The certainty of God's existence.

And I've already told you why this is wrong.

You did not make a case for your opinion.


Oddly enough the majority of theoretical physicists who are searching for the answers have no confidence in the argument and find it silly and absurd for good reason (BTW: John Allen Paulos takes this theory apart quite elegantly in his book, Irreligious).

For your book there are books that rebut it. I dont care about the battle of rebutting books.

Ti's trivially true. Time is Change. That is the essence of relativity. Our only means to measure time is change. Change can only be measured by time. If there is no time there cannot be change that's a fact.

You are incorrect.

I've Einstein and 50 years of experimental data and inquiry.
Only if there is time. Logic demands it.
I can tell you that you are wrong. Einstein's theories won't work if time and change are not inextricably tied.
You would win a Nobel prize if you could prove that and Einstein's theory would be tossed.

GR agrees with the KCA.

; {>
 
Robin said:
The way I see it is that your P1 is true if and only if it is interpreted the way I have. For example something that is not an ordered set can be finite and have no beginning.

I can not agree that P1 is untrue because of your definition. I need to review it again I suppose.

Moreover if "beginning" is not defined as I have defined it then it is a non-sequitur - as Aquinas argued rather brilliantly a universe that has a beginning did not necessarily begin to exist.

That is the problem. I do not agree with Aquinas (he did not have the benefit of modern science demanding that the universe began). The universe began. Its an object. If you don't agree we can agree to disagree. I will get back with you on your set theory idea. My first reaction is that set theory need not apply it is a abstract concept and does not apply to actual objects.

That would be good.
You would think so wouldn't you?

But over at the Richard Dawkins forum they have a section devoted to one on one debates. I only became engaged in one but we both agreed that it was a really awful time for us, really, really hard work.
My opponent began his final argument "I feel like I have been let out of prison".

I am afraid your opponent was under qualified. Or maybe his time was limited. One on one debate gets much more complicated because we can stay focused, and I at least have to reaserch some rebuttals.

The only good thing about debating five or six people is that its not boring. Thanks for your comments and challenges Robin, at least you and a couple of other members keep me on my toes, all without resorting to a hint of insult. Wonderful! I would hope that you don't find my replies to you objectionable.

Hee hee being let out of prison eh? Thats kind of scary. You should convert to theism Robin we need you. Do you mind me asking your beliefs you can PM me...or not. :)

: }>
 
Last edited:
You wouldn't know humor if it hit you in the face eh? Its humor my friend... humor...thanks of thinking it so important you highlighted it in yellow it caught my eye.

Humor, indeed... (btw, I had a :) in there to denote sarcasm, you didn't. Where's your smiley, funny guy?)

...evangelistic atheists...

Again, no such thing. But anyway...

The problem of arises from frustration of vocal evangelistic atheists not being able to defeat a theist in debate...

The reason atheists will never ever defeat a theist in debate is because theists simply disregard logic, reason, and science when logic, reason, or science contradicts a theist's beliefs.

A theist, by definition, is incapable of logical debate on this subject because theists adhere to the illogical notion that some dude we can't see, hear, locate, prove, etc., is not only responsible for creating and running our world from afar, but also inhabits everyone and everything in it.
Uh... sure. That's logical, reasonable, AND scientific. :confused:
 
Last edited:
RandFan said:
Ti's trivially true. Time is Change. That is the essence of relativity. Our only means to measure time is change. Change can only be measured by time. If there is no time there cannot be change that's a fact.

RevDisturba said:
You are incorrect.

Could you expand on this? I think it's a major problem for your argument, and you look to be just handwaving it away.
 
Robin here is the address where Dr Craig rebuts Oppy as well as Mackie which has similar objections to P-1 and P-2 as you. If you have time look over the page because it covers the material better than I could. The reason I am doing this is because we are about to open a king sized (in length) can of worms. I included a small excerpt form the page long exchange. Anyway we can still discuss it but I thought I would provide you some of my source material in advance ;

"Graham Oppy on the Kalam Cosmological Argument

William Lane Craig

Graham Oppy has attempted to re-support J. L. Mackie's objections to the kalam cosmological argument, to which I responded in my article "Professor Mackie and the Kalam Cosmological Argument." Oppy's attempt to defend the possibility of the existence of an actual infinite is vitiated by his conflation of narrowly and broadly logical possibility. Oppy's attempt to defend the possibility of the formation of an actual infinite by successive addition founders on misinterpretations. Oppy's objections to the premiss that whatever begins to exist has a cause and to God's being that cause are based on modal confusions.

Source: "Graham Oppy on the Kalam Cosmological Argument." Sophia 32 (1993): 1-11.

Graham Oppy has recently attempted to re-support J. L. Mackie's objections to the kalam cosmological argument.1 In this discussion note, I shall try to state succinctly why I think this attempt does not succeed.
The Existence of an Actual Infinite ..."

http://www.reasonablefaith.org/site/News2?page=NewsArticle&id=5162

: {>
 
After thinking a bit more, I'd like to add the following to my last post.
Let's say we use both the proposed kinds of "beginning to exist", and keep track of which is which. We can then say that things in the universe begin to exist insofar that they are rearranged from stuff that already existed. These rearrangements are usually caused by other rearrangements in the past.
Now, none of these rearrangements can be anything like the beginning of the universe. That is, P1 uses our intuitive understanding of rearrangements of energy within the universe and then applies it to the creation of energy.
I hope you'll agree that P1 it is at the very least not the self-evident truth that you and Dr. Craig would like it to be.
 
From the article:
Dr. Craig said:
We do not require arguments against the possibility of solipsism or for the existence of other minds, for the truth concerning these matters is obvious and any argument in this regard would be based on premisses less obvious than the conclusion. In the same way, the premiss ex nihilo nihil fit is so obvious that even Hume accepted it without argument, regarding its denial as an instance of unlivable Pyrrhonic scepticism.
Hrgh...I registered for this? Hand waving? Argument from authority? Thanks, Dr. Craig...

Dr. Craig said:
Consider, nonetheless, Jonathan Edwards's argument on behalf of the causal principle: if something can come into being uncaused out of nothing, then it is inexplicable why anything and everything does not do so. Oppy says that any and everything does not come into being uncaused out of nothing because some things have actual causes. Of course, they do; but what is the explanation for that fact and for the fact that people, televisions, and Eskimo villages do not pop into being uncaused out of nothing, if this is, as Oppy proceeds to assert, possible?
First of all, as knowledgeable people pointed out, vitual particles do this all the time. Secondly, these examples would all be governed by the laws that apply to rearrangements of existing energy within this unverse; not to new universes. The rules that govern the creation of universes are not necessarily the rules that govern the rearrangement of energy within a universe. This has not been proven or even made likely; it's simply ignored. Is this really all he's got?

:hb:
 
Last edited:
REV.D said:
Don't worry I am sure you will get everything you deserve with interest compounded for eternity when the time comes. I wish I could be there!

Elizabeth I said:
And here we have another example of the vaunted Christian loving kindness.

And here we have an evangelical (atheist?) taking words out of context, ignoring everything that comes before it. News flash; I am a open theist christian, that means that I go by the adage that "God loves you so I don't have to...but I am trying". Try to think of me more as an archangel for God's truth rather than a fool that turns the other cheek so many times that he gets blisters. Someone like that needs some one to defend them from themselves, enter RevDisturbia and company, mercenary christian solider with verbal amour and a tongue for a sword. What is my wage? Just understanding and education of the christian challenged.

:I don't know why you think the government doesn't take a neutral stance."The notion that laws should not be informed by religion is an extreme one, Gov. Rick Perry said Sunday in remarks at a San Antonio church.

There are a lot of christian apologists in government. We have had several presidents that were real Christians (or as close to a christian as a politician can be). Anyway his comment was just that. I ask you what came of it? You have to remember I could fill this page with references to God by our founding fathers. But no worries, the separation (its a chasm now) of church and state has never been greater. That is a good thing. I don't want any government inference in my church or missions. These days its not too bad with a christian friendly government in place. I see the day that that may change. That will be a real test of the concept of government separation between church and state.

Hey is that a Appaloosa in your avatar? I had a palomino mare and a stud quarter horse in my youth. Man that goldnen mare was the fastest thing! I won many bets racing her. She (Ginger) could cut too, but not on par with the quarter horse (razor). I have been tempted to trade in my hogs (motorcycles) for horses again.
; {>
 
Last edited:
And as I pointed out before the way eternity is defined in theology precluded succession and change. So RevDisturba is also going against theological definitions of eternity. In light of that I think he needs to define more clearly how he is using the word.

I define the word in the context that I am using it. The standard dictionary will do for eternity.

Eternal ; 2. unchanging: unaffected by the passage of time
eternal truths
Encarta ® World English Dictionary © & (P) 1998-2004 Microsoft Corporation. All rights reserved.

And the word for atemporal ;

Atemporal ; adj. Independent of time; timeless. http://www.answers.com/topic/atemporal

I don’t use subject specific words such as actual infinite and infinite eternal etc to avoid confusion.

; {>
 
However as I stated this universe is the only one that can be said to be commonly accepted. One universe on the first try.
How do you know how many tries it took?

No, seriously, I'd be fascinated to know how you came upon this piece of knowledge.
 
Did you miss where I said this is a open universe? It is going to expand forever. However if enough mass is found to close it maybe it would cause a 'big crunch' and then rebound into another universe. But the observational suggests other wise
And this is relevant how, exactly? A cyclic universe is only one possibility.

I am not sure why you mention virtual particles. I think you are confusing virtual particles with a universe.
I don't think so, somehow.

A virtual particle has a twin. The twin exists in superposition (according to one version of the theory) as the other manifests here in our universe.
Wrong.

You may be thinking of quantum loop gravity which is a untestable theory that allows for more than one universe. However as I stated this universe is the only one that can be said to be commonly accepted. One universe on the first try.
That's still - at best - an unsupported assertion.

Primarily its the deductive logic of the KCA (I won't mention biblical evidence nor other evidences here, it leads to too many side arguments). To expand on that ; Premise one states that anything that begins to exist has a cause for its existence.
Which is known to be false.

According to the way I, (and most of the scientific community I would guess) interpret the Big Bang Model as saying that the universe began to exist about 14b years ago.
No. The Universe began 13.7 billion years. "Begin to exist" is a tautology if it means anything at all.

Then, according to BB cosmology time (spacetime) was created just after T-0.
That's not right. It's so bad, it's not even wrong.

However the universe requires a 'cause' to cause it to begin to exist.
Unsupported assertion. You claim it as a conclusion, but it rests on a false premise and a logical fallacy (fallacy of composition), so it's wrong twice.

Ok, this cause must of existed 'before'* T-0 making it atemporal or eternal because time was created just after the universe began to exist.
If you say "before", then you have to say "cause". Also "existed". Because none of those words "mean" what you have used them for elsewhere in your argument. That's equivocation, and it's yet another logical fallacy, so you're wrong yet again.

(or outside time)
Meaning what?
 
I don't think anything after T-0 is created or begins to exist. When something is said to begin to exist its merely a rearrangement of mass or energy. Neither is created nor destroyed so there is no violation.Nevertheless, your concern would not effect the validity of the KCA anyway. However, I may not understand your question. ; {>
Ah. Then P1 (P3 in your original version) is an argument by bare assertion, and your argument fails yet again.

How many errors is that? Is anyone keeping count?
 
And by the way I can understand the pressure - I have looked after two invalids and I have started a small business - but not at the same time. I think we can take into account that no one person with limited time can completely defend a metaphysical argument.

Good luck with the business.

Thanks Robin! Its a free food soup kitchen type thing. I hope to support it with donations, and am not requesting any other type of aid. I knew that your empathy welled from a good heart regardless of your religious ID (or none):duck:.

; }>
 
Ah. Then P1 (P3 in your original version) is an argument by bare assertion, and your argument fails yet again.

How many errors is that? Is anyone keeping count?

Hi Pixy. No the argument is arrived at by deductive logic.

"You will not apply my precept," he said, shaking his head. "How often have I said to you that when you have eliminated the impossible, whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth? We know that he did not come through the door, the window, or the chimney. We also know that he could not have been concealed in the room, as there is no concealment possible. When, then, did he come?"

Ah Yes, my dear Pixy, P1 and P2 is in the bold so to speak...

; {>
....\ <------ (thats my Holmes pipe, and yeah its Jesus nuggets, sacrament my dear, sacrament )
 
Last edited:
How do you know how many tries it took?

No, seriously, I'd be fascinated to know how you came upon this piece of knowledge.

I have told everyone here that several times. Care to look again? Hint; a open vs a closed universe.

; }>
 
After thinking a bit more, I'd like to add the following to my last post.
Let's say we use both the proposed kinds of "beginning to exist", and keep track of which is which. We can then say that things in the universe begin to exist insofar that they are rearranged from stuff that already existed. These rearrangements are usually caused by other rearrangements in the past.
Now, none of these rearrangements can be anything like the beginning of the universe. That is, P1 uses our intuitive understanding of rearrangements of energy within the universe and then applies it to the creation of energy.
I hope you'll agree that P1 it is at the very least not the self-evident truth that you and Dr. Craig would like it to be.

I am sorry but no I think that the logical implications even include the metaphysical concept of the universe being caused to exist by an cause. Of course after the universe began to exist and natural law was born we could observe cause and effect. ; {>
 
No. No, I don't think so.

Hi Pixy! Why do you think some resort to insult then? Its frustration yes? I know some anger is expressed because some theists ignore the evidence of science etc. And I agree that the problem is not exclusive to either side. I have to say that the non theists are far more likely to resort to insult than are the religious. Unless of course you see one christian trying to defend himself from five or six 'people' intent on doing him harm. ; }>
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom