The certainty of God's existence.

Myriad said:
However, I might point out that for whatever reason, the theologians have neglected to update the hymns to reflect this understanding.

Oh Gawd man you can do better than that. Wait! Hear that sound? " splash splash gurgle gurgle *sputter* splash splash *cof* " Its the sound of a drowning man trying to find a straw to grasp ...;)

; }>
 
I could be wrong, but I'm pretty sure the reason your argument is not sound is because it is a restatement of the 'first cause' argument.

The argument you just presented is sound. But that isn't what you originally presented. You presented that the universe's cause was atemporal.
 
I could be wrong, but I'm pretty sure the reason your argument is not sound is because it is a restatement of the 'first cause' argument.

The argument you just presented is sound. But that isn't what you originally presented. You presented that the universe's cause was atemporal.

It is my friend. That (the cause is atemporal* ie independent of time) is one of the conclusions of the KCA.

; }>

* Definitions of atemporal on the Web:

1.. Unaffected by time; timeless; permanent or unchanging
en.wiktionary.org/wiki/atemporal
 
Last edited:
Tell me why isn't it a sound argument. It meets the requirements of a sound argument. 'A deductive argument provides conclusive proof of its conclusions; if the premises are true, the conclusion must also be true. A deductive argument* is either valid or invalid. A sound argument is a valid argument whose premises are true. A sound argument therefore arrives at a true conclusion. Don't confuse sound arguments with valid arguments.

So its a sound deductive argument

1 * Every event has a cause (premise)
2 * The universe has a beginning (premise)
3 * All beginnings involve an event (premise)
4 * This implies that the beginning of the universe involved an event (inference)
5 * Therefore the universe has a cause (inference and conclusion).

Sounds sound to me. If it sounds unsound to you maybe you should go back and hit the books again, you may of missed something. Trust me with my memory failing faster than my erections*!* I have to continually reinforce both.

PT

* from the web

** You have to have top secret clearance to open the *!* file.

I could be wrong, but I'm pretty sure the reason your argument is not sound is because it is a restatement of the 'first cause' argument.

The argument you just presented is sound. But that isn't what you originally presented. You presented that the universe's cause was atemporal.

Quite. I don't see anything in the argument above that implies God. As Jeff Corey posted,

“Either everything has a cause, or there’s something that doesn’t.The first-cause argument collapses into this hole whichever tack we take. If everything has a cause, then God does, too, and there is no first cause. And if something doesn’t have a cause, it may as well be the physical world.”

John Allen Poulos, Irreligion
 
Tell me why isn't it a sound argument. It meets the requirements of a sound argument. 'A deductive argument provides conclusive proof of its conclusions; if the premises are true, the conclusion must also be true.
If the premises are true, and the logic is valid, the conclusion is true.

A deductive argument* is either valid or invalid. A sound argument is a valid argument whose premises are true.
Right.

A sound argument therefore arrives at a true conclusion. Don't confuse sound arguments with valid arguments.
I didn't.

So its a sound deductive argument
Non-sequitur, specifically, affirming the consequent.

1 * Every event has a cause (premise)
False.

2 * The universe has a beginning (premise)
False.

It doesn't have a beginning in the sense that objects within the Universe have beginnings. This is the fallacy of composition.

3 * All beginnings involve an event (premise)
What is this supposed to mean? What is a beginning if not an event in itself?

4 * This implies that the beginning of the universe involved an event (inference)
False. Fallacy of composition.

5 * Therefore the universe has a cause (inference and conclusion).
Non-sequitur.

Sounds sound to me.
Then perhaps you should examine it with more care.

If it sounds unsound to you maybe you should go back and hit the books again, you may of missed something.
Nope. You're simply wrong.
 
Last edited:
Mashuna, God is the personal cause in the expanded version. I will expand if that doesn't help.

; {>
 
Mashuna, God is the personal cause in the expanded version. I will expand if that doesn't help.
The "personal cause" part of the argument is - as many of us noted earlier in the thread - a non-sequitur of epic proportion. Furthermore, getting from there to God is also a non-sequitur.

The KCA fails in both its premises and its logic, and its failures are legion.
 
As has been mentioned multiple times. That is called 'special pleading'. Here, see for yourself.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_pleading

I have refuted that several times. Please in your own words please be specific and tell me why you think 'it' (the whole argument, the premises? etc) is a case of special pleading. I can tell you you are wrong. If that was the case it would of been laughed off the many stages and other esteemed venues that it has been debated. I would be happy to personally put your concerns to rest though, its good practice. :jaw-dropp Thanks for your comment.

; {>
 
Mashuna, God is the personal cause in the expanded version. I will expand if that doesn't help.

; {>

Ah, I see it back at the start of the thread:

P1: If the universe has no beginning, there have been an infinite number of events.
P2: An infinite number of events is an absurdity and is impossible.
C1: Therefore, the universe must have had a beginning.
P3: Everything which has a beginning must have been caused by something.
P4: If C1 and P3, then C2.
C2: The universe must have been caused by something.
P5: The cause of the universe is eternal.
P6: The only way an eternal cause could produce something bound by time is for it to freely choose to.
P7: If P5 and P6, then C3.
C3: The cause of the universe must be personal.

In which case, I have issues with P5 and P6. But I see this is treading over old ground now.
 
The "personal cause" part of the argument is - as many of us noted earlier in the thread - a non-sequitur of epic proportion. Furthermore, getting from there to God is also a non-sequitur.

The KCA fails in both its premises and its logic, and its failures are legion.

You failed to tell me why you think it is a non sequitur. I can claim my basset hound is energetic but that doesn't make it true. Oh that goes for the KCA being defeated in any venue. Its still debated by PhDs today , but never been defeated, only challenged.

; {>
 
Last edited:
Quite. I don't see anything in the argument above that implies God. As Jeff Corey posted,

If you liked that, then here's another, "...the uncaused first cause needn’t have any traditional God-like qualities. It’s simply first, and as we know from other realms, being first doesn’t mean being best. No one brags about still using the first personal computers to come on the market. Even if the first cause existed, it might simply be a brute fact — or even worse, an actual brute.”
 
You failed to tell me why you think it is a non sequitur. I can claim my basset hound is energetic but that doesn't make it true.
Both P5 and P6 are non-sequiturs. They are asserted with neither supporting logic nor evidence, nor indeed with formal definitions of their terms.

In fact, when they were restated formally, you yourself rejected them as false.
 
In which case, I have issues with P5 and P6. But I see this is treading over old ground now.

I thought you said it was new ground? In any case I would watch where you step the KCA has been around for a thousand years or more. If it was easily defeated it would be discussed under bridges and bars instead of Universities and lecture halls etc. Not that under bridges and bars are bad I do some of my best work there, albeit its metaphyicial/religious work in those venues, the offer of a hot meal, etc...

; {>

: {>
 
No! I have explained this before. It would be extremely helpful if everyone would take the time to understand the KCA in its most simple form.

People do understand it. And do understand why it is flawed.

At what T did the universe not exist? At T1? At T0? At T239584085043? T8542347952093 maybe?

There is no such T.

Heck without the universe you don't even have the T's that you are basing the argument on to begin with.

It is like concluding that a CD or DVD must have been pressed because you can extrapolate that there is (or must be) a 'tracktime' 00:00:00.

The universe may have a beginning (T0?) according to the time-space continuum inherent in the universe. But once you lose the universe you also lose that time-space continuum for even claiming that the "universe began to exist."

For that, you'd need an orthogonal 'time-line' where the universe along with its time-space continuum can go from:

OrthT1: Does not exist
to
OrthT2: Begins to exist
to
OrthT3: Does exist

The reason that the ‘cause’ (for the universe begin) is atemporal is because according to big bang cosmology spacetime (time for our uses) was created after T-0 (the point where the BB banged). However the ‘cause’ must have existed via the syllogism ‘before’ (more correctly outside or independent of time) T-0.

Not only would the cause have to exist independently wrt the time inherent in the universe (AKA time-space continuum), no the universe (along with the time-space continuum and along with each and every T of that continuum) would have to do so too.

And be eternal, in that sense.
 
Oh that goes for the KCA being defeated in any venue. Its still debated by PhDs today , but never been defeated, only challenged.
The fact that it is still debated in no way implies that it has not been defeated. The fact that it is abjectly wrong, on the other hand...

And you can add argument from authority to your list of fallacies.
 
I thought you said it was new ground? In any case I would watch where you step the KCA has been around for a thousand years or more. If it was easily defeated it would be discussed under bridges and bars instead of Universities and lecture halls etc.
Non-sequitur, argument from authority, argument from antiquity.

This is not a game of logical fallacy bingo, RevD. Though if it were, you'd have some stiff competition from some of the other threads...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom