also can calculate the radius of a BH and that spacetime is warped or "ripped."

ETA - Physics breaks down at the EH and then again at the singularity.
 
Last edited:
Okay, I may need to correct my correction!

While the subject will observe themselves crossing the position of the event horizon as measured by the observer, they will never cross the event horizon as they see it. For the same reason that an external observer can never see the subject reach the event horizon, the subject himself can never see himself reach the event horizon. It recedes in front of him.

However, to the rest of the Universe, he's gone and no signal from him can ever escape. And from his point of view, well, he doesn't have a point of view at this point!
 
All due respect for not holding on to the deathbed story, you probably weren't very attached to it, but even so, a lot of people value 'face' over integrity and refuse to admit when they're wrong even when they are convinced of it themselves. Duly noted that you're not that kind of person.

Also, knowing you're not a 'flaming hell' Christian does somewhat mitigate your comment about seeing an atheist punished; however it is still a very horrible thing to say and I am mystified as to why a decent man would refuse to apologize for it. You might be surprised at how easily most of us would forgive you.
Absolutely. I think rev is a decent guy and I understand. It can be frustrating defending an unpopular view in a skeptics forum.
 
Not exactly. We can confidently say that gravity inside the EH is very chaotic. We also can calculate the radius of a BH and that spacetime is warped or "ripped."

ETA - Physics breaks down at the EH and then again at the singularity.
My knowledge breaks down at this point, but from what I do know, you're right. If only there were an astrophysicist in the house. ;)
 
My reply also stated that "lack of belief in gods" was 'the' doctrine. It was a cut and paste. BTW, I didn't say atheists had a multifaceted doctrine. That's more of your 'I said the Rev said' (because I know what he is thinking better than he does) doctrine.

; {>

This all started with your statement:

RevDisturba said:
The true villains are the SECULAR godless warlords that wont even let food in. Your atheist blinders only allow you to see what you want to see. (ie hate anything christian, because you forgot to say what good the church does compared to say atheist humanitarian groups.. wait none of those exist huh?)

You were clearly implying the moral inferiority of atheists with the above statement. Your simplistic rational was that the rarity of explicitly atheist charity and aid groups indicated that atheists do not care to commit acts of charity and aid for the benefit of their fellow humans. A few people have attempted to explain to you that the lack of belief in gods is not some sort of unifying doctrine such as those subscribed to by Catholics, Muslims, Buddhist etc. Basing a charitable organization on the lack of belief in gods would be every bit as silly as basing it on a lack of belief in the Easter Bunny or not collecting stamps. If I, an atheist, had the resources to establish a charitable foundation I would not establish it as an atheist charity. What would be the point of that?

And do you remember this statement?

RevDisturba said:
Well what do you mean by doctrine, the atheist manifesto?

Amazon.com: Atheist Manifesto: The Case Against Christianity ...
Amazon.com: Atheist Manifesto: The Case Against Christianity, Judaism, and Islam (9781559708203): Michel Onfray: Books.
http://www.amazon.com/Atheist-Manife....../1559708204 -

It is the original text from post #1160, which I had quoted before you edited it. It certainly appears that you are advancing that book as an atheist doctrine. I then asked if you could present evidence of an atheist doctrine that includes tenets that all theist subscribe to.

With the exception of one more comment to follow shortly, I am done with this semantic game. I look forward to you providing evidence to support any of your claims, such as that the Third Reich was a secular regime, or that atheists don't contribute to charities, or that theism greatly inhibits the spread of war and bloodshed.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom