The certainty of God's existence.

Wrong in my humble opinion. A correct statement would be there is no empirical proof that an intelligent agent exists.
Words are not physical laws of the universe and I only care that your usage of a word is understood by those who you are communicating with. If by evidence you mean any pretext to suppose that there could be a god then yeah. That said, IMO you have stipped the word of any meaning.

Evidence in its broadest sense includes everything that is used to determine or demonstrate the truth of an assertion.

I can think that fairy stools are evidence of fairies but it doesn't make it true.
 
Yes, you do attempt to mold me in your own twisted ideas of what a christian is.
I'm sorry but there simply is no defense IMO for such a statement. And no, there is no such molding.

I don't know who you are and being unable to look into your heart I don't know how to judge your intent or the events of your life that make you the person that you are.

As humans we all make mistakes. Most if not all of us indulge our ego from time to time or see ourselves as the persecuted guys in white hats. Thats fine but when you really come to believe that others are evil and are deserving of god's punishment then I think you've crossed a line. I find that ugly for anyone but I find it contemptible for one who makes Christianity a hallmark of his or hare life and then seeks to justify it with scriptures of Christ throwining people out of the temple. If there is a god (seriously doubtful) then it is he who will sit in judgement and not you which is reason behind the exhortation to judge not.

"If We Could Read the Secret History of Our Enemies, We Should Find in Each Person's Life Sorrow and Suffering Enough to disarm All Hostility." —Henry Wadsworth Longfellow

There are a handful of people alive or who have lived that I would want to see punished in a next life (assuming for a moment that there was one). Some anonymous person on the Internet who I think is rude or abusive isn't included in that group if for no other reason than I realize my own bias and human falibilities.

I'll let it go but I do so disappointingly.
 
Last edited:
After some research it appears that Darwin went to his death an agnostic. Darwin did not recant. Lady Hope claimed to of been by Darwin's bedside and said that he recanted. However his family denied the story along with some other convincing proof.

You and I obviously differ greatly when it comes to how we view the world, and to be honest I think you are a bit smug at times. But it takes a big man to look at evidence, change his view on things and admit it. That earns you some respect from me at least.

I will check it out, thanks for the heads up. I have often wondered why there wasn't a lot of atheist aid groups. If I were an wealthy atheist I would found one.

Many wealthy atheists do. Bill Gates is a great example, as one of the greatest philantropists of our times. However, most atheists do it pure and simply for charity, not for what they believe or don't believe in. They want to help people. That's their only agenda.

These reasons ;

University of Minnesota Study on American Attitudes Towards ...
It's not just that atheists are hated, though, but also that atheists seem to ... Research Finds that Atheists are Most Despised, Most Distrusted Minority ...
atheism.about.com/.../atheistbigotryprejudice/a/AtheitsHated.htm


Atheists obviously need some good massive PR to correct the bigotry and misinformation that exists. A huge atheist philanthropy in the model of any humanitarian missions/groups etc would be a great start.

Do you often think it's the responsibility of despised minorities to have to use 'massive PR' to gain acceptance? Shouldn't it rather be the job of the bigots to improve themselves?

In my country, atheists are not a despised minority. In fact, it's seen as the default position. That's mostly because those that don't believe haven't been vilified for decades like in the USA.

Anyway, if you've already left the thread, so be it. I really do appreciate you engaging in a dialogue, and it's been an interesting read.
 
RandFan, thanks for that video link upthread; I hadn't seen it before, since I never seem to make it to my weekly atheist meetings. (Shhhh, I'm really just avoiding the commitment to tithing.)

The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation is a pretty big humanitarian organization, headed up by a non-believer, and also now partly financed by huge contributions from Warren Buffett, another non-believer. But why would they put atheist anywhere in the title, when it has nothing to do with the aid they're giving? (eta: Ryokan had the same thought as I did.)
 
Last edited:
Ignored for personal content and an exhaustively beaten dead horse.

Don't respond but say you responded and then call it a dead horse. I've no doubt it works but it's not very honest. Calling it personal content is rather disengenous as well.
 
I give money to the Red Cross, to the World Wildlife Fund - and to the Salvation Army.

Yep, the Salvation Army is my primary charity as well - I like the fact that only about $.01 on the dollar goes to overhead.

So I'm only half way between you and people who mutilate and kill children.

Is it all right if we just skip Jesus altogether and worship you?

:D
 
How odd. You seem to imagine that atheists have something in common beyond a lack of belief in gods. They don't. How then would they form groups as atheists? Do you form groups on the basis of what you do not believe? Are there humanitarian aid groups run by those who do not believe in the tooth fairy and have banded together on that basis?

ETA: PixyMisa said this better than me :)

Theists seem to think that atheists non belief in god dominates their lives like the belief in god dominates theirs.
 
The National Association of Free Will Baptists, which I have never even heard of, has more churches than the American Atheists have members.

[/quote]

Oh, I've heard of them, all right, probably because I can practically see their headquarters from my house. I don't know why ALL the Baptists seem to be based here... the Southern Baptists... the Primitive Baptists... the Freewill Baptists... The Boy Scouts (they were taken over by the Southern Baptists 20 years ago)... anyway, the FWB beliefs are a little odd, if you ask me. Basically, if you EVER decide that you don't believe in God anymore, that's it-- you're going straight to hell! You do NOT get a second chance. :eek: Not the best deal, IMHO.

The Hitchens bio of Mother Teresa was mentioned a couple of pages ago, and I've read that too. It's one of those books where I kind of wish I hadn't read it. The research was clearly very well done, and I think I didn't really want to know what Hitchens came up with about her. But the truth is more important than holding onto illusions.
 
Last edited:
As for my beliefs how long do you have? :hypnotize Loosely said I am a open theist, red letter christian* that does not believe in a burning hell for humans, and subscribes to the love of money is the root of all evil the end is near (maybe) doctrine. :hypnotize

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red-Letter_Christian

; {>

RevDisturba, I think you may benefit from this post I made for member LightningStrike in the "Why Don't You Believe In God" thread. I think you, too, would benefit from shaku buku and being led to the true path to universal love and enlightement as a bodhisattva (enlightened one) attained within this lifetime. The flawed concept of God can only blind you to the true wisdom and divinity of Shakyamuni Buddha and the Lotus Sutra.

Peace.

No. I can't tell you how to do it. But I can tell you how I do it. It is all to do with attraction. It just depends what's most attracting at any time in my system.

The way is to be conscious of "me" the most intimate place inside all the time, and this does not preclude being conscious in the senses at the same time.

It is the inner that is the realm of love and the outer reflects the inner. Love of woman is very important she reflects a love to me that I do not intrinsically have as man. That is why we are attracted. In Lovemaking what's most attracting? It is the 'female' and how she appears so beautiful when truly loved. She is God in existence for me man.

Concepts of God are all wrong. I can't know anything about God out of existence but I can love it. Out of existence is accessed through "me" the intimate place inside. So you are right you can only love Love.
I see. I think, LightningStrike, that I can be of great assistance to you. I would like to show the means to understand true love and enlightenment and becoming a bodhisattva (enlightened one). What you need to do is abandon that flawed concept of God and embark on the true path to wisdom and everlasting love. That Golden Path is found through the Lotus Sutra and the enactment of its power through the chanting of Nam Myōhō Renge Kyō 南無妙法蓮華經. Your guide on this path to true existential liberation is Nichiren Daishōnin 日蓮大聖人 whom we might call in English the Great Sage Nichiren (though he is sometimes referred to in reverence for his divine wisdom and guidance as Nichiren Daibosatsu 日蓮大菩薩 "Great Bodhisattva Nichiren", and Risshō Daishi 立正大師 "Great Teacher Risshō").

I will engage for your benefit in the most venerable act of shaku buku, which is the effort to convert others by refuting their current beliefs and convincing them of the validity of Nichiren's teachings. In this way I can lead you through logic and reason to love and enlightenment. Nichiren Daishōnin expounded in great detail about women, I'm glad to tell you, and how romantic love fits within a greater whole of love. What needs to be impressed at present is the importance of the Lotus Sutra where we can find the highest teachings of Shakyamuni Buddha and the fact that that all people have an innate Buddha nature and are therefore inherently capable of attaining enlightenment in their current form and present lifetime. Yes, I know. It's hard to believe, but believe me, it's true.

This is done through the assiduous practice, Gongyō 勤行 which can be done in temple or at home. Gongyō is the formalized service of chanting daimoku (Nam Myōhō Renge Kyō). The purpose of chanting daimoku is to attain perfect and complete awakening (enlightenment). You can learn more about daimoku and the meaning of Nam Myōhō Renge Kyō here. Gongyō also features a recitation of the Four Great Vows which I will teach to you...

Sentient beings are innumerable; I vow to save them all.

Our evil desires are inexhaustible; I vow to quench them all.

The Buddha's teachings are immeasurable; I vow to study them all.

The way of the Buddha is unexcelled; I vow to attain the path sublime.


I hope this introduction to the way to true love and enlightenment as a bodhisattva reached within your lifetime has been valuable to you, LightningStrike. Please feel free to ask me questions about this.
 
Ok, yes this thread is not what it usta' be when Gerry was allowed in. ;)

I too am getting kind of over this thread as well...but I have a few cheeks left and a mote to get out or my eye according to Randy the Candy avatar look alike man...

; {>

I am hitching my pony up to my new thread topic ..."Specified Complexity the hallmark of Intelligent Design" I am not sure where it will end up at....

I will visit here as well....

How can something that does not exist have complexity?
 
I get a lot directed my way, its difficult to ignore when you are in my shoes.
Having been in many forums where I held the minority view I can understand your feelings but I honestly don't think you get a lot of hate. I think it's more about ego and firm convections more than anything. Most importantly you are not above the fray.
 
Lord Emsworth said:
Neither of these have anything to do with what I said?

Whatever, with all due respect I think they do.

Ah. But people don't agree to the conditions. People expect something more as the referrent of the word "God". Not a general something, anything. Rather something specific. Your own reply shows that:

Some people do some don't. Some people know that if it has the attributes of its necessarily God.

And here is the very first instance. You have your own definition of when something is "God" and when not: "supernatural/metaphysical first cause" (however meaningful that may be). That is not necessarily that what is being shown, or 'argued' in an ontological argument. ;)

That depends entirely on what ontological argument you are speaking of. Godel was showing evidence for a personal God.

To make use of my analogy once more. You already expect particulars about the peak of the mountain. Not anything will do. While it does have to be the highest point (general definition of "peak"), there are also additional requirements beyond that, for instance that the peak has got to be covered in pixy dust.

I simply think the analogy does not make sense when speaking about God. There are well known attributes of a philosophical God. Now as I said I don't use ontological arguments to defend my paradigm, so much of this is moot, I do however use cosmological arguments.

That can only hold true, if the same thing is being described. And that is a big if.

I will take the big 'if' ;).

No, that is not where I am going. But incidentally it would be true that if the FSM (I prefer the IPU) met the criteria of the ontological argument that is being used, then yes it would be God. And if we could show the FSM or IPU to exist then we would have found out more specifically what God is.

That’ s true, if the FSM met the attributes of God who cares what he looks like? In fact that is why I think the god of the bible doesn't manifest in this universe without using an temporal liaison, but that's another thread.

However it does not hold true, that if you have shown your ontological argument of choice to be 'correct,' that therefore your God conception of choice is true. It does not follow, that even if the IPU met the general definitons of your ontological argument of choice (for instance the IPU is necessary being) that it shows the existence of the IPU.[/qutoe]

I still don't follow that line of reasoning.

But that was not where I was going to as I said. I was more thinking into the exact opposite direction. I was thinking that your preconceived notion of "God" as something 'supernatural' would not be found in a modal ontological argument where "God" is necessary being. Instead there is nothing that would even barr anything 'natural' from counting as "God" as well.

I agree with that. So then we would have to decide on what is the most reasonable rational choice. As I said I just want to get God (a being that can create the universe) into the universe. After that I break from Dr Craig (which is most likely a grave mistake) and work backwards to make a case for a personal God. However I tried to post a rational and reasonable discussion in a new thread supporting that idea (ID & Specified Complexity) but due to the hecklers and instigators I could not discuss it intelligently. Its was the same as a book burning.

As I said, the soundness (or truthfulness) of the premises and the validity of the KCA make for great red herrings, don't they? And it even concludes Gee Ohh Dee!

The premises (of the KCA) are sound. 1-2-3. If you don’t think so its not the end of the world, we can agree to disagree.

; {>
 
Last edited:
RevDisturba,

You may claim that Craig understands eternity, but his words on the subject are a pitiful muddle as I have shown.

He thinks that if an eternal entity chooses to creates a state or object then that state or object would not be "from eternity" (his words). So what would they be from? From a certain time within eternity? Obviously not.

He seems to think that the man in his example who was sitting from eternity and chose to stand would be standing after he was sitting. Again, obviously not. In eternity there would be no ordering of the sitting and standing states. So if a man is sitting from eternity and chooses to stand he is standing from eternity.

So what else can he mean by this justification unless he is treating eternity as though it were an infinite regress of time?

In any case you have been using the term undefined here, and I have provided a full definition of how I am using "eternity"

So first key question: Can an eternal entity change?
What do you mean by series of events?
I already defined the concept clearly before I used it, you will find my definition in D1 and D2 of my interpretation of the KCM (which I have been regularly bumping). That is what I mean by a series of events.

A key premise of the KCM is based upon the concept "series of events", if it is undefined then I think we have a problem Houston.

So second key question: What do you mean be a series of events, as used in the KCM?
I mean begin as before the universe began there was nothing material. No space, no time, no energy, no subatomic particles, no quantum loop gravity, no quantum foam, nothing that could be considered material.

I hope that helps.
"Before" the universe began? You mean in the time prior to to time when there was no time? :)

You seem to be using the term "begin to exist" to describe the situation that in some ordered set of states there is a state that does not include the universe followed by a state that does? Yes?

Using the definition "began to exist", there is a false dichotomy in P1 and it should read:

P1: If the universe did not begin to exist then either there was an infinite regress or causality is not exclusively sequential​
So third key question: Do you agree that this more accurately describes the situation, if not, why not?

Final key question: Do you agree that to be consistent P1 should be applied to the cause of the universe if there is one?
 
Last edited:
Foster Zygote said:
Your intent was clear from your statement: you were implying that atheists were morally inferior to theists.

Well I am telling you you are WRONG. I could say that you imply that you hate all Christians. would that make it true? Even if you denied it?

You were implying

Don't get a job reading minds you are a failure at it.

that atheists don't contribute to humanitarian causes in the way that theists do.

That is a fact. If you have a guilt complex its not my problem. I was defending a brutal attack against christian icons and ideals from an irate member. So try to man up and look at it in context instead of attempting to soil my words?

You base this on the rarity of explicitly atheist charity and aid organizations.

The only thing I base on the rarity of explicitly atheist charity is the rarity of explicitly atheist charity, while defending my beliefs against an attack.

What you fail to understand, despite your assurances to the contrary, is that atheism is not a doctrine.

Hmmm.....

n. Atheism
2. The doctrine that there is no God or gods.

http://www.answers.com/topic/atheism

There may be an doctrine in the atheist manifesto, who knows?

Amazon.com: Atheist Manifesto: The Case Against Christianity ...
Amazon.com: Atheist Manifesto: The Case Against Christianity, Judaism, and Islam (9781559708203): Michel Onfray: Books.
www.amazon.com/Atheist-Manifesto-Against.../1559708204 -

There are no specifically atheistic beliefs other than the lack of belief in gods.

"This does not necessarily mean that atheists positively believe that there is no god. It simply means that they advocate a lifestyle that is devoid of one. They live their lives as if there were no god.

Atheism can be further broken down into the following sub-categories:

* Weak Atheist - lacks a belief in god or gods, and acknowledges that it is presumptuous to say for sure there is no god, although in the absence of any evidence, contends it is unlikely and not worthy of consideration

99% of most atheists are the "weak" variety, even though most theists' idea of atheism is something different:

* Strong Atheist - believes that there is no God; some argue this position, which is uncommon among atheists, is as equally presumptuous as claiming there is a god (It is accepted that it's virtually impossible to prove a negative, that something does not exist)

A typical atheist may be strong towards a specific deity such as Jesus, claiming that they are confident the Christian god does not exist. Likewise a Christian may be a strong atheist towards the Hindu gods. "

http://freethoughtpedia.com/wiki/Atheism

Perhaps you are measuring from your own cup. Not everyone is an strong atheist (although it sure would simplify things if there were only strong atheists).

; {>

Wee Oh Its thunder and hailing ...time to break from this whipping post
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom