The certainty of God's existence.

I posted before your apology, Rev Disturba: this may not have been clear to you and I should have quoted your post as it stood for the avoidance of doubt. Will do in future, thought I doubt I will post much in this thread for the reasons already given
 
Well that's a good way to put it. When it comes to building movements, nations, and belief systems I would say that the having solid structure and organization its equally as important what the people believe. However, that is somewhat backwards. In nation building religion the leaders use the belief and faith of the believers as a stepping stone to their own personal goals (which just might be a pyramid).
You seem to be saying that any religion is better than atheism. Given the contradictions between the beliefs of different religions, even between different sects of the same religion, what exactly do you believe in? And why is it better for people who don't believe in your god to believe in a different one or ones than treat them all as imaginary?
 
I posted before your apology, Rev Disturba: this may not have been clear to you and I should have quoted your post as it stood for the avoidance of doubt. Will do in future, thought I doubt I will post much in this thread for the reasons already given

Ok, yes this thread is not what it usta' be when Gerry was allowed in. ;)

I too am getting kind of over this thread as well...but I have a few cheeks left and a mote to get out or my eye according to Randy the Candy avatar look alike man...

; {>

I am hitching my pony up to my new thread topic ..."Specified Complexity the hallmark of Intelligent Design" I am not sure where it will end up at....

I will visit here as well....
 
Last edited:
You seem to be saying that any religion is better than atheism. Given the contradictions between the beliefs of different religions, even between different sects of the same religion, what exactly do you believe in? And why is it better for people who don't believe in your god to believe in a different one or ones than treat them all as imaginary?

Well I think atheism is somewhere in "the middle". Personally I think Levay satanism is a sickening religion but its above alleged Voodoo child killings and mutilations. I am biased for Christianity of course but atheism about five on a one to ten scale of paradigms/belief systems right there with non deistic religions.

As for my beliefs how long do you have? :hypnotize Loosely said I am a open theist, red letter christian* that does not believe in a burning hell for humans, and subscribes to the love of money is the root of all evil the end is near (maybe) doctrine. :hypnotize

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red-Letter_Christian

; {>
 
Today I posted a new thread titled "Specified Complexity the hallmark of Intelligent Design"

Here is an excerpt;

Nevertheless I will attempt to explain my beliefs and why I think ID is a credible idea.

How can an infinitesimally improbable event such as a finely-tuned Universe could warrant belief in a God and how about other incomprehensibly improbable events? We can say that in addition to high improbability events an conformity to an independently given pattern should also exist.....

Read more @

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=151085

; {>
 
Last edited:
So is mathematical constructs word games. I agree that ontological arguments are weaker than the KCA for example and just mentioned them in passing. Still they are a valid form of argument.



Yes, ontological arguments use reason and common sense.

Neither of these have anything to do with what I said?


Correct. If you agree to the conditions of the argument.

Ah. But people don't agree to the conditions. People expect something more as the referrent of the word "God". Not a general something, anything. Rather something specific. Your own reply shows that:

Lord Emsworth said:
Except that people expect something more than that, and there is really no need for any convoluted eyewashing.
Yes that's why ontological arguments are not satisfying to me and its why I would rather use a cosmological argument to describe my reasons for believing in a supernatural/metaphysical first cause.

And here is the very first instance. You have your own definition of when something is "God" and when not: "supernatural/metaphysical first cause" (however meaningful that may be). That is not necessarily that what is being shown, or 'argued' in an ontological argument. ;)

To make use of my analogy once more. You already expect particulars about the peak of the mountain. Not anything will do. While it does have to be the highest point (general definition of "peak"), there are also additional requirements beyond that, for instance that the peak has got to be covered in pixy dust.

However an ontological argument describing the same thing (God) is like using another math to describe the same problem.

That can only hold true, if the same thing is being described. And that is a big if.


Saying that one is less satisfying than the other does not detract from the credibility of either one.



I know were you are going with this, if the FSM has the attributes of God it doesn't mean that the FSM is a derogatory fabrication dreamed up by christian haters, it would be God.

No, that is not where I am going. But incidentally it would be true that if the FSM (I prefer the IPU) met the criteria of the ontological argument that is being used, then yes it would be God. And if we could show the FSM or IPU to exist then we would have found out more specifically what God is.

However it does not hold true, that if you have shown your ontological argument of choice to be 'correct,' that therefore your God conception of choice is true. It does not follow, that even if the IPU met the general definitons of your ontological argument of choice (for instance the IPU is necessary being) that it shows the existence of the IPU.



But that was not where I was going to as I said. I was more thinking into the exact opposite direction. I was thinking that your preconceived notion of "God" as something 'supernatural' would not be found in a modal ontological argument where "God" is necessary being. Instead there is nothing that would even barr anything 'natural' from counting as "God" as well.



Yes correct


Well, yes but it wouldn't matter because we are trying to show that the mountain has a peak,

No, I don't think you understood a single thing. We don't have to show any such thing! It is defined that way. (Remember, if we have a mountain, we also have a peak)

What you would have to argue for is not any kind of peak, you have to argue that there is pixy dust as well. And likely that it is made chocolate, and that bigfoots live there, and a host of other things.


And as long as you don't show and argue for your conception of "God" as first cause/necessary being that is also supernatural, (and likely some other things as well) ...



and that peak is God.

Here you are conflating the analogy and that what was the analogy about.



Look I agree with you that ontological arguments are not satisfying, that's why I do not use one as my primary argument for evidence of Gods existence. And this well written reply is another reason I don't use ontological arguments, its too easy for a layperson observer to discount an ontological argument even though its correct.

Or too easy for anybody, layperson or not, believer or not, to conflate what is being argued or shown with their expectation. "Oh looky, it says "Gee Ohh Dee does exist. I was right and He truly ..."



The premises to anyone that does not have an ax to grind. In fact they are undeniably sound. And the conclusion that God did it is a reasonable rational conclusion IMO.

As I said, the soundness (or truthfulness) of the premises and the validity of the KCA make for great red herrings, don't they? And it even concludes Gee Ohh Dee!

But what does that even mean?
 
Last edited:
I fully understand atheism, trust me.
I don't think you do. But we'll set that aside.

Yes,, but they could if they wanted to! Still there are large atheist organizations that are not humanitarian per se , like say the American atheists for example. So, what would stop me from starting say, The First (or 2nd) atheist food bank? See?
Because - which you are either failing to understand, or avoiding - atheism is irrelevant. If you are an atheist and think it is important to deliver food to the hungry, you just deliver food to the hungry.

Additionally, I am afraid that you, not I may not understand some atheist concepts. At least that there are many different types of atheists.
Your fears are groundless.

Hmmmm...

www.atheists.org/

www.atheistalliance.org/ -

A couple found in a one min. internet search.
You're joking, right? Did you even bother to read what I said?

I said:

There are no large, organised hierachies in atheism. None. There are various groups, but they are all independent and mostly small and local.

How many members do you think the American Atheists have?

According to poll data, the Catholic Church has about 57 million members in the United States. There are 36 million Baptists, and about 29 million Protestants of various affiliations. 32 million generic and non-denominational Christians, 8 million Pentecostal, 2 million Jehovah's Witnesses, a million Seventh-Day Adventists, and 3 million Mormons. And a million here, two million there, of Buddhists and Jews and Muslims and Hindus and such.

The American Atheists have about two thousand members.

Do you want to know how skewed the numbers are? The National Association of Free Will Baptists, which I have never even heard of, has more churches than the American Atheists have members.

I would form a strictly atheist foundation for obvious reasons.
What obvious reasons?

That's the point Pixi.
Yes, the point being you don't understand the people you are addressing.

There are exceedingly few strictly atheist humanitarian groups (that I know of).
Of course, because humanitarian goals come before the promotion of atheism. Proselytising a lack of belief is simply not a very high priority for many people.

Fred Hollows was a long-time and quite outspoken atheist. That didn't affect his work or the work of his foundation in any way. What he cared about was stopping kids in developing nations from going blind from preventable and treatable diseases. A million people owe their sight today to his work and that of his foundation.

God bless them :boxedin: with all due respect. No, seriously they need more groups like that.
Another point - they do not proselytize or promote atheism at all in connection with their charity work. If you're hungry, they'll feed you.
 
YET AGAIN I FEEL ITS TIME FOR A DISCLAIMER LEST THIS GETS TURNED AROUND. I AM SPEAKING OF ATHEIST GROUPS, NOT ATHEIST INDIVIDUALS WHOM, IF THEY ARE NON-HATERS WHICH MOST ARE GOOD MORAL PEOPLE, I HOLD IN THE HIGHEST REGARDS
I'll say this again: You seem to have hate on the brain.

See my response to Ms Pixy. Atheists do indeed have something in common, who needs anything extra than a "common beyond a lack of belief in gods"?
Let's get together this weekend and not play softball.

Any takers?

No, thought not.

That's a very good reason to come together and share etc.
Is it? You think so. Atheists don't. That's very clear from the tiny size of atheist organisations compared to religious ones.

This suggests that you don't understand atheists nearly as well as you think.

Many huge groups were formed with only one common belief etc.
And how many were formed on no common beliefs?

So to say your claim rings hollow is an understatement, it is borderline disingenuous.
No, you're simply completely failing to understand atheists. When there is a charitable need, they will work with whatever secular or religious charity is in the best position to help out.

I give money to the Red Cross, to the World Wildlife Fund - and to the Salvation Army.

I know of no organizations that use the tooth fairy as a God.
You have to understand, RevD. We see no difference in evidentiary support between your God and the Tooth Fairy. Both are fables.

However if they were I would respect them more than a group of people that sit on their arses and critique harass insult and lend hate to Christianity while they (en mass) have accomplished nearly nothing to assist mankind.
You have hate on the brain, Rev.

Atheists do an enormous amount to assist mankind. More, probably, than all the religions put together (and even neglecting the harm that religions cause).

Science, Rev, science. An overwhelming proportion of scientists are atheist, and a significant proportion beyond that are agnostic. A 1998 survey of leading scientists found that only 7% of them were religious.

Ad hominem.

YET AGAIN I FEEL ITS TIME FOR A DISCLAIMER LEST THIS GETS TURNED AROUND. I AM SPEAKING OF ATHEIST GROUPS, NOT ATHEIST INDIVIDUALS WHOM, IF THEY ARE NON-HATERS WHICH MOST ARE GOOD MORAL PEOPLE, I HOLD IN THE HIGHEST REGARDS
Ad groupinem.
 
These reasons ;

University of Minnesota Study on American Attitudes Towards ...
It's not just that atheists are hated, though, but also that atheists seem to ... Research Finds that Atheists are Most Despised, Most Distrusted Minority ...
atheism.about.com/.../atheistbigotryprejudice/a/AtheitsHated.htm


Atheists obviously need some good massive PR to correct the bigotry and misinformation that exists. A huge atheist philanthropy in the model of any humanitarian missions/groups etc would be a great start.
Ah. So the obvious reason is that so many religious people are bigots?

From the article:
Every single study that has ever looked at the issue has revealed massive amounts of bigotry and prejudice against atheists in America. The most recent data shows that atheists are more distrusted and despised than any other minority and that an atheist is the least likely person that Americans would vote for in a presidential election. It's not just that atheists are hated, though, but also that atheists seem to represent everything about modernity which Americans dislike or fear.

...


Every group except atheists is being shown much greater tolerance and acceptance than 30 years ago.


It goes on:


Some respondents associated atheism with illegal behavior, like drug use and prostitution: "that is, with immoral people who threaten respectable community from the lower end of the social hierarchy."
Yep, that's us. Immoral threat to the respectable community, what with our heathen web forums and podcasts and such.



Given the relatively low number of atheists in America, and the even lower number who are public about their atheism, Americans can't have come to their beliefs about atheists through personal experience and hard evidence about what atheists are really like.
About 15% of Americans report no religion in surveys, but only 5-15% those - i.e. 0.75% to 2.25% of the whole - describe themselves as atheists. That's a pretty small minority. And most American atheists aren't public about their atheism. After all, not wearing a cross or a yarmulke isn't exactly pronouncing your atheism to the world.
 
Well I think atheism is somewhere in "the middle". Personally I think Levay satanism is a sickening religion but its above alleged Voodoo child killings and mutilations. I am biased for Christianity of course but atheism about five on a one to ten scale of paradigms/belief systems right there with non deistic religions.
That's nice. Banner headline: "Atheists not as bad as child mutilators".
 
Today I posted a new thread titled "Specified Complexity the hallmark of Intelligent Design"

Here is an excerpt;

Nevertheless I will attempt to explain my beliefs and why I think ID is a credible idea.

How can an infinitesimally improbable event such as a finely-tuned Universe could warrant belief in a God and how about other incomprehensibly improbable events?
Oh look, one post and it's already a train wreck. I'm off to survey the damage.
 
I didn't say secular groups I said atheist groups. I am sure Christians and atheists alike abound in the red cross, but I doubt that many atheists are missionaries in a church led humanitarian endeavor. That said, if I were the leader of a church I would allow atheists to help or contribute.

; }>

Your intent was clear from your statement: you were implying that atheists were morally inferior to theists. You were implying that atheists don't contribute to humanitarian causes in the way that theists do. You base this on the rarity of explicitly atheist charity and aid organizations. What you fail to understand, despite your assurances to the contrary, is that atheism is not a doctrine. There are no specifically atheistic beliefs other than the lack of belief in gods.
 
I don't think that's quite correct. He wasn't implying those things, he was saying them explicitly.

Of course, he's entirely wrong either way.
 
I think your case is weak my friend. I want to tell you that I don't dislike secular humanist's, but simply think the belief system allows for more temptations, and as I said opens the door for behavior harmful to us.

; {>

Of course, if you'd bothered to read the list of quotes I'd posted, you would realize that National Socialism is not an example of secular humanism.
 
Well I think atheism is somewhere in "the middle". Personally I think Levay satanism is a sickening religion but its above alleged Voodoo child killings and mutilations. I am biased for Christianity of course but atheism about five on a one to ten scale of paradigms/belief systems right there with non deistic religions.

So I'm only half way between you and people who mutilate and kill children.

Is it all right if we just skip Jesus all together and worship you?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom