Jeff Corey
New York Skeptic
- Joined
- Aug 2, 2001
- Messages
- 13,714
My doG has no nose.
[Excessively literal mode]Then how does it smell?![]()
You know, half of all atheists don't have external sex organs.
That someone would be wrong. North is defined by the surface of a sphere. Polaris does not lie on the surface of the sphere in question.
[Excessively literal mode]
The olfactory nerve is located well back in the cranial space, so the lack of an external nose is irrelevant.
[/Excessively literal mode]
I think it's quite obvious Yrreg is trying to emulate the Socrates method
If this follows the typical yrreG pattern:
1. yrreG has it handed to him
2. yrreG realizes it long after everyone else does <=== That would be here
3. yrreG turns tail and flees the thread
4. yrreG licks his wounds and goes into hibernation mode
5. yrreG starts a new thread and never mentions this one again
6. yrreG eventually convinces himself that he won against the evil atheists
To sum up, and humor aside: accepting both P2 and P5 posits an entity that must experience only a finite number of events in an infinite time period. Care to reconsider?
Respectfully,
Myriad
P8: If P5, then C4.
C4: The cause of the universe has existed for an infinite amount of past time.
Very good, now at least there are atheists here certain about their noses.
Yrreg
Originally Posted by PixyMisa
RevDisturba, perhaps you could address my "proof" that God does not exist?
It may be instructive to see what flaws you can find in it, and then compare it to your own argument.
Naaah. They just need work, that is all.
For example I have noticed that in the argument presented in the first page, the terms 'time' and 'eternal' are introduced in P5 ande P6 without being defined or explicitly linked to any terms in the earlier premisses.
So I thought I would resolve the terms and produce a less ambiguous version of the argument while preserving it's logical structure. Please let me know how I can improve it even further.
Now you couldn't call that silly or absurd, could you?
D1 : An event is an entity that is the cause of it's successor if it has a successor and the effect of it's predecessor if it has a predecessor
D2: A universe is an ordered set of events.
P1. An ordered set of events is either infinite or has an event without a predecessor.
P2. An actual infinity is impossible
C1. The universe has an event without a predecessor.
P3. In an ordered set of events, any event that does not have a predecessor has a predecessor.
P4: If C1 and P3, then C2.
Whether the KCA is valid is very much in doubt. But it doesn't matter, because it most certainly isn't sound.I am rejecting your entire argument as a competing with the KCA because it is not a valid logical syllogism as the KCA is.
It has already been pointed out many times by many posters that this statement is untrue.C1 is faulty. The universe began so it must have a cause to begin. We observe nothing in nature that begins to exist with out a cause.
Exactly.In fact the entire thing is not a logical syllogism and not even a good argument.
Good.So I will reject it.
It is a (more) formal presentation of the KCA.If you can improve on it please re post it. If this is supposed to be a rewording of the KCA
Indeed it is. You have hit the nail squarely on the thumb.well it is simply and fully a obvious falsehood.
False.No! I have explained this before. It would be extremely helpful if everyone would take the time to understand the KCA in its most simple form. I could eliminate at least 90% of the counter posts and rebuttals if that were the case with all due respect. We know what a syllogism is right? Ok the first three premises of the KCA in its simple form is ;
1. Anything that begins to exist has a cause for its existence.
From observation and induction, this appears to be true.2. The universe began to exist.
This is not a premise. It is a non-sequitur.3. Therefore the universe had a cause of its existence.
Nope. A cause must be bound to an ordered sequence, or it is not a cause. So the regression cannot be stopped. This is special pleading.P5 is valid because infinite regression stops with the atemporal cause.
Please do.All the information you need is in that sentence, but I will expand.
No. This is logically and semantically incoherent.The reason that the ‘cause’ (for the universe begin) is atemporal is because according to big bang cosmology spacetime (time for our uses) was created after T-0 (the point where the BB banged).
If you don't mean before, don't say before. If you mean to refer to an ordered dimension of a superspace containing our Universe, say so.However the ‘cause’ must have existed via the syllogism ‘before’ (more correctly outside or independent of time) T-0.
Nope. Some of the errors you have made can be corrected without materially changing the argument, but others cannot, and you can't reach this point with a sound argument behind you.This deductive logically arrived at conclusion is inescapable (that the ‘cause’ that caused the universe to begin to exist is atemporal).
Special pleading.Now comes the clincher and what most people either do not understand or miss. The ‘cause’ that caused the universe to begin to exist DID NOT BEGIN TO EXIST as per the first premise of the KCA.
Special pleading.Its atemporal remember, not dependent on time, not created or did not begin to exist).
Non-sequitur.Therefore not beginning to exist, and satisfying the first premise of the syllogism, it stops infinite regression in its tracks.
Special pleading, non-sequitur, and probably affirming the consequent (it's hard to untangle this mish-mash).I hope this clears up why the ‘cause’ ie God violates no premises of the KCA, and reinforces the valid syllogism.
With all due respect, piffle.So with all due respect the laziness lies not in the creator in this case but in the created who has failed to do his homework
Hmm... Loathe as I am to cite SEP I don't have time to go to original sources:
Aquinas also explicitly adopts the timelessness view, saying that time is an illusion that humans have. For Aquinas eternity is timeless, changeless and all states are simultaneous.
I can't say what a majority of polled Theologians would say but I would guess that the majority of Christian ones at least would probably go with this Augustine, Boethius and Aquinas.
The Apostle's Creed said:I believe in the Holy Ghost;
the holy catholic church;
the communion of saints;
the forgiveness of sins;
the resurrection of the body;
and the life everlasting.
The Doxology said:Glory be to the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit. As it was in the beginning is now and ever shall be, world without end. Amen.
The Lord's Prayer (Protestant) said:... For Thine is the kingdom, and the power and the glory, forever."
Whether the KCA is valid is very much in doubt. But it doesn't matter, because it most certainly isn't sound.