The certainty of God's existence.

Even if Yrreg is as bad a person as a member recently claimed, I don't understand why he remains here.

I didn't say he was a bad person, I said he doesn't respond to posts. He talks to himself. I challenge you to find a single post of his where he acknowledges even the definition of atheist, despite being given it literally dozens of times.

Nothing gets discussed its all personal with maybe a fact or two squeezed in to try and obey the tos... Its just astonishing to watch.

I know. He has been infracted so many times for name-calling, I'm afraid he's going to get himself banned.
 
Last edited:
I didn't say he was a bad person, I said he doesn't respond to posts. He talks to himself. I challenge you to find a single post of which where he acknowledges even the definition of atheist, despite being given it literally dozens of times.



I know. He has been infracted so many times for name-calling, I'm afraid he's going to get himself banned.

Oh, what a blow to the forums that would be.
 
Which I think brings us back to the supposed "insults".

I will mock your argument, if it is carelessly constructed. And your argument is very carelessly constructed.
I am under the impression that what people also find insulting about your posts is the curtness.

"Wrong.

Wrong.

No.

Yes, but [insert reason]

No."

However, after seeing many of your posts I have come to think of you as motorised rather than insulting.
 
I am under the impression that what people also find insulting about your posts is the curtness.

"Wrong.

Wrong.

No.

Yes, but [insert reason]

No."

However, after seeing many of your posts I have come to think of you as motorised rather than insulting.

She is rather energetic huh?

; {>
 
That is a very clear example of intentional irrelevancy, owing to male fide malingering.


So that's it?

I answer your question, and all you can do is whine because it's not the answer you wanted to see? because it's not that answer that fits in ith your pre-determined conclusions?

I'm disappointed in you.

By the way: it's mala fide. If you're going to use Latin to make yourself seem more intelligent, you might want to take a few seconds to make sure it's correct.



Ask them this question:
What do you postulate in place of God?


Nothing. There is no "place" that needs to be filled.


I concur. We postulate nothing in place of god.


Okay, I have read some people saying their number one operating premise is nothing in place of God.
<snip>


How on earth did you manage to misunderstand a one-word answer?
We don't postulate "nothing" as an operating premise in place of god.
We simply don't have any operating premise there at all.

We don't view "god" as an operating premise that fills a necessary gap.

Quite simply: the concept does not enter into it. We don't see a gap that needs filling, and we don't claim that nothing is the cause of everything. This has been explained to you before.



Don't get me wrong, I have got nothing against matter in randomness, except that for atheists that is their God, which of course they will deny.


Of course we will.

It's the randomness part.

Consider gravity, electromagnetic forces, chemical reactions, physical laws.
These do not interact with matter randomly.



<snip>

That is really most absurd in the light of people who have not massacred their intelligence.


It only looks absurd to you because you've mangled it to suit your pre-conceptions.



Just tell me, atheists here, and answer only yes or no:

Is not matter in randomness in the ultimate terms your God, yes? no?​


No. See above.



No, no, don't answer you don't know, that is appeal to ignorance, and if you be ignorant as to not know or think as to come to an answer, please go away, don't waste the time of readers here and the forum's bandwidth.


What is your problem with people who are honest enough to admit ignorance?
I've got news for you: there are lots of things humanity doesn't know. But slapping "god" on it and worshipping it doesn't explain a damn thing, or gain us any additional knowledge.

Examples of things unknown:

- What happened prior to the big bang. Our physics can't yet describe the situations.

- The names of the prehistoric humans who made cave paintings.

- Whether any other planets (outside of earth) the universe have life.

Reckognizing the limits of our knowledge is not a bad thing, yrreg.

I ask you: Why are you so afraid to acknowledge that some things are unknown?
 
Last edited:
Male Fide?



ETA - Maybe he meant male members of the FIDE who have external sex organs and hands :)
 
Last edited:
I am hoping to explain to myself before the posters and readers of this forum my certainty of God's existence.

I have one question:

If you are certain, doesn't that preculde the need for faith? Do you find spirituality more fulfilling without the need for faith?

If so, I think you'd ultimately be happier with science as it demands no faith.

I find the people who are most comfortable with their spirituality and spend the least time trying to convince others of it are the ones who have genuine faith, and have no need to prove the existence of god(s).
 
I have told everyone here that several times. Care to look again? Hint; a open vs a closed universe.


That has nothing to do with whether or not our universe is unique, nor with how many "tries" it took. You are still left with a bare assertion as to the claim of "one universe, one try". And, as wollery mentioned, there is currently no conclusion on whether this universe is open or closed. Do not confuse a scientific model with reality, which is what Dr. Craig is doing. When the two conflict, it is the model that needs revision. As has been mentioned in other discussions, all models are wrong, some models are useful.

Also, you are missing the entire point of my mentioning of virtual particle pairs and seem to be confusing the discussion on vacuum fluctuations with the one Hawking radiation.
 
I find the people who are most comfortable with their spirituality and spend the least time trying to convince others of it are the ones who have genuine faith, and have no need to prove the existence of god(s).

What about Christianity? One of the teachings of Jesus is to tell others of Christianity. Of course Paul and other biblical teachers said we should defend Christianity with gentleness and reverence. Sometimes that teaching is ignored, but I think there are more Christians who quietly evangelize than their loud and sometimes obnoxious counterparts.

Even when I wasn't practicing Christianity I didn't find evangelicals of any faith disturbing or a source of anger. I always had a remote and crossed the street when I saw the rare sidewalk preacher. I do understand why some atheists are highly incensed about anything religious, but they are in the minority. The internet is about as loud as I get even though I am a real preacher with a church. My church sponsors the mission which has been humanitarian in the past (We are switching from a administrative aid based mission to a point of service food based one).

I have always thought that the missions would speak more eloquently and more honestly than a month of sermons. Nevertheless visitors at the new free bean kitchen might have to hear a little preaching on the speakers rather than music. I am toying with the idea of each table having a volume on off button, really I am.

Anyway the question what about religions that require we spread the good word?

; }>
 
That has nothing to do with whether or not our universe is unique, nor with how many "tries" it took. You are still left with a bare assertion as to the claim of "one universe, one try". And, as wollery mentioned, there is currently no conclusion on whether this universe is open or closed. Do not confuse a scientific model with reality, which is what Dr. Craig is doing. When the two conflict, it is the model that needs revision. As has been mentioned in other discussions, all models are wrong, some models are useful.

Also, you are missing the entire point of my mentioning of virtual particle pairs and seem to be confusing the discussion on vacuum fluctuations with the one Hawking radiation.

What happened to Wollery? I think he ran from the building as he left! The missing mass has everything to do with if the universe is open or closed. As I said I use the standard model of the big bang the same one that most of the schools use and the one that is most popular in academia of all grades including college. If the universe is open it will expand forever. How will it close? If it does not close how does it rebound and crunch and make a new universe? I am not talking about the MWT or quantum loop gravity etc. That is pure speculation. QG is not even developed. So I will repeat. This is the only universe that most of science acknowledges. Its the ONLY universe that is confirmed by empirical evidence.

As far as our discussion about virtual pairs what exactly are you saying? We were originally discussing does anything that begins to exist have a cause. I could of shut down the entire thing by telling you that virtual pairs are theoretical constructs and therefore we do not even know if they exist.

Lets keep the cause and effect to objects that are not theoretical affairs ok? It will make the debate far more honest. I was only granting you a straw because I knew everyone was struggling to name something that began to exist without a cause. See that's what I get for being nice.:confused:

PT
 
What happened to Wollery? I think he ran from the building as he left!


Why do you assume that?

The missing mass has everything to do with if the universe is open or closed. As I said I use the standard model of the big bang the same one that most of the schools use and the one that is most popular in academia of all grades including college. If the universe is open it will expand forever. How will it close? If it does not close how does it rebound and crunch and make a new universe? I am not talking about the MWT or quantum loop gravity etc. That is pure speculation. QG is not even developed. So I will repeat. This is the only universe that most of science acknowledges. Its the ONLY universe that is confirmed by empirical evidence.


Please note the use of "if". Please also note your use of "model". This is exactly what I was referring to in your post. You are assuming conclusions that have not yet been made.

As far as our discussion about virtual pairs what exactly are you saying? We were originally discussing does anything that begins to exist have a cause. I could of shut down the entire thing by telling you that virtual pairs are theoretical constructs and therefore we do not even know if they exist.


Then how do you account for the Casimir effect? If you want to state that the Casimir effect is caused by virtual particle pairs, what causes them? And, as has been pointed out, if you simply state that one-half of the pair causes the other, then you have a beautiful example of a self-sufficient internally-caused system. No outside entity required (or object or energy). Ouroboros can snack undisturbed.

Lets keep the cause and effect to objects that are not theoretical affairs ok?


You mean, like your theoretical atemporal, decision-making entity? OK.

It will make the debate far more honest. I was only granting you a straw because I knew everyone was struggling to name something that began to exist without a cause. See that's what I get for being nice.:confused:

PT


OK, let's tackle a more concrete example. How about spontaneous fission? What causes that?
 
Okay, Mojo, just give in not more than 50 words what is your most important number one thinking premise as an atheist, so that in place of God you postulate matter in randomness or what?


Yrreg, I can't explain the entire history of the universe in not more than 50 words.
 
I can not agree that P1 is untrue because of your definition. I need to review it again I suppose.
You are not reading closely. I did not say that it was untrue because of my definition.

I said it was only true if given my definition.
That is the problem. I do not agree with Aquinas (he did not have the benefit of modern science demanding that the universe began). The universe began. Its an object.
And Aquinas also agreed that the universe began. And that it was an object.

You missed the point. He said that just because it began it did not necessarily begin to exist and that there is is a distinction between those two things.

By the way, if the universe began to exist and had a cause then it is absolutely impossible that this cause was eternal, and you are simply contradicting yourself if you say it is.

If the cause creates the universe then the cause changes something and it is not changeless.
If you don't agree we can agree to disagree. I will get back with you on your set theory idea. My first reaction is that set theory need not apply it is a abstract concept and does not apply to actual objects.
If abstract concepts do not apply to actual objects then physics is in big trouble.

Anyway I am not using set theory, I am simply removing the ambiguity.

Do you think informal, ambiguous phrases apply better?

If something is not defined in precise consistent language then it is not a syllogism.

If you willy-nilly switch the object under consideration from being an event to being an object then that is bad metaphysical thinking.
 
Last edited:
So the universe was caused, and after that cause and effect began? I'm sorry, that does not compute for any one definition of the word cause.
Yep, but that is the impossibility of the concept of eternity - that the universe was created in changeless environment. You would a universe beginning to exist would count as a change.

As I said above, if the universe began to exist and was caused then the cause could not possibly have been eternal (which is defined as changeless).
 
Even if Yrreg is as bad a person as a member recently claimed, I don't understand why he remains here. Nothing gets discussed its all personal with maybe a fact or two squeezed in to try and obey the tos... Its just astonishing to watch.
But notice when an atheist makes an offending joke you say "typical atheist". When a Christian spends all of his entire threads throwing out insults you don't say "typical Christian".
 
From the article:
Hrgh...I registered for this? Hand waving? Argument from authority? Thanks, Dr. Craig...
Yeah, I have heard of argument from authority and argument from incredulity but I have never heard of argument from an authority's incredulity before.

I think that if the entire argument is based on a weak inductive empirical intuition then that would entail that the conclusion also was based on a weak inductive empirical intuition.

I also thought it funny that he said it was perfectly obvious that nothing could come from nothing, but elsewhere he says the universe came from nothing.
 
RevDisturba said:
My first reaction is that set theory need not apply it is a abstract concept and does not apply to actual objects.
Further to my remarks above if arguments about abstracts to not apply to actuals then what are you doing employing Hilbert's "Hotel" argument to argue that actual infinites are not possible?

And in fact Dr. Craig himself uses set theory in support of this premiss.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom