The certainty of God's existence.

In any case time is not needed to produce a series of events.
You have forgotten that this was one of the first points I made to you.

But since time is not needed to produce a series of events then your argument from P1 to C2 has nothing whatsoever to do with time.

So on what basis do you suddenly pluck these conclusions about time and timelessness from an argument that has not even introduced the concept?

The conclusion that the cause must be timeless has no basis in the argument you presented.
 
Last edited:
mondays are wonderful!

Hokulele said:
When you use the phrase "linked with gravity and space", does this mean that you, Dr. Craig, or both of you believe that time can exist independent of space? I am just asking for clarification purposes.

You don’t have to walk on eggshells around me Mr Hokulele.The only thing that torques my crank (biker slang) are insults to myself or the God I worship. Even then it takes a few tries to make my head spin around and blood shoot out of my eyes.

~ Anyway~

Not speaking for Dr Craig, when I say linked time I am specifying space time that was created in the big bang that I mean just after t-0 . Did God create spacetime ? Most theists say yes even Quentin Smith* is now throwing in with theists and accepting time began with the BB. I feel that God created time indirectly.

To what does Dr. Craig see time as being relational? To the universe? To God? To some other objective frame of reference?

I will refer you to a page where he discusses this in detail. May I ask, do you work with computers ?

Doesn't this imply there are restrictions on your version of God?

You see this is where it gets confusing. I have stated many times that I am a open theist Christian, with nuances. I believe that God exists in a perfect spiritual realm that is outside this universe, however I feel that God can interact casually (ie most of the time he sends liaisons to the temporal universe.

The burning bush, visions, voices, angels and the most profound of all Jesus Christ. However the material universe being made from fragile ‘atom based’ matter means that it appears non perfect to us. So yes God as Einstein mused, God does have self imposed limitations in this universe.

Please explain causality without time.In order for that to be true, you do need some sort of dimension (time, space, or "other"). For a series of events, I accept that you do not need a temporal dimension. However, for causality, you need a time dimension pretty much by definition. Otherwise your linking isn't causal, but spatial.

It’s a debatable question. Some say time is infinite and stretches in all directions infinitely. Hogwash. I don’t like infinities. The easy way to visualize it is to see events as numbers in linear sequence. The sequence is the arrow of time (without time) and the numbers are events. We know what numbers come before each other or where they should be in the graph and can explain it without having to use space-time.

This requires a time element, as noted by your use of "and then".

Or the event two comes after event three and before event one.

But you admit that the Big Bang model breaks down before t=0. That alone refutes its utility at making predictions regarding t=0, and refutes its utility at making general statements as to how our universe "began".

We were doing good until the last sentence! I haven’t said the BB can state why or how the universe began to exist that is the KCA’s job. The BB simply takes us to near t-0.

As has been pointed out before, there are many hypotheses, but no knowledge. Claiming the KCA holds water is based on wishful thinking rather than science.

I haven’t claimed that the KCA is based on science. It uses science as in the BB but the KCA is a cosmological argument for the existence of God. it’s a valid logical argument that relies on deductive logic (its premises) constructing a valid syllogism. However it can and does offer an explanation for those that are not too effected by their own belief system to understand it fully.

; }>


* Quentin Smith is “an American contemporary philosopher, atheist, scholar and professor of philosophy at Western Michigan University “.
 
Last edited:
You have forgotten that this was one of the first points I made to you.

But since time is not needed to produce a series of events then your argument from P1 to C2 has nothing whatsoever to do with time.

So on what basis do you suddenly pluck these conclusions about time and timelessness from an argument that has not even introduced the concept?

The conclusion that the cause must be timeless has no basis in the argument you presented.

The only thing I remember is that you (I thought it was you) agreed with me that time isn't necessary events. The reason this was brought up is of course that 'before' t-0, ie the point where the universe began exist, time did not exist. So in order for the cause to be able to produce action or events this have a way to do it.

Remember I said much earlier that I am defending P-1 through P-3. I said I would attempt to answer in a Craigely' manner if I know the answer for the extended version of the KCA as per Craig.

; {>
 
I'm going to venture a guess that definition 1 was along the lines of "disbelief in the existence of God or any other deity".

But just to be clear, the definition of "doctrine":

1. a particular principle, position, or policy taught or advocated, as of a religion or government: Catholic doctrines; the Monroe Doctrine.
2. something that is taught; teachings collectively: religious doctrine.
3. a body or system of teachings relating to a particular subject: the doctrine of the Catholic Church.

doc·trine [dóktrin]
(plural doc·trines)
n
1. rule or principle: a rule or principle that forms the basis of a belief, theory, or policy
2. ideas taught as truth: a body of ideas, particularly in religion, taught to people as truthful or correct
3. something taught: something taught to people (archaic)

Encarta ® World English Dictionary © & (P) 1998-2004 Microsoft Corporation. All rights reserved.
Synonyms:
1. tenet, dogma, theory, precept, belief.

Of course I was displaying the definition that I was using to indicate that it was a valid definition.
What I said, "There are no specifically atheistic beliefs other than the lack of belief in gods", still stands. Atheism is not a body or system of teachings. It is simply a lack of belief in gods.

I quoted what you said. You said atheism has no doctrine technically it does. I don't know why you even posted the rest, everything I rebutted was in quote tags, I was attempting to rectify your mistakes.

; {>
 
Last edited:
riginally Posted by RevDisturba View Post
There are well known attributes of a philosophical God. Now as I said I don't use ontological arguments to defend my paradigm, so much of this is moot, I do however use cosmological arguments.
In my opinion you'd be better served by a modal ontological argument.


(I really mean it, and yes that does not exactly express a very positive opinion on cosmological arguments. )

Kurt Godel was the greatest mind secondly only to Einstein in my book. He and Einstein were walking buddies at Princeton and he helped Einstein flesh out his theories of GR. He formulated the his famous incompleteness theorem, and which rocked the world of mathematics.

BTW Godel ontological argument is modal in nature, but its weak compared to the cosmological argument that modern philosophers like Craig and Koon present. I do wish Godel wouldn't of suffered OCD killed him.

;' {>
 
For some great wake up stuff, RevDisturbia, why not try daimoku and the chanting of Nam Myōhō Renge Kyō so as to connect with your own divinity and enact the Mystic Law which permeates all things? It will give you a great energy boost and help you to see the misguided nature of adhering to the limiting concepts of a creator deity character.

Gongyō is great! Defining yourself by an ultimately fruitless and clouding concept of "God"? Not so much.

Well well I see the kind Buddhist is showing a bit of his true nature. You fooled me which is remarkable. You must be swilling that juice to excess if you think I would take the your advice. I had reached enlightenment before you were born my fake friend.

One more thing bud your attempt at proselytizing (a direct attempt to convert me) in your earlier post is a violation of this sites tos. Please cease and desist.

: {>

BTW my mantra is Jesus Christ Is love.... Jesus Christ Is love,,,,
 
Last edited:
I quoted what you said. You said atheism has no doctrine technically it does. I don't know why you even posted the rest, everything I rebutted was in quote tags, I was attempting to rectify your mistakes.

; {>

Then you should have no trouble pointing out what beliefs are common to atheists beyond lack of belief in gods.
 
Kurt Godel was the greatest mind secondly only to Einstein in my book. He and Einstein were walking buddies at Princeton and he helped Einstein flesh out his theories of GR. He formulated the his famous incompleteness theorem, and which rocked the world of mathematics.

BTW Godel ontological argument is modal in nature, but its weak compared to the cosmological argument that modern philosophers like Craig and Koon present. I do wish Godel wouldn't of suffered OCD killed him.

;' {>

Yes, Einstein and Gödel were remarkable. But they both human and made mistakes. Einstein, in his ignorance of geology, supported some geological ideas that were laughable. Long after the evidence of Stalin's atrocities became clear he refused to abandon his support of Communism, preferring to cling to his idealistic view of it. And Gödel had his ontological argument...
 
But since time is not needed to produce a series of events...
I've been arguing the opposite. Under what theory can a series of events take place without time?

A series necessates that things happen before and after. There is no before and after without time.
 
Last edited:
Then you should have no trouble pointing out what beliefs are common to atheists beyond lack of belief in gods.

My reply also stated that "lack of belief in gods" was 'the' doctrine. It was a cut and paste. BTW, I didn't say atheists had a multifaceted doctrine. That's more of your 'I said the Rev said' (because I know what he is thinking better than he does) doctrine.

; {>
 
Not speaking for Dr Craig, when I say linked time I am specifying space time that was created in the big bang that I mean just after t-0 . Did God create spacetime ? Most theists say yes even Quentin Smith
Never heard of him. Argument from lack of authority.

You see this is where it gets confusing. I have stated many times that I am a open theist Christian, with nuances. I believe that God exists in a perfect spiritual realm that is outside this universe, however I feel that God can interact casually (ie most of the time he sends liaisons to the temporal universe.
This is known variously as having your cake and eating it; the retreat to unfalsifiability; and special pleading.

The burning bush, visions, voices, angels and the most profound of all Jesus Christ.
You forgot Gandalf and the Balrog. Oh wait, that was a story in a book.

However the material universe being made from fragile ‘atom based’ matter means that it appears non perfect to us. So yes God as Einstein mused, God does have self imposed limitations in this universe.
Equivocation.

It’s a debatable question. Some say time is infinite and stretches in all directions infinitely.
Who the heck says that?

Hogwash. I don’t like infinities.
Argument from incredulity.

The easy way to visualize it is to see events as numbers in linear sequence.
False analogy.

The sequence is the arrow of time (without time)
Contradiction.

and the numbers are events.
False analogy.

We know what numbers come before each other or where they should be in the graph and can explain it without having to use space-time.
Non-sequitur.

Or the event two comes after event three and before event one.
False analogy.

We were doing good until the last sentence! I haven’t said the BB can state why or how the universe began to exist that is the KCA’s job. The BB simply takes us to near t-0.
This is one of your several dozen problems. You are basing your argument in part on big bang cosmology. It doesn't get you where you need to go.

I haven’t claimed that the KCA is based on science. It uses science as in the BB
Contradiction.

but the KCA is a cosmological argument for the existence of God. it’s a valid logical argument that relies on deductive logic (its premises)
It what?

constructing a valid syllogism.
Its validity is doubtful. It remains unsound.

However it can and does offer an explanation for those that are not too effected by their own belief system to understand it fully.
Ad hominem.
 
Last edited:
doc·trine [dóktrin]
(plural doc·trines)
n
1. rule or principle: a rule or principle that forms the basis of a belief, theory, or policy
2. ideas taught as truth: a body of ideas, particularly in religion, taught to people as truthful or correct
3. something taught: something taught to people (archaic)

Encarta ® World English Dictionary © & (P) 1998-2004 Microsoft Corporation. All rights reserved.
Synonyms:
1. tenet, dogma, theory, precept, belief.

Of course I was displaying the definition that I was using to indicate that it was a valid definition.

I quoted what you said. You said atheism has no doctrine technically it does.
No. Not according to any of those definitions, nor even the synonyms.
 
I've been arguing the opposite. Under what theory can a series of events take place without time?

A series necessates that things happen before and after. There is no before and after without time.

Its not easy to visualize and that is at least part of the difficulty. I may go out on a limb and speculate that events taking place without time could be events that happen inside an event horizon of a black hole etc.

Time does not actually stop (for both parties at least) at the event horizon but would appear to stop if a friend could watch you falling into the black hole from a safe distance. If you could live through the experience you would notice nothing strange, but to your observer it would appear that you were slowing down and eventually stopping 'at' the event horizon. So time would appear to the observer to of stopped. So that may be a bad example.

Anyway the logic of the KCA tells us that the 'cause' is atemporal, which is true if time was created in the big bang along with space energy etc. and the premises are sound. It also tells us that it has to be able to influence this mass and energy to create the universe i.e. to cause it to begin to exist. So to summarize we may not know the mechanism unless it could be similar to 1-2-3-4 example I gave before.

; {>
 
Its not easy to visualize and that is at least part of the difficulty. I may go out on a limb and speculate that events taking place without time could be events that happen inside an event horizon of a black hole etc.
Ah. You're talking about things that it is impossible to have any knowledge of.

Anyway the logic of the KCA tells us that the 'cause' is atemporal
Contradiction.

which is true if time was created in the big bang along with space energy etc. and the premises are sound.
Soundness is not a property of premises.

It also tells us that it has to be able to influence this mass and energy to create the universe i.e. to cause it to begin to exist.
That depends entirely on the cosmological model.

So to summarize we may not know the mechanism unless it could be similar to 1-2-3-4 example I gave before.
Similar to a false analogy?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom