The certainty of God's existence.

Randfan said:
No. You want to have your cake and eat it too. It doesn't work that way for a number of reasons.
* To state that god exists outside of time is to speak gibberish. No one knows what that means and it is incoherent.

Gibberish eh? Incoherent eh? *cof* (more on that later). Must I tell you many, many, people do absolutely know what my words mean, but you simply don’t so that isn’t gibberish or incoherent its only demonstrable ignorance of the subject.

The interior of a black hole is atemporal for example. The premises of the KCA demands that the cause exist outside of time or independent of time. It has to if its syllogism is valid.

Time is changes. Change is time. Time is
measured by change and change by time.

With all due respect, You don’t know what your talking about. Your speaking of intuitive time. The ‘time’ of physics is much different. Now I have to ask why you have to add the hostility to your reply? It does not help your case at all and rather detracts from it.

RD:{>
 
Last edited:
I don't have hate for anybody, I have never personally experienced hate towards me, I know and have known Christians, Muslims, Hindus, Sikhs and many more religions and belief systems and have never yet come across any hate.

So I am not sure what you are talking about.

I wasn't talking specifically to you Ms Robin.

: {>
 
The interior of a black hole is atemporal for example. The premises of the KCA demands that the cause exist outside of time or independent of time. It has to if its syllogism is valid.
Still waiting for how you get from C1 to Jesus.
 
H'ethetheth; said:
A very puzzling statement. What is this good, non-empirical evidence? In fact, what does the phrase mean? I'm not being snide; I honestly have no idea what kind of evidence you mean by good evidence that is not empirical.

I wouldn't think it puzzling in the least, For our uses there are two types of evidences empirical & circumstantial.

I'm sorry, but again: This is a very odd thing to say in my world. Logic works one way; muddled thinking is not part of it. The difference, as I see it, is that some people accept your premises because they already hold them true. Well, several people here do not, clearly.
If I am required to accept a premise that I don't already, I want to see the argument that forces me to accept it based on premises that I do agree with. It really is that simple.

Well I said one mans muddled thinking was another mans valid argument. What I meant is that I may have a different criteria on what constitutes a good argument than you. However, if we cant agree we may have to agree to disagree. That's perfectly fine.

Also, if I may be so bold, you haven't responded to the problems with your original premise P3.

I am working on a way to get out of it :p. Not really but close. I agreed its weak. And its difficult to defend. Very difficult. Long and difficult. So I am wondering why try to defend a difficult weak premise when we do not agree on the first three easy and simple premises? I feel at this point (which may change quickly) it would not be productive and while you are one of my favorite members and I enjoy talking with you it might be a waste of our time.


And thank you for your kind reply...

: {>
 
Still waiting for how you get from C1 to Jesus.

Been there done that. Oh you mean here. First we have to get past P-1. If we remain constipated I may start another thread and work not from 'before' the big bang forward but rather T-14B + or - years back.; {>
 
Been there done that. Oh you mean here. First we have to get past P-1. If we remain constipated I may start another thread and work not from 'before' the big bang forward but rather T-14B + or - years back.; {>
Hey, I'll be super nice. I'll give you P1 and C1. Now get from there to Jesus.
 
Very good, but not good enough, where do the physical laws come from?


From the minds of scientists - "physical laws" are just models that attempt to describe the behaviour of the universe.

As for why the universe behaves the way it does - we don't know.

Why don't you just be honest and say that in place of God you postulate matter in randomness.


Why don't you be honest and say that in place of admitting that you don't know you postulate God?
 
Gibberish eh? Incoherent eh? *cof* (more on that later). Must I tell you many, many, people do absolutely know what my words mean, but you simply don’t so that isn’t gibberish or incoherent its only demonstrable ignorance of the subject.
Okay, then, what do your words mean?

The interior of a black hole is atemporal for example.
No.

The premises of the KCA demands that the cause exist outside of time or independent of time.
That's a contradiction in terms.

It has to if its syllogism is valid.
You have a problem, then, don't you?

With all due respect, You don’t know what your talking about. Your speaking of intuitive time. The ‘time’ of physics is much different.
In what way?

Now I have to ask why you have to add the hostility to your reply?
What hostility?

It does not help your case at all and rather detracts from it.
Again I ask, what hostility?
 
I wouldn't think it puzzling in the least, For our uses there are two types of evidences empirical & circumstantial.
But the KCA is neither of these. So what is it, then?

Well I said one mans muddled thinking was another mans valid argument.
Which is not true.

What I meant is that I may have a different criteria on what constitutes a good argument than you.
Well, clearly this is the case. But this is because your criteria are invalid.

However, if we cant agree we may have to agree to disagree. That's perfectly fine.
Perhaps. But you are still wrong.

I am working on a way to get out of it :p. Not really but close. I agreed its weak. And its difficult to defend. Very difficult. Long and difficult. So I am wondering why try to defend a difficult weak premise when we do not agree on the first three easy and simple premises? I feel at this point (which may change quickly) it would not be productive and while you are one of my favorite members and I enjoy talking with you it might be a waste of our time.
If you can't defend the premises of your own argument, it's not really much of an argument, is it?

Ding! That will be five pounds, please.
 
...Atheists here maintain that only matter (in place of God) exists and it 'works' by randomness whereby after billions of years man appears as a conscious intelligent being endowed with free will.*[/indent]...

No. The atheist position is independent of one's view of free will vs. determinism. Atheists can believe that free will is an illusion, as I do.
 
Here is what I see to be the impasse between me as a rational theist and the atheists here:

I maintain that God exists and is a conscious intelligent being Who made everything in the whole totality of existence including the physical universe, and He put the scheme of intelligent order in the whole totality of existence as described.​

tr: I believe in god(s)

Atheists here maintain that only matter (in place of God) exists and it 'works' by randomness whereby after billions of years man appears as a conscious intelligent being endowed with free will.*


tr: Atheists lack belief in god(s)​

That is the impasse between me a rational theist and the atheists in this forum.



Are both of us certain of our number one operating premise?


I am certain as humans can be certain who allow their reason to work as God has intended it to work.


What about you atheists, are you certain of your number one operating premise, and what kind of certainty is it, human or what?




Yrreg


*Hokulele does not subscribe to the fact that humans are conscious intelligent free agents, but when confronted further she or he said instead that (s)he was being funny.

Atheists are always like that here, they will say something and then claim to be funny when confronted with the absurdity and impracticality of their ideological positions.​
 
Last edited:
I wouldn't think it puzzling in the least, For our uses there are two types of evidences empirical & circumstantial.
Hm. I'm not sure I agree that these are mutually exclusive, because there is lots of scientific circumstantial evidence. Think of things like the common ancestor of bananas and men. This creature has not been observed, but its existence can be inferred with enormous confidence. DNA as the carrier of genes was discovered long after the existence of genes was inferred from circumstantial evidence. At the moment scientists are trying to get their fingers behind dark matter and dark energy, the existence of which is, again, inferred from circumstantial empirical evidence.
I guess what I'm trying to say is: Could you give me some examples of evidence you call circumstantial?

Well I said one mans muddled thinking was another mans valid argument. What I meant is that I may have a different criteria on what constitutes a good argument than you. However, if we cant agree we may have to agree to disagree. That's perfectly fine.
That may all be, but I don't want to jump that gun just yet. I would like to see some arguments first, if that's okay with you.

I am working on a way to get out of it :p. Not really but close. I agreed its weak. And its difficult to defend. Very difficult. Long and difficult. So I am wondering why try to defend a difficult weak premise when we do not agree on the first three easy and simple premises? I feel at this point (which may change quickly) it would not be productive and while you are one of my favorite members and I enjoy talking with you it might be a waste of our time.
Look, I have time and I'm purposely spending it on finding out why you believe what you say you believe; You won't be wasting my time.

And thank you for your kind reply...

: {>
You're welcome.
 
No, it has to do with demonstrating/admitting that you were wrong. Even if it was a mild wrong. I will address your erroneous ideas concerning the age of the KCA when and if you do the right thing.

sin_in_full-searly'

; {wwjd>

I thought you wanted to have an actual debate. But if you'd rather try to get that last nail in all by yourself, be my guest.

By the way, others have raised the same issues regarding the faults of the KCA. Do you intend to address them?
 
Even if the KCA WAS correct, wouldn't it point to the universe being created by Nyarlathotep just as well as pointing to YHVH?

RevDisturba, impress me. Demonstrate that you are capable of considering this question. If you can do this, Yrreg's place is yours.
 
Don't worry I am sure you will get everything you deserve with interest compounded for eternity when the time comes. I wish I could be there! :covereyes

; {O>

That reminds me of another question you didn't answer: what do you feel the consequences of not choosing Christianity are?
 
Even if the KCA WAS correct, wouldn't it point to the universe being created by Nyarlathotep just as well as pointing to YHVH?

RevDisturba, impress me. Demonstrate that you are capable of considering this question. If you can do this, Yrreg's place is yours.
We shall see.
Hey, I'll be super nice. I'll give you P1 and C1. Now get from there to Jesus.
 
As already mentioned: 153 words. You are not very good at your own game, are you?

Okay, I have read some people saying their number one operating premise is nothing in place of God.

If you start from nothing, then you are nothing, go away, nothing.

Non sequiteur, and false conclusion.

That somebody puts nothing instead of God does not imply that they think we start from nothing (just for example, we can discuss whether things need to have a start at all).

And the conclusion that 'you are nothing' is false, since it is not established that nothing can come from nothing.

Some state that it is event governed by physical laws.

Very good, but not good enough, where do the physical laws come from?

Where does your God come from? He was always there/created himself/cam from nothing? Take your pick, it will also work for your question.

And tell me you believe in events without subjects enacting or undergoing or being involved in the events?

Unlikely. But 'subjects' does not imply intelligence, or even life.

Why don't you just be honest and say that in place of God you postulate matter in randomness.

Because that is an incomplete statement.

Hans
 
Even if the KCA WAS correct, wouldn't it point to the universe being created by Nyarlathotep just as well as pointing to YHVH?
Depends. Have you recently been:

(a) Devoured and/or driven mad by hideous gibbering apparitions.
(b) Struck by lightning and/or turned into a condiment supply.
(c) Flayed alive and/or had your still beating heart torn from your chest.
(d) All of the above.
 
If you start from nothing, then you are nothing, go away, nothing.
I thought I was here, I guess a magic man must be making me appear invisible!

Some state that it is event governed by physical laws.

Very good, but not good enough, where do the physical laws come from?
A magic man in the sky!

And tell me you believe in events without subjects enacting or undergoing or being involved in the events?
It's all magic, baby!

That is not according to human intelligence.

Consult experts in IQ on what is human intelligence and how human intelligence cannot accept events without subjects involved in the events and physical laws without authors.
Here's a hint - MAGIC!

Why don't you just be honest and say that in place of God you postulate matter in randomness.
Why don't you appreciate my magic man?

Yrreg, why do you not see that saying "I don't know" is a better answer than "It's magic!" Does your special brand of magic really give you more insight into reality, or does it just make you feel good to think that your magic man loves you?
 
Must I tell you many, many, people do absolutely know what my words mean...
No they don't, if they did they could tell me what it means. They can't. You can't either.

Nor can you tell me how god could exist outside of time or the mechisms he employs to create the universe or time. You can't posit any theory for any mechanisms and there is no explanatory power to your theory. It is only an attempt at a stop gap but it fails at that.

The interior of a black hole is atemporal for example.
Anything that "exists" in atemporal evnironment ISN'T changing and it certainly isn't thinking or choosing and isn't existing as you and I think of as existing. As a god would have to exist. You don't tell us what it means to exist atemporaly but you do tell us that this atemporal being has a changing state. A changing state is time. The hypothesis is internaly inconsistent.

You don’t know what your talking about. Your speaking of intuitive time. The ‘time’ of physics is much different.
No. Einstein made clear that time is change and change is time. Those are his words in reference to relativity and not mine.

Now I have to ask why you have to add the hostility to your reply?
There is no hostility. If you interpreted my words as hostile then I appologize for giving you that impression.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom