The certainty of God's existence.

Okay, atheists, you state your #1 operating premise, and be clear and definite about it.


My number 1 operating premise?

Follow the simplest explanation for the available evidence.

That's it.



I must say again, that it is very difficult to get any kind of viable exchange of thoughts with you atheists, because you just can't be relevant but must indulge in all kinds of diversionary tactics, indicating that you have almost nothing if anything at all clear and definite and categorical to which you can claim to have any conviction for.


Except that your words are rife with anger and hatred for God owing to your fear of God.


1) We neither hate nor fear god. We merely don't see any evidence for gods existence, nor do we see a necessity for the god hypothesis in explaining the world. The god hypothesis merely adds needless complication without really explaining anything. Most of us regard it as on-par with saying "fairies did it".

2) The "diversionary tactics" you refer to are mostly attempts to show you where and why your arguments fail. That you seem unable (or unwillig?) to comprehend this is your problem, not ours.
 
Is this all because you want to avoid addressing the fact that the age of the KCA in no way confirms its veracity?

No, it has to do with demonstrating/admitting that you were wrong. Even if it was a mild wrong. I will address your erroneous ideas concerning the age of the KCA when and if you do the right thing.

sin_in_full-searly'

; {wwjd>
 
Okay, atheists, you state your #1 operating premise, and be clear and definite about it.


For the present, don't attend to anything else in my post above, except to get the drift of the message.


Here is my clear, definite, honest answer without trying to be funny or sarcastic:

I believe1, based on the evidence2, that all living things evolved from simple, self-replicating molecules through a process of natural selection3. I believe these initial, simple, self-replicating molecules came into existence either by chance4 or through natural laws of physics and chemistry that we are yet to fully understand5.

The matter from which these initial self-replicating molecules developed, are part of a universe that has been expanding for several billion years. Our current science breaks down a tiny fraction of a second prior to the beginning of this expansion, which leaves everything that happened before the tiny fraction of a second in the dark. It is possible that the universe is one of many universes and/or a universe that goes through a cycle of expansion and contraction.

I believe, based on the evidence, that consciousness and intelligence are late-comers to existence6. Accepting that our science breaks down a tiny fraction of a second prior to the beginning of the expansion of our current universe, I do not completely reject the possibility that some type of intelligence may have been behind this particular universe7, however, since all consciousness and intelligence seems to have evolved from non-conscious, non-intelligent self-replicating molecules, the creator would likewise have evolved from something else and the question of ultimate source would still remain unanswered.

I also accept that since our science breaks down a tiny fraction of a second prior to the beginning of the expansion of our current universe, it is impossible and ridiculous and baseless to conclude that - even if there was a consciousness or intelligence behind the universe - the creator is supernatural, omnipotent, omniscient, omnibenevolent, male, the only one of his kind, was not created himself or gives two hoots about one species of tens of millions of species orbiting one star amongst hundreds of billions of stars in a galaxy amongst over one-hundred billion galaxies in one universe potentially amongst billions of universes.

The end.

Notes:
1 I used the word "believe" rather than the word "know", not to be diplomatic, but because, at this time, knowledge of our ultimate source is impossible.
2 I qualify my beliefs with evidence, since without relying on evidence, I would be open to beliefs in all sorts of nonsense from fairies to ghosts to psychic powers to unicorns.
3 Natual selection is not randomness. There is a randomness component to evolution (i.e. mutations), but natural selection ensures that only beneficial or neutral mutations make it through to future generations. The key driver of evolution is not randomness.
4 I grant that the chances are very slim indeed, but there are multiple planets orbiting stars amongst hundreds of billions of stars in over one hundred billion galaxies throughout the universe, which may be one universe amongst many, many bubble universes. The slim-chance event only had to happen once.
5 Although, Richard Dawkins touches on these theories in The Blind Watchmaker.
6 There were billions of years without life and then billions of years without intelligent life prior to our arrival in this universe.
7 The possibility of human beings one day creating a universe of their own has been seriously discussed by some physicists (google if interested).
 
Last edited:
fosterzygote said:
I told you, my anger and hatred for God stems from the fact that he still owes me $500 and he ducks me every time I see him.

Don't worry I am sure you will get everything you deserve with interest compounded for eternity when the time comes. I wish I could be there! :covereyes

; {O>
 
Okay, atheists, you state your #1 operating premise, and be clear and definite about it.
"No, really, duck!"

I must say again, that it is very difficult to get any kind of viable exchange of thoughts with you atheists, because you just can't be relevant but must indulge in all kinds of diversionary tactics, indicating that you have almost nothing if anything at all clear and definite and categorical to which you can claim to have any conviction for.
No.

Except that your words are rife with anger and hatred for God owing to your fear of God.
We have no more anger, hatred, or fear of God than we do for Zeus or Athena or Osiris or Nut or Inanna or Ishtar or Marduk or Tiamat or Odin or Freya or Loviatar or Louhi or Cthulhu or Hastur or Quetzalcoatl or Opochtli or the Rainbow Serpent or Ahura-Mazda or Raven or Coyote or Monkey or Garuda or Ganesh or Shiva or Melkor or Yavanna or the Lady of Pain or Arioch or Xiombarg or Erebus or Abaia or Perun or Chernobog or Baal or Melqart or Astarte or Dagon or Lugh or Brigid or Telepinu or Inara or... Well, I hope you're beginning to get the picture here.
 
Robert Oz said:
I believe these initial, simple, self-replicating molecules came into existence either by chance4 or through natural laws of physics and chemistry that we are yet to fully understand5.

I am happy to see a good civil and interesting post devoid of personal insults and comment. Good natured jokes and mild flame are OK, but I better get to the point lest I fall victim to my own critical words.

The item in the quote brackets are the weakest point of your entire belief system, at least compared to what I believe. In regards to you denying an intelligent agent is to blame for the beautiful design and implementation of our exquisite universe, I would simply say I disagree. I think good evidence exists for both ideas (God vs no God), however empirical evidence is lacking for both ideas. My areas of interest lie in origins because I take a heavily metaphysical deistic view of the universe. However that does not mean that I disagree with science at every turn. Anyway replies such as yours could lead us away from the personal toxicities of ancient grudges and suspicions of logical positivism /secular thinking vs. Metaphysical Christian eschatology etc.

Regards

RD: }>
 
Last edited:
While we were waiting for the justification of P6, I thought I would provide one I found on the web. It is a prime example of the muddled thinking inherent in this argument. Note the references to time in a timeless environment. Note how he muddles the two meanings of eternity 1) timeless, 2) an infinite period of time. And there is no such thing as "already" when there is no such thing as time.

Essentially he seems to be saying that only an entity with free will would be able to create the universe at a certain time in an environment in which time has no meaning:

(My bolding)
3.) An entity with the ability to make decisions.
This is the most important point with regards to the identification of the First Cause entity. If it can be shown that the entity responsible for the creation of the universe makes decisions, you are basically forced to acknowledge the existence of God in one form or another. A naturalistic cause does not have the ability to make decisions. Therefore, if this point is proven, it seems inevitable that we will be forced to admit that God is the only logical possibility for the First Cause in question, or at least the most plausible possibility.

Such a justification of this characteristic is possible. The First Cause in question requires an entity with the ability to make decisions, because an eternally existing cause without such an ability is not capable of creating something unique. This is because, since it has existed forever, the naturally occurring cause would have already created the universe. An automated, inanimate cause cannot will something into existence, because such a cause only responds to conditions. Since it would have existed forever, such conditions would have been met an eternity ago and our universe would have already existed forever. Either that or the conditions would have never been met, and our universe would not exist. On the other hand, God has the ability to make decisions, and thus can “will” something into existence even in the absence of any automated condition to do so. An inanimate, eternally existing cause cannot create something unique, while an entity that is able to make decisions can.

This concept can be difficult to grasp. Imagine that there was a giant lever, and if this lever was pulled down, the universe would be created, if it is left as it is, the universe will not be created. There are three possibilities for this lever:

1. It may never be pulled, so that no universe is created.
2. It may be pulled from eternity (in other words, it is always pulled down).
3. It may be pulled at a certain time, say, fifteen billion years ago.

Option 1 is false because the universe exists. Option 2 is theoretically possible, but it would result in an eternally existing universe, which has been demonstrated to be false. This leaves Option 3. How could this lever be pulled down after waiting for an eternity at a certain time? Let us postulate a Rude Goldberg machine, in which an extraordinarily complex chain reaction lasting trillions of years leads to the eventual pull of the lever. Could this explain the origin of the universe, in theory?

No, because even an extremely long Rude Goldberg machine would not cause the universe to be created a finite time ago. From the standpoint of eternity, a machine that takes up 10 trillion years has no effect. Infinity – 10 trillion = Infinity. There is simply no way for the machine to effect the infinity. Thus, even a Rude Goldberg machine lasting 10 trillion years would result in Option 2, which is untenable. Thus, a personal agent with the free decision to create the universe (or, to follow the example, pull the lever) is required.
http://www.skepticalchristian.com/cosmological_argument.htm
 
Last edited:
The item in the quote brackets are the weakest point of your entire belief.
The item doesn't posit unknown forces (magic) and unknown entities (invisible magic being). It is therefore parsimonious. Do you have another option that is also parsimonious?

You know, it might look like the magician actually saws the lady in half. You might also think that my assumption to as to how the magician does it is likely prosaic and natural is "weak" but it is parsimonious. And that's the thing, supernatural explanations aren't.

That's the thing that gets me about those who take their cars to mechanics when they break down but think that the origin of life must have a supernatural cause. Why? Why don't you go to a voodoo doctor to fix the car? Or pray. It could be supernaturally inoperable. You don't know for a fact that it isn't.

When you get sick do you first assume a demon? Some people still do but such beliefs are becoming increasingly rare. There was a time when many materialistic explanations for many events were rejected. Oh those skeptics and their emperical based medicine.

OTOH, if we could, as a species, bridge those last remaining gap. Give up our superstition for good.

I can hope.
 
Last edited:
We have no more anger, hatred, or fear of God than we do for Zeus >>>brevity snip<<<<< Well, I hope you're beginning to get the picture here.

Then where does the anger come from? I don’t have a problem with anyone that believes in the tooth fairy. None at all. That is their business. If they had the money to have special channels on TV a remote with a change the channel function came with it for free! My schools are protected from anyone mentioning the tooth fairy [even first graders lest they think tooth fairies really exist].

Now, we are talking about Christians here, atheists have their bashers too, I would be the first to admit it. But that’s another topic.

So there is a rabid rage that boils up from somewhere, one so great that Christians are attacked at every turn in any forum where secular's have an overwhelming majority of members moderators and an administrator that doesn’t give a damn. (Of course I am not talking about this forum or any specific forum ). If there were some self restraint from ALL the members Christian and secular alike and if moderators fairly and without ANY bias enforced the rules and guidelines, these forums could be a wonderful place of mutual understanding and respect.

; {>
 
I am happy to see a good civil and interesting post devoid of personal insults and comment. Good natured jokes and mild flame are OK, but I better get to the point lest I fall victim to my own critical words.

The item in the quote brackets are the weakest point of your entire belief system, at least compared to what I believe. In regards to you denying an intelligent agent is to blame for the beautiful design and implementation of our exquisite universe, I would simply say I disagree. I think good evidence exists for both ideas (God vs no God), however empirical evidence is lacking for both ideas. My areas of interest lie in origins because I take a heavily metaphysical deistic view of the universe. However that does not mean that I disagree with science at every turn. Anyway replies such as yours could lead us away from the personal toxicities of ancient grudges and suspicions of logical positivism /secular thinking vs. Metaphysical Christian eschatology etc.

Regards

RD: }>

Hey Rev, aren't you supposed to be busy providing the justification for P6?
 
Then where does the anger come from?
Maybe you could give us an example of what you are talking about?
So there is a rabid rage that boils up from somewhere, one so great that Christians are attacked at every turn in any forum where secular's have an overwhelming majority of members moderators and an administrator that doesn’t give a damn. (Of course I am not talking about this forum or any specific forum ).
Some fictional forum then? I could probably give an account of where this alleged anger came from if you could provide me an example of what you are talking about.
 
I am happy to see a good civil and interesting post devoid of personal insults and comment. Good natured jokes and mild flame is ok , but anyway lest I fall victim to my own words.

The item in the quote brackets are the weakest point of your entire belief. In regards to you denying an intelligent agent is to blame for the beautiful design and implementation of our exquisite universe, I would simply say I disagree.


I find that believing that an intelligent designer designed the universe in the way it appears is more of a leap than 'blaming' natural laws and chance. If a designer is responsible for it all, it raises an infinite number of difficult questions:

- What is the purpose of the cold, wasteful emptiness of space?

- What is the purpose of debilitating viruses?

- What is the purpose of making animals brutally kill and eat other animals in order to survive?

- What is the purpose of creating life on a planet in a solar system with a finite life?

- What is the purpose of wisdom teeth that don't fit in our jaws, light-sensitive cells being obstructed in our eyes, an appendix that can kill us if burst, a spine shaped in such a way that it makes back pain common, having bodies, minds and senses that deteriorate as we age, etc.?

The list goes on and on and on. Perhaps a designer designed them this way or perhaps they are the result of indifferent nature. Inserting 'God' where I have inserted 'nature' seems the weaker choice.

The other problem with inserting 'God' here is the problem of never knowing where the 'God' insertion trully belongs:

- Can't explain how the sun rises and sets? Must be God. Oh, wait, science figured out the natural cause.

- Can't explain how people get sick? Must be God. Oh, wait, science figured out the natural cause.

- Can't explain how tens of millions of species appeared on the planet? Must be God. Oh, wait, science figured out the natural cause.

By inserting 'God' wherever we lack current understanding, we stop advancement of that understanding in its tracks.
 
Then where does the anger come from? I don’t have a problem with anyone that believes in the tooth fairy.
Nearly everyone I know and love is a Christian. I'm not angry at Christians. I get frustrated and irritated when the religious try to get religion taught in science classes. When religion is foisted on solders who just want to do their job without church state entanglement. I get frustrated and irritated when government doesn't take a neutral stance on religious issues. I get irritated when stupid ideas like atheists are immoral are propagated to the point that an atheist couldn't get elected today. I get irritated when I'm accused of anger without any basis for such an accusation.

Irritated isn't anger.
 
I thought I would provide one I found on the web. It is a prime example of the muddled thinking inherent in this argument. Note the references to time in a timeless environment. Note how he muddles the two meanings of eternity 1) timeless, 2) an infinite period of time. And there is no such thing as "already" when there is no such thing as time.

Essentially he seems to be saying that only an entity with free will would be able to create the universe at a certain time in an environment in which time has no meaning:

(My bolding)

http://www.skepticalchristian.com/cosmological_argument.htm

Essentially he seems to be saying that only an entity with free will would be able to create the universe at a certain time in an environment in which time has no meaning:

Craig as well as I would say that after time was created the cause could choose to enter time if it wished.

While we were waiting for the justification of P6,

The first paragraph is helpful~

"This is the most important point with regards to the identification of the First Cause entity. If it can be shown that the entity responsible for the creation of the universe makes decisions, you are basically forced to acknowledge the existence of God in one form or another. A naturalistic cause does not have the ability to make decisions. Therefore, if this point is proven, it seems inevitable that we will be forced to admit that God is the only logical possibility for the First Cause in question, or at least the most plausible possibility."

I agree that P-6 is fairly lame and for me one of the weakest premises. However its valid in Craigs take and I suppose I will be forced to agree with Craig or risk inserting a fatal flaw in the KCA.

In any case and as I have said all along the KCA is simply a valid cosmological argument that uses logic to make a case for a cause for the universe cause and ultimately a case for the existence of God as all Ontological /cosmological arguments do. When an atheist or simply someone is curious asks me what evidence do I have for the existence of God I usually tell him about the KCA. Its one of a many evidences. I ask an agnostic atheist to provide an equivalent valid logical argument for why he believes as he does, and of course he can't do it. So while the KCA is weak in some areas it fulfills the requirements for a valid cosmological argument. One mans muddled thinking is another valid argument and recognized as such by the academia powers that be. And who ever else makes those quantifications.

That's more than unbelievers have, with all due respect.

RD ; {!>
 
Last edited:
By inserting 'God' wherever we lack current understanding, we stop advancement of that understanding in its tracks.
When I was beginning to question the idea of god I talked to my father. I told him that I had started a journey of discovery that had led me to question much of what I had once held as true. I thought he would understand since he was the one who first introduced me to science. I learned a lot of things long before I ever heard about them in school. He taught me about Einstein, Marie Curie, Plate tectonics, Galileo, Copernicus, etc, etc. I used to love to hear my father talk about science. I didn't always understand but I loved his passion and that he knew so much.

Over the years my father became more and more religious. His response to me was, "what good is the search for truth if it steals your faith"?

:(
 
...the cause could choose to enter time if it wished.
Einstein used change to illustrate time. Without time there is no change. Without change there is no time. To torture the point, we measure time by change and we measure change, in large part, by time. To "choose" is to change a state. One cannot be outside of time and choose. You might as well posit god as a square circle. It becomes meaningless to state that god is outside of time. To do so is to render either time or god meaningless.
 
Last edited:
Heh heh heh..I wondered when you would notice my icon...how have you been my old friend? And how are things at Religious-Science? I kind of miss everyone. Hey send me their addy? I promise I won't tell you gave it to me. I have brushed up on the finer points of the KCA.

Take care brother. I will be around here for a while unless I get edited too much etc

; }>

ps is Cory still around? I was concerned that my nemesis was in ill health.
I was going to reply in a PM, so as not to clutter the thread, but it appears you've got them disabled?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom