RevDisturba
Muse
- Joined
- Feb 1, 2009
- Messages
- 647
No they don't, if they did they could tell me what it means. They can't. You can't either.
Nor can you tell me how god could exist outside of time or the mechisms he employs to create the universe or time. You can't posit any theory for any mechanisms and there is no explanatory power to your theory. It is only an attempt at a stop gap but it fails at that.
First I already have told everyone here how a 'cause' could be an atempoal agent within the guidelines and by the results of a logically valid cosmological argument. I also told you how I bridge the God gap not by the KCA but by a rational conclusion. That was derived at by asking this question; What is eternal ie atemporal and can cause a universe to begin to exist on the first try (according to the most popular form, and the most accepted model of the Big Bang theory). Not just any universe but one that is clumpy and produced sentient life that can ask questions about its own origins. I am saying that a rational reasonable person would say that describes God.
Anything that "exists" in atemporal evnironment ISN'T changing and it certainly isn't thinking or choosing and isn't existing as you and I think of as existing.
Support that claim please. I have a naturalistic example in mind so you have been warned. I will also tell you that if the logic demands that it can change well it can change. I can also tell you cause and effect doesn't need 'time' to produce change, I already described why that was so too in an earlier post.
As a god would have to exist. You don't tell us what it means to exist atemporaly but you do tell us that this atemporal being has a changing state. A changing state is time. The hypothesis is internaly inconsistent.
You may want to brush up on your physics Mr Randfan. You are asking more than one question as well. I gave you some examples of natural atemporality'. I said the being can apparently make changes to its created environment, and can enter time, but doesn't seem to be able to in its own form according to biblical texts which will make a great theology thread !
No. Einstein made clear that time is change and change is time. Those are his words in reference to relativity and not mine.
Could you please provide that by Mr Albert quote in full? Its too vague and short to make any kind of determination about it.I hero worship Big E but he wasn't perfect, when he began he thought the universe was eternal and static.
There is no hostility. If you interpreted my words as hostile then I appologize for giving you that impression.
Likewise my friend.
; }>