The certainty of God's existence.

I must be tired, what does this say? Can someone translate please? (I do understand the paired/twin/whatever virtual particle thing...I think...if it's the same thing from the SGU a while back where they were talking about spin up/down and not being able to use it as FTL communication).

He says that one of the twins comes into existence spontaneously, then brings its twin in afterward.
But what causes the first twin to come into existence?
 
...the logical implications even include the metaphysical concept of the universe being caused to exist ... Of course after the universe began to exist ... we could observe cause and effect. ; {>
So the universe was caused, and after that cause and effect began? I'm sorry, that does not compute for any one definition of the word cause. Cause, effect, and time are all strictly observed within our universe. On what grounds do you allow one outside and not the other? And how are they not inextricably linked?

The only reason I can see at the moment is that it's a way to get out of impossibility of infinites. A premise that is itself arrived at by doing arithmetic with infinites as if infinity were a number, so why bother?
In other words:

1) We don't know if actual infinites exist, but Hilbert's hotel certainly isn't a logical argument that proves they don't, and there is no logical inconsistency in the concept of infinity itself.
2) No justification is given for the assertion that the creation of universes obeys the laws of physics within that universe.
3) No justification is given nor is there reason to assume that causation can happen without time.

Or, in yet other words: The Kalam Cosmological Argument fails to solve a non-problem of its own making.
 
I must be tired, what does this say? Can someone translate please? (I do understand the paired/twin/whatever virtual particle thing...I think...if it's the same thing from the SGU a while back where they were talking about spin up/down and not being able to use it as FTL communication).

Yes quarks up down strange etc...Confusing! But wonderful and interesting. Maybe this will help?

In physics, a virtual particle is a particle that exists for a limited time and space, introducing uncertainty in their energy and momentum due to ...
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virtual_particle

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virtual_particle

I am going to check out this site for validity and content you may want to read it as well.

http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&...GESsq5F5rfmQf46rHSBg&sa=X&oi=definer&ct=&cd=1

; }>
 
He says that one of the twins comes into existence spontaneously, then brings its twin in afterward.
But what causes the first twin to come into existence?

Hang on, (thank you btw), there isn't a "afterward" is there? Isn't the pair thing simultaneous? I must be thinking of the wrong thing, will definately stop now.
 
To start out with bill and ted are conjoined twins. Ted and bill exist in a an housing project called the quantum foam. There are many residents. Bill is talking to ted and all the sudden ted vanishes,yes its messy ! I am sitting in a housing project called reality. Then all the sudden half of the co joined twins arrive on my couch but he can only stay for a fraction of a second, then he has to go back and be joined with his twin lest he die.

That's more accurate.
And completely wrong. Next!
 
Hang on, (thank you btw), there isn't a "afterward" is there? Isn't the pair thing simultaneous? I must be thinking of the wrong thing, will definately stop now.

No, you're probably right. I just now jumped in.
If you are right, though, that's interesting... one twin comes into existence spontaneously, pulling its twin through at the same time... so, in essence, they could have just both chosen that exact moment to do it and there's no way to show that they are twins.
Yeah, I'm pretty sure it's nonsense now.
 
That sure told you Wollery. Bet you wish you knew some basic astronomy now, huh?
Hang on. . .

So do I !

It's genius! Genius, I say! Congratulations, Wollery! You have just proven that time is an illusion! Lunchtime, doubly so!

Intuitive time is just an illusion. Its time for basic Godel it seems. Check out this after the basic astronomy class!

"Gödel added a philosophical argument that demonstrates, by what have become known as Gödel's lights, that as a consequence, time does not exist in our world ...
www.daviddarling.info/encyclopedia/G/Godel_universe.html

Smashing eh?

; }>
 
:jaw-dropp
My dear fellow member did you forget your science? Virtual particles have a TWIN! I have said this so many times that I want to hurl virtual vomit! The green Linda Blair kind. My head wants to spin and I want to speak in a satan voice....; Do your homework lest ye be slaughtered in debate with Dr Craig...!!"

Now once more? ; a virtual particle has a what? A twin. The twin is the cause of the particle existing or popping in out of not nowhere but somewhere. ; }>
So let me get this straight...

You ignore my actual argument and pick out an aside that I admit I don't know much about?

Congratulations.

Now tell me why the creation of universes should obey the rules of rearrangement of energy within that universe. Apparently it's obvious to you and Dr. Craig, so it can't be that hard to explain.
 
Last edited:
"Gödel added a philosophical argument that demonstrates, by what have become known as Gödel's lights, that as a consequence, time does not exist in our world ..."
Godel argued that time is not explicitly ordered, that it is just another dimension like space. We use entropy as the arrow of time, and order causality that way, but it's not necessarily something built into the fabric of the Universe.

I mentioned this about ten pages back.
 
So let me get this straight...

You ignore my actual argument and pick out an aside that I admit I don't know much about?
And he gets it completely wrong, and for support links to an article that refutes his claims.

Congratulations.
Indeed!

Now tell me why the creation of universes should obey the rules of rearrangement of energy within that universe. Apparently it's obvious to you and Dr. Craig, so it can't be that hard to explain.
Yeah, that too.
 
That Wikipedia article you just linked to?

Read it.

I don't have to. It was just a courtesy to provide background information. As I said there are different interpertations. I like this part of the site best;

"This article needs additional citations for verification.
Please help improve this article by adding reliable references. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed. (August 2007)"

Let me give you a more brief and easier to understand definition. It also fits my interpretation of the heisenberg uncertainty principle better.

virtual particle
n. A subatomic particle whose existence violates the principle of conservation of energy but is allowed to exist for a short time by Heisenberg's uncertainty principle.

Do you know what Heisenberg's uncertainty principle is? I am sure you do. There are many interpertations of this principle as well. I subscribe to the definition that states that superposition is a real event, not a mathematical construct. Now do you think you can bridge by your common sense why I said one of the pair is in superposition and the other is detectable? Remember all of quantum theory the particles existence etc are theory and incomplete. If I were an atheist I would pray for the LHC at cern be repaired post haste in hopes of finding the predicted and vindicating higgs boson.

Until then particle antiparticle twins virtual particles and such are theory, good theory but incomplete.

; {>
 
Last edited:
So let me get this straight...

You ignore my actual argument and pick out an aside that I admit I don't know much about?

Congratulations.

Now tell me why the creation of universes should obey the rules of rearrangement of energy within that universe. Apparently it's obvious to you and Dr. Craig, so it can't be that hard to explain.

No I wasn't trying to do that. I was attempting to correct you nicely. I picked out QT because it was the best way to rebut your concerns. Sorry if I offended you. The reason that creation of universes do not have to have a scientific explanation is because our rules of physics break down before T-0 'arrives'.

So we have to use other tools such as cosmological arguments and logic to explore what may of happened. There is a huge difference between a philosophical argument and a scientific theory. They both have criteria they must meet. However a cosmological argument is much better than "I don't know and I don't like that type of argument because it hints at God" .

So to summarize the reason the creation of a universe does not obey our rules of science is that its now a metaphysical construct which neither agrees or disagrees with science.

; }>
 
Last edited:
I don't have to.
You do. Trust me, you do.

No, wait. You're linking to articles to support your argument, and you haven't read them, and you not only admit this but claim you don't need to?

Do you know what Heisenberg's uncertainty principle is?
Yes.

I am sure you do. There are many interpertations of this principle as well. I subscribe to the definition that states that superposition is a real event, not a mathematical construct.
Meaning what?

Now do you think you can bridge by your common sense why I said one of the pair is in superposition and the other is detectable?
No. That's impossible.

Remember all of quantum theory the particles existence etc are theory and incomplete.
No. Quantum theory is not a complete description of the Universe, that much is true. But that is not a license for you to pick and choose parts of it to suit your whim.

If I were an atheist I would pray for the LHC at cern be repaired post haste in hopes of finding the predicted and vindicating higgs boson.
The Higgs boson is predicted by the Standard Model. If it isn't found at the energy levels produced by the LHC, that's a problem for the Standard Model. That you should think it would be of concern to atheists qua atheists (much less that atheists should pray for any particular outcome of the experiments at CERN) betrays an astonishing befuddlement with regards to all the above topics.

Until then particle antiparticle twins virtual particles and such are theory, good theory but incomplete.
Do you know what a theory is, RevD? It's the highest standard of validation that any scientific proposition can attain.

So yes, virtual particle pairs are a theory.
 
Last edited:
Just so I don't misunderstand, were you wishing that you knew basic astronomy, or that Wollery did? Because my post was kinda in reference to his profession.

I was being sarcastic responding to criticisms of my statements. (I wish I knew basic astronomy but I already do). ; {>
 
Last edited:
No I wasn't trying to do that. I was attempting to correct you nicely. I picked out QT because it was the best way to rebut your concerns. Sorry if I offended you. The reason that creation of universes do not have to have a scientific explanation is because our rules of physics break down before T-0 'arrives'.
No, wrong. The physics breaks down AT T0.

So we have to use other tools such as cosmological arguments and logic to explore what may of happened.
Unfortunately, this doesn't work.

There is a huge difference between a philosophical argument and a scientific theory.
Yes. Yes there is.

They both have criteria they must meet. However a cosmological argument is much better than "I don't know and I don't like that type of argument because it hints at God" .
Strawman.

No-one here has said that, or anything resembling that. The problem with your argument is that all its premises are false.

So to summarize the reason the creation of a universe does not obey our rules of science is that its now a metaphysical construct which neither agrees or disagrees with science.
That doesn't answer the question. In fact, it answers the direct opposite of the question actually asked, and hammers yet another nail into the coffin of the KCA in the process.
 
PixyMisa said:
Quote:
Until then particle antiparticle twins virtual particles and such are theory, good theory but incomplete.
Do you know what a theory is, RevD? It's the highest standard of validation that any scientific proposition can attain.

So yes, virtual particle paris are a theory.

Evolution is just a theory! Saying that to a neodarwin proponent is worse than calling a woman the C word.

Anyway you gotta love string theory then. Its a non predictive waste of time and hardly deserves to be called theory. Again until the higgs boson is found quantum theory is incomplete.

Large Hadron Collider: The Higgs boson vs. John's jackets
We need a theory of quantum gravity, not toys for chasing some ..... The elusive Higgs boson is so central to the standard model - the theory on which ...
www.god-does-not-play-dice.net/LHC.html -

You will like that link it bashes religion and my take on QT. ANd I found it a great read (even though I disagreed with it ; }>)

; {>
 
Last edited:
Fair enough. I was just amused by you telling a professional astrophysicist to Google 'Open Universe'.

Do I have some questions for him! I am buying a new instrument and need some advice on Orion's 12" scope. Should I spend the money on a smaller better instrument or go for the gusto? I own a eight inch scope now. I am kind of interested in good refractors vs the reflectors such as Orions 12"er and my current 8" instrument. Planetary viewing is my favorite activity. (sorry for the off topic rant). PM me if you do that sort of thing?
; {>
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom