The certainty of God's existence.

Except that your words are rife with anger and hatred for God owing to your fear of God.




Yrreg
Oh my, this old saw again. It seems that Gerry thinks it is perfectly normal to have anger, hatred, and fear for an imaginary being. Thinking doesn't come any more muddled than that, whatever your religion.
 
Oh my, this old saw again. It seems that Gerry thinks it is perfectly normal to have anger, hatred, and fear for an imaginary being. Thinking doesn't come any more muddled than that, whatever your religion.
I guess it's relative. After all, atheists have one more imaginary being to be angry about than he does.
 
Consult experts in IQ on what is human intelligence and how human intelligence cannot accept events without subjects involved in the events and physical laws without authors.

Every physicist in the world will be surprised to find that they don't possess human intelligence.

Where is the evidence that physical laws have authors?
 
Some off-topic and bickering posts moved to AAH. Don't bicker off-topicly.

Thank you.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Tricky
 
I thought you wanted to have an actual debate. But if you'd rather try to get that last nail in all by yourself, be my guest.

By the way, others have raised the same issues regarding the faults of the KCA. Do you intend to address them?

I don't think you are debating in good faith with all due respect. I was not so keen for an apology but rather was using the request for aplogy to gauge your intent etc.

Yes I intend to answer all relevant replies, especially H'ethetheth. I am attempting to learn what he and others can accept as evidence etc. Call it debate foreplay. We have not even started petting yet. I mean if we can not agree on the most simple premise say P-1 why jump to the more difficult to explain and much weaker P-6 which requires the validity of the other premises? As I said maybe with some foreplay we (I) wont make the same mistakes again.
 
Even if the KCA WAS correct, wouldn't it point to the universe being created by Nyarlathotep just as well as pointing to YHVH?

RevDisturba, impress me. Demonstrate that you are capable of considering this question. If you can do this, Yrreg's place is yours.

Trust me, I don't want Yrregs place (with all due respect). But anyway the name of God be it the FSM, Narely, or whatever does not make a difference. If the FSM had the attributes of God it would be God.

; {>
 
And where do scientists get their brain, where else but matter in randomness?

Originally Posted by yrreg
Very good, but not good enough, where do the physical laws come from?
​


From the minds of scientists - "physical laws" are just models that attempt to describe the behaviour of the universe.

[...]



And where do scientists get their brain, where else but matter in randomness.



Edited by Lisa Simpson: 
Edited to remove personal remarks.


Please keep in mind the Membership Agreement and do not use personal attacks to argue your point.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Lisa Simpson




Okay, Mojo, just give in not more than 50 words what is your most important number one thinking premise as an atheist, so that in place of God you postulate matter in randomness or what?







Yrreg
 
Last edited by a moderator:
That is why with your kind of scientific thinking, you will flunk any IQ tests which test your human intelligence, because your kind of thinking is not in accordance with human intelligence.

This, by the way, is the kind of language that provokes those mod actions you're busy whining about in Forum Managment.

A roundabout way of calling someone an idiot is still calling someone an idiot.
 
This, by the way, is the kind of language that provokes those mod actions you're busy whining about in Forum Managment.

A roundabout way of calling someone an idiot is still calling someone an idiot.

He is now deliberately trying to get banned. There ain't no martyr like a Christian martyr.
 
Don't get me wrong, I have got nothing against matter in randomness, except...

Don't get me wrong, I have got nothing against matter in randomness, except that for atheists that is their God, which of course they will deny.


How can that be not their God, when they make it or they give it the credit for everything that I a rational theist give to God.


It is matter that is the God of atheists, that matter that works by randomness and takes billions and billions and billions and billions and billions... of years to get anything with any kind of showing of order and intelligence to come up.



That is really most absurd in the light of people who have not massacred their intelligence.





Just tell me, atheists here, and answer only yes or no:


Is not matter in randomness in the ultimate terms your God, yes? no?​



No, no, don't answer you don't know, that is appeal to ignorance, and if you be ignorant as to not know or think as to come to an answer, please go away, don't waste the time of readers here and the forum's bandwidth.






Yrreg
 
Don't get me wrong, I have got nothing against matter in randomness, except that for atheists that is their God, which of course they will deny.

Yrreg

Why do you deny that you simply believe in god(s) but always say that you know there are god(s)?
 
Atheists don't have gods, Yrreg

What is about this that you cannot understand?

Seems quite simple to me
 
Don't get me wrong, I have got nothing against matter in randomness, except that for atheists that is their God, which of course they will deny.


How can that be not their God, when they make it or they give it the credit for everything that I a rational theist give to God.


It is matter that is the God of atheists, that matter that works by randomness and takes billions and billions and billions and billions and billions... of years to get anything with any kind of showing of order and intelligence to come up.



That is really most absurd in the light of people who have not massacred their intelligence.





Just tell me, atheists here, and answer only yes or no:


Is not matter in randomness in the ultimate terms your God, yes? no?​



No, no, don't answer you don't know, that is appeal to ignorance, and if you be ignorant as to not know or think as to come to an answer, please go away, don't waste the time of readers here and the forum's bandwidth.






Yrreg

Message breakdown:

[accusation]
[anecdotal evidence]
[unfounded statement]
[insult]
[question about above statement]
[pre-emptive insult]
[unnecessary gap]
[screenname]
 
Gibberish eh? Incoherent eh? *cof* (more on that later). Must I tell you many, many, people do absolutely know what my words mean, but you simply don’t so that isn’t gibberish or incoherent its only demonstrable ignorance of the subject.
No, I think it is you who are demonstrating a poor grasp of the subject. You are making the mistake of assuming that timelessness would just be another kind of time, but it wouldn't.

Timelessness has to be devoid of any kind of succession at all - as my quote from Aquinas says - otherwise your God is subject to just the same arguments as in P1-C2 of your arguments.

So if God experiences one moment, then experiences another moment, then experiences another moment then that is what is called time, even if not the time of the universe, time nevertheless.

The same thing goes if God has to rely on quantum probability to guess at the future.

An eternal God must experience all events in the Universe as a unity. When God is observing the Battle of Runymede he is also observing Ypres, Iwo Jima and Long Tan.

That is what eternal means (at least in the Boethius - Aquinas sense).

Timelessness is not a problem when we ascribe it to mindless physical objects.

But when you ascribe it to a being with a mind you have a contradiction since things like choice imply succession - action following intention for example.

And if you ascribe timelessness to a being who can interact with the universes timeline you end up with a paradox - even without taking free will into account.

So even if your argument does necessitate a timeless cause, proceeding to tack a mind onto that timeless cause only leads to problems and has absolutely no explanatory power.
 
Last edited:
Don't get me wrong, I have got nothing against matter in randomness, except that for atheists that is their God, which of course they will deny.

You're right, we will. Atheists have no god. That is the POINT of being an atheist. An atheist can believe that the entire universe is ordered - maybe every particle of matter is sentient, or the universe is a hivemind, or something like that. As long as they do not believe in a supreme omnipotent being they are atheists.

How can that be not their God, when they make it or they give it the credit for everything that I a rational theist give to God.

It can not be our god because we don't worship it. You are stretching the definition of "god" to suit your argument.

It is matter that is the God of atheists, that matter that works by randomness and takes billions and billions and billions and billions and billions... of years to get anything with any kind of showing of order and intelligence to come up.

Support this claim, please (the "matter is God" part, not the other stuff).

That is really most absurd in the light of people who have not massacred their intelligence.

I think it may be a new record - Yrreg actually got three whole sentences into a post before devolving into (slightly veiled) flaming.

Just tell me, atheists here, and answer only yes or no:

Is not matter in randomness in the ultimate terms your God, yes? no?​

No. And now you will promptly ignore my response to this question, if not this entire post.

No, no, don't answer you don't know, that is appeal to ignorance, and if you be ignorant as to not know or think as to come to an answer, please go away, don't waste the time of readers here and the forum's bandwidth.

Take your own freaking advice. Your arguments are nonsense, and your constant veiled insults are really grating on my nerves.




Yrreg

In addition to everything I said above, I would like to ask that, in future, you make your sentences actually mean something grammatically. I'm not sure whether or not English is your first language, but please make sure that you're not spouting gibberish before posting. An example of bad grammar is:

No, no, don't answer you don't know, that is appeal to ignorance, and if you be ignorant as to not know or think as to come to an answer, please go away, don't waste the time of readers here and the forum's bandwidth.

You may understand exactly what this sentence means, but we don't. It makes no sense; we get the general idea, that you're assuming that we'll dodge the question, but your exact meaning escapes us. At least, it escapes me. Maybe the users here who are more experienced with your mutilations of the language will be able to read it.
 
I don't think you are debating in good faith with all due respect. I was not so keen for an apology but rather was using the request for aplogy to gauge your intent etc.
Appeal to motive.

Yes I intend to answer all relevant replies, especially H'ethetheth. I am attempting to learn what he and others can accept as evidence etc.
Simple: Actual evidence. Stuff you made up does not count.

I mean if we can not agree on the most simple premise say P-1 why jump to the more difficult to explain and much weaker P-6 which requires the validity of the other premises?
No problem. Forget P6 for now. Try to defend P1, which is also wrong.
 
And I have just had a wonderful thought.

What if that nonsense I cited before really accurately represented William Lane Craig's justification for the last premiss of the KCA?

Now that would be priceless - the world's greatest Christian apologist getting his definitions of eternity muddled? :)

I should go and read his book to find out, since RevDisturba is not going to provide either his or Craig's justification for this premiss.
 
Last edited:
I mean if we can not agree on the most simple premise say P-1 why jump to the more difficult to explain and much weaker P-6 which requires the validity of the other premises?
No it doesn't, it only requires an acceptance of P5. If you look at the structure of the argument there is no linkage between P5 and any previous conclusion and neither C1 nor C2 is used in C3.

So P-6 can be debated stand alone and if we can dismiss it (as I think we can) then we have a more manageable argument - one who's only conclusion is "The universe has a cause".

In any case when I tried to debate P1-C2 with you you began well but abandoned the debate.

If you want to debate P1 then maybe you can tell me why my version of P1 is not equivalent to your version of P1, and then provide your own alternate definition for the "beginning" of a series of causal events:
RevDisturba | Robin
|D1: An event is an entity that is the cause of it's successor if it has a successor and the effect of it's predecessor if it has a predecessor
|D2: A universe is an ordered set of events.
P1: If the universe has no beginning, there have been an infinite number of events.|P1: An ordered set of events is either infinite or has an event without a predecessor.

(and since you are asking all and sundry if they know what a syllogism is, I assume that you are acquainted with the need for clearly defined and consistently used terms)
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom