The certainty of God's existence.

I thought something looked familiar!

Hey, RevDisturba! How you doing, me old bean? Was it really a year or more ago that you and I had this KCA argument over on Religious-Science? It's good to see you here in my neck of the woods.
 
My next thread will be on "Why are atheists so afraid of God, thus angry and hateful toward God?"

If it hadn't been started already, I was going to pre-emptively start the thread. But would that be a breach of protocol and/or rude/insensitive and/or simply trollish behaviour? Wouldn't it just be 10 pages of people pointing out exactly why the question itself is all wrong with (certain unnamed persons) struggling to read (let alone understand) the posts from their high horses?

But if it happens...I want an aisle seat, 3rd row.
 
Hey, no trying to sneak arguments from incredulity and design through!
I missed that one - complexity presupposes intelligence, but apparently intelligence does not presuppose complexity.
All the KCA gives you, if accepted, is that the universe has a cause.
Yes, I don't know why people get so excited about it.
 
I missed that one - complexity presupposes intelligence, but apparently intelligence does not presuppose complexity.
Better to equivocate fantasy with reality my dear.
Yes, I don't know why people get so excited about it.
Better to weasel in Jesus and Yahweh into the argument my dear.
 
That was an invitation for atheists to think of the kinds and degrees of certainty.

Are you done with this thread now?

I have taken the time to address your statement concerning atheists not thinking certainty about the existence of God is important.
(http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=4989904&postcount=429)

You have no response?


That post from me was an invitation for atheists to think of the kinds and degrees of certainty.


As usual similarly with other things of the heart and mind, atheists cannot see the kinds and degrees of human certainty, because they have inured themselves from seeing beyond their medical condition of hating God, which hatred of God is due to their also medical condition of fearing God, and likewise their anger is due to their fear of God.


You see there are many people who don't believe in God or who don't give any importance to God, and they go about life without any axe to grind against God; but only people with a medical condition of morbid fear of God which I call theophobia write massively, lividly, rabidly, acerbically against God and fellow humans who know for certain that God does exist.

Take the writings of atheists like Dawkins, Hitchens, Harris, and their emulants, they are conspicuously betraying [pun intended] their medical condition of morbid fear of God.



Back to certainty about God's existence, that post you responded to is an invitation for atheists to think about the kinds and degrees of certainty.

The first kind and degree of certainty is for things which like your nose and your external sex organ and also you whole physical being you can touch with your hands, as also others can touch with their hands.

The certainty of God is another kind and degree of human certainty.

Then there is the pseudo certainty of people atheists who insist that there is no God.


I am about through but not yet, and still perhaps yes, with this thread: because it has served me very well for me myself to have come to the idea that as mankind cannot achieve absolute certainty in anything, still mankind can and do enjoy different kinds of and different degrees of certainty, and also kinds of pseudo certainty like the kind atheists with the medical malaise of theophobia feel that they are certain God does not exist.



I am now absorbed in thinking about the medical condition of extremist exhibitionist atheists who suffer the medical condition which I think most appropriately deserves to be termed theophobia.


The fear of God for healthy people is the beginning of wisdom.

For the psychologically ill, maladjusted atheists, it is the beginning of anger and hatred against God.​





Yrreg
 
That post from me was an invitation for atheists to think of the kinds and degrees of certainty.


As usual similarly with other things of the heart and mind, atheists cannot see the kinds and degrees of human certainty, because they have inured themselves from seeing beyond their medical condition of hating God, which hatred of God is due to their also medical condition of fearing God, and likewise their anger is due to their fear of God.


You see there are many people who don't believe in God or who don't give any importance to God, and they go about life without any axe to grind against God; but only people with a medical condition of morbid fear of God which I call theophobia write massively, lividly, rabidly, acerbically against God and fellow humans who know for certain that God does exist.

Take the writings of atheists like Dawkins, Hitchens, Harris, and their emulants, they are conspicuously betraying [pun intended] their medical condition of morbid fear of God.



Back to certainty about God's existence, that post you responded to is an invitation for atheists to think about the kinds and degrees of certainty.

The first kind and degree of certainty is for things which like your nose and your external sex organ and also you whole physical being you can touch with your hands, as also others can touch with their hands.

The certainty of God is another kind and degree of human certainty.

Then there is the pseudo certainty of people atheists who insist that there is no God.


I am about through but not yet, and still perhaps yes, with this thread: because it has served me very well for me myself to have come to the idea that as mankind cannot achieve absolute certainty in anything, still mankind can and do enjoy different kinds of and different degrees of certainty, and also kinds of pseudo certainty like the kind atheists with the medical malaise of theophobia feel that they are certain God does not exist.



I am now absorbed in thinking about the medical condition of extremist exhibitionist atheists who suffer the medical condition which I think most appropriately deserves to be termed theophobia.


The fear of God for healthy people is the beginning of wisdom.

For the psychologically ill, maladjusted atheists, it is the beginning of anger and hatred against God.​





Yrreg


Praise the Lord!
 
Hey Yrreg what are your psychological or medical expertise to make up a new medical diagnosis?
Not only is Yrreg a pseudo-philosopher, he's now a pseudo-psychologist. He truly has an amazing array of pseudo-talents.
 
Last edited:
As usual similarly with other things of the heart and mind, atheists cannot see the kinds and degrees of human certainty, because they have inured themselves from seeing beyond their medical condition of hating God, which hatred of God is due to their also medical condition of fearing God, and likewise their anger is due to their fear of God.


You see there are many people who don't believe in God or who don't give any importance to God, and they go about life without any axe to grind against God; but only people with a medical condition of morbid fear of God which I call theophobia write massively, lividly, rabidly, acerbically against God and fellow humans who know for certain that God does exist.

Take the writings of atheists like Dawkins, Hitchens, Harris, and their emulants, they are conspicuously betraying [pun intended] their medical condition of morbid fear of God.


You seem to be suffering from atheophobia.
 
I, for one, am convinced by yrreg's arguments.

He says he knows for certain that God exists. He knows for certain!

And after so many threads and so many pages of declaring his certainty, I finally see he must be right... because he is as certain as he is of the nose on his face and his external sex organ.

You see, if his nose exists and his external sex organ exists, God must also exist, because he is just as certain of God's existence as he is of his nose and external sex organ.

All of Christianity then logically flows from external-sex-organ-certainty.
 
Last edited:
You see there are many people who don't believe in God or who don't give any importance to God, and they go about life without any axe to grind against God;

Yes, there are. We're called atheists. I'm glad you finally understand this.
 
That post from me was an invitation for atheists to think of the kinds and degrees of certainty.


<cut for length>

For the psychologically ill, maladjusted atheists, it is the beginning of anger and hatred against God.[/indent]



Yrreg

Sorry, wasn't going to include the whole thing. Um, well...tried to find something coherent to rebut...but am I wrong - is there anything here other than an from-on-high sermon? It was just a big pile of baseless, unevidenced assertions wasn't it? A lot of the logic and physics being argued can over my head at times but this seemed to be nonsense - absolutely nothing he said applies to any of the atheists I know about/of.:confused:
 
Good question! I have been asked that by several people that actually understand the KCA.

See ya.




Just kidding I will type you a response but I have to research something first, you guys are smarter than the average bear, and I want to be sure I use the correct terms and words.
I was about to become offended, but it was a joke. Okay, moving along.
The thing is, so far you haven't answered except by telling the "people who actually understand the KCA" they're wrong, leaving out the how and why.

Look:
...C2 is arbitrary. Even if every thing in the universe has a cause, it does not follow that the universe has a cause. Classic part-whole fallacy.

I grant none of your premises.
...
P3 is untrue.

The PAC (Pixy's Antecosmological Counterargment)

...

P3. Cause precedes effect.
P4. Precedence is a reference to time.
C2. Therefore there can be no cause and effect without time.
C3. Since time is a property of the Universe itself, and cause and effect is meaningless without reference to time, the Universe cannot have a cause.

[P3. is an undischarged] premiss. A beginning does not imply an antecedent cause.

In fact there is a model of the universe proposed by one of the major physicists of our time in which the universe has a beginning and no antecident cause.

Now it does not matter for the purposes of philosophy whether this model is right or not, the fact that you can model it mathematically demonstrates that it is logically possible.

If it is logically possible to have a universe with a beginning and no antecedent cause then this premiss is incorrect.

Ah yes, the Kalām cosmological argument:

...Second, it exempts the "first cause" i.e. "God" from the restrictions placed on the universe. It simply assumes an infinite regress and then asserts a convenient eternal construct to terminate the regress. ...

...More likely is that the KCA falls down due to misunderstanding of such basic ideas as what constitutes a "thing" in the sense that a universe might be regarded as a "thing,"...

P5 is contradicted by P2. Therefore your argument is false.

That's where the fine print says "Insert special pleading here."

It doesn't have a beginning in the sense that objects within the Universe have beginnings. This is the fallacy of composition.

Your only response to this has been that this requires some kind of atemporal precedence. We figured that out, thank you, but why is it necessary to accept this? How can one exclude the possibility that the universe is itself like the first cause you propose, in that it isn't temporal and therefore does not require a cause? At the very least that would cut out the middle man; i.e. the ridiculously speculative premise P6 in your original syllogism.
 
First you owe me an aplogy for telling lies about my beleifs. If I can go back and find the offending post you can to.

You are playing semantic games. You rejected Buddhism. And your argument that the duration of a belief is indicative of its veracity is still fallacious.

Not so, but its too silly to address. All right. I like talking about the most important man in the world (outside Jesus). When I become disillusioned with my belief system, it has nothing to do with duration (where in Hades did you get that?) because of emerging evidence that discredits it etc., I usually coast until something else comes into my life. Buddhism and eastern mysticism was slapping me in the face literally (martial arts training) when I was in the army and in a country where eastern religions were de rigueur.
I became curious and the rest is history. So you are playing games too. Please cease and desist.

; {>
 
I am happy you are back yrreg! You are like a bullet sponge in a firefight. When you are around the usual suspects forget about attacking me and gun for you. I hope you have your Kevlar on.

; {>
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom