The certainty of God's existence.

"Drop Kick Me Jesus Through the Goalposts of Life"-- 6,010 hits.
:) Nothing like musical appreciation, I always say!


When we realize that atheists are a minority that range from 2.5% (atheist) of the world's population to 12.7% (non-religious) according to Wikipedia, your figures Maia, only tell me that atheists like to evangelize more than the religious types. Or search on Google more, who knows?

;{>
 
Last edited:
Do you know any religious fanatics who can think for themselves,Pax?

Fanatics of all ilks have a difficult time expressing themselves rationally eh? That word 'fanatic' is the prime mover in that sentence. They by definition usually have a ulterior motive other than their title.

; {>
 
So you keep claiming.
Gotcha in what way? Via a useless lame attempt in blinding me with an irrelevant point?

Perhaps you have empirical evidence that proves the universe did not begin? Additionally. Please lets keep the taunting rhetoric to yourself, this forum is better than that. I usually don't answer any reply that has a hint of hate or taunt in it because it leads down a slippery slope of derailing the thread and getting off topic. This paragraph proves it, as does the majority of the content in your reply.

Note that the universe began 13.7* years ago is basic well accepted cosmology. Of course there has been concerted efforts to avoid saying that the universe began to exist in the popular press and pop science magazines. I think the reason for this is because the BB does prove that the universe began, and that fits so well with theistic explanations cosmology. (science wrongly claimed the universe was eternal and static ie unchanging up until at least the mid 20the century).

The 'Gotcha' remark alluded to the fact that the BB isn't a black hole, and the singularity is much different. I may edit my original reply for clarity, however no one has yet to say the singularity remark was grossly incorrect.

*From the web ; "Observations suggest that the universe as we know it began around 13.7 billion years ago.This timeline of the Big Bang describes the events according to the widely accepted scientific theory of the Big Bang, using the cosmological time parameter of comoving coordinates.This timeline of the Big Bang describes the events according to the widely accepted scientific theory of the Big Bang, using the cosmological time parameter of comoving coordinates."

http://www.answers.com/topic/timeline-of-the-big-bang

; {>
 
Last edited:
Wow, I was mildly amused when I first saw the checklist..but now I've seen it a few times since then and he's following it exactly. I don't understand the thread - is he making any arguments for God or is he doing "look, look OTHER people are certain, and I agree with them"? Seriously, I'm unsure what he wants.
 
Wow, I was mildly amused when I first saw the checklist..but now I've seen it a few times since then and he's following it exactly. I don't understand the thread - is he making any arguments for God or is he doing "look, look OTHER people are certain, and I agree with them"? Seriously, I'm unsure what he wants.
As someone who follows yrreg's threads out of morbid curiousity in the same way you can't take your eyes off a car crash, I know how you feel.
 
I am hoping to explain to myself before the posters and readers of this forum my certainty of God's existence....
Just one request to posters here, please don't waste the time of readers here and the forum's bandwidth.

If you have trouble understanding this, you may want to listen to the sound of one hand for awhile. Also, if you have eaten your rice, go and wash your rice bowl. Then you may begin to understand that there is no understanding and no certainty.

The example is incorrect because it mixes arithmetic using finite quantities with arithmetic using infinite quantities.

What in the hell is going on in this thread? :confused:
 
Perhaps you have empirical evidence that proves the universe did not begin?
You made a claim and when called to support your claim, you reply with a," Prove me wrong"?
Special Pleading at its finest.
Additionally. Please lets keep the taunting rhetoric to yourself, this forum is better than that. I usually don't answer any reply that has a hint of hate or taunt in it because it leads down a slippery slope of derailing the thread and getting off topic. This paragraph proves it, as does the majority of the content in your reply.
Psssst...Ryokan? Ryokan ! Hey Ryokan!!!...Ya' there my friend?

; {>
An attempt at Poisoning the Well? Hypocrisy at its finest.
Note that the universe began 13.7* years ago is basic well accepted cosmology.
No.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planck_epoch
An entire argument based on a completely false premise. Sounds ever so familiar.
Of course there has been concerted efforts to avoid saying that the universe began to exist in the popular press and pop science magazines.
Except in the most colloquial sense but yes, the "popular press" and "pop science" and just about most cosmologists avoids saying the Big Bang is the "beginning" since it is a false statement. Strange huh?
I think the reason for this is because the BB does prove that the universe began, and that fits so well with theistic explanations cosmology. (science wrongly claimed the universe was eternal and static ie unchanging up until at least the mid 20the century).
Since your statement continues to be false, you conclusion is invalid. But then attempting to lay claim to the achievement of others, is religion's forte.
Prop Hoc Ergo Propter Hoc at its finest.
The 'Gotcha' remark alluded to the fact that the BB isn't a black hole, and the singularity is much different. I may edit my original reply for clarity, however no one has yet to say the singularity remark was grossly incorrect.
So? Since no one here or just about any scientist has ever said that the Big Bang Singularity is a black hole, your point is irrelevant...or did you have any point at all?
 
Last edited:
paximperium said:
You made a claim and when called to support your claim, you reply with a," Prove me wrong"? Special Pleading at its finest.

I supported my claim and then asked you to support yours as well. No special pleading need apply.

An entire argument based on a completely false premise.

Please support your claim in your own words. No lengthy cut and pastes that describe quantum gravity and open universes as per GR ie (FRW) answers concerning gravitational field equations of general relativity.*

Sounds ever so familiar. Except in the most colloquial sense but yes, the "popular press" and "pop science" and just about most cosmologists avoids saying the Big Bang is the "beginning" since it is a false statement. Strange huh?

No not at all I described my take on it. Most cosmologists do not avoid saying the universe began. Perhaps you can support that claim as well, in your own words?

Since your statement continues to be false, you conclusion is invalid. But then attempting to lay claim to the achievement of others, is religion's forte.

Again sorry you saying so just ain’t so, I supported my claim not its time for once that you support yours. Again sorry you saying so just ain’t so

Prop Hoc Ergo Propter Hoc at its finest..

Paximperium’s extemporized replies noted and saved for the outside chance he may actually be able to support them one day.

So? Since no one here or just about any scientist has ever said that the Big Bang Singularity is a black hole, your point is irrelevant...or did you have any point at all?

The point? That the universe began as per the BB. I have fought off many secular fourm members in other forums that did claim that the BB singularity was a black hole type. In any case I supported my claims now its time for a little reciprocal action support all your claims or for starters support just one of your claims. That may at least prove you aren’t making up your responses as you go along.

; {>

Do you see whats going on? An entire reply based on personal BS. Be aware that's the last time I will indulge that type of reply. Nevertheless thanks for the reply such that it was ~
 
Last edited:
What are your psychological motivations for striving to topple the certainty of God?

[...]

But we have already a very useful distinction in the psychological motivations and the logical motivations for a person's certainty of God's existence, from the first hit made with Google.




Yrreg


You know, atheists, that people who are certain logically of God are moved by psychological motivations to examine the logical certainty of God and accordingly do find the logical grounds for the certainty of God.

I am sure you know what these psychological motivations are, but for the sake of readers here, just name only four psychological motivations of people logically certain of God.


As atheists you are also urged on by psychological motivations to topple the certainty of God in the hearts and minds of people who know from certainty God's existence.

Please examine your heart and mind to pinpoint also four psychological motivations why you are striving so hard to topple the certainty of God in people who do enjoy the certainty of God in their heart and mind.



Yrreg
 
Psssst...Ryokan? Ryokan ! Hey Ryokan!!!...Ya' there my friend?

; {>

Sorry. As you can see below my picture, I'm European. My last post in this thread was made at almost 3am my time. I really needed some beauty sleep :)

It’s easy to see that an actually infinite number of things is self-contradictory.

I'm ready to grant you that. That's really not where my contention is. At the same time as an infinite number of events is called absurd, an eternal 'cause' is not. Infinite and eternal is close to being the same, so if an infinite number of events is absurd, I must conclude that an eternal personal cause must also be.

I understand that you're going to feel ganged up upon on this site in religious discussions, and that there will be far more questions for you than you can answer. But since I'm on almost the other side of the planet from you, with a daily rythm that is out of sync with yours, I'm afraid a continuous conversation will be difficult. I also see that there are people who can argue this much better than I can. If you want to 'attach' yourself to one of them instead, I will understand :)
 
You know, atheists, that people who are certain logically of believe in God are moved by psychological motivations to examine the logical certainty of belief in God and accordingly do find the logical grounds for the certainty of belief in God.

Yrreg

I won't harp on the differences between knowledge and belief if you won't misuse them anymore.

Deal?
 
...As atheists you are also urged on by psychological motivations to topple the certainty of God in the hearts and minds of people who know from certainty God's existence.

Please examine your heart and mind to pinpoint also four psychological motivations why you are striving so hard to topple the certainty of God in people who do enjoy the certainty of God in their heart and mind.

Yrreg
You are wrong again. Don't you ever read other people's posts? Most atheists are not "urged... to topple the certainty of god...". The proselytizing is typically attempted by the theists.
 
You know, atheists, that people who are certain logically of God

*waits for evidence that any such person exists*

are moved by psychological motivations to examine the logical certainty of God

*knows no such thing*


and accordingly do find the logical grounds for the certainty of God.

*waits for these logical grounds to be laid out*

I am sure you know what these psychological motivations are, but for the sake of readers here, just name only four psychological motivations of people logically certain of God.

*wonders why the psychological motivations of people should vary between theists and non theist, any more than within either group*


As atheists you are also urged on by psychological motivations to topple the certainty of God

*knows no such thing*

in the hearts and minds of people who know from certainty God's existence.

If they have logical grounds for that certainty that would be neither possible nor desirable.

Please examine your heart and mind to pinpoint also four psychological motivations why you are striving so hard to topple the certainty of God in people who do enjoy the certainty of God in their heart and mind.

* waits for evidence in support of this extraordinary claim*
 
The certainty of The Flying Spaghetti Monster

I am hoping to explain to myself before the posters and readers of this forum my certainty of The Flying Spaghetti Monster existence.


And my approach here is to look up with Google the following words, "certainty of The Flying Spaghetti Monster's existence", to find out what people whose writings are in the web say about the certainty of The Flying Spaghetti Monster's existence.


Just one request to posters here, please don't waste the time of readers here and the forum's bandwidth.






aknarfj
 
I am going to read this first hit from Google on "certainty of The Flying Spaghetti Monster's existence."

If you are interested please also look up Google for these words in quotation marks, "certainty of certainty of The Flying Spaghetti Monster's existence."


I am going to explain myself but I will consult people who have any writing found in the web on the topic, and of course I will see if any posts here can help to explain what is certainty from the part of mankind in regard to certainty of The Flying Spaghetti Monster's existence




aknarfj
 
Last edited:
You know, atheists, that people who are certain logically of God are moved by psychological motivations to examine the logical certainty of God and accordingly do find the logical grounds for the certainty of God.
No.

I am sure you know what these psychological motivations are, but for the sake of readers here, just name only four psychological motivations of people logically certain of God.
No.

As atheists you are also urged on by psychological motivations to topple the certainty of God in the hearts and minds of people who know from certainty God's existence.
No.

Please examine your heart and mind to pinpoint also four psychological motivations why you are striving so hard to topple the certainty of God in people who do enjoy the certainty of God in their heart and mind.
No.
 
**Flying Spaghetti Monster auctions have started on eBay. Be sure to bid and help us in our fundraising efforts. You only have a week!** For details etc click the picture on the right-hand side of the page or visit our DONATE*page.

What have I learned from the first hit of Google on the certainty of certainty of The Flying Spaghetti Monster's existence?


There are psychological and there are logical motivations for the certainty of certainty of The Flying Spaghetti Monster's existence.

The psychological motivations deal with how people feel, and these motivations need not be argued about because they are people's feelings.

The logical motivations can be argued about because they are independent of people's feelings, but are founded on people's reasoning.



So, one has to be cautious with feelings as to not mistake them for reasons.


What is my certainty for the certainty of the existence of The Flying Spaghetti Monster?

Both psychological and logical, but in forum writings I keep to the logical reasons for my certainty of certainty of The Flying Spaghetti Monster; just the same many people here will disagree with me.


Question: Who is to judge whether a person's motivations for his certainty of certainty of The Flying Spaghetti Monster's existence are psychological or are logical, and which ones are the logical ones, and how persuasive they are?



Let me read more hits from Google, and report here.




aknarfj
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom