The certainty of God's existence.

Haha, gotcha, see? you are afraid, angry, and hateful for being an atheist.
No, I actually do think you don't listen and are in fact exceedingly stupid.
My next thread will be on "Why are atheists so afraid of God, thus angry and hateful toward God?"
Why should anyone be afraid of anything they don't believe exist?
Haha, gotcha, paximp.
If this follows the typical yrreG pattern:

1. yrreG has it handed to him-Check
2. yrreG realizes it long after everyone else does--Check
3. yrreG turns tail and flees the thread--Check
4. yrreG licks his wounds and goes into hibernation mode
5. yrreG starts a new thread and never mentions this one again---About to happen
6. yrreG eventually convinces himself that he won against the evil atheists<--- We are here
 
C1 is faulty. The universe began so it must have a cause to begin.
So let us get this clear, you are claiming that in a causal chain of events every event has a predecessor event - yes?
In fact the entire thing is not a logical syllogism and not even a good argument.
The logical structure follows your precisely - precisely. So if you are saying mine is not a logical syllogism then neither is yours. The only difference in my argument is that the ambiguities are removed.
So I will reject it.
Well duh, it is not supposed to be a valid proof of the existence of God.
If this is supposed to be a rewording of the KCA, well it is simply and fully a obvious falsehood.
It is just the same argument you presented with the ambiguities removed.

For example you introduce the undefined term "eternal" late in the argument without showing what bearing it has on previous arguments.

You bring in the term "time" at the very last premise when the early premises do not deal with time at all. I was simply removing these ambiguities.

Why don't you show me the argument with these ambiguities removed? You ask others if they know what a syllogism is, do you?

Do you really think that an ambiguous argument can be a syllogism?

(Oh and did you ever get around to providing the justification requested for P3 and P6?)
 
Last edited:
A rational theist maintains that everything with a beginning has a cause.
A rational person would not claim something unless they could demonstrate good reasons for believing it was true. I have been asking for a justification for this premiss for a while. I suppose one will come one day
Atheists in effect do not accept the concept of things with a beginning, ....
And irrational people are forced to resort to out and out lying in order to defend their position.
 
In any case I would watch where you step the KCA has been around for a thousand years or more.
No, the cosmological argument has been around for a few hundred years, the Kalam Cosmological Argument is less than a hundred years old as far as I am aware.

If you include Aristotle's original argument then you can say it has been around for thousands of years.

But neither of these arguments sought to demonstrate the existence of a purposefully intelligent being and so were not arguments in favour of the existence of God.
If it was easily defeated it would be discussed under bridges and bars instead of Universities and lecture halls etc.
Well I think everybody agrees that it is true in that the conclusions follow from the premisses.

But before anybody can claim that it demonstrates the existence of God you would have to remove the ambiguities, tighten up the definitions and show the premisses to be at least reasonable.

This burden falls on the proposer, not the refuter. I thought you would have known that already.

But you have been asked from page 1 to provide justification for P6 and I cannot see that you have. If it just rests on "coz I say so" then you may as well just say "God exists, therefore God exists".
 
Last edited:
However, I might point out that for whatever reason, the theologians have neglected to update the hymns to reflect this understanding.
That is Robin's second law of Theology. Every Theist has two Gods. The one that they worship and the one that they defend to unbelievers.
So, have Augustine, Boethius and Aquinas decided that "eternal," "everlasting," "without end," and "forever" do not actually imply an infinite span of time, but rather, an existence outside of time in which an infinite number of events is impossible? Given that the number of events in eternity must perforce be finite, has there been any inquiry into approximately how many events we can look forward to? When were they (or their successors) planning on letting the rest of the congregation in on this?

Respectfully,
Myriad
Well I never said the concept made sense, in fact I have long argued that it doesn't. A while ago I put the example of receiving a letter from God first thing in the morning detailing precisely what you were going to do that day - so could you do otherwise?

A timeless, immanent God is incompatible with a universe that contains free will.
 
Last edited:
RevDisturbia | Robin
|D1: An event is an entity that is the cause of it's successor if it has a successor and the effect of it's predecessor if it has a predecessor
|D2: A universe is an ordered set of events.
P1: If the universe has no beginning, there have been an infinite number of events.|P1: An ordered set of events is either infinite or has an event without a predecessor.
P2: An infinite number of events is an absurdity and is impossible.|P2: An actual infinity is impossible
C1: Therefore, the universe must have had a beginning.|C1: The universe has an event without a predecessor.
P3: Everything which has a beginning must have been caused by something.|P3: In an ordered set of events, any event that does not have a predecessor has a predecessor.
P4: If C1 and P3, then C2.|P4: If C1 and P3, then C2.
C2: The universe must have been caused by something.|C2: The first event in the universe has a predecessor
P5: The cause of the universe is eternal.|P5: The predecessor of the first event in the universe has no predecessors or successors
P6: The only way an eternal cause could produce something bound by time is for it to freely choose to.|P6: The only way that an event with no predecessors or successors could have a successor with predecessors and successors is for it to have a predecessor (an intention).
P7: If P5 and P6, then C3.|P7: If P5 and P6 then C3
C3: The cause of the universe must be personal.|C3: The cause of the universe must be personal.
RevDisturbia has claimed the argument in the right hand column is not a logical syllogism. Can anybody tell me the difference in logical structure between the argument in the right hand column and the argument in the left hand column?
 
RevDisturbia has claimed the argument in the right hand column is not a logical syllogism. Can anybody tell me the difference in logical structure between the argument in the right hand column and the argument in the left hand column?
From C2 onwards, the left hand side is using a different, unspecified, version of causality. That makes the entire argument a non-sequitur.

The right hand side is consistent in its definitions, but that leads to a contradiction.

It's double jeopardy for the KCA yet again.
 
From C2 onwards, the left hand side is using a different, unspecified, version of causality. That makes the entire argument a non-sequitur.

The right hand side is consistent in its definitions, but that leads to a contradiction.

It's double jeopardy for the KCA yet again.
Maybe when he said it was not a logical syllogism he meant it was not a theological syllogism. Not vague enough, too consistent.
 
Last edited:
My next thread will be on "Why are atheists so afraid of God, thus angry and hateful toward God?"
Now why am I not falling over with surprise?

RevDisturbia, maybe you can help Yrreg out with a little syllogism on this one.
 
My next thread will be on "Why are atheists so afraid of God, thus angry and hateful toward God?"


Shouldn't you start multiple threads:

1. "Why are atheists so afraid of God, thus angry and hateful toward God?"

2. "Why is yrreg so afraid of fairies, thus angry and hateful toward fairies?"

3. "Why is yrreg so afraid of unicorns, thus angry and hateful toward unicorns?"

4. "Why is yrreg so afraid of celestial teapots, thus angry and hateful toward celestial teapots?"

5. "Why is yrreg so afraid of time-travelling chimpanzees, thus angry and hateful toward time-travelling chimpanzees?"

...and so on.
 
<<<sarcasm>>>>Of course the universe is such a dull mundane uncomplicated place :cool: that any fool could design it. <<<sarcasm>>>>

Hey, no trying to sneak arguments from incredulity and design through! All the KCA gives you, if accepted, is that the universe has a cause.
 
Why do you beg the question?

My next thread will be on "Why are atheists so afraid of God, thus angry and hateful toward God?"
Why is yrreg affraid of the truth thus angry and hateful toward those who share the truth with him?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom