The certainty of God's existence.

What happened to Wollery? I think he ran from the building as he left!
You wish! I have a life, a job, a two week old baby, a wife recovering from a C-section, three pets, and yesterday was my brother-in-law's girlfriends birthday. Oh, and I need to sleep from time to time.

The missing mass has everything to do with if the universe is open or closed. As I said I use the standard model of the big bang the same one that most of the schools use and the one that is most popular in academia of all grades including college. If the universe is open it will expand forever. How will it close? If it does not close how does it rebound and crunch and make a new universe? I am not talking about the MWT or quantum loop gravity etc. That is pure speculation. QG is not even developed. So I will repeat. This is the only universe that most of science acknowledges. Its the ONLY universe that is confirmed by empirical evidence.
All of which is completely accurate, and even more completely irrelevant.

Whether or not this Universe closes has no bearing on how it came to be, or how many tries it took.

What part of that are you having difficulty with?

As far as our discussion about virtual pairs what exactly are you saying? We were originally discussing does anything that begins to exist have a cause. I could of shut down the entire thing by telling you that virtual pairs are theoretical constructs and therefore we do not even know if they exist.
Funny, because their effects are observable. And try not to confuse virtual exchange particles with virtual pair production. In the former only one virtual particle is brought into existence, in the latter two particles are brought into existence and then annihilate. That's why it's called pair production.

Lets keep the cause and effect to objects that are not theoretical affairs ok? It will make the debate far more honest. I was only granting you a straw because I knew everyone was struggling to name something that began to exist without a cause. See that's what I get for being nice.:confused:
I didn't see anyone struggling. And now that you've been shown to be wrong about virtual particle pair production you want to stop talking about it?

Funny that. :rolleyes:
 
RevDisturba said:
I was only granting you a straw because I knew everyone was struggling to name something that began to exist without a cause.
How many things do we know about that actually begin to exist? As opposed to being rearrangements of pre-existing matter.

Well there is the universe - but I don't observe a cause for that so I can't say that it did or didn't have a cause.

What else is there?
 
Last edited:
Just went to look up virtual particles. Really cool!

See, can learn something useful in a Yrreg thread.
 
Evolution is just a theory!

...yet you consider quantum mechanics, omnipresence and resurrection to be fact?

I hate to quote myself, but sometimes you have to:
The problem of arises from frustration of vocal evangelistic atheists not being able to defeat a theist in debate.
The reason atheists will never ever defeat a theist in debate is because theists simply disregard logic, reason, and science when logic, reason, or science contradicts a theist's beliefs.
 
I am under the impression that what people also find insulting about your posts is the curtness.

"Wrong.

Wrong.

No.

Yes, but [insert reason]

No."
When someone makes the same factually false statement for the 15th time, there's often little left to say. Yes, people might feel insulted when they write a dozen paragraphs of nonsense and get a one-word reply, but my advice is don't do that, then.

Anyway, it's quite often more like:

Me said:
Ad hominem.

Ad hominem, non-sequitur.

Argument from ignorance.

Argument from authority, argument from antiquity, non-sequitur, your mother wears army boots.
 
When someone makes the same factually false statement for the 15th time, there's often little left to say. Yes, people might feel insulted when they write a dozen paragraphs of nonsense and get a one-word reply, but my advice is don't do that, then.
And as far as I know you have never accused me of being motivated by the Devil.
 
You wish! I have a life, a job, a two week old baby, a wife recovering from a C-section, three pets, and yesterday was my brother-in-law's girlfriends birthday. Oh, and I need to sleep from time to time.
I'm assuming congratulations are in order?
 
You did not make a case for your opinion.
This is just gainsaying. I did bTW.

For your book there are books that rebut it. I dont care about the battle of rebutting books.
If they exist they aren't likely part of any published peer reviewed paper.

You are incorrect.
You are gainsaying.

GR agrees with the KCA.
BS.

That said, thanks. I know you have a lot of posts to respond to. I've been in your position and it's not enviable. I wasn't impressed with the responses but I was glad I got something at all.

Cheers.
 
Last edited:
Could you expand on this? I think it's a major problem for your argument, and you look to be just handwaving it away.
Rev has dodged this one and simply declared it wrong but he has never told us how to measure time without change. It's the only means to measure time. To measure change we must compare units of change.

So, Rev, how about it? How can you measure time without change?
 
How can you measure time without change?

You're asking that to a self-proclaimed Christian theist? Here, let me save RevDisturbia some time and answer that question for him. :rolleyes:

I wish I was joking. Most theists are afraid to use the phrase, "I don't know" as an answer, and they usually tend to substitute those three words with three unrelated letters: G, O, and D.
 
Robin here is the address where Dr Craig rebuts Oppy as well as Mackie which has similar objections to P-1 and P-2 as you. If you have time look over the page because it covers the material better than I could. The reason I am doing this is because we are about to open a king sized (in length) can of worms. I included a small excerpt form the page long exchange. Anyway we can still discuss it but I thought I would provide you some of my source material in advance ;

"Graham Oppy on the Kalam Cosmological Argument

William Lane Craig

Graham Oppy has attempted to re-support J. L. Mackie's objections to the kalam cosmological argument, to which I responded in my article "Professor Mackie and the Kalam Cosmological Argument." Oppy's attempt to defend the possibility of the existence of an actual infinite is vitiated by his conflation of narrowly and broadly logical possibility. Oppy's attempt to defend the possibility of the formation of an actual infinite by successive addition founders on misinterpretations. Oppy's objections to the premiss that whatever begins to exist has a cause and to God's being that cause are based on modal confusions.

Source: "Graham Oppy on the Kalam Cosmological Argument." Sophia 32 (1993): 1-11.

Graham Oppy has recently attempted to re-support J. L. Mackie's objections to the kalam cosmological argument.1 In this discussion note, I shall try to state succinctly why I think this attempt does not succeed.
The Existence of an Actual Infinite ..."

http://www.reasonablefaith.org/site/News2?page=NewsArticle&id=5162

: {>

Well no, I never objected to P2 and I never tried to defend the existence of an actual infinite, so this is not relevant.

Basically P1 is ambiguous as a number of people have pointed out and that ambiguity needs to be addressed. Don't waste your time on P2 as currently nobody is asking about this as far as I am aware.

P1 needs to be rendered unambiguous. If you don't accept the way I have done it you should do this yourself. By the way you seem to be switching between the terms "begins" and "begins to exist" which are not necessarily equivalent, unless you are happy with the usage that an event begins to exist. But I don't think this would be useful for the argument.
 
RevDisturba said:
I don't think anything after T-0 is created or begins to exist. When something is said to begin to exist its merely a rearrangement of mass or energy.
And this is a major source of ambiguity.

You are saying:

1. Everything that begins to exist has a cause
2. We can justify this because everything that we see in nature that begins to exist has a cause
3. There is only one thing in nature that begins to exist and that is the universe itself.

That is obviously a contradiction.
 
You're asking that to a self-proclaimed Christian theist? Here, let me save RevDisturbia some time and answer that question for him. :rolleyes:

I wish I was joking. Most theists are afraid to use the phrase, "I don't know" as an answer, and they usually tend to substitute those three words with three unrelated letters: G, O, and D.
But I have already cited the standard theological definitions for eternity and RevDisturba rejects that. He even rejects the definition William Lane Craig uses (or rather one of the definitions he flip flops between).

So this "eternity" is completely undefined either in scientific terms or in theological terms. All I can glean is that there is apparently no time, but there is change and succession. But as I keep saying if there is change and succession within "eternity" we can run the entire argument again and prove that eternity cause caused.
 
Basically P1 is ambiguous as a number of people have pointed out and that ambiguity needs to be addressed. Don't waste your time on P2 as currently nobody is asking about this as far as I am aware.
Well, I rejected all his premises, but I don't mind what order he addresses them, as long as he addresses them.
 
But I have already cited the standard theological definitions for eternity and RevDisturba rejects that. He even rejects the definition William Lane Craig uses (or rather one of the definitions he flip flops between).

And he will keep rejecting anything that goes against his previously held beliefs. That's how theists operate.

I mean, how do you become a self-proclaimed "Christian theist" who quotes advanced physics literature while believing a man who was his own father rose from the dead, without cherry picking ideas and rejecting facts en masse?
 
Well, I rejected all his premises, but I don't mind what order he addresses them, as long as he addresses them.
P1 would be a good place to start.

A couple of people have pointed out the ambiguity about "begin" so this would help him to save time and address more than one person's questions at once.

We can have begin as in the beginning of a series of events, and begin as in "begin to exist" and the two are being used interchangeably.

It seems obvious to me that P1 is meaningless unless it means "the beginning of a series of events", and in that case obviously the beginning is an event with no predecessor.

I have restated the premise making this clear but I need to find out if RevDisturba accepts my premise or can resolve the ambiguity in another way.
 
What a lightweight.

wollery said:
All of which is completely accurate, and even more completely irrelevant.

Wrong

Whether or not this Universe closes has no bearing on how it came to be, or how many tries it took.
What part of that are you having difficulty with?

Why? You are saying there is no theory that if the universe is open it will expand forever? And that its possible that this is the only universe? Or that the most popular consensus is that this is the only universe so far? Or that this universe is the only one we have empirical evidence for? What is your day job again?

Funny, because their effects are observable.

Correct and complete irrelevant :rolleyes:.

And try not to confuse virtual exchange particles with virtual pair production. In the former only one virtual particle is brought into existence, in the latter two particles are brought into existence and then annihilate. That's why it's called pair production
.

Ok Mr Astrophysicist, master, sir, expert, etc :rolleyes:. I will try not to confuse the issues . Be aware we are talking about cause and effect only. I am saying that virtual particles have a cause. The side issues we were discussing had little relevance to the original claim.

I didn't see anyone struggling. And now that you've been shown to be wrong about virtual particle pair production you want to stop talking about it?
Funny that.

No, I am not wrong about anything that is relevant to the question which is cause and effect so maybe you should stick to the facts. We are talking about real events. If you have to lower yourself to theoretical constructs to prove your (secular) point you don't have a point to prove. BTW you are an professional astrophysicist huh? Would you mind telling me your specific job title? Just curious.

; {>
 
Last edited:
And he will keep rejecting anything that goes against his previously held beliefs. That's how theists operate.

I mean, how do you become a self-proclaimed "Christian theist" who quotes advanced physics literature while believing a man who was his own father rose from the dead, without cherry picking ideas and rejecting facts en masse?

I don't reject everything that goes against my previously held beliefs that's simply a lie. Remember I started out as an atheist then over the period of twenty years changed my entire paradigm. In fact I change everything to meet the emerging evidence. So either you are ignorant of the facts or have a typical hateful agenda to harm what you don't understand.

As for your last sentence again that is a lie (or is primarily lies). So I am going to have to ignore you if you insist on a personal attack as an debate tactic. You are simply frustrated you can not win in open civil and fair debate. As I said. Typical for people of your ilk.

; {>
 
Why? We are using the most popular model of the BB. Not if other universes were created via quantum loop gravity etc.
I'll say it slowly. And hopefully for the last time.

How this Universe might possibly end has no bearing on how it began or how many attempts there might have been to make it. None. At all.

I'm not interested in other universes, or other models of the Big Bang. I want to know how you can claim that this Universe was created by the one and only attempt to create any universe.

And no, you can't just say, "I'm using the most popular model of the Big Bang", because that doesn't answer the question.

Firstly, it's an appeal to popularity. Secondly, it's an appeal to authority. Thirdly, it's a hand-waving cop-out.

And just for clarity. The "most popular model of the Big Bang" has absolutely nothing to say about what caused the Big Bang. Nothing.

And we still don't actually know whether or not the Universe is open or closed, so even if we were to accept your assertion your argument still rests on a big if.

We are talking about cause and effect only. I am saying that virtual particles have a cause.
You claim that the cause in pair production is the other particle in the pair. But the pair come into existence simultaneously, so they can't cause each other. If that were the case then they must be causing each other in a non-temporal way, which kind of kills your argument.

The side issues we were discussing had little relevance to the original claim.
Given that your claim rests on there being no acausal events, it has everything to do with it.

No, stick to the facts. We are talking about real events. If you have to lower yourself to theoretical constructs to prove your point you don't have a point to prove.
So, your atemporal cause for the Big Bang is a real event, and in no way theoretical?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom