The certainty of God's existence.

Yes I said as much and provided links.

No another lie. Please cease and desist. I said virtual particles were a totally theoretical construct. Our universe and the Big bang has empirical evidence to support it including that the universe is OPEN. But a man of your title should know that.

Don't you read my posts? I said that my last write on virtual particles ie the clarification supersedes all others.

Lets keep the cause and effect to objects that are not theoretical affairs ok? It will make the debate far more honest.

I see. You aren't willing to discuss theoretical constructs when they oppose your point of view (virtual particle pair production), but when they support it (Big Bang origins) you want theoretical constructs to be included.

You stipulate above that you agree that the origin of the Universe is unknown and that there are multiple proposed mechanisms. All theoretical, with absolutely no way to differentiate between them.

So I guess the following quote, from you, applies.

If you have to lower yourself to theoretical constructs to prove your point you don't have a point to prove.
 
No I just clarified my position on virtual particles. THEY HAVE A CAUSE (wake up!) Fission has a cause just as radioactivity does. You are confusing random events with cause and effect.


If it is random, how can it have a cause?

BTW by accepting virtual particles as reality rather than a theoretical model it is you that are confusing the two and thinking that a theoretical construct is reality.Please get your facts correct, and drink a double shot of espresso.


So you are now claiming that virtual particles do not exist?
 
Originally Posted by RandFan How can you measure time without change?

Causality is not an easy concept to visualize. I will try to explain and ask for help from the other members if I am off base in this explanation. In human experience cause and effect would seem to be time related. However if we could observe space time like a loaf of rye bread. (I know suckie analogy but it’s the only I can think of at 430am.) The seeds are events. When we cut the bread we see events different events. I could point to hundreds of events and describe them without using time to explain them. See ;

Causality (physics) - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
For different physical theories the notions of cause and effect may be different. ... The possibility of such a time-independent view is at the basis of the ...
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Causality_(physics) -

Excerpt;

The possibility of such a time-independent view is at the basis of the deductive-nomological (D-N) view of scientific explanation, ...read more at '

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Causality

; {>
 
Okay, perhaps no one has been clear. Suppose this universe is the first one created. Now suppose God creates 10 more independent self-contained open universes with their own space-time continuum. Do you suppose there is a way for people in the 11th universe to know about any of the other universes, and do you think they may also suppose theirs is the first? Are they right?

To answer your question I would suppose (a pure speculation) that each universe would be unavailable to the other. Despite your good idea but we can't just say goddidit. That's what this discussion is about eh? An rational explanation for the existence of God?

; {>
 
So you are now claiming that virtual particles do not exist?

No. Please reread post 869 again.

Time for starbucks or maybe I will try Micky dees new espresso. Somehow Micky dees and good coffee does not compute.

; {>
 
From the article, a few lines down from your excerpt:
wikipedia said:
...In modern physics, the notion of causality had to be clarified. The insights of the theory of special relativity confirmed the assumption of causality, but they made the meaning of the word "simultaneous" observer-dependent[6]. Consequently, the relativistic principle of causality says that the cause must precede its effect according to all inertial observers. ...
You're not making a great case here.
 
To answer your question I would suppose (a pure speculation) that each universe would be unavailable to the other. Despite your good idea but we can't just say goddidit. That's what this discussion is about eh? An rational explanation for the existence of God?

; {>
I know, and I just gave you an argument why another one of your claims turns out to be insufficiently thought through.
 
No. Please reread post 869 again.


Post 869 treats virtual particles as if they are real, not as if they are theoretical constructs. It then goes on to state that a quantum vacuum is somehow different from a "true" vacuum and credits this as the source of those particles. You then accuse me of "accepting virtual particles as reality" in post 873 and claim that virtual particles are a theoretical construct.

Please make up your mind.
 
That does not make a bit of sense.

SENSE?? :eek: You of all people want sense? See if any of this makes sense:

I am a open theist christian

For anyone who doesn't know (Rev), open theism is the belief that God gave everyone free will, but he's still omnipresent and knows what's going to happen. :confused: A Christian believes Jesus Christ of Nazereth was the living son of God, born to a virgin mother, and rose from the dead.

Nothing is 100% certain, not even God. I have been saying that for 13 years.

Okay, now this quote is an entirely different belief structure that has NOTHING TO DO WITH OPEN THEISM CHRISTIANITY!!!!

RevDisturbia, you are obviously confused. You claimed to be a "former" atheist, although 13 years later you still adhere to the fact that God may not be. Let's see that stuff one more time... You say:
Nothing is 100% certain, not even God.
I am a open theist christian
...and I'm the one that makes no sense?? :boggled: Hypocracy, anyone?

I don't like jumping on people who's beliefs are different than mine, but you brought this on yourself. Your statement that God is not 100% certain is a way of thinking called "agnostic theism" -- not "open theist Christianity."
It'd be a bit weird, don't you think, preaching the word of God and Jesus when you really don't believe in them 100%?

I know I'm not going to change your view or your beliefs (or your incorrect title for a religion). I'm simply pointing out one of your massive, unfortunate contradictions.
 
From the article, a few lines down from your excerpt:
You're not making a great case here.

So you too think that cause and effect is time dependent?

I agree that wiki isn't the best of sources but its one everyone knows, isn't a blog, not a personal site, (there were four and a half million hits for "Time is independent of cause and effect").

I already know (Causality) is/can be independent of time, but was attempting to get a reference up for the members.

; {>
 
Post 869 treats virtual particles as if they are real, not as if they are theoretical constructs. It then goes on to state that a quantum vacuum is somehow different from a "true" vacuum and credits this as the source of those particles. You then accuse me of "accepting virtual particles as reality" in post 873 and claim that virtual particles are a theoretical construct.

Please make up your mind.


My mind is made up, this is in the first paragraph; "As I said these subatomic particles are theoretical entities and its not at all certain that they actually exist rather than being theoretical constructs. That’s important in this discussion. These particles if real don’t come from nothing. Not at all."

And this in the last paragraph;

I hope this clears up my take on the quantum particle thing it supersedes any thing I wrote before.


That is brutally clear. Sorry for the misunderstandings.

; {>
 
Last edited:
MikeSun5 said:
For anyone who doesn't know (Rev), open theism is the belief that God gave everyone free will, but he's still omnipresent and knows what's going to happen. A Christian believes Jesus Christ of Nazereth was the living son of God, born to a virgin mother, and rose from the dead.

First there are variations on open theism. Just as there is in atheism and some religions. I think that God knows with a high probability what we are going to do, but not 100%. That gives us free will. I believe God is omnipresent in his realm only. This universe is designed to run on probabilities so its not perfect in a biblical sense. Some Christians don’t belief in the virgin birth. Most believe he rose from the dead.

Okay, now this quote is an entirely different belief structure that has NOTHING TO DO WITH OPEN THEISM CHRISTIANITY!!!! RevDisturbia, you are obviously confused. You claimed to be a "former" atheist, although 13 years later you still adhere to the fact that God may not be. Let's see that stuff one more time... You say:

I say that no one can be 100% certain of anything. That is impossible. It does not reflect on my faith. Its kind of like light speed and time dilation. Nothing exciting happens until one gets to the 95% range of c.

.and I'm the one that makes no sense?? Hypocracy, anyone?
I don't like jumping on people who's beliefs are different than mine, but you brought this on yourself. Your statement that God is not 100% certain is a way of thinking called "agnostic theism" -- not "open theist Christianity." It'd be a bit weird, don't you think, preaching the word of God and Jesus when you really don't believe in them 100%?

Again no one has a 100% belief in anything. Nothing is 100% certain in a natural law universe. Only God is 100% accurate in his realm, however for whatever reason he designed this universe to run on uncertainties which are tied with probabilities. Throw Chaos and entropy into the mix.

I know I'm not going to change your view or your beliefs (or your incorrect title for a religion). I'm simply pointing out one of your massive, unfortunate contradictions.

You are simply wrong again. I only change if the evidence changes.

; {>
 
wollery said:
I see. You aren't willing to discuss theoretical constructs when they oppose your point of view (virtual particle pair production), but when they support it (Big Bang origins) you want theoretical constructs to be included.

Again I direct you to post 869 (forgive me if I have already answered you)

You stipulate above that you agree that the origin of the Universe is unknown and that there are multiple proposed mechanisms. All theoretical, with absolutely no way to differentiate between them.

In a scientific sense yes. Philosophical arguments such as ontological arguments have a much different criteria to meet. The quote you post is in a superseded post as per post 869. I said that out of anger more than anything else. Additionally, empirical evidence will trump theoretical evidence in every case I know of.

; {>
 
Last edited:
I say that no one can be 100% certain of anything. That is impossible....Again no one has a 100% belief in anything. Nothing is 100% certain in a natural law universe.

:jaw-dropp Wow. Just... I mean.... Wow.

Okay... first off, you don't live in a "natural law universe" if you think that a virgin had a kid and a dude came back to life. Second, certainty deals with knowledge, not belief. You're confusing two entirely different ideas (just like agnosticism vs. theism). You really don't get what I'm saying... I think you're intentionally missing it, but hey... that's typical of your ilk. :rolleyes:

You are simply wrong again. I only change if the evidence changes.

I see. So what exactly was the evidence were you presented that pulled you from atheism to "not-quite-100%" open theist Christianity?
 
The title of this thread ie certainty of Gods existence, should be edited to say 'The probability of Gods existence is high'. Or to secular types "The threat is real". :duck:The KCA and ontological arguments are only one of many evidences that point toward God. Much of emerging science fits biblical and religious concepts, of course all these claims are vehemently rejected by the secular science establishment! :catfight:

I think there are evidences from most of the major branches of science that support the argument that an intelligent agent was responsible for our fantastic universe. Yes secular humanists are aghast at this push for a new scopes monkey trial, and for good reason. They fear their paradigm is threatened.

Heck we won the last one this one should be a cake walk. I think this will be an 'war' of attrition. It doesn't have to be. The only thing we want is a bit of fairness. And equity.No totalitarianism like today, choice instead of a secular railroad and forced (exclusive) neo- Darwinism brain washing by the force of law. Hey we want our own brain washing machine, make mine a maytag.

; {>
 
I agree DC! At last someone that doesn't have to make wild disingenuous claims about my beliefs to cheer themselves up. Nothing is 100% certain, not even God. I have been saying that for 13 years.

; {>

well i would add, and you would propably not agree there,
The certainty of God's non existence is pretty certain.

;)
 
:jaw-dropp Wow. Just... I mean.... Wow.
Okay... first off, you don't live in a "natural law universe" if you think that a virgin had a kid and a dude came back to life.

Again not all Christians believe that.

Second, certainty deals with knowledge, not belief.

? How does one acquire 100% knowledge of anything?

You're confusing two entirely different ideas (just like agnosticism vs. theism). You really don't get what I'm saying... I think you're intentionally missing it, but hey... that's typical of your ilk. :rolleyes:

No you are not making sense. Nothing is 100% certain not belief, not the postulates of math nor science. If I believed in God 100% I wouldn't be here. Nor would most Christians. Having some doubt is acceptable and even the Disciples had it. Even the saints and mother Teresa. Its a human condition, a requirement and trade off for being able to carry around our soul in a vessel that can navigate the temporal universe. Eh?

; {>


PS

I see. So what exactly was the evidence were you presented that pulled you from atheism to "not-quite-100%" open theist Christianity?

To begin with I had my doubts about origins of the universe. When the big bang was confirmed, dashing sciences hopes for a static eternal universe, that was a start. I may do a thread, because it was a lot of emerging evidences.
 
well i would add, and you would propably not agree there,
The certainty of God's non existence is pretty certain.

;)

Correct I don't agree, but that's what we are here for, to come to an understanding eh? If we can not change each others opinion, no worries the truth usually comes out by the end...or maybe after the end :dig:

; {>
 
To begin with I had my doubts about origins of the universe. When the big bang was confirmed, dashing sciences hopes for a static eternal universe, that was a start. I may do a thread, because it was a lot of emerging evidences.

What makes you think science had hopes for a static eternal universe? Some scientists favoured that theory, other scientists had better evidence for a big bang approach.
 
The master of Logical Fallacies at work. They must teach it at Seminary School.
The title of this thread ie certainty of Gods existence, should be edited to say 'The probability of Gods existence is high'. Or to secular types "The threat is real". :duck:The KCA and ontological arguments are only one of many evidences that point toward God.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bare_assertion_fallacy
Much of emerging science fits biblical and religious concepts, of course all these claims are vehemently rejected by the secular science establishment! :catfight:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Texas_sharpshooter_fallacy
I think there are evidences from most of the major branches of science that support the argument that an intelligent agent was responsible for our fantastic universe.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bare_assertion_fallacy
Yes secular humanists are aghast at this push for a new scopes monkey trial, and for good reason. They fear their paradigm is threatened.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poisoning_the_well
Heck we won the last one this one should be a cake walk. I think this will be an 'war' of attrition. It doesn't have to be. The only thing we want is a bit of fairness.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_to_moderation
And equity.No totalitarianism like today, choice instead of a secular railroad and forced (exclusive) neo- Darwinism brain washing by the force of law. Hey we want our own brain washing machine, make mine a maytag.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ad_hominem
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom