Robin
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Apr 29, 2004
- Messages
- 14,971
I have bolded the operative phrase. I agree - what is necessary is to demonstrate that the first cause has a mind, not just to demonstrate that it is a cause.Craig as well as I would say that after time was created the cause could choose to enter time if it wished.
The first paragraph is helpful~
"This is the most important point with regards to the identification of the First Cause entity. If it can be shown that the entity responsible for the creation of the universe makes decisions, you are basically forced to acknowledge the existence of God in one form or another. A naturalistic cause does not have the ability to make decisions. Therefore, if this point is proven, it seems inevitable that we will be forced to admit that God is the only logical possibility for the First Cause in question, or at least the most plausible possibility."
I agree that P-6 is fairly lame and for me one of the weakest premises. However its valid in Craigs take and I suppose I will be forced to agree with Craig or risk inserting a fatal flaw in the KCA.
In any case and as I have said all along the KCA is simply a valid cosmological argument that uses logic to make a case for a cause for the universe cause and ultimately a case for the existence of God as all Ontological /cosmological arguments do. When an atheist or simply someone is curious asks me what evidence do I have for the existence of God I usually tell him about the KCA. Its one of a many evidences. I ask an agnostic atheist to provide an equivalent valid logical argument for why he believes as he does, and of course he can't do it. So while the KCA is weak in some areas it fulfills the requirements for a valid cosmological argument. One mans muddled thinking is another valid argument and recognized as such by the academia powers that be. And who ever else makes those quantifications.
That's more than unbelievers have, with all due respect.
RD ; {!>
But I am still in the dark as to how you or Craig would justify this premiss - presumably Craig does not consider it weak? Surely the argument I quoted above does not accurately reflect his thinking on this?