The certainty of God's existence.

No they don't, if they did they could tell me what it means. They can't. You can't either.

Nor can you tell me how god could exist outside of time or the mechisms he employs to create the universe or time. You can't posit any theory for any mechanisms and there is no explanatory power to your theory. It is only an attempt at a stop gap but it fails at that.

First I already have told everyone here how a 'cause' could be an atempoal agent within the guidelines and by the results of a logically valid cosmological argument. I also told you how I bridge the God gap not by the KCA but by a rational conclusion. That was derived at by asking this question; What is eternal ie atemporal and can cause a universe to begin to exist on the first try (according to the most popular form, and the most accepted model of the Big Bang theory). Not just any universe but one that is clumpy and produced sentient life that can ask questions about its own origins. I am saying that a rational reasonable person would say that describes God.

Anything that "exists" in atemporal evnironment ISN'T changing and it certainly isn't thinking or choosing and isn't existing as you and I think of as existing.

Support that claim please. I have a naturalistic example in mind so you have been warned. I will also tell you that if the logic demands that it can change well it can change. I can also tell you cause and effect doesn't need 'time' to produce change, I already described why that was so too in an earlier post.

As a god would have to exist. You don't tell us what it means to exist atemporaly but you do tell us that this atemporal being has a changing state. A changing state is time. The hypothesis is internaly inconsistent.

You may want to brush up on your physics Mr Randfan. You are asking more than one question as well. I gave you some examples of natural atemporality'. I said the being can apparently make changes to its created environment, and can enter time, but doesn't seem to be able to in its own form according to biblical texts which will make a great theology thread !

No. Einstein made clear that time is change and change is time. Those are his words in reference to relativity and not mine.

Could you please provide that by Mr Albert quote in full? Its too vague and short to make any kind of determination about it.I hero worship Big E but he wasn't perfect, when he began he thought the universe was eternal and static.

There is no hostility. If you interpreted my words as hostile then I appologize for giving you that impression.

Likewise my friend.

; }>
 
No it doesn't, it only requires an acceptance of P5. If you look at the structure of the argument there is no linkage between P5 and any previous conclusion and neither C1 nor C2 is used in C3.

So P-6 can be debated stand alone and if we can dismiss it (as I think we can) then we have a more manageable argument - one who's only conclusion is "The universe has a cause".

In any case when I tried to debate P1-C2 with you you began well but abandoned the debate.

If you want to debate P1 then maybe you can tell me why my version of P1 is not equivalent to your version of P1, and then provide your own alternate definition for the "beginning" of a series of causal events:
RevDisturbia | Robin
|D1: An event is an entity that is the cause of it's successor if it has a successor and the effect of it's predecessor if it has a predecessor
|D2: A universe is an ordered set of events.
P1: If the universe has no beginning, there have been an infinite number of events.|P1: An ordered set of events is either infinite or has an event without a predecessor.

So what does he do if he can't prove that they're different? I think you should establish conditions now.
 
No it doesn't, it only requires an acceptance of P5. If you look at the structure of the argument there is no linkage between P5 and any previous conclusion and neither C1 nor C2 is used in C3.

So P-6 can be debated stand alone and if we can dismiss it (as I think we can) then we have a more manageable argument - one who's only conclusion is "The universe has a cause".

In any case when I tried to debate P1-C2 with you you began well but abandoned the debate.

If you want to debate P1 then maybe you can tell me why my version of P1 is not equivalent to your version of P1, and then provide your own alternate definition for the "beginning" of a series of causal events:
RevDisturbia | Robin
|D1: An event is an entity that is the cause of it's successor if it has a successor and the effect of it's predecessor if it has a predecessor
|D2: A universe is an ordered set of events.
P1: If the universe has no beginning, there have been an infinite number of events.|P1: An ordered set of events is either infinite or has an event without a predecessor.

Ok let me put it this way. In reality I only use the first three premise to get God into the universe. Its a complete valid syllogism. Then I use a separate method that is not a logical syllogism nor part of the KCA to determine what and who this 'cause' is.

At this time, not having read all of Craigs reason for defending a personal God via the KCA using P-6 etc. I don't feel qualified to speak on behalf of Craig. I would be happy to give you some sites that describe how Craig uses the KCA to determine the cause is a personal God. He has some articles both popular and advanced for this.

How is that?

In any case when I tried to debate P1-C2 with you you began well but abandoned the debate.

To be honest with you I do remember discussing this with you but don't remember how far we got. I have pretty well described the entire logic train to if not you other members. However if you want to pick up where I became overwhelmed or stopped because of insults and posts that contained more personal insults than on topic material (or stopped posting for administrative reasons, I think its in violation of the sites rules to discuss these things) I would be happy to continue where we left off. However be aware that if I have already answered (even in posts to other members) your question I may refer you back to the post where I answered earlier.

Thanks for your interest and your civility Robin.

; {>

; }>

ps what would really really be sweet is some way to debate with only ONE member at a time. I am getting a small non profit business up and running, going to night school and taking care of
one semi invalid and another wholly invalid. That's when I get some time for recreation i.e. these forums. In addition I today took on a part time job. So one member at a time is doable, two members at time is doable three members at a time is not really doable to do it well, four members at a time everyone suffers, five members at a time and I am not responsible for what I type...six members at a time I am not responsible for what I type or think about having to answer so many posts...
 
Last edited:
First I already have told everyone here how a 'cause' could be an atempoal agent within the guidelines and by the results of a logically valid cosmological argument.
Sorry, this still doesn't work. At best, you're changing the definition of causality in the middle of your argument, which invalidates the entire argument.

I also told you how I bridge the God gap not by the KCA but by a rational conclusion. That was derived at by asking this question; What is eternal ie atemporal and can cause a universe to begin to exist on the first try
Begging the question.

(according to the most popular form, and the most accepted model of the Big Bang theory). Not just any universe but one that is clumpy and produced sentient life that can ask questions about its own origins. I am saying that a rational reasonable person would say that describes God.
Why?

Support that claim please.
dx/dt

I have a naturalistic example in mind so you have been warned.
Argument by the margin is too small.

I will also tell you that if the logic demands that it can change well it can change.
Argument by my logic can beat up your logic.

I can also tell you cause and effect doesn't need 'time' to produce change, I already described why that was so too in an earlier post.
Argument by reference to non-existent posts.

You may want to brush up on your physics Mr Randfan. You are asking more than one question as well. I gave you some examples of natural atemporality'. I said the being can apparently make changes to its created environment, and can enter time, but doesn't seem to be able to in its own form according to biblical texts which will make a great theology thread !
Argument by stringing random collections of words together.

Could you please provide that by Mr Albert quote in full? Its too vague and short to make any kind of determination about it.I hero worship Big E but he wasn't perfect, when he began he thought the universe was eternal and static.
He thought it wasn't expanding.
 
Ok let me put it this way. In reality I only use the first three premise to get God into the universe.
And fail.

Its a complete valid syllogism.
Hardly matters, does it, since the premises are false.

Then I use a separate method that is not a logical syllogism nor part of the KCA to determine what and who this 'cause' is.
You make it up?

At this time, not having read all of Craigs reason for defending a personal God via the KCA using P-6 etc. I don't feel qualified to speak on behalf of Craig. I would be happy to give you some sites that describe how Craig uses the KCA to determine the cause is a personal God. He has some articles both popular and advanced for this.
If you can't defend P6, why did you assert it in the first place?

To be honest with you I do remember discussing this with you but don't remember how far we got. I have pretty well described the entire logic train to if not you other members.
Your premises are still false.

ps what would really really be sweet is some way to debate with only ONE member at a time. I am getting a small non profit business up and running, going to night school and taking care of
one semi invalid and another wholly invalid. That's when I get some time for recreation i.e. these forums. In addition I today took on a part time job. So one member at a time is doable, two members at time is doable three members at a time is not really doable to do it well, four members at a time everyone suffers, five members at a time and I am not responsible for what I type...six members at a time I am not responsible for what I type or think about having to answer so many posts...
Your premises are still false. It doesn't matter how many people are pointing this out, since the number of premises doesn't change. You only have to adequately address each problem once. So far, you have not managed to address any of the flaws in your argument.
 
First I already have told everyone here how a 'cause' could be an atempoal agent within the guidelines and by the results of a logically valid cosmological argument. I also told you how I bridge the God gap not by the KCA but by a rational conclusion. That was derived at by asking this question; What is eternal ie atemporal and can cause a universe to begin to exist on the first try (according to the most popular form, and the most accepted model of the Big Bang theory). Not just any universe but one that is clumpy and produced sentient life that can ask questions about its own origins. I am saying that a rational reasonable person would say that describes God.


Please provide support for the statement I have underlined in the context of the bolded bit.
 
Please provide support for the statement I have underlined in the context of the bolded bit.

The only thing I can provide is whats already commonly known. Big bang cosmology doesn't rule out other universes but generally consider this to be the only one. Its open as well because we are missing over 90% of the mass to close it. As you should know there are many websites and other sources that cover this.

; {>
 
The only thing I can provide is whats already commonly known. Big bang cosmology doesn't rule out other universes but generally consider this to be the only one.
That just converts an unstated premise to an unsupported premise.

Its open as well because we are missing over 90% of the mass to close it.
How is that relevant?
 
The only thing I can provide is whats already commonly known. Big bang cosmology doesn't rule out other universes but generally consider this to be the only one. Its open as well because we are missing over 90% of the mass to close it. As you should know there are many websites and other sources that cover this.


Big Bang cosmology describes this as being the only observed universe, it states nothing about being a "first try" or the existence of other universes. For example, virtual particle pairs may present umpteen many simultaneous "tries" before a universe gets kicked off.

However, you stated that your eternal and atemporal can cause a universe on its first try. What is your reasoning behind this statement?
 
Try again, consult first experts on IQ what is human intelligence, and limit your statement of premise to not more than fifty (50) words, because if you say more than fifty words to deliver your number one operating premise, then I am sure that you have a very poor grasp of any number one operating premise for your atheist worldview.

Okay, I will give you sixty (60) words instead of fifty words.


What on earth are you babbling about? I gave you my answer and it stands, in full. I will not truncate it to make it easier for you to understand. You ask for short posts, but write pages and pages on multiple threads without even coming close to a cogent, logical argument.

Try responding like an intelligent adult rather than a ten-year-old child. "You're stupid" is not a counter-argument.


Don't get me wrong, I have got nothing against matter in randomness, except that for atheists that is their God, which of course they will deny.


How can that be not their God, when they make it or they give it the credit for everything that I a rational theist give to God.


No! You're God is a supernatural, conscious, intelligent being. Atheists do not believe in such a being.


It is matter that is the God of atheists, that matter that works by randomness and takes billions and billions and billions and billions and billions... of years to get anything with any kind of showing of order and intelligence to come up.



That is really most absurd in the light of people who have not massacred their intelligence.


So, it is intelligent to believe that an omnipotent being required billions and billions and billions and billions... of years to get anything with any kind of showing of order and intelligence to come up?

And even after such a long time designing intelligent beings, the creator made stuff-ups like putting four additional teeth in a jaw that is too small to hold them, curving the spine in such a way that it causes back pain, creating an appendix that kills his creation if it bursts, creating eyes upside-down and inside-out with a blind spot. Yeah, only intelligent people would come to the conclusion that it's all part of a divine plan.


Just tell me, atheists here, and answer only yes or no:


Is not matter in randomness in the ultimate terms your God, yes? no?​


No, it is not God! Atheists do not make up magical, intelligent beings to fill gaps in knowledge.
 
Last edited:
Don't get me wrong, I have got nothing against matter in randomness, except that for atheists that is their God, which of course they will deny.
We deny it because it's not true.

How can that be not their God, when they make it or they give it the credit for everything that I a rational theist give to God.
That's not true either.

[qupte]It is matter that is the God of atheists[/quote]
No.

That is really most absurd in the light of people who have not massacred their intelligence.
No.

Just tell me, atheists here, and answer only yes or no:

Is not matter in randomness in the ultimate terms your God, yes? no?​
No.

No, no, don't answer you don't know, that is appeal to ignorance, and if you be ignorant as to not know or think as to come to an answer, please go away, don't waste the time of readers here and the forum's bandwidth.
No.
 
Ok let me put it this way. In reality I only use the first three premise to get God into the universe. Its a complete valid syllogism. Then I use a separate method that is not a logical syllogism nor part of the KCA to determine what and who this 'cause' is.
But what I asked you was to tell me why my P1 differs from your P1. And if it does differ for you to give your alternate defintion for "begin" as applied to a series of events.

I think we can both agree that rigour and consistency of definition is part of being a valid syllogism. And if you are going to rely on any of this logic to make further conclusions it is not enough that the conclusion is true, the conclusion has to follow from the argument.

The way I see it is that your P1 is true if and only if it is interpreted the way I have. For example something that is not an ordered set can be finite and have no beginning.

Moreover if "beginning" is not defined as I have defined it then it is a non-sequitur - as Aquinas argued rather brilliantly a universe that has a beginning did not necessarily begin to exist.
At this time, not having read all of Craigs reason for defending a personal God via the KCA using P-6 etc. I don't feel qualified to speak on behalf of Craig. I would be happy to give you some sites that describe how Craig uses the KCA to determine the cause is a personal God. He has some articles both popular and advanced for this.

How is that?
That would be good.
ps what would really really be sweet is some way to debate with only ONE member at a time. I am getting a small non profit business up and running, going to night school and taking care of
one semi invalid and another wholly invalid. That's when I get some time for recreation i.e. these forums. In addition I today took on a part time job. So one member at a time is doable...
You would think so wouldn't you?

But over at the Richard Dawkins forum they have a section devoted to one on one debates. I only became engaged in one but we both agreed that it was a really awful time for us, really, really hard work.

My opponent began his final argument "I feel like I have been let out of prison".
 
Last edited:
It is matter that is the God of atheists, that matter that works by randomness and takes billions and billions and billions and billions and billions... of years to get anything with any kind of showing of order and intelligence to come up.



That is really most absurd in the light of people who have not massacred their intelligence.

What's absurd about it?
 
First I already have told everyone here how a 'cause' could be an atempoal agent within the guidelines and by the results of a logically valid cosmological argument.
And I've already told you why this is wrong.

I also told you how I bridge the God gap not by the KCA but by a rational conclusion.
I also told you why your bridge is wrong and it's wrong for many reasons.

What is eternal ie atemporal and can cause a universe to begin to exist on the first try (according to the most popular form, and the most accepted model of the Big Bang theory). Not just any universe but one that is clumpy and produced sentient life that can ask questions about its own origins. I am saying that a rational reasonable person would say that describes God.
Oddly enough the majority of theoretical physicists who are searching for the answers have no confidence in the argument and find it silly and absurd for good reason (BTW: John Allen Paulos takes this theory apart quite elegantly in his book, Irreligious).

Support that claim please.
Ti's trivially true. Time is Change. That is the essence of relativity. Our only means to measure time is change. Change can only be measured by time. If there is no time there cannot be change that's a fact.

I have a naturalistic example in mind so you have been warned.
I've Einstein and 50 years of experimental data and inquiry.

I will also tell you that if the logic demands that it can change well it can change.
Only if there is time. Logic demands it.

I can also tell you cause and effect doesn't need 'time' to produce change, I already described why that was so too in an earlier post.
I can tell you that you are wrong. Einstein's theories won't work if time and change are not inextricably tied.

You would win a Nobel prize if you could prove that and Einstein's theory would be tossed.
 
Last edited:
Don't worry I am sure you will get everything you deserve with interest compounded for eternity when the time comes. I wish I could be there!

And here we have another example of the vaunted Christian loving kindness.


I think the sabbath if that was what you were talking about was created for us.

Genesis 2:2 "And on the seventh day He rested."

So it looks like your atemporal entity can get tired.


I don't know why you think the government doesn't take a neutral stance.

"The notion that laws should not be informed by religion is an extreme one, Gov. Rick Perry said Sunday in remarks at a San Antonio church..."
 
I gave you some examples of natural atemporality'.
Does't obviate my point.

I said the being can apparently make changes to its created environment...
Nonsense. You've no idea how such a being could do any of this. You just assert it. How does he make changes? What are the forces? What laws if any must it follow?

Could you please provide that by Mr Albert quote in full? Its too vague and short to make any kind of determination about it.I hero worship Big E but he wasn't perfect, when he began he thought the universe was eternal and static.
I'll have to get back to you on the quote.
 
Still waiting for how you get from C1 to Jesus.

I'm not sure of all the logic steps, but if I understand this thread correctly, I believe it has something to do with God having a penis but no hands, and Jesus being the right hand of God. Nobody mentioned St. Kevin of Kleenex, but I'm pretty sure he figures in there somewhere, too.
 
I'm not sure of all the logic steps, but if I understand this thread correctly, I believe it has something to do with God having a penis but no hands, and Jesus being the right hand of God. Nobody mentioned St. Kevin of Kleenex, but I'm pretty sure he figures in there somewhere, too.

...eeewww...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom