The certainty of God's existence.

If you liked that, then here's another, "...the uncaused first cause needn’t have any traditional God-like qualities. It’s simply first, and as we know from other realms, being first doesn’t mean being best. No one brags about still using the first personal computers to come on the market. Even if the first cause existed, it might simply be a brute fact — or even worse, an actual brute.”

Yes - I'm always surprised that the purported first cause is some massively complex, intelligent super-being. Surely it's more likely to be a cosmic version of a burning fuse. . .

Wait, if this is an ACME universe, it would explain a great deal.
 
If you liked that, then here's another, "...the uncaused first cause needn’t have any traditional God-like qualities. It’s simply first, and as we know from other realms, being first doesn’t mean being best. No one brags about still using the first personal computers to come on the market. Even if the first cause existed, it might simply be a brute fact — or even worse, an actual brute.”

I agree the KCA assigns no personal attributes to the cause/God. That's what religion is for. However if someone does agree with the KCA and then tells me that the cause doesn't have to be God I agree (nothing is 100% certain) but then ask ; What is eternal and can cause a universe that supports life (when it shouldn't) to begin to exist out of the void. :eek:

; {>
 
Yes - I'm always surprised that the purported first cause is some massively complex, intelligent super-being. Surely it's more likely to be a cosmic version of a burning fuse. . .

Wait, if this is an ACME universe, it would explain a great deal.

<<<sarcasm>>>>Of course the universe is such a dull mundane uncomplicated place :cool: that any fool could design it. <<<sarcasm>>>>

Ive got to bail and insert this bod amongst some sanity ...come here Bogie time to spoon...

Hugs to all and Peace on earth

1t.jpg


; {>
 
Last edited:
Non-sequitur, argument from authority, argument from antiquity.

This is not a game of logical fallacy bingo, RevD. Though if it were, you'd have some stiff competition from some of the other threads...

Wrong as usual. I did not say that it was correct I said that its been around for that long and would of been defeated by now. There is a difference ZZZZZZZZZzzzz.

; {>
 
Last edited:
So RevDisturba, if I may overwhelm you with responses somewhat more: Why are a-temporal events somehow allowed outside the universe, but not a-causal events?
You base the rejection of uncaused events on observations within this universe, but for the exact same reasons I could reject a-temporal events.

To clarify further:
You say: Everything that begins to exist has a cause.
I say: Everything that exists, exists in time as well as in space.

What seems to me to be missing in both statments is the qualifier "in this universe". If you agree, it is up to you to prove why some things we observe inside the universe apply beyond too, and some do not.
 
I agree the KCA assigns no personal attributes to the cause/God.
Nor can it.

That's what religion is for.
But for that very reason any jump from the KCA (ignoring its manifold flaws) to religion (ignoring its manifold flaws) is yet another non-sequitur.

However if someone does agree with the KCA
We don't.

and then tells me that the cause doesn't have to be God I agree (nothing is 100% certain) but then ask ; What is eternal and can cause a universe that supports life (when it shouldn't) to begin to exist out of the void.
Quantum fluctuation. Brane impact. Chaotic inflation.

Or the Universe could simply be infinitely old but cyclic, with the earlier cycles sealed from view by the singularity of the Big Crunch / Big Bang.

What we have here, RevD, is a failure of imagination. Think big. That this Universe is the only one is just another of your unexamined assumptions.
 
Wrong as usual. I did not say that it was correct I said that its been around for that long and would of been defeated by now. There is a difference ZZZZZZZZZzzzz.
Nope. Argument from antiquity, again.

Of course, it has been defeated, resoundingly so, so it's also a non-sequitur and begging the question, for those of you trying to fill in your cards.
 
What we have here, RevD, is a failure of imagination. Think big. That this Universe is the only one is just another of your unexamined assumptions.
Certain religions are specialists at thinking small. Unable to see the vastness of the cosmos, they limit to a personification of a magic father figure that is as powerful as random chance. Small indeed.
 
Randfan; you are predictably fair and decent and open minded.



(people like you really piss me off.)
 
I really appreciate your good work, whoever engaged in whatever good work.


Keep it up.


How do I survive?

Would you believe it's because it's fun for me, safe and very economical and convenient fun, and no need to go out the home, but of course I get to learn things about people's in particular atheists' psychology.



Yrreg

Funny, I don't see any evidence that you've actually learned anything about athiest psychology, apart from the fact that you have a very small sample size from which to extrapolate whatever conclusions you think you've reached.
 
Don't believe him, he is not taking my words in context.

I will chalenge him to give the link to those words.

Yrreg
Challenge met, Gerry.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/archive/index.php/t-147848.html

Tell us, what was the true context of the following statement?

Yrreg said:
But then atheist proponents of the theory of evolution, they don't have any sense of beauty, for them the universe is all ugly and they are ugly in their heart and mind, that is why I think to be logical they should do themselves in, i.e., commit self-departure.


Now, that is a good topic for a thread, who commit more suicides, atheists or theists?
 
You've just defined time, as presented in your argument, into meaninglessness.
Indeed. We've already seen that when RevD's argument is made explicit, he rejects it himself, so the essence must lie in avoiding precise definitions.

Is "argument by handwaving" recognised as a formal logical fallacy?
 
No! I have explained this before. It would be extremely helpful if everyone would take the time to understand the KCA in its most simple form. I could eliminate at least 90% of the counter posts and rebuttals if that were the case with all due respect. We know what a syllogism is right? Ok the first three premises of the KCA in its simple form is ;

1. Anything that begins to exist has a cause for its existence.
Unsupported assertion.

2. The universe began to exist.
Unsupported assertion.

3. Therefore the universe had a cause of its existence.
Unjustified conclusion.
 
Wrong as usual. I did not say that it was correct I said that its been around for that long and would of been defeated by now. There is a difference ZZZZZZZZZzzzz.

; {>

You stated earlier that you had rejected Buddhism because you found it to be false. Yet Buddhism is, in fact, older than Christianity. If your above reasoning is valid, then why are there still Buddhists after twenty-five centuries?
 
Oh Gawd man you can do better than that. Wait! Hear that sound? " splash splash gurgle gurgle *sputter* splash splash *cof* " Its the sound of a drowning man trying to find a straw to grasp ...;)

; }>


I notice that there is no actual argument in the above.

Nice sound effects, though.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
So RevDisturba, if I may overwhelm you with responses somewhat more: Why are a-temporal events somehow allowed outside the universe, but not a-causal events?
You base the rejection of uncaused events on observations within this universe, but for the exact same reasons I could reject a-temporal events.

To clarify further:
You say: Everything that begins to exist has a cause.
I say: Everything that exists, exists in time as well as in space.

What seems to me to be missing in both statments is the qualifier "in this universe". If you agree, it is up to you to prove why some things we observe inside the universe apply beyond too, and some do not.

Good question! I have been asked that by several people that actually understand the KCA.

See ya.




Just kidding I will type you a response but I have to research something first, you guys are smarter than the average bear, and I want to be sure I use the correct terms and words....For now I have to turn off the 'you have mail' thing it woke me...And I had to look see..dangit

; {>
 
You stated earlier that you had rejected Buddhism because you found it to be false. Yet Buddhism is, in fact, older than Christianity. If your above reasoning is valid, then why are there still Buddhists after twenty-five centuries?

Where did I say its false? That doesn't sound like something I would say.


; {>
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom