The certainty of God's existence.

Again not all Christians believe that.

O RLY?
Then why are they called Christians?


? How does one acquire 100% knowledge of anything?

You can't, at least about the big stuff.

No you are not making sense. Nothing is 100% certain not belief, not the postulates of math nor science.

:notm
I am 100% certain that this is correct:
1 + 1 = 2
There are some 100% certain things in math and science (mostly math, though).


If I believed in God 100% I wouldn't be here. Nor would most Christians.

Then why are KK and yrreg still here? They both strike me as the "know in my soul" type.

Having some doubt is acceptable and even the Disciples had it.

The Bible said:
Psalms 14:1 “The fool has said in his heart, 'There is no God.'”

Even the saints and mother Teresa.

Argument from authority. And bare assertion. Congratulations - you just made two separate logical fallacies in one sentence!

Its a human condition, a requirement and trade off for being able to carry around our soul in a vessel that can navigate the temporal universe. Eh?

Bare assertion again.

; {>


PS



To begin with I had my doubts about origins of the universe. When the big bang was confirmed, dashing sciences hopes for a static eternal universe, that was a start.

Start of what now?

I may do a thread, because it was a lot of emerging evidences.

This is fun. Let's do it again!
 
Last edited:
Much of emerging science fits biblical and religious concepts

....snip....

I think there are evidences from most of the major branches of science that support the argument that an intelligent agent was responsible for our fantastic universe.
I can't wait to see this evidence.

Any of it empirical?
 
The Rev has lost the debate pages ago and is the only one not acknowledging this fact. But he is stubborn as yrreg and will never admit his defeat.
 
The KCA argument was new to me, and it's nonsense. I quote:

"P1: If the universe has no beginning, there have been an infinite number of events.
P2: An infinite number of events is an absurdity and is impossible."

P2 is an example of the elementary fallacy of assuming that which you are trying to prove.
 
Much of emerging science fits biblical and religious concepts, of course all these claims are vehemently rejected by the secular science establishment!
Can you give us one or two examples? Not just the claims, but their vehement rejection?
 
The KCA argument was new to me, and it's nonsense. I quote:

"P1: If the universe has no beginning, there have been an infinite number of events.
P2: An infinite number of events is an absurdity and is impossible."

P2 is an example of the elementary fallacy of assuming that which you are trying to prove.


But it was doing so well up until there.
 
SENSE?? :eek: You of all people want sense? See if any of this makes sense:



For anyone who doesn't know (Rev), open theism is the belief that God gave everyone free will, but he's still omnipresent and knows what's going to happen. :confused: A Christian believes Jesus Christ of Nazereth was the living son of God, born to a virgin mother, and rose from the dead.



Well, to be fair, not necessarily. John Shelby Spong describes himself anew as a Christian in each of his books just before he proceeds to deconstruct the entire basis of Christianity for the next three hundred-odd pages. He always ends up explaining that he considers himself a Christian because his particular faith tradition came from the mythos of Jesus of Nazareth, not because of a literal belief in the tenets of Christianity (which wouldn't make much sense by that point, seeing as how he just finished demolishing them all in the book.)
 
The title of this thread ie certainty of Gods existence, should be edited to say 'The probability of Gods existence is high'. Or to secular types "The threat is real".
Sorry, Rev. This is a daydream.

To establish your claim, you have to establish all your premises. You have so far failed to establish any of them. Indeed, you are further from this now than you were when you started.

There's a reason that no-one is ever convinced by this sort of argument: They are constructed from the conclusion. They only appear convincing if you accept the conclusion and are willing to overlook the flaws and inconsistencies.

We don't accept the conclusion. That means you have to actually show that your argument is sound. Unfortunately for you, it's not.

The KCA and ontological arguments are only one of many evidences that point toward God.
Not only are they not evidence, they are not even sound arguments.

Much of emerging science fits biblical and religious concepts, of course all these claims are vehemently rejected by the secular science establishment!
Because it's not true.

I think there are evidences from most of the major branches of science that support the argument that an intelligent agent was responsible for our fantastic universe.
These "evidences" of yours exist, again, only in your imagination.

Yes secular humanists are aghast at this push for a new scopes monkey trial, and for good reason. They fear their paradigm is threatened.
Is that what we fear? Really?

Heck we won the last one this one should be a cake walk.
Yes, the forces of intolerance and ignorance won at State v. Scopes. Of course, the result was overturned, but it ushered in three decades of abysmal biology education in the United States. Fortunately, that has largely been overturned, and, despite the best efforts of entities such as the Discovery Institute and the Texas Board of Education, the Theory of Evolution is taught in every public school in the nation.

I think this will be an 'war' of attrition.
Yes, I fully agree.

It doesn't have to be.
No. All you have to do is accept that you are wrong, and it will all be over.

The only thing we want is a bit of fairness.
Clearly untrue from your preceding and following statements.

And equity.
Likewise untrue.

No totalitarianism like today, choice instead of a secular railroad and forced (exclusive) neo- Darwinism brain washing by the force of law. Hey we want our own brain washing machine, make mine a maytag.
And here we are.

Now, your motives here don't speak to the soundness of your argument. It's an avalanche of absurdities in its own right.

But this does put the lie to your previous statements.

I'm sorry, Rev, but you are even more hopelessly misguided here than in your KCA debacle. There is no "brainwashing". This is science education.

What is it, exactly, that you dispute?

That the world is 4.6 billion years old? Hardly, because you've already asserted that the Universe is 14 billion years old.

That we have a fossil record dating back hundreds of millions of years? Why, when you accept that the Universe is far older than that?

That the forces of genetic variation and natural selection shaped all life on this planet? You haven't spoken to that, merely cast aspersions at the unifying theory of all biology.

Well, news for you, Rev. The evidence supporting the Theory of Evolution is overwhelming. It is quite literally endless, because new findings are published faster than you can read them. And it's all out there for you to examine yourself. No secrets. No conspiracies.

The fossil record by itself is more than enough evidence to conclude that the Theory of Evolution is correct.

The molecular evidence by itself is more than enough to conclude that the Theory of Evolution is correct.

And we've seen it happen.

Darwin was right, RevD. If that's a problem for you, if that's a problem for your religion, then it's you that's wrong, your religion that's wrong. We can't help you there. You'll have to help yourself.
 
What makes you think science had hopes for a static eternal universe? Some scientists favoured that theory, other scientists had better evidence for a big bang approach.
He demonstrated the same fundamental misunderstanding of science in his comments on the Higgs boson. And a different, but deeper misunderstanding in his comments on evolution.

RevD, science has one goal: To make testable predictions. If the theory is not true - if it doesn't accurately represent the Universe around us - its predictions will fail and it will be discarded.

It doesn't matter whether your pet theory says the Universe is static or expanding. What matters is which one better predicts the behaviour of the actualy Universe. If your theory is wrong, it gets thrown out. That's how science works. That's why science works.

This is true for the Theory of Evolution just as it is for every theory. Evolution hasn't been discarded not because of some culture war or secular bias, but because it is correct.
 
Last edited:
So I am going to have to ignore you if you insist on a personal attack as an debate tactic. You are simply frustrated you can not win in open civil and fair debate. As I said. Typical for people of your ilk.
Which is exactly what your disrespectful reply to wollery was so I hope you understand why you are now on ignore.
 
Sorry, Rev. This is a daydream.

To establish your claim, you have to establish all your premises. You have so far failed to establish any of them. Indeed, you are further from this now than you were when you started.

There's a reason that no-one is ever convinced by this sort of argument: They are constructed from the conclusion. They only appear convincing if you accept the conclusion and are willing to overlook the flaws and inconsistencies.

We don't accept the conclusion. That means you have to actually show that your argument is sound. Unfortunately for you, it's not.


Not only are they not evidence, they are not even sound arguments.


Because it's not true.


These "evidences" of yours exist, again, only in your imagination.


Is that what we fear? Really?


Yes, the forces of intolerance and ignorance won at State v. Scopes. Of course, the result was overturned, but it ushered in three decades of abysmal biology education in the United States. Fortunately, that has largely been overturned, and, despite the best efforts of entities such as the Discovery Institute and the Texas Board of Education, the Theory of Evolution is taught in every public school in the nation.


Yes, I fully agree.


No. All you have to do is accept that you are wrong, and it will all be over.


Clearly untrue from your preceding and following statements.


Likewise untrue.


And here we are.

Now, your motives here don't speak to the soundness of your argument. It's an avalanche of absurdities in its own right.

But this does put the lie to your previous statements.

I'm sorry, Rev, but you are even more hopelessly misguided here than in your KCA debacle. There is no "brainwashing". This is science education.

What is it, exactly, that you dispute?

That the world is 4.6 billion years old? Hardly, because you've already asserted that the Universe is 14 billion years old.

That we have a fossil record dating back hundreds of millions of years? Why, when you accept that the Universe is far older than that?

That the forces of genetic variation and natural selection shaped all life on this planet? You haven't spoken to that, merely cast aspersions at the unifying theory of all biology.

Well, news for you, Rev. The evidence supporting the Theory of Evolution is overwhelming. It is quite literally endless, because new findings are published faster than you can read them. And it's all out there for you to examine yourself. No secrets. No conspiracies.

The fossil record by itself is more than enough evidence to conclude that the Theory of Evolution is correct.

The molecular evidence by itself is more than enough to conclude that the Theory of Evolution is correct.

And we've seen it happen.

Darwin was right, RevD. If that's a problem for you, if that's a problem for your religion, then it's you that's wrong, your religion that's wrong. We can't help you there. You'll have to help yourself.

Pixy, you have my compliments. But if RevD actually responds to your post I will be astonished. He's just another yrreg, remember; this is around the time when he'll head off on his own and forget that this thread ever happened.
 
The KCA and ontological arguments are only one of many evidences that point toward God.
Human progress has advanced because logic and truth are compelling. Scientists aren't really interested in propagating falsehoods. They are human, fully capable of error and ego but pet theories that lack rigor and stand in contrast to the best available evidence are discarded.

The KCA and other ontological arguments have not made any headway in the scientific community for simple reasons. They are not parsimonious (they posit undefined entities with unknown powers), they are not compelling, they have no explanatory power and they make few if any falsifiable predictions.

Experts have a term for such arguments. Unfortunately, decorum and forum rules prevent me from repeating it here.
 
Last edited:
Hi Pixy! Why do you think some resort to insult then? Its frustration yes? I know some anger is expressed because some theists ignore the evidence of science etc. And I agree that the problem is not exclusive to either side. I have to say that the non theists are far more likely to resort to insult than are the religious. Unless of course you see one christian trying to defend himself from five or six 'people' intent on doing him harm. ; }>

How many rude atheists DOES it take to match the venomous hatred of one Christian who openly expresses a desire to be present at the inauguration of eternal suffering for a fellow human being...and defends this pronoucement of seething contempt as being somehow righteous? Soldier of the Lord indeed, to bravely share his sadistic delight at the prospect of his opponents being tortured on the treacherous battlefield of the internet forums!

It's one thing to believe someone is going to hell, another to say so, and quite another to desire to witness it.

I submit that all the rudeness in this thread that the Rev complains of combined pales in comparison to the vitriolic rage contained in this one remark.

I confess that I am borrowing the Rev's style of language for my comment, but in contrast to his posts, the level of histrionics is actually comparable to the level of insult.

I am tempted to accept the cop-out of 'I didn't mean it how it sounded' or 'I was just kidding', or even 'you misunderstood me'; but as a stickler for apologies when not quoted exactly I'm sure he comprehends what the right thing to do is, at least when it is explicitly pointed to.

I hope this isn't taken too personally: I wish the Reverend a long, fruitful, and pleasant life; and if, to my surprise, there is a heavenly afterlife, I fervently hope he is admitted; and if he is destined for some post-death punishment I sincerely wish that it is administered by a just deity who would never permit more suffering than is merited by the Reverend's finite crimes during his temporally-bounded lifetime. After all, I'm not a monster.
 
Last edited:
My mind is made up, this is in the first paragraph; "As I said these subatomic particles are theoretical entities and its not at all certain that they actually exist rather than being theoretical constructs. That’s important in this discussion.


So they are simply theoretical (my italicizing)? So you have no idea whether or not they exist (my underlining)? I agree that it is important, because if they do not exist and are simply theoretical constructs, where do the effects that they generate come from?

These particles if real don’t come from nothing. Not at all."


And now you are treating them as if they are real. It sounds to me like you are trying to have it three different ways simultaneously, which is why your statements are confusing and contradictory.

Superpositioning only works on phenomena that experience wave/particle duality, not on assertions.
 
SENSE?? :eek: You of all people want sense? See if any of this makes sense:



For anyone who doesn't know (Rev), open theism is the belief that God gave everyone free will, but he's still omnipresent and knows what's going to happen. :confused: A Christian believes Jesus Christ of Nazereth was the living son of God, born to a virgin mother, and rose from the dead.



Okay, now this quote is an entirely different belief structure that has NOTHING TO DO WITH OPEN THEISM CHRISTIANITY!!!!

RevDisturbia, you are obviously confused. You claimed to be a "former" atheist, although 13 years later you still adhere to the fact that God may not be. Let's see that stuff one more time... You say:

...and I'm the one that makes no sense?? :boggled: Hypocracy, anyone?

I don't like jumping on people who's beliefs are different than mine, but you brought this on yourself. Your statement that God is not 100% certain is a way of thinking called "agnostic theism" -- not "open theist Christianity."
It'd be a bit weird, don't you think, preaching the word of God and Jesus when you really don't believe in them 100%?

I know I'm not going to change your view or your beliefs (or your incorrect title for a religion). I'm simply pointing out one of your massive, unfortunate contradictions.

To be fair, there is no contradiction or hypocrisy involved in being an agnostic theist, and I don't think open theists are required to claim certainty. Clearly the Rev believes in God while acknowledging there is no way to be certain of his existence. In counterpoint, the agnostic atheist does not believe in God while acknnowledging there is no way to be certain that some such being does not exist. I should also think that theists and atheists both should be allowed their doubts.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom