RevDisturba
Muse
- Joined
- Feb 1, 2009
- Messages
- 647
Robin said:RevDisturba, You may claim that Craig understands eternity, but his words on the subject are a pitiful muddle as I have shown.
To be honest with you I break company with Dr Craig at some point just after the time is created ie linked with gravity and space. I can also state that every time I begged to differ with the good Dr I was wrong and did not fully understand his concepts. I will attempt to answer for Craig and myself when it delineates from Craig.
He thinks that if an eternal entity chooses to creates a state or object then that state or object would not be "from eternity" (his words). So what would they be from? From a certain time within eternity? Obviously not.
It would be very beneficial if you could use quote tags or direct me back to the original source so I could read Craig’s entire response in context instead on relying on your critiques which may be right or wrong. Thanks in advance! Here is a quote from Craig about eternity ;
“These, then, are the alternatives. A relational* view of time seems superior to a Newtonian view because (1) it is difficult to see how time could exist apart from events and (2) the Newtonian objection that every instant of time implies a prior instant is adequately answered by the relational view. Thus, the proper understanding of God, time, and eternity would be that God exists changelessly and timelessly prior to creation and in time after creation.”
Craig takes a philosophical or theological view of eternity as it relates to time. I take a scientific view and simply equate a temporal with eternity, ie independent of time. This philosophical view leads to problems and at least one paradox. Soren Kierkegaard called this the Absolute Paradox; this is the contradiction of existence: the presence of the Eternal in time, how God can enter the space-time world without ceasing to be the Eternal. Well the way I see it is that God doesn’t enter the space-time world he sends temporal agents such as angels and weird liaisons such as the burning bush. Even Jesus was a temporal agent to get around God having to manifest in space time in his own form whatever that is. I can only think of one or two times that God might manifest in his own form here on earth (in our space-time).
He seems to think that the man in his example who was sitting from eternity and chose to stand would be standing after he was sitting. Again, obviously not. In eternity there would be no ordering of the sitting and standing states. So if a man is sitting from eternity and chooses to stand he is standing from eternity.
Ha yes! You should read his paper titled God time and eternity. He discusses in length your concerns. However as I said I don’t agree with some of Craigs interpretations and concepts of time. Again I differ from Craig in that I think time if it can be called that prior to time zero of the big bang is reduced to simple causality independent of time.
So what else can he mean by this justification unless he is treating eternity as though it were an infinite regress of time?
To be honest I am not sure.
http://www.reasonablefaith.org/site/News2?page=NewsArticle&id=5161#text1
In any case you have been using the term undefined here, and I have provided a full definition of how I am using "eternity"
I said eternity is independent of time or not effected by time.
So first key question: Can an eternal entity change?
By change do you mean implement change?
I already defined the concept clearly before I used it, you will find my definition in D1 and D2 of my interpretation of the KCM (which I have been regularly bumping). That is what I mean by a series of events.
I am sure you mean the KCA? With the usual suspects making up their own fantasy theories I cant be sure.
Nevertheless, I think that God can enter our space time. And I think that time as we know it did not exist before t-0 of the BB, limited causality did perhaps but we are limited in what we can know before t-0.
A key premise of the KCA is based upon the concept "series of events", if it is undefined then I think we have a problem Houston.
Which premise is based on a series of events? In any case time is not needed to produce a series of events. Events are like these numbers 1-2-3-4-5 we don't need time to see that 2 comes after 1 and before three.
"Before" the universe began? You mean in the time prior to to time when there was no time?![]()
I have explained this many times, at least five times. When I say before the universe began to exist I mean before time existed, but even that gets complicated because time according to science was not created until nano seconds after the BB banged t-0. So again for ease of understanding when I say before the BB I mean before time began to exist or most popular writers mistakenly say before t-0.
You seem to be using the term "begin to exist" to describe the situation that in some ordered set of states there is a state that does not include the universe followed by a state that does? Yes?
Began to exist means there was nothing and then there was something. When there was something it began to exist.
Using the definition "began to exist", there is a false dichotomy in P1 and it should read:
Wrong wrong wrong! The universe began to exist according to standard big bang cosmology. This is not to say that there are not other theories new and modified versions of the BB that allow for the universe not beginning to exist (I have covered this as well).
However our model of the BB is shaped like a cone drinking cup the point of the cup is where the universe began to exist. However in say a hawking non empirically supported dreamed up by imaginary numbers (sarcasm he uses them to attempt to rid the universe of the BB singularity and thus God) universe is shaped like a badminton birdie instead of a cone. You notice no pointey tip and no singularity, instead of coming to a point (singularity) you simply just come back into time and start again.
However (and there are always a however's) as I have said so many times these theories are just that weak unsupported theory unlike the big bang model we use which has empirical evidence galore.
P1: If the universe did not begin to exist then either there was an infinite regress or causality is not exclusively sequential
Not valid, unsupported by the observational evidence, and other evidence of the BB model. All the maneuvering in the world will not change the facts. the universe began to exist according to BB cosmology despite the fanatical hope of atheists. Please get used to it. If all this is based on the hope that the universe did not begin to exist I have covered it in detail already.
So third key question: Do you agree that this more accurately describes the situation, if not, why not?
No heck no! I described why above. I will be happy to expand or provide references on request.
Final key question: Do you agree that to be consistent P1 should be applied to the cause of the universe if there is one?
If there is no cause for the universe to begin to exist that alone would completely make the KCA toast in a Hiroshima way.
Thanks for your reply. I am sure you will want clarification because I wasn’t so sure of the questions at the beginning of the reply.
; {>