The certainty of God's existence.

No I wasn't trying to do that. I was attempting to correct you nicely. I picked out QT because it was the best way to rebut your concerns. Sorry if I offended you. The reason that creation of universes do not have to have a scientific explanation is because our rules of physics break down before T-0 'arrives'.
Okay, and could one possibly construe this as an indication that perhaps assuming that rules of causation do extend beyond this border is er...frivolous?

So we have to use other tools such as cosmological arguments and logic to explore what may of happened. There is a huge difference between a philosophical argument and a scientific theory. They both have criteria they must meet. However a cosmological argument is much better than "I don't know and I don't like that type of argument because it hints at God" .
Great, so you're saying that the Kalam Cosmological Argument proves that a possibly intelligent God may have intentionally created the universe, given the assumption that the creation of universes obeys the same rules as the creation of things like photons or wedgwood ceramics; and that infinity is a number.

So to summarize the reason the creation of a universe does not obey our rules of science is that its now a metaphysical construct which neither agrees or disagrees with science.

; }>
So I don't have to agree. Good, I'd say we're done here then.
 
Last edited:
Time to get out in the real world, do mom's meds and take bogie for a walk, counting my basset I have three invalids to care for!
: {>

1bug.jpg
 
Last edited:
I thought you were reasonable. Thanks for correcting my misperception.
It took you this long to figure it out? When someone attempt to base arguments on scientific concepts but does not understand it, reasonable is the last label I'd use.
 
Evolution is just a theory! Saying that to a neodarwin proponent is worse than calling a woman the C word.
Ah, that's slightly different. Evolution is both a theory and a fact. The fact of evolution is straightforward observation: New species arise. Not only do we have a couple of million living species that rather strongly suggest this, and the fossil record that very strongly indicates this, we've seen it happen, in the lab and in nature.

The theory of evolution explains how this happens.

So saying "evolution is just a theory" is factually false, and saying "the theory of evolution is just a theory" is redundant.

Anyway you gotta love string theory then. Its a non predictive waste of time and hardly deserves to be called theory.
It would for the most part be better termed a model, but it does make some testable predictions (particularly concerning gravity) and these predictions are being tested.

Again until the higgs boson is found quantum theory is incomplete.
You seem confused.

First, there is no such thing as "quantum theory". There is a field known as quantum mechanics (QM), which includes such areas as quantum chromodynamics (QCD), quantum electrodynamics (QED) and quantum field theory (QFT).

Second, quantum mechanics does not rise or fall on - or even require - the existence of the Higgs boson. The Higgs boson is predicted to exist within a certain range of energies by the Standard Model. The Standard Model might be wrong. That would be fine, and offer new and exciting opportunities for research. It wouldn't change (for example) QED, which is the most thoroughly and accurately tested scientific theory we have.

Large Hadron Collider: The Higgs boson vs. John's jackets
We need a theory of quantum gravity, not toys for chasing some ..... The elusive Higgs boson is so central to the standard model - the theory on which ...
www.god-does-not-play-dice.net/LHC.html -
Is this meant somehow to be apropos?
 
I thought he was reasonably reasonable. Though I also think he could have told us a little earlier that the KCA is only hypothetically an argument.
 
To start out with bill and ted are conjoined twins. Ted and bill exist in a an housing project called the quantum foam. There are many residents. Bill is talking to ted and all the sudden ted vanishes,yes its messy ! I am sitting in a housing project called reality. Then all the sudden half of the co joined twins arrive on my couch but he can only stay for a fraction of a second, then he has to go back and be joined with his twin lest he die.

That's more accurate.

; {>
 
This whole thing started to remind me of the Bigfoot conservation presentation in Futurama.

"Bigfoot is a crucial part of the ecosystem, if he exists. So let's all help keep Bigfoot possibly alive for future generations to enjoy unless he doesn't exist. THE END!!"
 
This is an yrreg thread, after all. Which definition of reasonable are we using, and who are we comparing him with?
I'm comparing to theists and other believers I've talked to on these boards. That varies from people like kurious kathy and her husband to lifegazer and Interesting Ian, to homeopaths like kumar and Dr.MAS and conspiracy theorists of various types.

RevDisturba actually honestly answers questions most of the time, and I have little trouble imagining him admitting he could be wrong about something, if he hasn't already. That's quite a bit right there.
 
I'm comparing to theists and other believers I've talked to on these boards. That varies from people like kurious kathy and her husband to lifegazer and Interesting Ian, to homeopaths like kumar and Dr.MAS and conspiracy theorists of various types.

RevDisturba actually honestly answers questions most of the time, and I have little trouble imagining him admitting he could be wrong about something, if he hasn't already. That's quite a bit right there.
Your faith is stronger than mine :D
 
I thought you were reasonable. Thanks for correcting my misperception.

You should include the entire sentence. Do you have an adgenda? Look; I suppose that you think all Christians are wonderful huh? You never delineate between fundies or evangelicals etc ?

It was entirely dishonest of you to post one word out of my reply then hole it up like you had done something of merit. Well you did, you added to the mistrust and reduced my respect for you.

; {>
 
Jezzus Pixi the reason I do not often answer your posts even when you temporarily cut the insults for reasons like this ;

You seem confused.

First, there is no such thing as "quantum theory". There is a field known as quantum mechanics (QM), which includes such areas as quantum chromodynamics (QCD), quantum electrodynamics (QED) and quantum field theory (QFT).

I answer like this, I know I know it will be met with open mouthed wonder but here we go anyway ;

Definitions of quantum theory on the Web:

* (physics) a physical theory that certain properties occur only in discrete amounts (quanta)
wordnetweb.princeton.edu/perl/webwn

* Quantum mechanics is a set of principles underlying the most fundamental known description of all physical systems at the submicroscopic scale (at the atomic level). ...
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Quantum_Theory

* Quantum Theory is an upcoming video game developed and published by Tecmo exclusively for the PlayStation 3. The game centers around two characters named Syd and Fillena who must fight through a "living tower." The game will feature a cover system similar to kill.switch, Gears of War, and ''''. ...
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_Theory_(video_game)

* A theory developed in early 20th century, according to which nuclear and radiation phenomena can be explained by assuming that energy only occurs in discrete amounts called quanta. In current usage quantum theory may refer to any or all of the following, depending on the context:
en.wiktionary.org/wiki/quantum_theory

* (Also quantum mechanics.) A theory of matter and radiation, developed in its essentials mostly between 1900 and 1930, distinguished from classical theory (or classical mechanics, Newtonian mechanics) in two important respects: discreteness and indeterminism. ...
amsglossary.allenpress.com/glossary/browse

* The branch of physical chemistry that describes how energy can only exist at certain levels and makes generalizations about how atoms behave from ...
misterguch.brinkster.net/vocabulary.html

* The modern theory of discretized matter, electromagnetic radiation, and interaction between matter and radiation. ...
www.csa.com/discoveryguides/crypt/gloss.php

* Introduced by Planck (1900) as an improvement upon classical Newtonian mechanics. An important principle is that some physical quantities can only assume discrete values.
www.ecotao.com/holism/glosoz.htm

* The theory that energy can only be absorbed or radiated in discrete values or quanta. All particles are subject to quantum theory. ...
www.fisicx.com/quickreference/science/glossary.html

* deBroglie waves, Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle, the Schrödinger equation. One-electron atoms. Many-electron atoms. ...
www.chem.rochester.edu/courses/courses.php

* The set of physical laws that apply primarily on a very small scale, the size of atoms or smaller.
library.thinkquest.org/15418/cgi-bin/pageserv/srv.cgi

* The theory first stated by Max Planck (before the Physical Society of Berlin on December 14, 1900) that all electromagnetic radiation is emitted and absorbed in quanta , each of magnitude hv , h being the Planck constant and v the frequency of the radiation. See radiation laws.
er.jsc.nasa.gov/seh/q.html

* the physics theory stating that radiant energy is transmitted in the form of discrete units or quanta; Albert Einstein developed this theory from ...
www.weizmann-usa.org/site/News2

* A physical theory that explains the behavior of matter in terms of particular energy levels-quantum levels-within atoms and other species.
bcs.whfreeman.com/practiceofchemistry//cat_080/gloss.htm

* A major branch of modern physics arguing for the emission of light (radiant energy) in discrete amounts or "quanta". It is now established as a corner-stone of modern physics, even though its philosophical problems (concerning reality and causality) remain contentious.
www.theology.edu/theology/glossary.htm

Like I said Jeesus.....If you could cut the obvious useless claims and ad hoc material out of your posts we may be able to communicate. Some of your questions and conclusions are actually very good, some are only just valid and some are completely worthless which leads me to believe you have other reasons to post such mundane material. I just think you are insincere (at times) when you say all you want is productive debate.

; {>
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom