The certainty of God's existence.

Hi Pixy. No the argument is arrived at by deductive logic.
Nope. Sorry, Rev.

What you are doing here is cargo-cult logic. You keep arguing that your syllogisms are valid. Perhaps they are, some of them. Perhaps so. We are still debating the point.

But they are not, not remotely, sound. P1 and P2 are false, so P3 is, at best, an argument by bare assertion.

"You will not apply my precept," he said, shaking his head. "How often have I said to you that when you have eliminated the impossible, whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth? We know that he did not come through the door, the window, or the chimney. We also know that he could not have been concealed in the room, as there is no concealment possible. When, then, did he come?"
He didn't.

Ah Yes, my dear Pixy, P1 and P2 is in the bold so to speak...
Whether they are in the bold or not, it remains that they are untrue.

None of your premises were true when you first stated them, and nothing you have said since has changed this in the least. On the contrary, you have introduced an entire raft of new logical fallacies to your argument.

The KCA perhaps has the outward appearance of a logical argument, but it falls apart upon even cursory examination with a properly critical eye. The terms used are not only not properly defined, they change meaning from one premise to the next. The premises are not only unsupported, they are established as factually false. And there's still the gaping non-sequitur of P6, that you haven't really addressed at all.
 
I have told everyone here that several times. Care to look again? Hint; a open vs a closed universe.

; }>
Tells us absolutely nothing about how many tries it took to get this Universe. If this Universe happens to be open (jury still out on that by the way) then that only tells us that it won't end in a big crunch that could cause a new Universe.

But since nobody knows how this Universe came into existence you can't possibly know how many "attempts" there were at making it.

You're taking an assumption about this Universe (i.e., that it is open), and an assumption about how universes are made, and then taking a flying leap across a huge chasm of logic to arrive at a totally unfounded conclusion.

And the worst part is the absolute certainty with which you make these statements. :nope:
 
Hi Pixy! Why do you think some resort to insult then? Its frustration yes? I know some anger is expressed because some theists ignore the evidence of science etc.
And the rules of logic, and the necessity for rigorous definitions...

And I agree that the problem is not exclusive to either side. I have to say that the non theists are far more likely to resort to insult than are the religious.
With all due respect, piffle. Read Yrreg's posts sometime. Every line is an insult. (And a logical fallacy to boot, but that's beside the point.)
 
From the article:
Hrgh...I registered for this? Hand waving? Argument from authority? Thanks, Dr. Craig...

First of all, as knowledgeable people pointed out, vitual particles do this all the time. Secondly, these examples would all be governed by the laws that apply to rearrangements of existing energy within this unverse; not to new universes. The rules that govern the creation of universes are not necessarily the rules that govern the rearrangement of energy within a universe. This has not been proven or even made likely; it's simply ignored. Is this really all he's got?

:hb:


:jaw-dropp
My dear fellow member did you forget your science? Virtual particles have a TWIN! I have said this so many times that I want to hurl virtual vomit! The green Linda Blair kind. My head wants to spin and I want to speak in a satan voice....; Do your homework lest ye be slaughtered in debate with Dr Craig...!!"

Now once more? ; a virtual particle has a what? A twin. The twin is the cause of the particle existing or popping in out of not nowhere but somewhere. ; }>
 
Last edited:
I have told everyone here that several times. Care to look again? Hint; a open vs a closed universe.
Non-sequitur.

I am sorry but no I think that the logical implications even include the metaphysical concept of the universe being caused to exist by an cause. Of course after the universe began to exist and natural law was born we could observe cause and effect.
Fallacy of composition, and by your own admission, a fallacy of decomposition, and an argument by bare assertion, and thus a bidirectional non-sequitur. Also equivocation.

If we were playing logical fallacy Scrabble, you would have just scored 140 points.
 
:jaw-dropp
My dear fellow member did you forget your science? Virtual particles have a TWIN! I have said this so many times that I want to hurl virtual vomit! The green Linda Blair kind. My head wants to spin and I want to speak in a satan voice....; Do your homework lest ye be slaughtered in debate with Dr Craig...!!"

Now once more? ; a virtual particle has a what? A twin. The twin is the cause of the particle existing or popping in out of not nowhere but somewhere. ; }>

Which one of the twins is the cause?
 
Tells us absolutely nothing about how many tries it took to get this Universe. If this Universe happens to be open (jury still out on that by the way) then that only tells us that it won't end in a big crunch that could cause a new Universe.

But since nobody knows how this Universe came into existence you can't possibly know how many "attempts" there were at making it.

You're taking an assumption about this Universe (i.e., that it is open), and an assumption about how universes are made, and then taking a flying leap across a huge chasm of logic to arrive at a totally unfounded conclusion.

And the worst part is the absolute certainty with which you make these statements. :nope:

Google open universe. Again according to the observational evidence and other evidences we do not have nearly the mass to close this universe. If It had more mass it MIGHT rebound into a crunch and then make a new universe from a new big bang. The reason we think this is the only universe is because it is going to expand 'forever' so it has no mechanism to make more than this very one that I am typing this response to you in.

I will attempt to help you by finding a thousand or so links and posting one or two. Really with all due respect this is basic common knowledge to anyone that contemplates these things.
; }>

ps I never say anything is 100% certain.I always say that there are other theories etc. So please get your facts straight when referring to anything about me. I base my paradigm on the uncertainty of everything.

Maybe if you read this (I have included the descriptive paragraph for your benefit).

Cosmic Hide and Seek: The Search for the Missing Mass
What does the expansion of the universe have to do with the missing mass? The more mass, the more gravity. Whether the universe is closed, open, ...
www.eclipse.net/~cmmiller/DM/


http://www.eclipse.net/~cmmiller/DM/
 
Last edited:
My dear fellow member did you forget your science? Virtual particles have a TWIN!
Not quite. Virtual particles exist in pairs.

I have said this so many times that I want to hurl virtual vomit! The green Linda Blair kind. My head wants to spin and I want to speak in a satan voice....; Do your homework lest ye be slaughtered in debate with Dr Craig...!!"
Argument from authority.

Now once more? ; a virtual particle has a what? A twin. The twin is the cause of the particle existing or popping in out of not nowhere but somewhere. ; }>
To repeat myself, this is so bad it's not even wrong.

Virtual particles exist only in pairs. The particle and its anti-particle are created simultaneously. Neither can be the cause for the other.
 
:jaw-dropp
My dear fellow member did you forget your science? Virtual particles have a TWIN! I have said this so many times that I want to hurl virtual vomit! The green Linda Blair kind. My head wants to spin and I want to speak in a satan voice....; Do your homework lest ye be slaughtered in debate with Dr Craig...!!"

Now once more a virtual particle has a what? A twin. The twin is the cause of the particle existing or popping in out of not nowhere but somewhere. ; }>
So let's see if I got this right. You have twin virtual particles, let's call them Bill and Ted.

What you're saying is that Bill causes Ted to come into existence. But what causes Bill to come into existence?

It can't be Ted, because that would mean that Ted had to come into existence before Bill, otherwise effect precedes cause, and we know that that can't happen. For Bill to cause Ted to exist Bill must precede Ted.

But Bill and Ted come into existence at the same time! Which means that cause and effect are mutual and simultaneous. The cause is the effect, and vice versa. :boggled:
 
Last edited:
Google open universe. Again according to the observational evidence and other evidences we do not have nearly the mass to close this universe. If It had more mass it MIGHT rebound into a crunch and then make a new universe from a new big bang. The reason we think this is the only universe is because it is going to expand 'forever' so it has no mechanism to make more than this very one that I am typing this response to you in.
Which (once again) tells us absolutely nothing about any previous universes, even assuming that previous universes were necessary to produce this Universe, which is a big assumption. Further it tells us absolutely nothing about how many "attempts" there were at making universes "before" this Universe came to be.

The best that you can state is that the one single event that made this Universe was the only event that made this Universe.

I know it's a tautology, but that's what happens when you try to make definitive statements about things that are beyond the bounds of possible investigation.
 
Google open universe. Again according to the observational evidence and other evidences we do not have nearly the mass to close this universe.
And?

If It had more mass it MIGHT rebound into a crunch and then make a new universe from a new big bang.
And?

The reason we think this is the only universe
Who's this "we", Reverend?

is because it is going to expand 'forever' so it has no mechanism to make more
Wrong, irrelevant, contradicts your own argument, non-sequitur, and its mother dresses it funny.

I will attempt to help you by finding a thousand or so links and posting one or two. Really with all due respect this is basic common knowledge to anyone that contemplates these things. ; }>
Then perhaps you would be advised seek out more than the basic common knowledge, because you are arguing with an astrophysicist.

(No, not me. I'm just some guy on the internet.)
 
So let's see if I got this right. You have twin virtual particles, let's call them Bill and Ted.

What you're saying is that Bill causes Ted to come into existence. But what Bill to come into existence?

It can't be Ted, because that would mean that Ted had to come into existence before Bill, otherwise effect precedes cause, and we know that that can't happen. For Bill to cause Ted to exist Bill must precede Ted.

But Bill and Ted come into existence at the same time! Which means that cause and effect are mutual and simultaneous. The cause is the effect, and vice versa. :boggled:

It's genius! Genius, I say! Congratulations, Wollery! You have just proven that time is an illusion! Lunchtime, doubly so!
 
Google open universe. Again according to the observational evidence and other evidences we do not have nearly the mass to close this universe. If It had more mass it MIGHT rebound into a crunch and then make a new universe from a new big bang. The reason we think this is the only universe is because it is going to expand 'forever' so it has no mechanism to make more than this very one that I am typing this response to you in.

I will attempt to help you by finding a thousand or so links and posting one or two. Really with all due respect this is basic common knowledge to anyone that contemplates these things.
; }>

ps I never say anything is 100% certain.I always say that there are other theories etc. So please get your facts straight when referring to anything about me. I base my paradigm on the uncertainty of everything.

Maybe if you read this (I have included the descriptive paragraph for your benefit).

Cosmic Hide and Seek: The Search for the Missing Mass
What does the expansion of the universe have to do with the missing mass? The more mass, the more gravity. Whether the universe is closed, open, ...
www.eclipse.net/~cmmiller/DM/


http://www.eclipse.net/~cmmiller/DM/

That sure told you Wollery. Bet you wish you knew some basic astronomy now, huh?

Hang on. . .(checks Wollery's profile information)
 
Last edited:
So let's see if I got this right. You have twin virtual particles, let's call them Bill and Ted.

What you're saying is that Bill causes Ted to come into existence. But what causes Bill to come into existence?

It can't be Ted, because that would mean that Ted had to come into existence before Bill, otherwise effect precedes cause, and we know that that can't happen. For Bill to cause Ted to exist Bill must precede Ted.

But Bill and Ted come into existence at the same time! Which means that cause and effect are mutual and simultaneous. The cause is the effect, and vice versa. :boggled:

To start out with bill and ted are conjoined twins. Ted and bill exist in a an housing project called the quantum foam. There are many residents. Bill is talking to ted and all the sudden ted vanishes,yes its messy ! I am sitting in a housing project called reality. Then all the sudden half of the co joined twins arrive on my couch but he can only stay for a fraction of a second, then he has to go back and be joined with his twin lest he die.

That's more accurate.

; {>
 
So the cause of the twin particles existing is the twin particles popping into existence?

Only one part of the twins can pop into existence the other remains where it was. (there are differing interpertations of 'where' it was , was or what it was) ; {>
 
The twin pops existence is the event the cause is its twin.

;{>

I must be tired, what does this say? Can someone translate please? (I do understand the paired/twin/whatever virtual particle thing...I think...if it's the same thing from the SGU a while back where they were talking about spin up/down and not being able to use it as FTL communication).

Edit: I just read the next few posts after that one....nevermind I'll figure it out in the morning (brain hurt now......fire hot, tree pretty)
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom