The certainty of God's existence.

You're asking that to a self-proclaimed Christian theist? Here, let me save RevDisturbia some time and answer that question for him. :rolleyes:

I wish I was joking. Most theists are afraid to use the phrase, "I don't know" as an answer, and they usually tend to substitute those three words with three unrelated letters: G, O, and D.
:)

Yeah, I've taken rev to task for simply positng undefined entities with unknown powers (magical).

KCA fails for so many reasons but it would be nice if the proponents would at least admit that it is not parsimonious.

I should also note that rev has never addressed the many theoretical arguments that are taken seriously.

M-Theory (also string theory and super gravity).

No one is seriously working on KCA because it isn't a theory. It's post hoc reasoning. Strung together premises in an attempt to justify a pre-determined conclusion.

No one gets to a belief in god via KCA because it isn't compelling, has no explanatory power and makes few if any falsifiable predictions.
 
Last edited:
I don't reject everything that goes against my previously held beliefs that's simply a lie.

Then I apologize for not making myself clear. By "previously held beliefs," I meant the views you currently hold, not what you believed when you claimed to be atheist.
What I meant to say was theists pick and choose science facts and Bible verses that support their current belief structure. Any evidence that contradicts said beliefs are rejected, and any that come along to support them are happily welcomed.

That is what I believe you are doing.

As for your last sentence again that is a lie (or is primarily lies).

Incorrect. The sentence was not a lie, because that sentence was a question.

...and while I'm not exactly sure what my "ilk" is, I did notice that your hasty, angry response is typical of people of the intolerant religious "ilk."
 
Yeah, I have heard of argument from authority and argument from incredulity but I have never heard of argument from an authority's incredulity before.

I think that if the entire argument is based on a weak inductive empirical intuition then that would entail that the conclusion also was based on a weak inductive empirical intuition.

I also thought it funny that he said it was perfectly obvious that nothing could come from nothing, but elsewhere he says the universe came from nothing.
I didn't notice that yet, but that must have been because I tried to limit myself to reading the parts relevant to the discussion. That was frustrating enough.
 
First good luck with those new youngins'. And my condolences to your wife and her procedure.


I'll say it slowly. And hopefully for the last time.

How this Universe might possibly end has no bearing on how it began or how many attempts there might have been to make it. None. At all.

Well, with all due respect to your job title speed it up and say it in Greek, Latin, French or German! You would still be stating a falsehood! I don't know how you can say that and hold the job you claim. I said that according to current cosmology, if the universe is open it will not rebound (I am sure as an astrophysicist you know what that term entails). However, if there was enough mass in the universe to 'close it' current theory tells us it could rebound into a 'big crunch'** (like the BB 'singularity') and start anew as another big bang, and a new universe (a cyclic universe). This is commonly known cosmological theory! Additionally closed universe is a mechanism where the universe could be reborn and be 'eternal' as a matter of speaking. Now, as I have told you we currently are missing the mass to close the universe. (and I shouldn't have to, again any astronomer would know this) . Here is a definition of the big crunch;

** The Big Crunch Theory is made possible by Big Bang cosmology, which states that all matter in the universe is now racing away from all other matter. If there is enough matter in the universe to create a gravitational force sufficient to bring this movement to a halt and to reverse its direction, then at some point in the remote future all matter in the universe will converge into an infinitely dense point in space, resembling a massive black hole. The end of the universe would then resemble its beginning—a singularity at which the laws of physics as we know them no longer apply. Such a universe is called a closed universe.

See also BIG BANG THEORY; CLOSED UNIVERSE; COSMOLOGY, PHYSICAL ASPECTS; SINGULARITY

The trouble is as I have said that the universe is OPEN. One universe one try. (without resorting to quantum loop gravity or the various MWT* all theoretical concepts.

And we still don't actually know whether or not the Universe is open or closed, so even if we were to accept your assertion your argument still rests on a big if.

We can go on the evidence both empirical and theoretical evidence we have. We do not see nor detect enough mass to close the universe.

; {>


*Many-Worlds Theory
I'm not a huge fan of many-worlds theory, but I do think that multiple Universes .... Originally Posted by Phrak View Post. What is the principle of MWT? ...
www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=291481
 
Last edited:
What, you're saying it's not accurate? Because it is most certainly irrelevant.

Why? You are saying there is no theory that if the universe is open it will expand forever? And that its possible that this is the only universe?
Possible? Possible? Oh, it's possible. But you're claiming this as a certainty. Your argument requires it. And it's not. Which is #37 on the list of reasons why you're wrong.

No, I am not wrong about anything that is relevant to the question which is cause and effect so maybe you should stick to the facts.
Sorry Rev, but that is precisely where you are completely and irretrievably wrong. (On this point, that is. You are completely and irretrievably wrong on all your other points for different reasons.)

If you would simply read the article you yourself linked to, you would understand this. But you refuse. Why?

We are talking about real events.
Yes we are. Pair production. Which absolutely does not happen the way you claim.

If you have to lower yourself to theoretical constructs to prove your (secular) point you don't have a point to prove.
Argument from self-immolation.
 
I don't know how you can say that and hold the job you claim.
You didn't read his post, did you?

I said that according to current cosmology, if the universe is open it will not rebound
You mean collapse. If the Universe is open, it will not collapse. That's by definition.

However, if there was enough mass in the universe to 'close it' current theory tells us it could rebound into a 'big crunch' (like the BB 'singularity') and start anew as another big bang, and a new universe (a cyclic universe).
Yes. Mind you, there are also models where the Universe could collapse even if it is currently open.

[bunch more irrelevant stuff snipped]

The trouble is as I have said that the universe is OPEN. One universe one try.
Non-sequitur.
 
Well, with all due respect to your job title speed it up and say it in Greek, Latin, French or German! You would still be stating a falsehood! I don't know how you can say that and hold the job you claim. I said that according to current cosmology, if the universe is open it will not rebound (I am sure as an astrophysicist you know what that term entails). However, if there was enough mass in the universe to 'close it' current theory tells us it could rebound into a 'big crunch'** (like the BB 'singularity') and start anew as another big bang, and a new universe (a cyclic universe). This is commonly known cosmological theory! Additionally closed universe is a mechanism where the universe could be reborn and be 'eternal' as a matter of speaking. Now, as I have told you we currently are missing the mass to close the universe. (and I shouldn't have to, again any astronomer would know this) . Here is a definition of the big crunch;

** The Big Crunch Theory is made possible by Big Bang cosmology, which states that all matter in the universe is now racing away from all other matter. If there is enough matter in the universe to create a gravitational force sufficient to bring this movement to a halt and to reverse its direction, then at some point in the remote future all matter in the universe will converge into an infinitely dense point in space, resembling a massive black hole. The end of the universe would then resemble its beginning—a singularity at which the laws of physics as we know them no longer apply. Such a universe is called a closed universe.

See also BIG BANG THEORY; CLOSED UNIVERSE; COSMOLOGY, PHYSICAL ASPECTS; SINGULARITY

The trouble is as I have said that the universe is OPEN. One universe one try. (without resorting to quantum loop gravity or the various MWT* all theoretical concepts.
I know all of that, and every single bit is about the future of the Universe, not its past, and certainly not its origin.

We have no way of knowing about its origin.

So I ask again, how can you state, "One universe one try", when you have no information about how the Universe came to exist?

We can go on the evidence both empirical and theoretical evidence we have. We do not see nor detect enough mass to close the universe.
Mass is not the only factor.
 
Since there seems to be some confusion about my claims of cause and effect concerning quantum particles (virtual particles etc) I will clarify my position. As I said these subatomic particles are theoretical entities and its not at all certain that they actually exist rather than being theoretical constructs. That’s important in this discussion. These particles if real don’t come from nothing. Not at all.

The quantum vacuum is not a true vacuum by any means. Its difficult for anyone to envision a vacuum as a sea of fluctuating energy, but it is. Its a ‘locality’ (place) of violent activity that has a plentiful physical structure that obeys physical laws. These particles are thought to originate by fluctuations of the energy in the vacuum.

So I can safely make a case that that its not an example of something coming from nothing, the quantum vacuum and the energy locked up in the vacuum are the cause of these particles. If you want to know where the quantum vacuum come from I can explain that as well but it’s a longer write. Just trust me it has an origin.

I hope this clears up my take on the quantum particle thing it supersedes any thing I wrote before.

; {>
 
The quantum vacuum is not a true vacuum by any means. Its difficult for anyone to envision a vacuum as a sea of fluctuating energy, but it is. Its a ‘locality’ (place) of violent activity that has a plentiful physical structure that obeys physical laws. These particles are thought to originate by fluctuations of the energy in the vacuum.


Sounds like someone is confusing a model with reality again.

So if you are done with virtual particle pairs, care to tackle spontaneous fission? What causes that?
 
I know all of that, and every single bit is about the future of the Universe, not its past, and certainly not its origin.

We have no way of knowing about its origin.

So I ask again, how can you state, "One universe one try", when you have no information about how the Universe came to exist?

Perhaps I am not being clear. If this is a open universe how do you think there was more than one try? I am saying that as a open universe the universe began to exist (this universe) and its still expanding with no mechanism to stop the expansion.

I am aware that mass isn't the only factor that would stop the expansion. (dark) E = mc2 eh?

; }>
 
Last edited:
...quantum particles (virtual particles etc)...subatomic particles are theoretical entities ...The quantum vacuum...I hope this clears up my take on the quantum particle thing
:slp:
I said that according to current cosmology...

...and according to current biology, a human woman cannot become impregnated without fertilization of the egg, and a dead human can not come back to life. (two beliefs which, in order to be considered a "Christian," like you claim, you pretty much must adhere to)

This is what I'm talking about... you cling to snippets of "current cosmology," and the Quantum Theory, and downplay evolution as "just a theory," and all the while you reject overwhelming scientific evidence in order to uphold your core Christian beliefs.

Seriously, this thread is called "the certainty of God's existence," and so far the only ones who are "certain" can't seem to explain why other than, "I think/believe so."
Of course, that could just be God's will. Perhaps He has willed Himself uncertain.
 
Sounds like someone is confusing a model with reality again.

So if you are done with virtual particle pairs, care to tackle spontaneous fission? What causes that?

No I just clarified my position on virtual particles. THEY HAVE A CAUSE (wake up!) Fission has a cause just as radioactivity does. You are confusing random events with cause and effect.

BTW by accepting virtual particles as reality rather than a theoretical model it is you that are confusing the two and thinking that a theoretical construct is reality.Please get your facts correct, and drink a double shot of espresso.

; {>
 
Last edited:
:slp:


...and according to current biology, a human woman cannot become impregnated without fertilization of the egg, and a dead human can not come back to life. (two beliefs which, in order to be considered a "Christian," like you claim, you pretty much must adhere to)

This is what I'm talking about... you cling to snippets of "current cosmology," and the Quantum Theory, and downplay evolution as "just a theory," and all the while you reject overwhelming scientific evidence in order to uphold your core Christian beliefs.

Seriously, this thread is called "the certainty of God's existence," and so far the only ones who are "certain" can't seem to explain why other than, "I think/believe so."
Of course, that could just be God's will. Perhaps He has willed Himself uncertain.

That does not make a bit of sense. Its all ad hoc and bad ad hoc at that.

; {>
 
Perhaps I am not being clear. If this is a open universe how do you think there was more than one try? I am saying that as a open universe the universe began to exist (this universe) and its still expanding with no mechanism to stop the expansion.
There are, quite frankly, a huge number of theories about how universes can form. We have no idea how they do it. We have no idea how this Universe formed. Which means that it's impossible to say how many different universes have formed, or whether or not this Universe was preceded by any others.

We can't say anything about it. We can speculate all we want, but that's all it is - speculation. Not even theory.

And you're the one asking us to remove all theoretical constructs from our arguments.

So go ahead.
 
The certainty of God's existence is uncertain.

I agree DC! At last someone that doesn't have to make wild disingenuous claims about my beliefs to cheer themselves up. Nothing is 100% certain, not even God. I have been saying that for 13 years.

; {>
 
There are, quite frankly, a huge number of theories about how universes can form. We have no idea how they do it. We have no idea how this Universe formed. Which means that it's impossible to say how many different universes have formed, or whether or not this Universe was preceded by any others.

We can't say anything about it. We can speculate all we want, but that's all it is - speculation. Not even theory.



So go ahead.

Yes I said as much and provided links.

And you're the one asking us to remove all theoretical constructs from our arguments.

No another lie. Please cease and desist. I said virtual particles were a totally theoretical construct. Our universe and the Big bang has empirical evidence to support it including that the universe is OPEN. But a man of your title should know that.

Don't you read my posts? I said that my last write on virtual particles ie the clarification supersedes all others.

; {>
 
Last edited:
Perhaps I am not being clear. If this is a open universe how do you think there was more than one try? I am saying that as a open universe the universe began to exist (this universe) and its still expanding with no mechanism to stop the expansion.

I am aware that mass isn't the only factor that would stop the expansion. (dark) E = mc2 eh?

; }>
Okay, perhaps no one has been clear. Suppose this universe is the first one created. Now suppose God creates 10 more independent self-contained open universes with their own space-time continuum. Do you suppose there is a way for people in the 11th universe to know about any of the other universes, and do you think they may also suppose theirs is the first? Are they right?
 
And you're the one asking us to remove all theoretical constructs from our arguments.

So go ahead.


No another lie. Please cease and desist. I said virtual particles were a totally theoretical construct.


Really?

Lets keep the cause and effect to objects that are not theoretical affairs ok? It will make the debate far more honest. I was only granting you a straw because I knew everyone was struggling to name something that began to exist without a cause. See that's what I get for being nice.:confused:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom