The certainty of God's existence.

Oh, by the way, the Atheist Community of Austin is a good example of an explicitly atheist (rather than just secular) charity.

I will check it out, thanks for the heads up. I have often wondered why there wasn't a lot of atheist aid groups. If I were an wealthy atheist I would found one.

; {>
 
No, I asked for atheist humanitarian aid groups not secular humanitarian aid groups. I was saying that Christians along with atheists agnostics etc were in the red cross.
Here's where, once again, you misunderstand the people you are addressing.

Atheism isn't a belief, it's a lack of belief. People don't, as a rule, gather together for weekly not-collecting-stamps meetings, or a game of not-playing-softball.

There are no large, organised hierachies in atheism. None. There are various groups, but they are all independent and mostly small and local.

When atheists want to form a charity, it is generally because they are concerned about some cause other than atheism. So they form a secular charity for that cause. The Fred Hollows Foundation is a perfect example of a charity formed by an atheist for an open, secular, purpose. There are a lot of secular charities.

This isn't exclusively the case, and as I said, the Atheist Community of Austin is a great example of an explicitly atheist charity. They run outreach programs and public science lectures, and also blood drives, food drives, and street cleanup activities.
 
No, I asked for atheist humanitarian aid groups not secular humanitarian aid groups. I was saying that Christians along with atheists agnostics etc were in the red cross.

; {>


How odd. You seem to imagine that atheists have something in common beyond a lack of belief in gods. They don't. How then would they form groups as atheists? Do you form groups on the basis of what you do not believe? Are there humanitarian aid groups run by those who do not believe in the tooth fairy and have banded together on that basis?

ETA: PixyMisa said this better than me :)
 
Last edited:
No, I asked for atheist humanitarian aid groups not secular humanitarian aid groups. I was saying that Christians along with atheists agnostics etc were in the red cross.

Then I'm afraid I don't understand your reference to 'church led' in your post. Could explain the point you were making?
I am sure Christians and atheists alike abound in the red cross, but I doubt that many atheists are missionaries in a church led humanitarian endeavor.

Also, in what sense are you using the term 'missionary'?
 
zooterkin said:
You might want to start a survivors' group with Ethnikos, who also seems to have had a near death experience. Oddly, the details of the god he believes it seem to differ from yours. As I suggested to him, you might want to find out more about how the brain works, or rather doesn't, in extreme conditions.

Thanks for the info! Nevertheless God is God. My God differs from everyone elses God as much as everyone is a abstract concept to me. And I am a abstract concept to you.

Have you read a good book then went to see a movie of it, only to find the hero and even the voices to be nothing like what you envisioned? I feel God is something like that.

So, it's not what people believe that's important, but the structure of the organisation that permits things like science to be investigated?

Well that's a good way to put it. When it comes to building movements, nations, and belief systems I would say that the having solid structure and organization its equally as important what the people believe. However, that is somewhat backwards. In nation building religion the leaders use the belief and faith of the believers as a stepping stone to their own personal goals (which just might be a pyramid).

; {>
 
Last edited:
PixyMisa said:
Here's where, once again, you misunderstand the people you are addressing.

I fully understand atheism, trust me.

Atheism isn't a belief, it's a lack of belief. People don't, as a rule, gather together for weekly not-collecting-stamps meetings, or a game of not-playing-softball.

Yes,, but they could if they wanted to! Still there are large atheist organizations that are not humanitarian per se , like say the American atheists for example. So, what would stop me from starting say, The First (or 2nd) atheist food bank? See?

Additionally, I am afraid that you, not I may not understand some atheist concepts. At least that there are many different types of atheists.

There are no large, organised hierachies in atheism. None. There are various groups, but they are all independent and mostly small and local.

Hmmmm...

www.atheists.org/

www.atheistalliance.org/ -

A couple found in a one min. internet search.

When atheists want to form a charity, it is generally because they are concerned about some cause other than atheism. So they form a secular charity for that cause. The Fred Hollows Foundation is a perfect example of a charity formed by an atheist for an open, secular, purpose. There are a lot of secular charities.

I would form a strictly atheist foundation for obvious reasons. That's the point Pixi. There are exceedingly few strictly atheist humanitarian groups (that I know of).

This isn't exclusively the case, and as I said, the Atheist Community of Austin is a great example of an explicitly atheist charity. They run outreach programs and public science lectures, and also blood drives, food drives, and street cleanup activities.

God bless them :boxedin: with all due respect. No, seriously they need more groups like that.

: }>
 
Last edited:
YET AGAIN I FEEL ITS TIME FOR A DISCLAIMER LEST THIS GETS TURNED AROUND. I AM SPEAKING OF ATHEIST GROUPS, NOT ATHEIST INDIVIDUALS WHOM, IF THEY ARE NON-HATERS WHICH MOST ARE GOOD MORAL PEOPLE, I HOLD IN THE HIGHEST REGARDS

How odd. You seem to imagine that atheists have something in common beyond a lack of belief in gods. They don't. How then would they form groups as atheists? Do you form groups on the basis of what you do not believe? Are there humanitarian aid groups run by those who do not believe in the tooth fairy and have banded together on that basis?

ETA: PixyMisa said this better than me :)

See my response to Ms Pixy. Atheists do indeed have something in common, who needs anything extra than a "common beyond a lack of belief in gods"? That's a very good reason to come together and share etc. Many huge groups were formed with only one common belief etc. So to say your claim rings hollow is an understatement, it is borderline disingenuous.

I know of no organizations that use the tooth fairy as a God. However if they were I would respect them more than a group of people that sit on their arses and critique harass insult and lend hate to Christianity while they (en mass) have accomplished nearly nothing to assist mankind.

eh?

; }>

YET AGAIN I FEEL ITS TIME FOR A DISCLAIMER LEST THIS GETS TURNED AROUND. I AM SPEAKING OF ATHEIST GROUPS, NOT ATHEIST INDIVIDUALS WHOM, IF THEY ARE NON-HATERS WHICH MOST ARE GOOD MORAL PEOPLE, I HOLD IN THE HIGHEST REGARDS
 
Last edited:
See my response to Ms Pixy. Atheists do indeed have something in common, who needs anything extra than a "common beyond a lack of belief in gods"? That's a very good reason to come together and share etc. Many huge groups were formed with only one common belief etc. So to say your claim rings hollow is an understatement, it is borderline disingenuous.

I know of no organizations that use the tooth fairy as a God. However if they were I would respect them more than a group of people that sit on their arses and critique harass insult and lend hate to Christianity while they (en mass) have accomplished nearly nothing to assist mankind.

So, atheists who take part in humanitarian work, and set up organisations to do so, are wasting their time unless they do it solely for an atheist organisation?

ETA: You've since added this:
YET AGAIN I FEEL ITS TIME FOR A DISCLAIMER LEST THIS GETS TURNED AROUND. I AM SPEAKING OF ATHEIST GROUPS, NOT ATHEIST INDIVIDUALS WHOM, IF THEY ARE NON-HATERS WHICH MOST ARE GOOD MORAL PEOPLE, I HOLD IN THE HIGHEST REGARDS

If that's what you mean, then you need to re-read what you've actually written. You've asked why atheists have not started purely atheist charities, not why atheist groups (whichever ones you have in mind, you have not been specific) are not charitable organisations.
 
Last edited:
Then I'm afraid I don't understand your reference to 'church led' in your post. Could explain the point you were making?

Which post was that? I vaguely remember making the remark but don't know the context it was in.

Also, in what sense are you using the term 'missionary'?

Again in what post do you refer to?

; {>
 
What obvious reasons?

These reasons ;

University of Minnesota Study on American Attitudes Towards ...
It's not just that atheists are hated, though, but also that atheists seem to ... Research Finds that Atheists are Most Despised, Most Distrusted Minority ...
atheism.about.com/.../atheistbigotryprejudice/a/AtheitsHated.htm


Atheists obviously need some good massive PR to correct the bigotry and misinformation that exists. A huge atheist philanthropy in the model of any humanitarian missions/groups etc would be a great start.

; {>
 
Last edited:
See my response to Ms Pixy. Atheists do indeed have something in common, who needs anything extra than a "common beyond a lack of belief in gods"? That's a very good reason to come together and share etc. Many huge groups were formed with only one common belief etc. So to say your claim rings hollow is an understatement, it is borderline disingenuous.

I am afraid you are just wrong about this. But since you go so far as to suggest I am disingenuous I think it is not worth responding further. It might be quite good if you held yourself to the standards of debate you demand from others: just an idea :)
 
I am afraid you are just wrong about this. But since you go so far as to suggest I am disingenuous I think it is not worth responding further. It might be quite good if you held yourself to the standards of debate you demand from others: just an idea :)

Again you are expanding on words that I did not say. I said you are borderline disingenuous.

My exact words " it is borderline disingenuous" (of you).

A huge difference. You know exactly what you are doing.

Allow me to explain something to you that any adult should know. When you insist on comparing a beloved religious concept with the tooth fairy you must be prepared to receive some mild rebuttal in one form or another.

; {?

:p Oopsie!!! Ms Fiona, as I was preparing another mild comeback I reread your comment. I was wrong in what I said you said ! I apologize for saying that you comparing a beloved religious concept with the tooth fairy. That was completely wrong. I will delete it or otherwise fix it if you wish.:p

; {>
 
Last edited:
A distinction without a difference, Rev Disturba: and I am equally sure you know what you are doing. So does everyone else :)
 
YET AGAIN I FEEL ITS TIME FOR A DISCLAIMER LEST THIS GETS TURNED AROUND. I AM SPEAKING OF ATHEIST GROUPS, NOT ATHEIST INDIVIDUALS WHOM, IF THEY ARE NON-HATERS WHICH MOST ARE GOOD MORAL PEOPLE, I HOLD IN THE HIGHEST REGARDS



See my response to Ms Pixy. Atheists do indeed have something in common, who needs anything extra than a "common beyond a lack of belief in gods"? That's a very good reason to come together and share etc. Many huge groups were formed with only one common belief etc. So to say your claim rings hollow is an understatement, it is borderline disingenuous.

I know of no organizations that use the tooth fairy as a God. However if they were I would respect them more than a group of people that sit on their arses and critique harass insult and lend hate to Christianity while they (en mass) have accomplished nearly nothing to assist mankind.

eh?

; }>

YET AGAIN I FEEL ITS TIME FOR A DISCLAIMER LEST THIS GETS TURNED AROUND. I AM SPEAKING OF ATHEIST GROUPS, NOT ATHEIST INDIVIDUALS WHOM, IF THEY ARE NON-HATERS WHICH MOST ARE GOOD MORAL PEOPLE, I HOLD IN THE HIGHEST REGARDS

I do not hate Christianity.Why would you think that? You're warped.
 
I do not hate Christianity.Why would you think that? You're warped.

Some do eh? That part of the disclaimer was meant for those 1%ers. Please re read. Here I will make it easy for you : " IF THEY ARE NON-HATERS WHICH MOST (atheists) ARE GOOD MORAL PEOPLE"

See? Next time if you don't see your name on it don't sweat it.

; {>
 
Last edited:
A distinction without a difference, Rev Disturba: and I am equally sure you know what you are doing. So does everyone else :)

? I was apologizing for a mistake, thats more than I get most of the time. What am I doing here hmmmm.....ahhhhh give me a min....ahhhh dang this is a difficult one.....uhhhh ...duhhhhh...ahhhhh....

Oh right I almost forgot there is so much personal BS and off topic rants...(yes I indulge too) I am here taking Gerrys place at the whipping post while he is...ummmm ahhhh. <-------levity.

I am here to say my bit about the thread subject.

; {?>
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom