The certainty of God's existence.

Foster Zygote said:
I'm guessing that you missed his post in which Yrreg declared that atheists are incapable of experiencing love and beauty in their lives and then suggested that they should just commit suicide.

Don't believe him, he is not taking my words in context.

I will chalenge him to give the link to those words.

:popcorn2
 
I'm certain that the arguments in favor of god are silly and absurd.
Naaah. They just need work, that is all.

For example I have noticed that in the argument presented in the first page, the terms 'time' and 'eternal' are introduced in P5 ande P6 without being defined or explicitly linked to any terms in the earlier premisses.

So I thought I would resolve the terms and produce a less ambiguous version of the argument while preserving it's logical structure. Please let me know how I can improve it even further.
D1 : An event is an entity that is the cause of it's successor if it has a successor and the effect of it's predecessor if it has a predecessor
D2: A universe is an ordered set of events.
P1. An ordered set of events is either infinite or has an event without a predecessor.
P2. An actual infinity is impossible
C1. The universe has an event without a predecessor.
P3. In an ordered set of events, any event that does not have a predecessor has a predecessor.
P4: If C1 and P3, then C2.
C2: The first event in the universe has a predecessor
P5: The predecessor of the first event in the universe has no predecessors or successors
P6: The only way that an event with no predecessors or successors could have a successor with predecessors and successors is for it to have a predecessor (an intention).
P7: If P5 and P6 then C3
C3: The cause of the universe must be personal.
Now you couldn't call that silly or absurd, could you?
 
Not much grey area in theism/atheism.
I wonder where Castanada fits?
God isn't mentioned; but an unfathomable mystery is, as well as an optimal means to experience it.

The closest thing to God in castanada's description, is the mythical Eagle, which feeds on awareness as we die. If the Eagle lets anyone slip by, its only because of the need for a seed-stock for more awareness to feed on. Definitely not atheism, but an assault on meat and potatoes theism.
 
I am certain that I have a better ability to recognize humor and sarcasm than Yrreg.

I am certain that all gods are man-made entities.

I am certain that there's peanut butter in my cabinet and cheese in my fridge.

I am certain that I'm sitting at a computer in my living room.

I am certain of the love of my family.
 
Now you couldn't call that silly or absurd, could you?
Yes. I could and would. It calls for special pleading and violates parsimony in more ways than one.
  • What preceded god?
  • What caused god?
  • Wait, let me guess, unknown forces and special circumstances.
  • God transcends time. Time is change. Thought requires change. If god thinks it can't transcend time unless god has special powers that we don't understand and would otherwise violate all known laws of physics (unknown forces and special circumstances).
"...and then a miracle happens" ISN'T A VALID PREMISE TO AN ARGUMENT.

Sorry for shouting but that point really shouldn't need to be made to anyone who understands what logically valid argument is.

That said, let's assume for a moment that it isn't fatally flawed from the word go by special pleading and violating parsimony. P1 is easily within current conventional wisdom. Physicists don't really see your argument, scratch their head and simply hope their isn't a god because they can't resolve a fundamental problem. Experimental data and multiple theories (string, super gravity, M-theory) provide elegant answers that don't violate known laws of physics and require anyone to posit miracles.

It really is a silly and absurd argument that fails in many ways.

Perhaps equally important, no one comes to god via this argument. It's made post hoc by people who want to justify their beliefs and are willing to posit unknown forces and circumstances to make the argument work so long as the argument sounds as if it could be logically valid.

Sound arguments tend to lead to consensus even among those not inclined to accept the argument. This one isn't a sound argument and it really doesn't deserve discussion or debate beyond someone pointing out that it violates parsimony and requires special pleading.
 
Last edited:
...tell me what is STFU; I am not conversant with forum acronyms.

[...]


Originally Posted by yrreg
Keep quiet, go away...

​


You keep saying this. Are you telling atheists to STFU?


Honestly, you have to tell me what is STFU; I am not conversant with forum acronyms.


By keeping quiet, go away, I mean it literally, because if people cannot be relevant to the thread's topic, they are wasting the time of readers and the forum's bandwidth.


Now, if posters here think I should follow my own directive, they are entitled to their opinion.





Yrreg
 
But "eternal" does not mean an infinite time period - there is no time for God. So God experiences all events in the universe equally, not one before or after another.


"Eternal" certainly does mean an infinite time period. It might (or might not) also mean what you say re transcending time, but the basic meaning of "eternal" is "never-ending."

Ask any Abrahamic theologians whether or not there will be some future time in which God will not exist, and whether there was a past time (e.g. before the Creation) when God did not exist. None of the vast majority who will answer "no" to either question can be logically consistent with anything other than an infinite time period.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Tell me some things you are certain of, like for example your nose
Oh, that's really funny.

You've seen my avatar. You can see I have no nose, and there is a mouth where my brain is supposed to be.

Do you think it's funny to mock my disability? I wouldn't mock yours. Even if you have a mouth instead of a brain, it is not being fun of me to take nose of it.

You are a horrible, horrible man.
 
Not much grey area in theism/atheism.
I wonder where Castanada fits?
God isn't mentioned; but an unfathomable mystery is, as well as an optimal means to experience it.

OH! I like it. Well, I don't know about the "optimal means", necessarily. Okay, I like the "unfathomable mystery" part. Let's stick with that. :)
 
I must congratulate you for your courage to admit to certainty of things you are...

Originally Posted by yrreg
I am asking whether atheists are certain about anything at all.

​

Within certain epistemological limits, yes. I'm certain I love my wife and children. I'm certain that if I don't pay my taxes there will be hell to pay instead. I'm certain that the arguments in favor of god are silly and absurd.



I must congratulate you for your courage to admit to certainty of things you are certain about.

Some people are scared to death to admit the certainty of things they are certain about, why? because they fear having to admit the implications of things they are certain about, that is why.

Meaning therefore they have a self-imposed limit to the mental grasp of reality, so that it is thereby constricted to only their immediate mental vision and nothing any furhter that can be consequential to their immediate mental vision arising from their sense perceptions.


Now, you have a nose in your face, can you admit to that without so many qualifications, that you are certain you have a nose?

Here, listen to me, I can say right away without so many beating about the bush:


Yes, I am certain I have a nose in my face.​


There, now am I thereby going to lose my case that if I were an atheist I might have to implicate from the nose to the certain existence of God?


That is the insuparable obstacle to discussion with atheists here, you cannot establish and maintain contact with them.


See, I am asking them whether they can be certain they have a nose, how many if any at all even just one atheist have answered without any reservations, qualifications, equivocations, pre-transmitted tergiversations (hahahaha), and prevarications (more hahahahaha)?




Yrreg

By the way, RandFan, you know Loss Leader, is he still around in this forum? I used to have a lot of exchange with him and heady messages at that in my Buddhissm sojourn phase here.​
 
"Eternal" certainly does mean an infinite time period. It might (or might not) also mean what you say re transcending time, but the basic meaning of "eternal" is "never-ending."

Ask any Abrahamic theologians whether or not there will be some future time in which God will not exist, and whether there was a past time (e.g. before the Creation) when God did not exist. None of the vast majority who will answer "no" to either question can be logically consistent with anything other than an infinite time period.

Respectfully,
Myriad

Hmm... Loathe as I am to cite SEP I don't have time to go to original sources:
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy said:
Concepts of eternity have developed in a way that is, as a matter of fact, closely connected to the development of the concept of God in Western thought, beginning with ancient Greek philosophers; particularly to the idea of God's relation to time, the idea of divine perfection, and the Creator-creature distinction. Eternity as timelessness, and eternity as everlastingness, have been distinguished. Following the work of Boethius and Augustine of Hippo divine timelessness became the dominant view.
Aquinas also explicitly adopts the timelessness view, saying that time is an illusion that humans have. For Aquinas eternity is timeless, changeless and all states are simultaneous.

I can't say what a majority of polled Theologians would say but I would guess that the majority of Christian ones at least would probably go with this Augustine, Boethius and Aquinas.
 
When are you guys, atheists, ever going to have the guts to admit to the certainty...

When are you guys, atheists, ever going to have the guts to admit to the certainty of the external parts of your physical body like your nose and your external sex organs?


Why do I want you to admit to that certainty of the external parts of your physical body?

Because if you guys cannot even be certain about the existence of the external parts of your physical body, please go away, because we cannot have any constructive and thus productive exchange of ideas if you keep shying away from certainty starting with your nose and also your external sex organs.




Yrreg
 
Who here is lacking the guts to admit their certainty to having a nose on their face?

If you want to talk about sex organs again, I'm afraid you'll have to find other members to play with.



(;))


eta: I am certain I have a nose on my face.
 
Who here is lacking the guts to admit their certainty to having a nose on their face?

If you want to talk about sex organs again, I'm afraid you'll have to find other members to play with.



(;))


eta: I am certain I have a nose on my face.
Yes, I am not sure what he is on about now. I am imagining that copious quantities of some alcoholic brew are now coming into play.

I definitely have a nose on my face but how this proves the existence of God I do not know and I suspect Yrreg is not going to make it clear either.
 
Ah, at last I can be in the cool kids club. I am certain that I have a nose, and I am also certain that I have a penis. Someone else is also certain that I have one. Rowr!

At least this means that I don't have to go away this time.
 
I am certain of the nose on my face.

I am equally certain that certainty of God's existence through reason alone is impossible.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom