The certainty of God's existence.

Rev said:
In the mean time Christians to atheists should try to get rid of the hate, if we don't we are all in trouble.

RandFan said:
Accusing atheists of dishonesty and bigotry isn't helping anything.

Well I accused all of us ALL of having bigotry and hate not just atheists. I see it on both sides, and I didn't say you were a bigot either. If you call me dishonest for not agreeing that irritated and anger is the same thing, well that's a minor issue.

Look, I won't accuse you of dishonesty and things I can't know without reading your mind if you will do likewise.I'll call it the golden rule and you can call it Christian values.Fair enough?

I know you are at least approachable and that you are fair by you extending a offer to meet in the middle. I hope you don't get angry but I only read the last of your post, but for good reason. I did not want to rebut your comments. Its enough that I know you are a fair and reasonable guy.

Now with that my fellow JREF fellows its time to try and sleep again.....

: {Zzzz>
 
Last edited:
I agree.(that its sad, because its not a good way to practice faith!) Emerging evidence defines my faith. Science is what led me to my religion and is the reason I have remained in this particular religion. I have never heard faith described as you did. True faith is based on trust. If the sun come up every morning you have faith that it will come up the next morning. Faith is also based on love. You have faith that your loved ones will do so and so. I think a study is due on faith. Personally being a theist I feel we are designed to accept faith, even though I came to it backwards...

; {>


I agree. Faith based on evidence is reasonable.

Of course, we disagree on what the evidence says, but that's what debate is for. :)
 
See my post. Additionally God may be omniscient only in his realm outside time. He designed the (temporal) universe to run on uncertainty, chaos and probabilities. I hope that helped.
No. You want to have your cake and eat it too. It doesn't work that way for a number of reasons.
  • To state that god exists outside of time is to speak gibberish. No one knows what that means and it is incoherent. Time is change. Change is time. Time is measured by change and change by time.
  • God (if it existed) could not make choices outside of time. That is a nonsensical statement.
  • You can't have uncertainty and omnicience.
  • Uncertainy =! certainty.
If you want to abandon logic that is fine but go all the way, don't then attempt to use logic to make any argument. Rules don't work by making them up as you go along and ditching the ones you don't like.
 
Last edited:
Craig as well as I would say that after time was created the cause could choose to enter time if it wished.


As Robin mentioned, this still implies a temporal framework.

The first paragraph is helpful~

"This is the most important point with regards to the identification of the First Cause entity. If it can be shown that the entity responsible for the creation of the universe makes decisions, you are basically forced to acknowledge the existence of God in one form or another. A naturalistic cause does not have the ability to make decisions. Therefore, if this point is proven, it seems inevitable that we will be forced to admit that God is the only logical possibility for the First Cause in question, or at least the most plausible possibility."


This paragraph fails to clarify what is meant by "makes decisions" and how that can be done in an atemporal setting. Without cause and effect (a trigger for the decision and the choices to be decided between), a decision is nothing more than random fluctuations. Hello, virtual particle pairs!

I agree that P-6 is fairly lame and for me one of the weakest premises. However its valid in Craigs take and I suppose I will be forced to agree with Craig or risk inserting a fatal flaw in the KCA.


What is Craig's take? Without a solid reference, all we have here is an unfounded assertion.

In any case and as I have said all along the KCA is simply a valid cosmological argument that uses logic to make a case for a cause for the universe cause and ultimately a case for the existence of God as all Ontological /cosmological arguments do. When an atheist or simply someone is curious asks me what evidence do I have for the existence of God I usually tell him about the KCA. Its one of a many evidences. I ask an agnostic atheist to provide an equivalent valid logical argument for why he believes as he does, and of course he can't do it. So while the KCA is weak in some areas it fulfills the requirements for a valid cosmological argument. One mans muddled thinking is another valid argument and recognized as such by the academia powers that be. And who ever else makes those quantifications.

That's more than unbelievers have, with all due respect.


Not at all. Once the flawed premises are dropped (particularly the notion of "eternal" as being meaningful and the notion of "choice" being necessary), standard uncaused events satisfy a solid logical argument as to the nature of the observed universe.

And at least there is observed evidence to support such concepts, which is more than the believers have, with all due respect.
 
I must say again, that it is very difficult to get any kind of viable exchange of thoughts with you atheists, because you just can't be relevant but must indulge in all kinds of diversionary tactics, indicating that you have almost nothing if anything at all clear and definite and categorical to which you can claim to have any conviction for.


Except that your words are rife with anger and hatred for God owing to your fear of God.

It was you, Yrreg, who brought up penis touching as part of some sort of amusing logical 'chain' to demonstrate the certainty of God's existence.
A few pages back you even claimed our existence is proof of a Creator.
And now you try to lash us into attention with this:
"....you have almost nothing if anything at all clear and definite and categorical to which you can claim to have any conviction for."

So what? I don't recall being asked about my convictions when I joined tihis forum. Who needs convictions to be able to see your arguments/proofs of the certainty of God's existence are laughable?
Since when is laughing at your arguments a proof I hate God?
 
Well I accused all of us ALL of having bigotry and hate not just atheists. I see it on both sides, and I didn't say you were a bigot either. If you call me dishonest for not agreeing that irritated and anger is the same thing, well that's a minor issue.
If I had hatred toward Christians it would be bigotry. There's that logic again. Rev, the things you say have logical consequences. I'm capable of hatred. I'm capable of anger. I don't hate Christians and I've no conscious bias against Christians simply for the sake of being Christian.

I would prefer if you didn't claim to read my mind. If I tell you that I'm irritated I would prefer if you took me at my word. Irritation is not the same thing as anger. People commit heinous acts out of anger. Few if any react out of irritation.

What you are failing to understand is that emotions are not all the same. Some are mild and some are extreme.

I know you are at least approachable and that you are fair by you extending a offer to meet in the middle. I hope you don't get angry but I only read the last of your post, but for good reason.
I've been angry on this forum before but I'm getting older and wiser. I don't think that such an admission would have ever made me angry. It is irritating though but that's fine.

I did not want to rebut your comments.
It was an argument and a good one if I say so myself.

You can lead a horse to water but you can't make it drink.

Thanks rev, I do like to think of myself as fair, approachable and rational. I try very hard. But I'm human and it's possible to push my buttons. I see little if anything that would do that.

Cheers.
 
Not by my understanding. As I said I think Gods original crib is a perfect atemporal realm. Its where he existed 'before' the universe existed.
There is no "before" in eternity there is no succession.
God wanted a material universe. This material universe is ruled by time. We think its imperfect and it is in certain ways. The universe is 'imperfect' because it has to be and still be a temporal material universe.

Just as quantum physics are ruled by probability's (we can know only one attribute of a particle not both at the same time neither can we know what that particle will do with certainty) our decisions are ruled by probability. So God could tell you what the universe (or you) are going to do with an exceedingly high degree of probability, but not with a 100% certainty. Why? Numerous reasons. One is to give you free will. God only knows with a very high probability what you will do. Its the nature of the universe.

; {>
So an atemporal God does not see the future until it happens?
 
Then where does the anger come from?
What anger?

I don’t have a problem with anyone that believes in the tooth fairy. None at all. That is their business.
Except that they are, of course, wrong.

If they had the money to have special channels on TV a remote with a change the channel function came with it for free! My schools are protected from anyone mentioning the tooth fairy [even first graders lest they think tooth fairies really exist].
What?

Now, we are talking about Christians here, atheists have their bashers too, I would be the first to admit it. But that’s another topic.
What?

So there is a rabid rage that boils up from somewhere, one so great that Christians are attacked at every turn in any forum where secular's have an overwhelming majority of members moderators and an administrator that doesn’t give a damn.
No.

Christian theological arguments - any theological arguments - are attacked and torn to shreds, because they are nonsense. Any nonsense will be treated similarly. The fact that you happen to believe in one particular brand of nonsense will not be taken into account at all. Nor should it.

(Of course I am not talking about this forum or any specific forum ).
Of course not.

If there were some self restraint from ALL the members Christian and secular alike and if moderators fairly and without ANY bias enforced the rules and guidelines, these forums could be a wonderful place of mutual understanding and respect.
No.

Your ideas are full of holes, and your posts are full of logical fallacies. We are pointing this out to you as gently as possible.

No anger is involved. No bias. And a lot of restraint on the secular side.

If your feelings are going to be hurt because people point out the flaws in your philosophy, it's time to either toughen up or subscribe to a less flawed philosophy.
 
I can understand some of your irritation (whats the difference between irritation and anger?). Atheists are in the extreme minority. They aren't for the most part well liked. I think much of this mistrust and hate (yes hate) comes from many sources. I think most of its unfair and regrettable.
So what you are saying is that the irritation of atheists towards Christians stems from the hatred of atheists by Christians?

I think you may have answered your own question there.

However I see nothing wrong at all with at least mentioning ID when and if ID can devise a secular theory.
It can't. ID is not secular and is not a theory.

You have to look at the religious side of the issue. We (I am a open theist christian) see evangelical atheists with a mission to destroy Christianity and everything it stands for.
No. It's just that your arguments are wrong. Not wrong as in evil. Not wrong as in morally or ethically wrong. Wrong as in based on false premises and derived using invalid logic. Incorrect. Untrue.

You might just as well accuse geography teachers of being on a mission to destroy the Flat Earth Society and everything it stands for, or math teachers of being on a mission to destroy the Church of the Four-Sided Triangle and everything it stands for.

I can make a case and I know its arguable that the country really was founded on christian and deistic values with God present at every turn.
Deists are not Christian.

If I were an atheist I would be as happy as a pig in slop. We live in a republic where unpopular minorities are protected. Look at that as an advantage to build your movement from a little wet spot to movement like Christianity or Islam. You would not have that chance in a theocracy or even a true democracy where the majority was Christian or Muslim, especially Muslim, with them its convert or die.
So? Your arguments are still wrong.

So I still think there is something not being told about where that hate...er irritation arises. In any case, you live in a free country :rolleyes: (yeah right , I know) but its free enough to build your paradigm from something to maybe a world force. In the mean time Christians to atheists should try to get rid of the hate, if we don't we are all in trouble.
Whatever. Your argument is still fuller of holes than Blackburn, Lancashire. Perhaps you could address that rather than this imaginary atheist hatred.
 
...I think good evidence exists for both ideas (God vs no God), however empirical evidence is lacking for both ideas.
A very puzzling statement. What is this good, non-empirical evidence? In fact, what does the phrase mean? I'm not being snide; I honestly have no idea what kind of evidence you mean by good evidence that is not empirical.

...One mans muddled thinking is another valid argument...
I'm sorry, but again: This is a very odd thing to say in my world. Logic works one way; muddled thinking is not part of it. The difference, as I see it, is that some people accept your premises because they already hold them true. Well, several people here do not, clearly.
If I am required to accept a premise that I don't already, I want to see the argument that forces me to accept it based on premises that I do agree with. It really is that simple.

Also, if I may be so bold, you haven't responded to the problems with your original premise P3.

Thanks.
 
Last edited:
A naturalistic cause does not have the ability to make decisions.
This is patently false.

In any case and as I have said all along the KCA is simply a valid cosmological argument that uses logic to make a case for a cause for the universe cause and ultimately a case for the existence of God as all Ontological /cosmological arguments do.
As everyone else here has noted, its validity is dubious and its soundness is nonexistent.

When an atheist or simply someone is curious asks me what evidence do I have for the existence of God I usually tell him about the KCA.
And when they've finished enumerating the flaws in KCA - which might take some time, I admit - how do you reply?

Its one of a many evidences. I ask an agnostic atheist to provide an equivalent valid logical argument for why he believes as he does, and of course he can't do it.
Agnostic atheists don't believe; by definition, they lack belief. This is because there is no evidence to support a belief in any god. And any atheist will point this out to you.

No, they don't have unsound logical arguments. They don't need them to shore up their faith, because they have no faith.

So while the KCA is weak in some areas it fulfills the requirements for a valid cosmological argument.
No.

One mans muddled thinking is another valid argument
Special pleading.

and recognized as such by the academia powers that be.
Argument from authority.

And who ever else makes those quantifications.
Likewise.

That's more than unbelievers have, with all due respect.
On the contrary. The KCA is so flawed as to be of negative value.
 
That is a very clear example of intentional irrelevancy, owing to malingering.

My number 1 operating premise?

Follow the simplest explanation for the available evidence.

That's it.


[...]



That is a very clear example of intentional irrelevancy, owing to male fide malingering.


The topic is about the certainty of God's existence where I say that there is an impasse between me and atheists here.

For me God exists, but for atheists God does not exist but instead matter in randomness exists.


Please read the concerned posts again:

Edited by Tricky: 
Edited for rule 12


Ask them this question:
What do you postulate in place of God?
​
See if they will answer this question; most probably they will again go inter diversions.

If they will be truthful to themselves and sincere to people reading this thread, their answer is:
In place of God we [they atheists] postulate matter in randomness.
​

Edited by Tricky: 
Edited for rule 12

If you are specifically addressing the atheists here, then calling them names is considered a personal attack and a rule 12 violation.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Tricky





Yrreg
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Ask them this question:

What do you postulate in place of God?

Since you have, earlier, stated your own definition of God as:

The creator of everything.

My response is that what I postulate instead of that is:

The creation of everything.

You will, of course, appreciate that your definition implies an entity, whereas mine implies an event.

See if they will answer this question; most probably they will again go inter diversions.

Seems two atheists have already shown your prediction wrong.

If they will be truthful to themselves and sincere to people reading this thread, their answer is:
In place of God we [they atheists] postulate matter in randomness.
​

If you will be truthful to yourself and others, you will admit that this is not true. We postulate matter under physical laws.

Hans
 
Last edited:
In few words, matter in its randomness, that is what, an intelligent premise?

Here is my clear, definite, honest answer without trying to be funny or sarcastic:

I believe1, based on the evidence2, that all living things evolved from simple, self-replicating molecules through a process of natural selection3. I believe these initial, simple, self-replicating molecules came into existence either by chance4 or through natural laws of physics and chemistry that we are yet to fully understand5.

The matter from which these initial self-replicating molecules developed, are part of a universe that has been expanding for several billion years. Our current science breaks down a tiny fraction of a second prior to the beginning of this expansion, which leaves everything that happened before the tiny fraction of a second in the dark. It is possible that the universe is one of many universes and/or a universe that goes through a cycle of expansion and contraction.

I believe, based on the evidence, that consciousness and intelligence are late-comers to existence6. Accepting that our science breaks down a tiny fraction of a second prior to the beginning of the expansion of our current universe, I do not completely reject the possibility that some type of intelligence may have been behind this particular universe7, however, since all consciousness and intelligence seems to have evolved from non-conscious, non-intelligent self-replicating molecules, the creator would likewise have evolved from something else and the question of ultimate source would still remain unanswered.

I also accept that since our science breaks down a tiny fraction of a second prior to the beginning of the expansion of our current universe, it is impossible and ridiculous and baseless to conclude that - even if there was a consciousness or intelligence behind the universe - the creator is supernatural, omnipotent, omniscient, omnibenevolent, male, the only one of his kind, was not created himself or gives two hoots about one species of tens of millions of species orbiting one star amongst hundreds of billions of stars in a galaxy amongst over one-hundred billion galaxies in one universe potentially amongst billions of universes.

The end.

Notes:
1 I used the word "believe" rather than the word "know", not to be diplomatic, but because, at this time, knowledge of our ultimate source is impossible.
2 I qualify my beliefs with evidence, since without relying on evidence, I would be open to beliefs in all sorts of nonsense from fairies to ghosts to psychic powers to unicorns.
3 Natual selection is not randomness. There is a randomness component to evolution (i.e. mutations), but natural selection ensures that only beneficial or neutral mutations make it through to future generations. The key driver of evolution is not randomness.
4 I grant that the chances are very slim indeed, but there are multiple planets orbiting stars amongst hundreds of billions of stars in over one hundred billion galaxies throughout the universe, which may be one universe amongst many, many bubble universes. The slim-chance event only had to happen once.
5 Although, Richard Dawkins touches on these theories in The Blind Watchmaker.
6 There were billions of years without life and then billions of years without intelligent life prior to our arrival in this universe.
7 The possibility of human beings one day creating a universe of their own has been seriously discussed by some physicists (google if interested).





In few words, you mean matter in its randomness.

That is what? an intelligent premise, coming from your kind of human intelligence?



Try again, consult first experts on IQ what is human intelligence, and limit your statement of premise to not more than fifty (50) words, because if you say more than fifty words to deliver your number one operating premise, then I am sure that you have a very poor grasp of any number one operating premise for your atheist worldview.

Okay, I will give you sixty (60) words instead of fifty words.





Yrreg
 
With such operating premises you will flunk the IQ test with flying colors.

Okay, I have read some people saying their number one operating premise is nothing in place of God.

If you start from nothing, then you are nothing, go away, nothing.

Some state that it is event governed by physical laws.

Very good, but not good enough, where do the physical laws come from?

And tell me you believe in events without subjects enacting or undergoing or being involved in the events?

That is not according to human intelligence.

Consult experts in IQ on what is human intelligence and how human intelligence cannot accept events without subjects involved in the events and physical laws without authors.




Why don't you just be honest and say that in place of God you postulate matter in randomness.



If you be consistent with your socalled number one operating premises above and take an IQ test consistently following those premises, you will flunk the test with flying colors.





Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom