The certainty of God's existence.

Having been in many forums where I held the minority view I can understand your feelings but I honestly don't think you get a lot of hate. I think it's more about ego and firm convections more than anything. Most importantly you are not above the fray.

I don't think there is a lot of true hate, just the kind that is built up with no one to take it out on. However I could name some names. But I won't, one reason being I just have to fart too loud to get a warning or infraction !

I am used to that as well in a forum with atheist moderators and a majority of atheist members. No worries, as my drill sgt told me, "if you like me I am not doing my job.I would rather you want to frag me than go into combat and get killed for me being too easy on you".

; {>
 
Last edited:
I don't think there is a lot of true hate, just the kind that is built up with no one to take it out on. However I could name some names. But I won't, one reason being I just have to fart too loud to get a warning or infraction !
I've gotten an infraction. Search Form Management for name and you will find me complaigning. For one I've recieved infraction for being off topic in yrreg's threads.

I am used to that as well in a forum with atheist moderators and a majority of atheist members.
The mods are human but they are some of the most consistently fair folk I've ever seen.

No worries, as my drill sgt told me, "if you like me I am not doing my job.I would rather you want to frag me than go into combat and get killed for me being too easy on you".
Cool.
 
I am used to that as well in a forum with atheist moderators and a majority of atheist members. No worries, as my drill sgt told me, "if you like me I am not doing my job.I would rather you want to frag me than go into combat and get killed for me being too easy on you".

; {>

Winning peoples hearts and minds to the path of true salvation and enlightenment can be achieved by peaceful means that need not create conflict. Through the venerable act of shaku buku I will apply the same logic and reason you would use to show you that your feelings and beliefs about Jesus Christ and a believe in god are misguided. Here is a biography of the blessed and amazing life of the True Buddha who appears in the Latter Day of the Law to establish the true Buddhism which will enable all mankind to attain Buddhahood, Nichiren Daishōnin 日蓮大聖人.

You can learn about his persecutions and how the heavens themselves intervened in the attempt to excecute him, which no mortal was able to do. RevDisturbia, you, too, can attain Buddahood in your life. However, you will first have to take on the Four Great Vows. Here is a paper on Nichiren Buddhism and Christianity which will allow you to begin understanding that what you call "God" is really the Mystic Law...

Buddhism and Christianity - Do Buddhists Believe in God?

Peace
 
Well I am telling you you are WRONG. I could say that you imply that you hate all Christians. would that make it true? Even if you denied it?
So when you said that you would place atheists at 5 on a scale from 1 -10 with, presumably, child murderers at 1 and Christians at 10 you weren't implying any sort of moral hierarchy? You don't think an atheist would be justified in taking offense at such a bigoted remark?

Don't get a job reading minds you are a failure at it.
Why do I suspect that if someone else had said this to you it would be placed on your laundry list of "brutal attacks"?

That is a fact.
That is not a fact, it is your assertion. You have no idea how generous atheists are relative to theists.

If you have a guilt complex its not my problem. I was defending a brutal attack against christian icons and ideals from an irate member. So try to man up and look at it in context instead of attempting to soil my words?
Guilt complex? Because you seek to apply your straw man to me? Not likely. And having you impugn my masculinity shames me not. I've seen your words. You have implied your delight at the prospect of seeing me punished by your god and you have declared the moral inferiority of atheists. Many of your words have plenty of soil of their own.

The only thing I base on the rarity of explicitly atheist charity is the rarity of explicitly atheist charity, while defending my beliefs against an attack.
And you conveniently ignore reasons why explicitly atheist charities would be as rare as explicitly non-stamp-collecting charities. Does the rarity of explicitly non-stamp-collecting charities indicate to you that people who don't collect stamps are selfish?

Well what do you mean by doctrine, the atheist manifesto?

Amazon.com: Atheist Manifesto: The Case Against Christianity ...
Amazon.com: Atheist Manifesto: The Case Against Christianity, Judaism, and Islam (9781559708203): Michel Onfray: Books.
www.amazon.com/Atheist-Manifesto-Against.../1559708204 -
No. I mean an actual doctrine, not a book about atheism. Do you know what a doctrine is? Can you give evidence of an atheist doctrine that includes tenets that all theist subscribe to?

"This does not necessarily mean that atheists positively believe that there is no god. It simply means that they advocate a lifestyle that is devoid of one. They live their lives as if there were no god.

Atheism can be further broken down into the following sub-categories:

* Weak Atheist - lacks a belief in god or gods, and acknowledges that it is presumptuous to say for sure there is no god, although in the absence of any evidence, contends it is unlikely and not worthy of consideration

99% of most atheists are the "weak" variety, even though most theists' idea of atheism is something different:

* Strong Atheist - believes that there is no God; some argue this position, which is uncommon among atheists, is as equally presumptuous as claiming there is a god (It is accepted that it's virtually impossible to prove a negative, that something does not exist)

A typical atheist may be strong towards a specific deity such as Jesus, claiming that they are confident the Christian god does not exist. Likewise a Christian may be a strong atheist towards the Hindu gods. "

http://freethoughtpedia.com/wiki/Atheism
And your point would be what?

Perhaps you are measuring from your own cup.
I am not a strong atheist. That is your unjustified assumption.

Not everyone is an strong atheist (although it sure would simplify things if there were only strong atheists).
How would it simplify things?
 
I can't speak for anyone else here but I didn't form my beliefs by point and click so don't expect to find or classify them by point and click.

Don't look in a pigeon-hole for my beliefs, because you won't find them there.

I formed my beliefs through years of open-minded research, reading, studying, wide-ranging discussions, honest seeking and deep, hard thinking.

You don't have to go to a Wiki to find my beliefs, you only need to ask and I will say.

I will state my beliefs in the clearest and most consistent language of which I am capable.

Here is the starting point:

Never assert anything as true unless I believe I can justify it

Never assume that I cannot be wrong in anything

When any assertion depends upon a word, phrase or term I try as much as humanly possible to ensure that I have a rigorous and clear definition of the word and that I keep to that one definition.

If I cannot provide a satisfactory response to a challenge then I need to rethink the belief​
 
Last edited:
I've gotten an infraction. Search Form Management for name and you will find me complaigning. For one I've recieved infraction for being off topic in yrreg's threads.

The mods are human but they are some of the most consistently fair folk I've ever seen.

Cool.

Well I agree with all but the last sentence. I am sure most of them (mods) are like a cross section of any group, most good, some bad with an ax to grind and a bully pulpit to do it at. But I have had the ummm'... I have only met one moderator and that one has taken a special interest in me.

You and I got off on the wrong track, then on then off then on :o maybe from here on out we can display mutual respect for each other.

I am a very good judge of character and people. I think you have a big heart (too big maybe) and are a good guy that goes out of his way to help others....just a hunch.

; {>
 
Last edited:
I can't speak for anyone else here but I didn't form my beliefs by point and click so don't expect to find or classify them by point and click.

Don't look in a pigeon-hole for my beliefs, because you won't find them there.

I formed my beliefs through years of open-minded research, reading, studying, wide-ranging discussions, honest seeking and deep, hard thinking.

You don't have to go to a Wiki to find my beliefs, you only need to ask and I will say.

I will state my beliefs in the clearest and most consistent language of which I am capable.

Here is the starting point:

Never assert anything as true unless I believe I can justify it

Never assume that I cannot be wrong in anything

When any assertion depends upon a word, phrase or term I try as much as humanly possible to ensure that I have a rigorous and clear definition of the word and that I keep to that one definition.

If I cannot provide a satisfactory response to a challenge then I need to rethink the belief​

I am am truly sorry Robin for not answering your posts! I PROMISE I will have a look at them later tonight or in the morning....

; }>
 
How would it simplify things?
Presumably because it is easier to attack a position than to defend one.

I can sympathise but we cannot avoid the fact that the theist is the claimant and the atheist is not.

In fact I once put my reasons for believing there was no God and it was probably just about the shortest thread in JREF history and nobody actually addressed my arguments.
 
That depends entirely on what ontological argument you are speaking of. Godel was showing evidence for a personal God.

I cannot remember Godel's off the top of my head, but I'd wager to say it is not going to knock me off my feet. God in Godel's OA is probably about as much of a "personal God" as the God of Plantinga's OA is omnipotent, omniscient, and wholly good.



I simply think the analogy does not make sense when speaking about God.

It makes perfect sense when talking about the Gods of various ontological arguments. If you feel it does not make sense for God per se ... *smug grin*


There are well known attributes of a philosophical God. Now as I said I don't use ontological arguments to defend my paradigm, so much of this is moot, I do however use cosmological arguments.

In my opinion you'd be better served by a modal ontological argument.


(I really mean it, and yes that does not exactly express a very positive opinion on cosmological arguments. ;))



Lord Emsworth said:
However it does not hold true, that if you have shown your ontological argument of choice to be 'correct,' that therefore your God conception of choice is true. It does not follow, that even if the IPU met the general definitons of your ontological argument of choice (for instance the IPU is necessary being) that it shows the existence of the IPU.

I still don't follow that line of reasoning.

Put more bluntly:
If the IPU exists it is also necessary being.
We have necessary being. (via a most bare modal OA for instance)
Therefore the IPU exist.

You surely agree that this does not follow. It will also not follow for most people's (real) conceptions of God, and it will also not follow for different OAs apart from the most bare modal OAs.
 
I cannot remember Godel's off the top of my head, but I'd wager to say it is not going to knock me off my feet.
Whether Goedel's argument is about a personal God would of course depend upon whether intelligence could objectively be classified a "positive" attribute.

The problem with the Goedelian ontological argument is that it implicitly assumes that there could be an independent standard against which a God could be judged. If you don't buy this assumption then the argument is a non-starter.

Atheists obviously would not accept the premiss without justification and even many theists would reject it. C.S. Lewis might accept that premiss, but William Lane Craig - a professed Paleyan in this respect - would have to reject Goedel's ontological argument if he is to be consistent.
 
n. Atheism
2. The doctrine that there is no God or gods.

I'm going to venture a guess that definition 1 was along the lines of "disbelief in the existence of God or any other deity".

But just to be clear, the definition of "doctrine":

1. a particular principle, position, or policy taught or advocated, as of a religion or government: Catholic doctrines; the Monroe Doctrine.
2. something that is taught; teachings collectively: religious doctrine.
3. a body or system of teachings relating to a particular subject: the doctrine of the Catholic Church.

Synonyms:
1. tenet, dogma, theory, precept, belief.

What I said, "There are no specifically atheistic beliefs other than the lack of belief in gods", still stands. Atheism is not a body or system of teachings. It is simply a lack of belief in gods.
 
Perhaps not. Merriam-Webster had this to say:

1 archaic : ungodliness, wickedness
2 a : a disbelief in the existence of deity b : the doctrine that there is no deity

True. But then the Oxford English Dictionary defines it as "disbelief in, or denial of, the existence of a god". There's no mention of "doctrines" at all.
 
True. But then the Oxford English Dictionary defines it as "disbelief in, or denial of, the existence of a god". There's no mention of "doctrines" at all.

I was more interested in the possibilities for the missing definition #1. I was asserting the possibility RevDisturba's source also lead with the archaic meaning, and RevDisturba has kind enough to omit it as not relevant.
 
Whether Goedel's argument is about a personal God would of course depend upon whether intelligence could objectively be classified a "positive" attribute.

The problem with the Goedelian ontological argument is that it implicitly assumes that there could be an independent standard against which a God could be judged. If you don't buy this assumption then the argument is a non-starter.

And what if that standard is not independent of God, but instead packet and parcel with it? Means, that any attribute that God possesses is by definition positive. I don't think it is impossible, just very trivial.
 
Hi and welcome new guy.

Sorry to see you have apostatized...



Still it took ten more years to complete the metamorphosis from human new creature. Sounds creepy, I like it!

; {>

At first I abandoned all of my faith, to keep the false parts out. I'm very careful about what to believe, since I messed up my life with error.
I was happiest not believing at all, or embracing a "Great Spirit" sort of idea; with belief in no God I have peace, with belief in God I have fear; but God's not supposed to be like that so something's wrong.

I couldn't just toss Christ aside lightly- I'm small; who am I to deny Christ?

Even if the story of Christ is just symbolic, it's still a wonderful miracle cause with it God brought the concepts of forgiveness and repentance into the world, and a cure for guilt and regret. His blood doesn't need to do more than that to be miraculous.

I don't understand what you mean "from human new creature" or "from human to new creature"
 
I was happiest not believing at all, or embracing a "Great Spirit" sort of idea; with belief in no God I have peace, with belief in God I have fear; but God's not supposed to be like that so something's wrong.
What was it you feared?
 
Well I agree with all but the last sentence. I am sure most of them (mods) are like a cross section of any group, most good, some bad with an ax to grind and a bully pulpit to do it at. But I have had the ummm'... I have only met one moderator and that one has taken a special interest in me.

You and I got off on the wrong track, then on then off then on :o maybe from here on out we can display mutual respect for each other.

I am a very good judge of character and people. I think you have a big heart (too big maybe) and are a good guy that goes out of his way to help others....just a hunch.
Fair enough. Thanks.

BTW: My bark is much worse than my bite. Some times I can come accross strident when I'm really not and I don't mind giving an appology where it is due.

Cheers.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom