The certainty of God's existence.

So an infinite number of events is absurd, but a 'personal eternal cause' is not? Why?

I am in a bit of a hurry,so I hope this soundbyte helps; The cause that caused the universe to exist did so 'before' T-0 it was eternal (atemporal) because time was created just after T-0. Therefore the cause that caused the universe to exist did not begin to exist therefore according to the premise of the KCA it did not require a cause for its existence. Infinite regression ended with the cause.
: {>
 
Since Bing Bang theory DOES NOT claim that the universe "began", I still don't see your point.

The universe began 14.7 B years ago. However it was not a true singluarity, (as in a black hole singularity)Why? It had no mass. Gotcha eh?

; {>
 
I am in a bit of a hurry,so I hope this soundbyte helps; The cause that caused the universe to exist did so 'before' T-0 it was eternal (atemporal) because time was created just after T-0. Therefore the cause that caused the universe to exist did not begin to exist therefore according to the premise of the KCA it did not require a cause for its existence. Infinite regression ended with the cause.
: {>

That sounds... absurd :p

Now I just need someone to explain to me how an infinite number of events is absurd, yet the above quoted part is not.
 
Results 1 - 10 of about 2,750 for "certainty of god's existence". (0.18 seconds)
Search Results Results include your SearchWiki notes for "certainty of god's existence". Share these notes

Copy and paste this link into an email or IM:

See a preview of the shared page

Descartes using the certainty of God's existence as a crutch ...Does anybody else think that Descartes ends up using his complete ... His arguments are logical, not psychological. For example, if someone were ...
answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid... - Cached - Similar -

[...]


I am going to read this first hit from Google on "certainty of God's existence."

If you are interested please also look up Google for these words in quotation marks, "certainty of God's existence."


I am going to explain myself but I will consult people who have any writing found in the web on the topic, and of course I will see if any posts here can help to explain what is certainty from the part of mankind in regard to God's existence.





Yrreg
 
So, one has to be cautious with feelings as to not mistake them for reasons.

Quote:
Results 1 - 10 of about 2,750 for "certainty of god's existence". (0.18 seconds)
Search Results Results include your SearchWiki notes for "certainty of god's existence". Share these notes

Copy and paste this link into an email or IM:

See a preview of the shared page

Descartes using the certainty of God's existence as a crutch ...Does anybody else think that Descartes ends up using his complete ... His arguments are logical, not psychological. For example, if someone were ...
answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid... - Cached - Similar -

[...]

​


I am going to read this first hit from Google on "certainty of God's existence."

If you are interested please also look up Google for these words in quotation marks, "certainty of God's existence."


I am going to explain myself but I will consult people who have any writing found in the web on the topic, and of course I will see if any posts here can help to explain what is certainty from the part of mankind in regard to God's existence.





Yrreg


What have I learned from the first hit of Google on the certainty of God's existence?


There are psychological and there are logical motivations for the certainty of God's existence.

The psychological motivations deal with how people feel, and these motivations need not be argued about because they are people's feelings.

The logical motivations can be argued about because they are independent of people's feelings, but are founded on people's reasoning.



So, one has to be cautious with feelings as to not mistake them for reasons.


What is my certainty for the existence of God?

Both psychological and logical, but in forum writings I keep to the logical reasons for my certainty of God; just the same many people here will disagree with me.


Question: Who is to judge whether a person's motivations for his certainty of God's existence are psychological or are logical, and which ones are the logical ones, and how persuasive they are?



Let me read more hits from Google, and report here.




Yrreg
 
I am hoping to explain to myself before the posters and readers of this forum my certainty of God's existence.


And my approach here is to look up with Google the following words, "certainty of God's existence", to find out what people whose writings are in the web say about the certainty of God's existence.


Just one request to posters here, please don't waste the time of readers here and the forum's bandwidth.






Yrreg


*sigh*


Yes, Yrreg, whatever you say, I agree....



There. Under ten words and it's what you want to hear.
 
Both psychological and logical, but in forum writings I keep to the logical reasons for my certainty of God; just the same many people here will disagree with me.
No Yrreg you do not "keep to the logical reasons". Your inability to see how illogical and silly your arguments are, are the cause for the complete and utter failure of your attempt to convert anyone.
Question: Who is to judge whether a person's motivations for his certainty of God's existence are psychological or are logical, and which ones are the logical ones, and how persuasive they are?
Great we're back to the same Equivocating nonsense. If a person's reasoning is logical, no matter the motivation, the argument is logical. It may not be sound if the premise is false.
 
I am going to read this first hit from Google on "certainty of God's existence."

If you are interested please also look up Google for these words in quotation marks, "certainty of God's existence."


I am going to explain myself but I will consult people who have any writing found in the web on the topic, and of course I will see if any posts here can help to explain what is certainty from the part of mankind in regard to God's existence.

Ever since you started posting here back in 2006, your number one message to others has always been in your own words! Whenever someone has given you a quote from someone else, you have always chastised them, told them they were brainless and brainwashed, of parroting others without a thought for themselves?

Why don't you tell us in your own words why you're certain that your god exists? Are you sure you're certain, that you already know why? Why must you suddenly research and find out what others mean, before you can tell us why you are certain? I don't get it. Months and months of telling atheists you're certain of your god's existence, now you're not so certain after all?

Is your certainty just another guise, like you being an atheist on the IIDB? Are you, in fact, just lying to us? Are you just pulling our chains, trolling us?
 
Last edited:
Useful distinction between psychological and logfical certainty of God's existence.

This is the second hit of Google on the certainty of God's existence.

The Certainty of God's ExistenceGrace to You... John MacArthur's in-depth Bible teaching brings the life-transforming truth of God's Word to millions of people every day.
www.gty.org.uk/Products/Audio+Lessons/GTY66 - Cached - Similar -​


I read it but found nothing in it that is useful for any explanation that is logical on the certainty of God's existence.


What about you anyone here who care to contribute his opinions about the second hit of Google on the certainty of God's existence?



Tell you what, everyone here, I will just bring up reasons for a person's certainty of God's existence, instead of his feelings.


So that we will not waste the time of readers here and the forum's bandwidth.




But we have already a very useful distinction in the psychological motivations and the logical motivations for a person's certainty of God's existence, from the first hit made with Google.




Yrreg
 
Umm, Yrreg, that links takes me to a site when I can buy an audio-cd called The Certainty of God's Existence, costing £2.72.
 
Last edited:
Umm, Yrreg, that links takes me to a site when I can buy an audio-cd called The Certainty of God's Existence, costing £2.72.


It seems likely that nobody will ever accuse Gerry of being the brightest candle on the cake.
 
Is yrreg just reading whatever he can find on Google that supports his pre-determined conclusion, and parroting it back to us?

Because that's what it looks like.

Actually, that's not quite true. When I see behaviour like this, it makes me think of someone whose certainty has been severely damaged, and who is looking to comfort himself by shoring it up whatever way is possible.


But seriously, I think hhat unless yrreg gives his certainties, this thread is pointless and should be turfed.
If we wanted to read bad apologetics, we would do it for ourselves.

But why? I no more desire to read Christian apologetics than I desire to read Buddhist, Zoroastrian, Hindu, Sikh or even atheist apologetics. For that matter, I rather doubt yrreg has a desire to read apologetics of worldviews other than his own.
 
Last edited:
Hey Yrreg if you like rational, logical ontological arguments what do you think about Kurt Godels ontological argument for the existence of God? I am happy that one of the greatest mathematical minds of history beleived in God and expressed it in a logical expression. ; {>

Or the KCA (being a rational logical argument for the existence of God)

ie

P1: If the universe has no beginning, there have been an infinite number of events.
P2: An infinite number of events is an absurdity and is impossible.
C1: Therefore, the universe must have had a beginning.
P3: Everything which has a beginning must have been caused by something.
P4: If C1 and P3, then C2.
C2: The universe must have been caused by something.
P5: The cause of the universe is eternal.
P6: The only way an eternal cause could produce something bound by time is for it to freely choose to.
P7: If P5 and P6, then C3.
C3: The cause of the universe must be personal.

For those who don't know, the KCA is the Kalam Cosmological Argument, kissing cousin of the the First Mover and First Cause arguments:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kalam_cosmological_argument

As for the argument above:

P2 is arbitrary.

P3 is a blunder. Trivially, every effect has a cause. Whether every thing — with or without a beginning — has a cause is another question.

C2 is arbitrary. Even if every thing in the universe has a cause, it does not follow that the universe has a cause. Classic part-whole fallacy.

P6 and C3 are just wild. How — in the name of all that is literate! — did causes acquire the capacity for choice? And personality, forsooth!
 
yrreg said:
Both psychological and logical, but in forum writings I keep to the logical reasons for my certainty of God; just the same many people here will disagree with me.

How about instead of asking us to follow you on your Google hunt with color commentary, you simply link back to some of your own logical forum writings outlining your certainty of god. Something better than the lame "Satellites, Moons, therefore God" argument you tried to make awhile ago, please.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom