The certainty of God's existence.

Ti's trivially true. Time is Change. That is the essence of relativity. Our only means to measure time is change. Change can only be measured by time. If there is no time there cannot be change that's a fact.
And as I pointed out before the way eternity is defined in theology precluded succession and change. So RevDisturba is also going against theological definitions of eternity. In light of that I think he needs to define more clearly how he is using the word.
 
ps what would really really be sweet is some way to debate with only ONE member at a time. I am getting a small non profit business up and running, going to night school and taking care of one semi invalid and another wholly invalid. That's when I get some time for recreation i.e. these forums. In addition I today took on a part time job.
And by the way I can understand the pressure - I have looked after two invalids and I have started a small business - but not at the same time. I think we can take into account that no one person with limited time can completely defend a metaphysical argument.

Good luck with the business.
 
Last edited:
I should point out, RevDisturba, that the first part of the argument does not mention time at all. The conclusion it draws (if it is valid) does not have to do with time, it has to do with change.

So if time is not change then time is irrelevant to the argument - it is change that you should be addressing.
 
I found Craig's justification for P6 in his own words and it really does seem that he has muddled up his definitions of eternity or at least not given any serious thought about what it means:
William Lane Craig said:
In fact, I think that it can be plausibly argued that the cause of the universe must be a personal Creator. For how else could a temporal effect arise from an eternal cause? If the cause were simply a mechanically operating set of necessary and sufficient conditions existing from eternity, then why would not the effect also exist from eternity? For example, if the cause of water's being frozen is the temperature's being below zero degrees, then if the temperature were below zero degrees from eternity, then any water present would be frozen from eternity. The only way to have an eternal cause but a temporal effect would seem to be if the cause is a personal agent who freely chooses to create an effect in time. For example, a man sitting from eternity may will to stand up; hence, a temporal effect may arise from an eternally existing agent. Indeed, the agent may will from eternity to create a temporal effect, so that no change in the agent need be conceived. Thus, we are brought not merely to the first cause of the universe, but to its personal Creator.

http://www.leaderu.com/truth/3truth11.html
Of course he is a little more vague in what he is saying, but what is this "from eternity"?

It does appear to me that he is using the term 'eternity' as though it were an infinite period of time, that something might happen before something else in eternity.

If an intelligent being with free choice created something in eternity then that thing would also exist from eternity.

What do you say, can anybody else make head or tail of this? Do you think he has any idea of what he means when he says "eternity"?


(Later he uses the more traditional "changeless" for eternity. So what he appears to be saying is that only a personal being could choose to make a change in an environment where change is impossible).
 
Last edited:
We (I am a open theist christian) see evangelical atheists with a mission to destroy Christianity and everything it stands for.
I wasn't talking specifically to you Ms Robin.
...yea, Ms Robin, he was talking to you and all the other atheists. ;) Let's look at that one more time:
We (I am a open theist christian) see evangelical atheists with a mission to destroy Christianity and everything it stands for.

My my, what a terrible agenda. I wonder what would happen to that statement if you substituted the words "atheists" for "Christians" and "Christianity" for "science." ...wait, what? :eek:
Anyway, calling atheists evangelical doesn't make sense because atheism isn't a religion.

We live in a republic where unpopular minorities are protected. Look at that as an advantage to build your movement from a little wet spot to movement like Christianity or Islam. You would not have that chance in a theocracy or even a true democracy where the majority was Christian or Muslim, especially Muslim, with them its convert or die....So I still think there is something not being told about where that hate...er irritation arises.

...simply oozing with condescension, I love it.
So this irritating little wet spot of an atheist movement only has a chance in America. I've never heard that before. Interesting...

six members at a time I am not responsible for what I type or think about having to answer so many posts...

Convenient. You could always do what yrreg (and his infallible penis/nose/god) does and only respond to yourself... :)
 
My my, what a terrible agenda. I wonder what would happen to that statement if you substituted the words "atheists" for "Christians" and "Christianity" for "science." ...wait, what? :eek:
And the fact is, even if I was a demon-motivated, hate-and-fear-filled evangelist out to destroy Christianity and everything it stood for that would still not alter the logic of the argument under debate one bit.
 
What do you say, can anybody else make head or tail of this? Do you think he has any idea of what he means when he says "eternity"?
No. It's just asserted. BTW: Theories that are formulated by reputable theoretical physicists and other scientists aren't allowed to posit unkown forces (then a miracle happens) yet the the argument at the center of discussion doesn't explain how something exists and changes and thinks outside of time. The argument doesn't tell us the mechanisms at play to create space time, hundreds of millions of galaxies with hundreds of millions of stars (I could be off a factor or two) and people.

It's magic. It tells us nothing and it most certainly is not a compelling argument for anything.

However there actually are real theories being discussed by real scientists and theoretical physicists and THIS ISN'T ONE OF THOSE THEORIES.

There's no there, there.
 
No. It's just asserted. BTW: Theories that are formulated by reputable theoretical physicists and other scientists aren't allowed to posit unkown forces (then a miracle happens) yet the the argument at the center of discussion doesn't explain how something exists and changes and thinks outside of time. The argument doesn't tell us the mechanisms at play to create space time, hundreds of millions of galaxies with hundreds of millions of stars (I could be off a factor or two) and people.

It's magic. It tells us nothing and it most certainly is not a compelling argument for anything.

However there actually are real theories being discussed by real scientists and theoretical physicists and THIS ISN'T ONE OF THOSE THEORIES.

There's no there, there.
Yes, I get the impression that "eternity" is a bit like "immaterial", it is a magicky mysterious realm wherein all logical problems disappear.

And he is not even a skilled "metaphysical thinker" as RevDisturba seems to think - he is a sloppy metaphysical thinker.
 
Yes, I get the impression that "eternity" is a bit like "immaterial", it is a magicky mysterious realm wherein all logical problems disappear.

And he is not even a skilled "metaphysical thinker" as RevDisturba seems to think - he is a sloppy metaphysical thinker.
Yep, all we need is a perpetual motion machine that operates outside of all known laws of physics and we will solve out energy problem.
 
I just hit a question for the people better versed in physics: What does it mean exactly for something to begin to exist in the universe? All the energy was already there, right? So can things within the universe really be said to begin to exist at all in a meaningful way? I'm not sure, but then I'm just an engineer; most of the physics I know is centuries old.
 
Last edited:
I just hit a question for the people better versed in physics: What does it mean exactly for something to begin to exist in the universe? Al the energy was already there, right? So can things within the universe really be said to begin to exist at all in a meaningful way?

Good questions... :popcorn1
 
Big Bang cosmology describes this as being the only observed universe, it states nothing about being a "first try" or the existence of other universes. For example, virtual particle pairs may present umpteen many simultaneous "tries" before a universe gets kicked off.

Did you miss where I said this is a open universe? It is going to expand forever. However if enough mass is found to close it maybe it would cause a 'big crunch' and then rebound into another universe. But the observational suggests other wise.

I am not sure why you mention virtual particles. I think you are confusing virtual particles with a universe. A virtual particle has a twin. The twin exists in superposition (according to one version of the theory) as the other manifests here in our universe. These sub atomic particles have nothing to do with the BB. Or maybe you were thinking of the early universe was analogous to a virtual particle ?

You may be thinking of quantum loop gravity which is a untestable theory that allows for more than one universe. However as I stated this universe is the only one that can be said to be commonly accepted. One universe on the first try.

However, you stated that your eternal and atemporal can cause a universe on its first try. What is your reasoning behind this statement?

Primarily its the deductive logic of the KCA (I won't mention biblical evidence nor other evidences here, it leads to too many side arguments). To expand on that ; Premise one states that anything that begins to exist has a cause for its existence. According to the way I, (and most of the scientific community I would guess) interpret the Big Bang Model as saying that the universe began to exist about 14b years ago.

Then, according to BB cosmology time (spacetime) was created just after T-0. However the universe requires a 'cause' to cause it to begin to exist. Ok, this cause must of existed 'before'* T-0 making it atemporal or eternal because time was created just after the universe began to exist.

PT


* (or outside time)
 
Last edited:
I just hit a question for the people better versed in physics: What does it mean exactly for something to begin to exist in the universe? All the energy was already there, right? So can things within the universe really be said to begin to exist at all in a meaningful way? I'm not sure, but then I'm just an engineer; most of the physics I know is centuries old.


I don't think anything after T-0 is created or begins to exist. When something is said to begin to exist its merely a rearrangement of mass or energy. Neither is created nor destroyed so there is no violation.Nevertheless, your concern would not effect the validity of the KCA anyway. However, I may not understand your question. ; {>
 
Originally Posted by RevDisturba View Post
six members at a time I am not responsible for what I type or think about having to answer so many posts...
Convenient. You could always do what yrreg (and his infallible penis/nose/god) does and only respond to yourself...

You wouldn't know humor if it hit you in the face eh? Its humor my friend... humor...thanks of thinking it so important you highlighted it in yellow it caught my eye.

The problem of arises from frustration of vocal evangelistic atheists not being able to defeat a theist in debate (most atheists do not become frustrated and resort to questionable tactics). This forum has changed for the better in the last couple of weeks. I don't know if its because of the activities of the moderators or what but I see a minor change for the better. I hope it continues. ;{>
 
...I am not sure why you mention virtual particles. I think you are confusing virtual particles with a universe. ...

... Premise one states that anything that begins to exist has a cause for its existence. ...
Do you honestly not see that in P1 you confuse the exact same categories you accuse hokulele of confusing?
As far as is knowable, P1 strictly applies to things within the universe (if at all, and perhaps only for certain definitions of 'to exist').

Things in the universe are not the universe.
 
I don't think anything after T-0 is created or begins to exist. When something is said to begin to exist its merely a rearrangement of mass or energy.
This is muddled thinking. You are defining the phrase "to begin to exist" in two contradictory ways in two succesive sentences. Which of these definitions are you talking about in P1?

Neither is created nor destroyed so there is no violation. Nevertheless, your concern would not effect the validity of the KCA anyway. However, I may not understand your question. ; {>
Yes it would, because if I would use the first of your definitions of "begin to exist" above, the only 'thing' we know of that began to exist is the universe itself. That makes P1 utterly beg the question.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom