The certainty of God's existence.

You stated earlier that you had rejected Buddhism because you found it to be false. Yet Buddhism is said:
You stated earlier that you had rejected Buddhism because you found it to be false. Yet Buddhism is, in fact, older than Christianity. If your above reasoning is valid, then why are there still Buddhists after twenty-five centuries?

Rev Writes; "After that didn't pan* out out I moved on to eastern mysticism while a guest of uncle sam in south east Asia, Buddhism to be exact. I took a lot of good stuff with me when I became disillusioned with all the Gods and no good god. It was like eating rabbit food when I wanted a rare steak."

Please get your claims correct in the future? I have a difficult enough time defending myself , your fabrications don't help....
; {>
 
Last edited:
Vacuum energy is pretty much the textbook example of something without a cause.

It has a cause, you are confusing random causes with no cause I suspect. Its cause are virtual particles. We measure the energy which is one (particle) from pair. So vacuum energy derives from the particle in superposition vs the one in 'our universe'.

Wiki "Vacuum energy can also be thought of in terms of virtual particles (also known as vacuum fluctuations) which are created and destroyed out of the vacuum. These particles are always created out of the vacuum in particle-antiparticle pairs, which shortly annihilate each other and disappear."

; {>
 
Last edited:
Rev Writes; "After that didn't pan* out out I moved on to eastern mysticism while a guest of uncle sam in south east Asia, Buddhism to be exact. I took a lot of good stuff with me when I became disillusioned with all the Gods and no good god. It was like eating rabbit food when I wanted a rare steak."

Please get your claims correct in the future? I have a difficult enough time defending myself , your fabrications don't help....
; {>

You are playing semantic games. You rejected Buddhism. And your argument that the duration of a belief is indicative of its veracity is still fallacious.
 
It has a cause, you are confusing random causes with no cause I suspect. Its cause are virtual particles. We measure the energy which is one (particle) from pair. So vacuum energy derives from the particle in superposition vs the one in 'our universe'.

Wiki "Vacuum energy can also be thought of in terms of virtual particles (also known as vacuum fluctuations) which are created and destroyed out of the vacuum. These particles are always created out of the vacuum in particle-antiparticle pairs, which shortly annihilate each other and disappear."

; {>


Virtual particles do not exist in any real sense, hence the word "virtual" in their name. They are a mathematical construct used to visualize the process, as your own source notes in the parenthetical comment on vacuum fluctuations. Therefor vacuum energy does not have a cause.

Or, if semantics is the game du jour, vacuum fluctuations/virtual particle pair creation do not have a cause.
 
Virtual particles do not exist in any real sense, hence the word "virtual" in their name. They are a mathematical construct used to visualize the process, as your own source notes in the parenthetical comment on vacuum fluctuations. Therefor vacuum energy does not have a cause.

Or, if semantics is the game du jour, vacuum fluctuations/virtual particle pair creation do not have a cause.
Virtual particles are real. Maybe it would be better to name them temporary (very temporary) particles. But even then there are exceptions like Hawking radiation.
 
A response to yrreg.

The fact again is that there are billions of human beings who maintain it is important to be certain, i.e., to know for sure, that God exists.

For atheists they don't accept that it is of any importance.


I disagree that atheists don't accept that it is of any importance. I personally feel that, in the society that I live in, it is very important.

Before I explain further I would like to point out that your word choice presupposes a God. If you had said "it is important to be certain, i.e., to know for sure, whether or not God exists" then I think you would be more accurate.

The certainty of God's existence was something I struggled with the whole time I was a Christian. I wanted to hear God's voice, but I never did. I wanted to be overcome with the spirit, but I never was. I wanted to have a personal relationship with Jesus, but he never manifested himself to me in any way. I wanted to believe, but I found nothing of substance to believe in.



Your nose and your external sex organs are parts of your body that you can certify to exist by touching them, and others can ascertain them to be existing by touching them.

The same also with your very own physical existence, you can ascertain your physical existence and others can do also by your hitting yourself hard on your head with a lead pipe, and others also by similarly hitting your head with a lead pipe.

How does that connect with the certainty of God's existence?


I am certain of the existence of my nose because I can see it with my eyes. I can touch it with my hand. I can hear the air passing in and out of it with my ears. I can it feel when it is being touched. It gets cold, hot, sunburned, itchy, it runs, it becomes congested, it bleeds, it has hair in it that needs occasional trimming, etc, etc.

As for God. I have never seen him with my eyes. I have never heard his voice with my ears. I have never touched him with my hands. I have never felt his touch on my skin. I have never witnessed an event that could only be explained by the presence or action of God. All I have ever been presented with was anecdotal evidence of his presence or actions and hypotheses that are developed to explain the unknown.



Well, that is their business, but why do they want to talk all the time and write articles and books trying to show first it is not of any importance to them to be certain about God's existence, and second, they attempt to prove that God does not exist.


As I said before, I disagree that that it is not of any importance. In the society I live in, the existence of God is instilled from an early age and is prevalent in all aspects of daily life. It is taken for granted that God exists and people are expected to acknowledge this and behave accordingly. I tried to see what they see but no matter how hard I looked it just wasn't there. I attempted to fit in. When people prayed, I prayed. When people became emotional, I acted as if I too was overcome with emotion. When people told stories of how god was moving in their life, I also acted as though God was moving in my life.

This is when I decided that I needed to discover for myself, to be certain if you will, whether or not God exists. In the end I discovered there was indeed no substance. It was all wishful thinking and not wanting to appear as though I was blind to what everybody else was experiencing. Once I realized this, I had no choice but to stand up and declare "the Emperor has no clothes."

I have no intention of proving God does not exist. However, I will be quick to point out, to any one that asks, that I have found no evidence whatsoever for the existence of this "God" everyone keeps talking about.



Which efforts on their part prove exactly the opposite, namely, first that it is important to them in reality the question of the certainty of God's existence...


I would repeat that it is indeed important for some, but only if the question is worded properly i.e. "it is important to them in reality the question of whether or not God exists"



...efforts on their part prove...that God does exist...


Please explain how this is true.
 
Virtual particles are real. Maybe it would be better to name them temporary (very temporary) particles. But even then there are exceptions like Hawking radiation.


I think a better way to describe them is as having the potential to become real or the potential to exist. The way I understood this way back in my undergraduate days (way, way back :(), they couldn't be measured in any sense of the word, seeing as how they would be available for less than a Planck length (the time unit, not the distance unit). Being unmeasurable and unobservable, they didn't "exist" as far as physicists were concerned, but did as far as the mathematics were concerned.

In the case of Hawking radiation, the separation of the pair at an event horizon forces one half of the pair into "normal" existence, while the other half becomes lunch for the black hole. Up until the separation, they do not exist. In other words, the black hole triggers a creation event, but the potential for that event is eternal (in a Planckian sense of the word).
 
I think a better way to describe them is as having the potential to become real or the potential to exist. The way I understood this way back in my undergraduate days (way, way back :(), they couldn't be measured in any sense of the word, seeing as how they would be available for less than a Planck length (the time unit, not the distance unit). Being unmeasurable and unobservable, they didn't "exist" as far as physicists were concerned, but did as far as the mathematics were concerned.

In the case of Hawking radiation, the separation of the pair at an event horizon forces one half of the pair into "normal" existence, while the other half becomes lunch for the black hole. Up until the separation, they do not exist. In other words, the black hole triggers a creation event, but the potential for that event is eternal (in a Planckian sense of the word).
your undergrad days were long ago (and so were mine). Virtual particles are without doubt real. If you really would like to know the science, ask over in the science forum. But "normal" existence?? You mean it isn't in any type of existence between the time it is created and the instant it's partner crosses the EH?
 
your undergrad days were long ago (and so were mine). Virtual particles are without doubt real. If you really would like to know the science, ask over in the science forum. But "normal" existence?? You mean it isn't in any type of existence between the time it is created and the instant it's partner crosses the EH?


I agree, this would probably be better off in SMMT, but now we get to the Philosophy part.

What is real? What is normal? The way I had learned it, real and normal meant something could be observed and measured, although accuracy in measurement was limited by the uncertainty principle, position vs. velocity and all that jazz. Note, I do not mean observation requires a conscious observer, just to avoid that equivocation sandtrap.

There are many things that can only be inferred by its effects, but there doesn't appear to be anything behind those effects. At least not that we can tell at this point in time. Gravity is another classic example. We can observe and measure the effects of gravtity, but we have yet to spy a "graviton" in action.

But even if I am wrong (which is quite possible), it doesn't help the KCA at all. It just pushes the cause back one step. As I stated earlier, if I stipulate the existence of virtual particle pairs, what caused them?
 
Even though I'm new to the forums I can see that these types of threads are almost useless. I mean the original poster doesn't even respond to criticism nor attempt to make a counter-argument. And will you devout people stop creating threads that are almost all the same. Heres how god exists, or Proof of god. These threads don't spark good debate, and they only show how pathetic your argument for god is. (And yes I left god lowercase on purpose)
 
A rational theist maintains that everything with a beginning has a cause.

“Either everything has a cause, or there’s something that doesn’t.The first-cause argument collapses into this hole whichever tack we take. If everything has a cause, then God does, too, and there is no first cause. And if something doesn’t have a cause, it may as well be the physical world.”

John Allen Poulos, Irreligion



A rational theist maintains that everything with a beginning has a cause.


I am a rational theist.


Even atheists have a cause, and ultimately it is God, the maker of everything in the whole totality of existence including the physical universe, and author of the scheme of intelligent order in the whole totality of existence as described.

I must add to my definition of God so that the new definition of God should be:

God is the maker of everything in the whole totality of existence with a beginning including the physical universe, and author of the scheme of intelligent order in the whole totality of existence as described.​

However if you are thinking constructively and thus productively, these three words define God more than adequately:
Maker of everything.​



Atheists in effect do not accept the concept of things with a beginning, notwithstanding the Big Bang arrived at by astronomical physicists, indicating that the physical universe has a beginning.

They maintain instead that matter (not God alone) is eternal and randomness is the way matter works and thus we humans with conscious intelligence and free choice come about.

So for God as defined above by Yrreg the rational theist, they atheists substitute matter and randomness, which then for them supposedly explain better everything in the whole totality of existence.


That is why atheists are a glaring example of paradoxical thinking, all because they are so afraid of God, which fear of God also explains all the language of fear, anger, and hatred against God and people who know with certainty of God's existence.





Yrreg
 
A rational theist maintains that everything with a beginning has a cause.
Even when wrong? Not very rational at all.
I am a rational theist.
As per YOUR definition, sure.

Even atheists have a cause, and ultimately it is God, the maker of everything in the whole totality of existence including the physical universe, and author of the scheme of intelligent order in the whole totality of existence as described.
No. Unsupported Nonsense.
I must add to my definition of God so that the new definition of God should be:
God is the maker of everything in the whole totality of existence with a beginning including the physical universe, and author of the scheme of intelligent order in the whole totality of existence as described.​
However if you are thinking constructively and thus productively, these three words define God more than adequately:
Maker of everything.​
I reject that definition. Who created your god again?
Atheists in effect do not accept the concept of things with a beginning, notwithstanding the Big Bang arrived at by astronomical physicists, indicating that the physical universe has a beginning.
False statement.
They maintain instead that matter (not God alone) is eternal and randomness is the way matter works and thus we humans with conscious intelligence and free choice come about.
No. Strawman.
So for God as defined above by Yrreg the rational theist, they atheists substitute matter and randomness, which then for them supposedly explain better everything in the whole totality of existence.
Actually yes.
That is why atheists are a glaring example of paradoxical thinking, all because they are so afraid of God, which fear of God also explains all the language of fear, anger, and hatred against God and people who know with certainty of God's existence.
Edited by Lisa Simpson: 
Edited to remove personal remarks.


Please keep in mind the Membership Agreement and do not use personal attacks to argue your point.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Lisa Simpson
 
Last edited by a moderator:
However if someone does agree with the KCA and then tells me that the cause doesn't have to be God I agree (nothing is 100% certain) but then ask ; What is eternal and can cause a universe that supports life (when it shouldn't) to begin to exist out of the void. :eek:

How do you know it's eternal? What do you mean the universe "shouldn't" support life?
 
Haha, gotcha, see? you are afraid, angry, and hateful for being an atheist.

A rational theist maintains that everything with a beginning has a cause.


I am a rational theist.


Even atheists have a cause, and ultimately it is God, the maker of everything in the whole totality of existence including the physical universe, and author of the scheme of intelligent order in the whole totality of existence as described.

I must add to my definition of God so that the new definition of God should be:
God is the maker of everything in the whole totality of existence with a beginning including the physical universe, and author of the scheme of intelligent order in the whole totality of existence as described.
​
However if you are thinking constructively and thus productively, these three words define God more than adequately:
Maker of everything.
​
Atheists in effect do not accept the concept of things with a beginning, notwithstanding the Big Bang arrived at by astronomical physicists, indicating that the physical universe has a beginning.

They maintain instead that matter (not God alone) is eternal and randomness is the way matter works and thus we humans with conscious intelligence and free choice come about.

So for God as defined above by Yrreg the rational theist, they atheists substitute matter and randomness, which then for them supposedly explain better everything in the whole totality of existence.


That is why atheists are a glaring example of paradoxical thinking, all because they are so afraid of God, which fear of God also explains all the language of fear, anger, and hatred against God and people who know with certainty of God's existence.



Yrreg


Even when wrong? Not very rational at all.
As per YOUR definition, sure.

No. Unsupported Nonsense.
I reject that definition. Who created your god again?
False statement.
No. Strawman.
Actually yes.
Edited by Gaspode: 
Edited for Rule 12
Edited by Tricky: 
Removed Rule 12 violation.

That is why atheists are a glaring example of paradoxical thinking, all because they are so afraid of God, which fear of God also explains all the language of fear, anger, and hatred against God and people who know with certainty of God's existence. -- Yrreg
​
My next thread will be on "Why are atheists so afraid of God, thus angry and hateful toward God?"



Edited by Tricky: 
Edited for civility.





Yrreg
Please do not make personal attacks.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Tricky
 
Last edited by a moderator:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom