The certainty of God's existence.

Robin said:
RevDisturba, You may claim that Craig understands eternity, but his words on the subject are a pitiful muddle as I have shown.

To be honest with you I break company with Dr Craig at some point just after the time is created ie linked with gravity and space. I can also state that every time I begged to differ with the good Dr I was wrong and did not fully understand his concepts. I will attempt to answer for Craig and myself when it delineates from Craig.

He thinks that if an eternal entity chooses to creates a state or object then that state or object would not be "from eternity" (his words). So what would they be from? From a certain time within eternity? Obviously not.

It would be very beneficial if you could use quote tags or direct me back to the original source so I could read Craig’s entire response in context instead on relying on your critiques which may be right or wrong. Thanks in advance! Here is a quote from Craig about eternity ;

“These, then, are the alternatives. A relational* view of time seems superior to a Newtonian view because (1) it is difficult to see how time could exist apart from events and (2) the Newtonian objection that every instant of time implies a prior instant is adequately answered by the relational view. Thus, the proper understanding of God, time, and eternity would be that God exists changelessly and timelessly prior to creation and in time after creation.”

Craig takes a philosophical or theological view of eternity as it relates to time. I take a scientific view and simply equate a temporal with eternity, ie independent of time. This philosophical view leads to problems and at least one paradox. Soren Kierkegaard called this the Absolute Paradox; this is the contradiction of existence: the presence of the Eternal in time, how God can enter the space-time world without ceasing to be the Eternal. Well the way I see it is that God doesn’t enter the space-time world he sends temporal agents such as angels and weird liaisons such as the burning bush. Even Jesus was a temporal agent to get around God having to manifest in space time in his own form whatever that is. I can only think of one or two times that God might manifest in his own form here on earth (in our space-time).

He seems to think that the man in his example who was sitting from eternity and chose to stand would be standing after he was sitting. Again, obviously not. In eternity there would be no ordering of the sitting and standing states. So if a man is sitting from eternity and chooses to stand he is standing from eternity.

Ha yes! You should read his paper titled God time and eternity. He discusses in length your concerns. However as I said I don’t agree with some of Craigs interpretations and concepts of time. Again I differ from Craig in that I think time if it can be called that prior to time zero of the big bang is reduced to simple causality independent of time.

So what else can he mean by this justification unless he is treating eternity as though it were an infinite regress of time?

To be honest I am not sure.
http://www.reasonablefaith.org/site/News2?page=NewsArticle&id=5161#text1

In any case you have been using the term undefined here, and I have provided a full definition of how I am using "eternity"

I said eternity is independent of time or not effected by time.

So first key question: Can an eternal entity change?

By change do you mean implement change?

I already defined the concept clearly before I used it, you will find my definition in D1 and D2 of my interpretation of the KCM (which I have been regularly bumping). That is what I mean by a series of events.

I am sure you mean the KCA? With the usual suspects making up their own fantasy theories I cant be sure.

Nevertheless, I think that God can enter our space time. And I think that time as we know it did not exist before t-0 of the BB, limited causality did perhaps but we are limited in what we can know before t-0.

A key premise of the KCA is based upon the concept "series of events", if it is undefined then I think we have a problem Houston.

Which premise is based on a series of events? In any case time is not needed to produce a series of events. Events are like these numbers 1-2-3-4-5 we don't need time to see that 2 comes after 1 and before three.

"Before" the universe began? You mean in the time prior to to time when there was no time? :)

I have explained this many times, at least five times. When I say before the universe began to exist I mean before time existed, but even that gets complicated because time according to science was not created until nano seconds after the BB banged t-0. So again for ease of understanding when I say before the BB I mean before time began to exist or most popular writers mistakenly say before t-0.

You seem to be using the term "begin to exist" to describe the situation that in some ordered set of states there is a state that does not include the universe followed by a state that does? Yes?

Began to exist means there was nothing and then there was something. When there was something it began to exist.

Using the definition "began to exist", there is a false dichotomy in P1 and it should read:

Wrong wrong wrong! The universe began to exist according to standard big bang cosmology. This is not to say that there are not other theories new and modified versions of the BB that allow for the universe not beginning to exist (I have covered this as well).

However our model of the BB is shaped like a cone drinking cup the point of the cup is where the universe began to exist. However in say a hawking non empirically supported dreamed up by imaginary numbers (sarcasm he uses them to attempt to rid the universe of the BB singularity and thus God) universe is shaped like a badminton birdie instead of a cone. You notice no pointey tip and no singularity, instead of coming to a point (singularity) you simply just come back into time and start again.

However (and there are always a however's) as I have said so many times these theories are just that weak unsupported theory unlike the big bang model we use which has empirical evidence galore.

P1: If the universe did not begin to exist then either there was an infinite regress or causality is not exclusively sequential​

Not valid, unsupported by the observational evidence, and other evidence of the BB model. All the maneuvering in the world will not change the facts. the universe began to exist according to BB cosmology despite the fanatical hope of atheists. Please get used to it. If all this is based on the hope that the universe did not begin to exist I have covered it in detail already.

So third key question: Do you agree that this more accurately describes the situation, if not, why not?

No heck no! I described why above. I will be happy to expand or provide references on request.

Final key question: Do you agree that to be consistent P1 should be applied to the cause of the universe if there is one?

If there is no cause for the universe to begin to exist that alone would completely make the KCA toast in a Hiroshima way.

Thanks for your reply. I am sure you will want clarification because I wasn’t so sure of the questions at the beginning of the reply.

; {>
 
Fair enough. Thanks.

BTW: My bark is much worse than my bite. Some times I can come accross strident when I'm really not and I don't mind giving an appology where it is due.

Cheers.

I thought that might be the case, and as I have said good people like you are the rule in the atheist/agnostic community.

: }>
 
When I say before the universe began to exist I mean before time existed, but even that gets complicated because time according to science was not created until nano seconds after the BB banged t-0. So again for ease of understanding when I say before the BB I mean before time began to exist or most popular writers mistakenly say before t-0.
The word 'before' only has meaning once time has begun. If time began at the Big Bang it is meaningless to talk about 'before' the Big Bang, in the same way that it is meaningless to talk about a place further north than the North Pole.
 
Winning peoples hearts and minds to the path of true salvation and enlightenment can be achieved by peaceful means that need not create conflict. Through the venerable act of shaku buku I will apply the same logic and reason you would use to show you that your feelings and beliefs about Jesus Christ and a believe in god are misguided. Here is a biography of the blessed and amazing life of the True Buddha who appears in the Latter Day of the Law to establish the true Buddhism which will enable all mankind to attain Buddhahood, Nichiren Daishōnin 日蓮大聖人.

I am down with Buddhism and was an adherent in the 70's while a visitor of south east Asia at the behest of my uncle. I lied about my age to get the free visit. (I turned 17 in the army). Anyway I have often said that Christians should defend their faith with reverence and gentleness. However, I am still working on that, ego and pride are huge roadblocks to the road of enlightenment. BTW I still mediate every day

You can learn about his persecutions and how the heavens themselves intervened in the attempt to excecute him, which no mortal was able to do. RevDisturbia, you, too, can attain Buddahood in your life. However, you will first have to take on the Four Great Vows. Here is a paper on Nichiren Buddhism and Christianity which will allow you to begin understanding that what you call "God" is really the Mystic Law...

I took the vows as a first order of business by my teacher. I will check it out and was unaware that Christianity and Buddhism was compatible as in a merged religion. I still retain much of my Buddhist teachings and incorporated them into my Christianity. Back in the 70's I wasn't a christian so it did not concern me.


Likewise.

; }>
 
Presumably because it is easier to attack a position than to defend one.

I can sympathise but we cannot avoid the fact that the theist is the claimant and the atheist is not.

In fact I once put my reasons for believing there was no God and it was probably just about the shortest thread in JREF history and nobody actually addressed my arguments.

Oh now Robin, I think its quite unfair for an atheist to shift the burden of proof to the theist every time. Btw you are lucky I wasn't there for to critique your thread. Of course it was a short thread how many Christians are there here right now? I am going to dust off a thread I have posted on several sites that clearly demonstrates why I feel that its unfair for the theist to be saddled with the burden of proof exclusively.

; {>
....\
 
The word 'before' only has meaning once time has begun. If time began at the Big Bang it is meaningless to talk about 'before' the Big Bang, in the same way that it is meaningless to talk about a place further north than the North Pole.

That may be true for a very, very simplistic view of the world. But atemporality* its topic of discussion among philosophers etc. Time is not what you may think it is. Remember 1-2-3-4 ? Do you need time to tell you two comes after one and before three? Events work the same way when 'time' ** is not present.

*... Definitions of atemporal on the Web: Unaffected by time; timeless; permanent or unchanging en.wiktionary.org/wiki/atemporal

**...Measuring time and other spatio-temporal quantities
http://www.ling.su.se/staff/hartmut/uhr.htm

; {>
 
Last edited:
To be honest with you I break company with Dr Craig at some point just after the time is created ie linked with gravity and space.


When you use the phrase "linked with gravity and space", does this mean that you, Dr. Craig, or both of you believe that time can exist independent of space? I am just asking for clarification purposes.

“These, then, are the alternatives. A relational* view of time seems superior to a Newtonian view because (1) it is difficult to see how time could exist apart from events and (2) the Newtonian objection that every instant of time implies a prior instant is adequately answered by the relational view. Thus, the proper understanding of God, time, and eternity would be that God exists changelessly and timelessly prior to creation and in time after creation.”


To what does Dr. Craig see time as being relational? To the universe? To God? To some other objective frame of reference?

Well the way I see it is that God doesn’t enter the space-time world he sends temporal agents such as angels and weird liaisons such as the burning bush. Even Jesus was a temporal agent to get around God having to manifest in space time in his own form whatever that is. I can only think of one or two times that God might manifest in his own form here on earth (in our space-time).


Doesn't this imply there are restrictions on your version of God?

And I think that time as we know it did not exist before t-0 of the BB, limited causality did perhaps but we are limited in what we can know before t-0.


Please explain causality without time.

Which premise is based on a series of events? In any case time is not needed to produce a series of events. Events are like these numbers 1-2-3-4-5 we don't need time to see that 2 comes after 1 and before three.


In order for that to be true, you do need some sort of dimension (time, space, or "other"). For a series of events, I accept that you do not need a temporal dimension. However, for causality, you need a time dimension pretty much by definition. Otherwise your linking isn't causal, but spatial.

Began to exist means there was nothing and then there was something. When there was something it began to exist.


This requires a time element, as noted by your use of "and then".

Not valid, unsupported by the observational evidence, and other evidence of the BB model. All the maneuvering in the world will not change the facts. the universe began to exist according to BB cosmology despite the fanatical hope of atheists. Please get used to it. If all this is based on the hope that the universe did not begin to exist I have covered it in detail already.


But you admit that the Big Bang model breaks down before t=0. That alone refutes its utility at making predictions regarding t=0, and refutes its utility at making general statements as to how our universe "began".

If there is no cause for the universe to begin to exist that alone would completely make the KCA toast in a Hiroshima way.


As has been pointed out before, there are many hypotheses, but no knowledge. Claiming the KCA holds water is based on wishful thinking rather than science.
 
Oh now Robin, I think its quite unfair for an atheist to shift the burden of proof to the theist every time.
Sorry, but that's just how it works. You claim these things, you have to support them.

Btw you are lucky I wasn't there for to critique your thread.
Agreed.

I am going to dust off a thread I have posted on several sites that clearly demonstrates why I feel that its unfair for the theist to be saddled with the burden of proof exclusively.
That will be interesting.
 
That may be true for a very, very simplistic view of the world. But atemporality* its topic of discussion among philosophers etc. Time is not what you may think it is. Remember 1-2-3-4 ? Do you need time to tell you two comes after one and before three? Events work the same way when 'time' ** is not present.
Sorry, but that's pure handwaving, and doesn't address the point in any way.
 
By change do you mean implement change?
No, he means change. After all, to implement something is to take action, and action is change.

I am sure you mean the KCA? With the usual suspects making up their own fantasy theories I cant be sure.
What usual suspects, RevD? Or is this just an argumentum ad imaginary hominems?

Nevertheless, I think that God can enter our space time. And I think that time as we know it did not exist before t-0 of the BB, limited causality did perhaps
We've already established this as a contradiction.

but we are limited in what we can know before t-0.
Limited, yes. To nothing.

Which premise is based on a series of events? In any case time is not needed to produce a series of events. Events are like these numbers 1-2-3-4-5 we don't need time to see that 2 comes after 1 and before three.
Handwaving and equivocation.

Numbers are not events.

I have explained this many times, at least five times. When I say before the universe began to exist I mean before time existed
Contradiction in terms.

but even that gets complicated because time according to science was not created until nano seconds after the BB banged t-0.
No.

Time began at T0. That's the definition of T0. What do you think the 0 means?

So again for ease of understanding when I say before the BB I mean before time began to exist
Contradiction.

most popular writers mistakenly say before t-0.
Which is different from what you are saying how, exactly?

Began to exist means there was nothing and then there was something. When there was something it began to exist.
Ah. So this never happens, so your entire argument is built up from a null set.

Wrong wrong wrong!
Wrong how, exactly?

The universe began to exist according to standard big bang cosmology.
It began, certainly. By your definition of "began to exist", no, standard big bang cosmology doesn't say anything about that.

However our model of the BB is shaped like a cone drinking cup the point of the cup is where the universe began to exist. However in say a hawking non empirically supported dreamed up by imaginary numbers (sarcasm he uses them to attempt to rid the universe of the BB singularity and thus God) universe is shaped like a badminton birdie instead of a cone. You notice no pointey tip and no singularity, instead of coming to a point (singularity) you simply just come back into time and start again.
I have no idea what you think you're talking about, much less what this is supposed to mean.

Not valid
What's not valid?

unsupported by the observational evidence and other evidence of the BB model.
What's unsupported?

All the maneuvering in the world will not change the facts.
What are you talking about?

the universe began to exist according to BB cosmology
By your definition of the phrase "began to exist", again, big bang cosmology doesn't speak to this point one way or another.

The Universe began. Whence, we cannot say.

despite the fanatical hope of atheists.
RevD, this is a complete and utter delusion, and an ad hominem attack. Stop it.

Please get used to it.
To modern cosmology? We already are, thanks.

If all this is based on the hope that the universe did not begin to exist I have covered it in detail already.
Yes, you have. You're wrong.

If there is no cause for the universe to begin to exist that alone would completely make the KCA toast in a Hiroshima way.
It was toast before you even started, RevD. Now it's a small pile of blackened crumbs.
 
Bob from NJ said:
At first I abandoned all of my faith, to keep the false parts out. I'm very careful about what to believe, since I messed up my life with error.

We all fail and make gross errors Mr Bob. I have made one that most likely resulted in death, not a day goes by that I don’t think if I had this or that they would still be around

I was happiest not believing at all, or embracing a "Great Spirit" sort of idea; with belief in no God I have peace, with belief in God I have fear; but God's not supposed to be like that so something's wrong.

Well considering the quality of the preachers these days I can not blame you for fearing God.

I couldn't just toss Christ aside lightly- I'm small; who am I to deny Christ?

Hmmm’ I am not so sure what you mean. I have cursed God before and meant it. I am sure I looked like a raving madman , because I was!

Even if the story of Christ is just symbolic, it's still a wonderful miracle cause with it God brought the concepts of forgiveness and repentance into the world, and a cure for guilt and regret. His blood doesn't need to do more than that to be miraculous.

I can’t say that agree but many believe just as you do.

I don't understand what you mean "from human new creature" or "from human to new creature"

That is mountain talk for being born again. I feel as if I am a new person.

; } >
 
Good morning Pixi, man I wish I had the same wake up stuff you do, whats your secret, a mason jar of espresso with a shot coffee ?

: {>
 
Good morning Pixi, man I wish I had the same wake up stuff you do, whats your secret, a mason jar of espresso with a shot coffee ?

: {>

For some great wake up stuff, RevDisturbia, why not try daimoku and the chanting of Nam Myōhō Renge Kyō so as to connect with your own divinity and enact the Mystic Law which permeates all things? It will give you a great energy boost and help you to see the misguided nature of adhering to the limiting concepts of a creator deity character.

Gongyō is great! Defining yourself by an ultimately fruitless and clouding concept of "God"? Not so much.
 
Last edited:
For some great wake up stuff, RevDisturbia, why not try daimoku and the chanting of Nam Myōhō Renge Kyō so as to connect with your own divinity and enact the Mystic Law which permeates all things?
Or tomato juice.

It will give you a great energy boost and help you to see the misguided nature of adhering to the limiting concepts of a creator deity character.
Tomato juice does all that too.

Gongyō is great! Defining yourself by an ultimately fruitless and clouding concept of "God"? Not so much.
Tomatoes are berries.
 
Not valid, unsupported by the observational evidence, and other evidence of the BB model.
I asked for thoughtful rather than quick. Was I being too optimistic?

Let us get this clear - I also believe the universe probably began to exist and had a cause - have you got that now? I have no need to believe the universe does not have a cause.

But the fact that the universe had a cause is borne out by proper science, it does not follow from the argument you presented. OK?

What we are talking about whether premiss P1 in the argument you presented is true

Now refresh your memory about your original P1:
P1: If the universe has no beginning, there have been an infinite number of events.
So in other words you are saying that if the univese was began to exist then there would have been an infinite number of events.

What I am saying is this claim is not true, if the universe did not begin to exist then there would not necessarily have been an infinite number of events.

Thus your conclusion - that the universe began to exist, albeit probably true, does not follow from the argument presented.

I don't get what you don't get about that.
 
Oh now Robin, I think its quite unfair for an atheist to shift the burden of proof to the theist every time.
Oh please, in a thread called "The certainty of God's existence" you are saying that the burden of proof should not be on those who claim to have that certainty?
Btw you are lucky I wasn't there for to critique your thread. Of course it was a short thread how many Christians are there here right now?
There were a lot of Christians around then and others who were non-Christian theists.

I wish you had been there.
 
Last edited:
I have explained this many times, at least five times. When I say before the universe began to exist I mean before time existed, but even that gets complicated because time according to science was not created until nano seconds after the BB banged t-0. So again for ease of understanding when I say before the BB I mean before time began to exist or most popular writers mistakenly say before t-0.
My dictionaries say that "before" means "at an earlier time" or "preceding in time". So by "before" time you mean at a time when time didn't exist, yes?

Or, are you saying that there can be a "before" in something which is not time?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom