The certainty of God's existence.

Craig as well as I would say that after time was created the cause could choose to enter time if it wished.



The first paragraph is helpful~

"This is the most important point with regards to the identification of the First Cause entity. If it can be shown that the entity responsible for the creation of the universe makes decisions, you are basically forced to acknowledge the existence of God in one form or another. A naturalistic cause does not have the ability to make decisions. Therefore, if this point is proven, it seems inevitable that we will be forced to admit that God is the only logical possibility for the First Cause in question, or at least the most plausible possibility."

I agree that P-6 is fairly lame and for me one of the weakest premises. However its valid in Craigs take and I suppose I will be forced to agree with Craig or risk inserting a fatal flaw in the KCA.

In any case and as I have said all along the KCA is simply a valid cosmological argument that uses logic to make a case for a cause for the universe cause and ultimately a case for the existence of God as all Ontological /cosmological arguments do. When an atheist or simply someone is curious asks me what evidence do I have for the existence of God I usually tell him about the KCA. Its one of a many evidences. I ask an agnostic atheist to provide an equivalent valid logical argument for why he believes as he does, and of course he can't do it. So while the KCA is weak in some areas it fulfills the requirements for a valid cosmological argument. One mans muddled thinking is another valid argument and recognized as such by the academia powers that be. And who ever else makes those quantifications.

That's more than unbelievers have, with all due respect.

RD ; {!>
I have bolded the operative phrase. I agree - what is necessary is to demonstrate that the first cause has a mind, not just to demonstrate that it is a cause.

But I am still in the dark as to how you or Craig would justify this premiss - presumably Craig does not consider it weak? Surely the argument I quoted above does not accurately reflect his thinking on this?
 
Over the years my father became more and more religious. His response to me was, "what good is the search for truth if it steals your faith"?

:(


It's interesting and sad that many religious people hold this position. Faith is based on location of birth, family and circumstances. Science is based on evidence.
 
...the cause could choose to enter time if it wished.
Also, such a claim is utterly without foundation. There is no explanatory power or prediction or even what it means to be "outside of time". It's just asserted as if it has any meaning. It doesn't have any meaning. It's just an attempt to solve a logical contradiction. It's also really lazy and dishonest. No respected peer reviewed paper is going to include "and then a miracle happens".

One could easily bastardize any and every law and every contradiction with such assertions.

Bob: I have a perpetual motion machine.
Ted: The concept violates laws of thermodynamics.
Bob: My machine operates outside of entropy.
 
Last edited:
Craig as well as I would say that after time was created the cause could choose to enter time if it wished.
So for example it could place a letter on my mantlepiece first thing in the morning that detailed everything I would do during that day?
 
Nearly everyone I know and love is a Christian. I'm not angry at Christians. I get frustrated and irritated when the religious try to get religion taught in science classes. When religion is foisted on solders who just want to do their job without church state entanglement. I get frustrated and irritated when government doesn't take a neutral stance on religious issues. I get irritated when stupid ideas like atheists are immoral are propagated to the point that an atheist couldn't get elected today. I get irritated when I'm accused of anger without any basis for such an accusation.

Irritated isn't anger.

I can understand some of your irritation (whats the difference between irritation and anger?). Atheists are in the extreme minority. They aren't for the most part well liked. I think much of this mistrust and hate (yes hate) comes from many sources. I think most of its unfair and regrettable.

However I see nothing wrong at all with at least mentioning ID when and if ID can devise a secular theory. I don't know what you mean by religion being " foisted on solders who just want to do their job without church state entanglement" the army is very open to all religions and atheist. Or it was when I was in long ago. I don't know why you think the government doesn't take a neutral stance. And you are full of ....well irritation if you want to call it that. I don't know why you deny it.

You have to look at the religious side of the issue. We (I am a open theist christian) see evangelical atheists with a mission to destroy Christianity and everything it stands for. I can make a case and I know its arguable that the country really was founded on christian and deistic values with God present at every turn.

If I were an atheist I would be as happy as a pig in slop. We live in a republic where unpopular minorities are protected. Look at that as an advantage to build your movement from a little wet spot to movement like Christianity or Islam. You would not have that chance in a theocracy or even a true democracy where the majority was Christian or Muslim, especially Muslim, with them its convert or die.

So I still think there is something not being told about where that hate...er irritation arises. In any case, you live in a free country :rolleyes: (yeah right , I know) but its free enough to build your paradigm from something to maybe a world force. In the mean time Christians to atheists should try to get rid of the hate, if we don't we are all in trouble.

; {>
 
Why would an entity that is outside time need a day of rest?

I think the sabbath if that was what you were talking about was created for us. I haven't looked up the Hebrew words in that area in the OT so I have no educated answer.

Aquinas would say it was just a manner of speaking, just as corporeal terms are used to describe a non-corporeal God.

Agreed.

; }>
 
Last edited:
So for example it could place a letter on my mantlepiece first thing in the morning that detailed everything I would do during that day?
How does an omniscient being "choose".
  • Does god know what he is going to do tomorrow?
  • Could he write it down on a piece of paper?
  • Could he then "choose" to change his mind?
I guess that's the thing with magical thinking. Logical inconsistency is simply ignored. Inference and consequence are of significance only when they suit preconceived notions.

I have a sister-in-law who loves to send e-mails about scientific announcements that seems to prove some preconceived religious belief. The contradictory ones she never sends out.
 
How does an omniscient being "choose".
  • Does god know what he is going to do tomorrow?
  • Could he write it down on a piece of paper?
  • Could he then "choose" to change his mind?
I guess that's the thing with magical thinking. Logical inconsistency is simply ignored. Inference and consequence are of significance only when they suit preconceived notions.

I have a sister-in-law who loves to send e-mails about scientific announcements that seems to prove some preconceived religious belief. The contradictory ones she never sends out.
And even if it could - would I find myself forced to do all the things in the letter - even though I tried not to?
 
So for example it could place a letter on my mantlepiece first thing in the morning that detailed everything I would do during that day?

That is getting into free will. Think probabilities. I think he could give you the probabilities of what you would do for that day month year or decade. Or think time travel. Lets do the twin light speed time dilation experiment. One twin stays on earth while the other speeds away at near the speed of light c (in a vacuum). The theory goes that if you went to the nearest star and returned depending on your velocity you would age maybe 30 years but earth would age millions of years. However lets say you have a super telescope where you can observe what happens to earth in fast action. You slow down the motion and watch your twins entire life. You know everything he will do.

God could be similar. God could know exactly what you are going to do but you would still have the free will to do it. I think its a combination of calculating probabilities (of what the universe will do) and something like the time dilated twins. I hope that made sense. I was supposing you knew the twins thought experiment and how quantum probabilities are calculated.

; {>
 
Last edited:
How does an omniscient being "choose".

See my post. Additionally God may be omniscient only in his realm outside time. He designed the (temporal) universe to run on uncertainty, chaos and probabilities. I hope that helped.

; }>
 
I can understand some of your irritation (whats the difference between irritation and anger?). Atheists are in the extreme minority. They aren't for the most part well liked. I think much of this mistrust and hate (yes hate) comes from many sources. I think most of its unfair and regrettable.

However I see nothing wrong at all with at least mentioning ID when and if ID can devise a secular theory. I don't know what you mean by religion being " foisted on solders who just want to do their job without church state entanglement" the army is very open to all religions and atheist. Or it was when I was in long ago. I don't know why you think the government doesn't take a neutral stance. And you are full of ....well irritation if you want to call it that. I don't know why you deny it.

You have to look at the religious side of the issue. We (I am a open theist christian) see evangelical atheists with a mission to destroy Christianity and everything it stands for. I can make a case and I know its arguable that the country really was founded on christian and deistic values with God present at every turn.

If I were an atheist I would be as happy as a pig in slop. We live in a republic where unpopular minorities are protected. Look at that as an advantage to build your movement from a little wet spot to movement like Christianity or Islam. You would not have that chance in a theocracy or even a true democracy where the majority was Christian or Muslim, especially Muslim, with them its convert or die.

So I still think there is something not being told about where that hate...er irritation arises. In any case, you live in a free country :rolleyes: (yeah right , I know) but its free enough to build your paradigm from something to maybe a world force. In the mean time Christians to atheists should try to get rid of the hate, if we don't we are all in trouble.

; {>
I don't have hate for anybody, I have never personally experienced hate towards me, I know and have known Christians, Muslims, Hindus, Sikhs and many more religions and belief systems and have never yet come across any hate.

So I am not sure what you are talking about.
 
That is getting into free will. Think probabilities. I think he could give you the probabilities of what you would do for that day month year or decade. Or think time travel. Lets do the twin light speed time dilation experiment. One twin stays on earth while the other speeds away at near the speed of light c (in a vacuum). The theory goes that if you went to the nearest star and returned depending on your velocity you would age maybe 30 years but earth would age millions of years. However lets say you have a super telescope where you can observe what happens to earth in fast action. You slow down the motion and watch your twins entire life. You know everything he will do.

God could be similar. God could know exactly what you are going to do but you would still have the free will to do it. I think its a combination of calculating probabilities (of what the universe will do) and something like the time dilated twins. I hope that made sense. I was supposing you knew the twins thought experiment and how quantum probabilities are calculated.

; {>

But a timeless God would have perfect knowledge of all times equally - he does not need to calculate probabilities, he can simply observe, so he could give me an absolutely detailed description of what I was about to do.

And even if I tried to do otherwise I would find myself doing exactly what the letter told me I would be doing - and yet I have free will - yes?
 
Last edited:
It's interesting and sad that many religious people hold this position. Faith is based on location of birth, family and circumstances. Science is based on evidence.


I agree.(that its sad, because its not a good way to practice faith!) Emerging evidence defines my faith. Science is what led me to my religion and is the reason I have remained in this particular religion. I have never heard faith described as you did. True faith is based on trust. If the sun come up every morning you have faith that it will come up the next morning. Faith is also based on love. You have faith that your loved ones will do so and so. I think a study is due on faith. Personally being a theist I feel we are designed to accept faith, even though I came to it backwards...

; {>
 
I can understand some of your irritation (whats the difference between irritation and anger?).
  • People who innocently cause me harm irritate me.
  • People who go out of their way to cause me harm anger me.
However I see nothing wrong at all with at least mentioning ID when and if ID can devise a secular theory. I don't know what you mean by religion being " foisted on solders who just want to do their job without church state entanglement" the army is very open to all religions and atheist. Or it was when I was in long ago. I don't know why you think the government doesn't take a neutral stance. And you are full of ....well irritation if you want to call it that. I don't know why you deny it.
The Freedom From Religion Foundation documents the many abuses and serious infractions of Chapalains and military leaders who make many soldiers lives hell for being atheist.

Life is too short to live with anger. I'm a happy and positive person. There was a time in my life when I was full of anger. I do know the difference.

You have to look at the religious side of the issue. We (I am a open theist christian) see evangelical atheists with a mission to destroy Christianity and everything it stands for. I can make a case and I know its arguable that the country really was founded on christian and deistic values with God present at every turn.

When I was a missionary I had a talk about America's theist roots and I had lot's of selected statements to buttress my argument so I understand you.



You are wrong.
  1. There are religious roots but America was clearly meant to be secular. The Declaration ("creator"), Jefferson's letter to the Danbury Baptists, The Treaty of Tripoli, make it clear that Christianity was not intended to be the foundation of the Constitution which doesn't mention god or Christ even once.
  2. If America were in fact founded on Christian values it wouldn't make it right to entangle religion with government. BTW: Separation of church and state is the the best thing ever for religion AND freedom of religion.
  3. Atheists don't see Christianity any different from any other religion. Currently atheists like myself are under the most attack for attacking Islam. Every religion thinks that they are specially targeted for persecution. The can't all be specially targed to someone's paranoid (perhaps they all are).
  4. Again, when I was a believer I thought as you did. Once I stopped believing in god I realized that atheists don't really care about belief. They care about the abuses and the very real problems caused by religion.
If I were an atheist I would be as happy as a pig in slop. We live in a republic where unpopular minorities are protected. Look at that as an advantage to build your movement from a little wet spot to movement like Christianity or Islam. You would not have that chance in a theocracy or even a true democracy where the majority was Christian or Muslim, especially Muslim, with them its convert or die.
Many theocratic nations are in fact less religious than America. It's odd I know which is why you as a Christian should be as happy as a pig in slop because America has the highest degree of belief of most western Democracies.

So I still think there is something not being told about where that hate...er irritation arises.
This is beneath you and it isn't very Christian of you either.

In the mean time Christians to atheists should try to get rid of the hate, if we don't we are all in trouble.
Accusing atheists of dishonesty and bigotry isn't helping anything.

Look, I won't accuse you of dishonesty and things I can't know without reading your mind if you will do likewise.

I'll call it the golden rule and you can call it Christian values.

Fair enough?
 
Last edited:
But a timeless God would have perfect knowledge of all times equally - he does not need to calculate probabilities, he can simply observe, so he could give me an absolutely detailed description of what I was about to do.

And even if I tried to do otherwise I would find myself doing exactly what the letter told me I would be doing - and yet I have free will - yes?

Not by my understanding. As I said I think Gods original crib is a perfect atemporal realm. Its where he existed 'before' the universe existed. God wanted a material universe. This material universe is ruled by time. We think its imperfect and it is in certain ways. The universe is 'imperfect' because it has to be and still be a temporal material universe.

Just as quantum physics are ruled by probability's (we can know only one attribute of a particle not both at the same time neither can we know what that particle will do with certainty) our decisions are ruled by probability. So God could tell you what the universe (or you) are going to do with an exceedingly high degree of probability, but not with a 100% certainty. Why? Numerous reasons. One is to give you free will. God only knows with a very high probability what you will do. Its the nature of the universe.

; {>
 
Last edited:
Aquinas would say it was just a manner of speaking, just as corporeal terms are used to describe a non-corporeal God.


Chuck Norris likes to knit sweaters in his free time. And by "knit", I mean "kick", and by "sweaters", I mean "babies".


I think the sabbath if that was what you were talking about was created for us. I haven't looked up the Hebrew words in that area in the OT so I have no educated answer.


If the sabbath was created for us, surely Adam and Eve would have been aware of the requirement to keep the sabbath holy. And yet, time went on through Adam and Eve, Cain, Abel and Seth, Noah and his family, Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, Joseph, the hundreds of years spent in bondage and finally Moses, before God finally revealed his holy plan regarding a day of rest.

And thousands of years later, the sabbath day has become a semi-serious commandment to most. Take a look at how many religious people work on the weekends.

Conversation between God and a believer in heaven

God: You have been a good Christian in most respects, but why did you not take my commandment regarding the sabbath seriously?
Believer: I tried, Lord, but the boss offered double-time.
 
Last edited:
However lets say you have a super telescope where you can observe what happens to earth in fast action. You slow down the motion and watch your twins entire life. You know everything he will do.
And if you could get a message to the twin would he or she be able to alter their decisions?

God could be similar. God could know exactly what you are going to do but you would still have the free will to do it.
Formal logic can be hard. As I programmor I understand the percise nature of it. Humans are capable of thinking in the abstract and so they can declare things like, "I'm going down to the store today and buy square circle".

Just because you can declare that men regularly have babies doesn't mean that it is true. Now, I realize this might be patronizing but logic isn't something that is flexible and maleable. Squares are, by definition, never simultaneously circles. A doesn't ever equal not A.

Now, you can declare that god could know what you are going to do and you could still change your mind but that is not logically possible. You are simply employing a trick of semantics to state a logicaly invalid claim.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom