Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
ON the Bamyan statutes:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buddhas_of_Bamiyan

But their destruction is just peachy keen to some people here.
And how dare the internatinal community have branded this an outrage.

Only a child would believe that the decisions of the US to invade countries are predicated on defending human rights or cultural heritage.

The world is full of groups and governments committing atrocities, and yet we only decide to invade some and not others.

It shows the desperation of the pro-war voices that they must now resort to such naive arguments such as this. It's a tacit admittance that any argument towards any tactical or practical victory in this decades old war is beyond reach.
 
You don't have much respect for cultural monuments, I see.

The damn thing burnt to the ground. That was a shame. It was a beautiful building

I do think it was a crime that it was built in the first place. I also think it it is awful that some of the world's wealthiest individuals pledged billions of dollars to rebuild it. That shows me how screwed up people's priorities are. We'll let people sleep on the streets, but an old building is burned and it gets priority?
 
Only a child would believe that the decisions of the US to invade countries are predicated on defending human rights or cultural heritage.
The world is full of groups and governments committing atrocities, and yet we only decide to invade some and not others.

It shows the desperation of the pro-war voices that they must now resort to such naive arguments such as this. It's a tacit admittance that any argument towards any tactical or practical victory in this decades old war is beyond reach.

Yep.
Does anyone think it's a coincidence that despite 12 of 13 of the Hijackers on September 11 being from Saudi Arabia we didn't invade Saudi Arabia whose human rights atrocities have been bad since it became a nation?

No, we invaded Iraq and Afghanistan for what exactly? We certainly never invaded Afghanistan to save the monuments or the women. We did it to get Bin Laden and I'm not sure even that was true. There wasn't an advanced nuclear weapons program in Iraq and Bin Laden wasn't in Afghanistan.

Funny how that works.
 
Jesus Christ on a pogo stick! Just stop with the gross exaggerations!!

Please quote anyone here supporting the destruction of the statues or claiming it was just 'peachy keen' in any way. We've actually said the opposite. I said this several posts ago: " They were, sadly, destroyed, but to call it 'violence' is exaggeration."

You and I see to define violence in a different way. You seem to think Violence must involve an attack on other human beings. I think the criminal destruction of property ia a acto of violence, and I am betting that the standard dictionary defination wuld support me.And the internatinal community considered the destruction of the Banyan Statues to be a criminal acto of destruction.
 
Last edited:
Some of these attempts to put a gloss on the Taliban are pretty fatuous. No, I’m not going to accuse anyone of being apologists for them, but don’t get in the game of trying to minimize what they are. They are extreme Islamic fundamentalists, and they claim that what is against the Koran or against the Hadiths are haram and must be punished. That is of course why they blew up the statues at Bamiyan and why they stone women for adultery in front of crowds and cut off the hands of thieves or lash them in the square and parcel off women to the Taliban fighters in forced marriages, ban education for girls and women, close schools, ban publications, prevent women from most forms of employment and don’t allow women to leave the house uncovered and without a male chaperone.

There have been some cheap laughs at this from people on the right making fun of the so-called “woke” by saying that the Taliban have kicked out a government that enforces face coverings (LOL! That’s masks for Covid, gettit!), destroy statues (Lol! They mean the confederate statues - because we know that is exactly the same thing, right!), and mutilate the genitals of children (ROFLMAO! The transgender thing, right!). But the thing is that these things (including the Kingdome thing) are not put forward as complete jokes. They are put forward as half-jokes. People say, “come on, I’m joking but…” and then we have a list of ways in which the person saying it wants the point to be taken seriously.

No, the more I think about this the more I think it was a massive error to pull out from Afghanistan at all. There is a good video featuring Rory Stewart in which he goes over a number of achievements that had been made in Afghanistan over the last twenty years and now it is all up in smoke. For him one of the key incriminating incidents for Biden was allowing the US to abruptly pull out of Bagram, apparently overnight and not even informing their Afghan counterparts or other allies. This stripped the Afghan forces of air cover and basically meant the Taliban could use the main highways to drive from town to town. It’s no wonder the Afghan forces were demoralized. As much as obvious corruption played a big part in the collapse, the point is things were actually getting better there and by pulling out completely and in this way, the West is now a hostage to fortune. There is nothing for it but to hope the Taliban are not quite as bad as last time even though we know that they will still be bad and much worse than what existed in Afghanistan until a week ago.

I can’t help thinking it is a big waste.
 
You and I see to define violence in a different way. You seem to think Violence must involve an attack on other human beings. I think the wanton destruction of property ia a acto of violence, and I am betting that the standard dictionary defination wuld support me.

I hate to point this out to you. But that is semantics in a nutshell. BTW, dictionaries do not provide authoritative meanings, they track usages. It also doesn't matter if a word or a term has a universal meaning if the two people in the discussion have their own meanings.

Destroying other people's property is violence no doubt. But not all destruction constitutes violence. Such as when they destroyed the Kingdome.
 
Last edited:
No, the more I think about this the more I think it was a massive error to pull out from Afghanistan at all. There is a good video featuring Rory Stewart in which he goes over a number of achievements that had been made in Afghanistan over the last twenty years and now it is all up in smoke. For him one of the key incriminating incidents for Biden was allowing the US to abruptly pull out of Bagram, apparently overnight and not even informing their Afghan counterparts or other allies. This stripped the Afghan forces of air cover and basically meant the Taliban could use the main highways to drive from town to town. It’s no wonder the Afghan forces were demoralized. As much as obvious corruption played a big part in the collapse, the point is things were actually getting better there and by pulling out completely and in this way, the West is now a hostage to fortune. There is nothing for it but to hope the Taliban are not quite as bad as last time even though we know that they will still be bad and much worse than what existed in Afghanistan until a week ago.

I can’t help thinking it is a big waste.

It is a big waste. I agree with that.

I also expect many people will make that argument. That if we just stay there another year or two longer we will have transformed into a nation that can take care of itself. Most of the people I'm hearing this from are the Neocons who launched the damn war in 2001. Most of whom maintain financial interests in pursuing the neverending war.

If a total collapse in days doesn't tell you that staying there longer was folly, nothing will.
 
It is a big waste. I agree with that.

I also expect many people will make that argument. That if we just stay there another year or two longer we will have transformed into a nation that can take care of itself. Most of the people I'm hearing this from are the Neocons who launched the damn war in 2001. Most of whom maintain financial interests in pursuing the neverending war.

If a total collapse in days doesn't tell you that staying there longer was folly, nothing will.

That was always the problem. Conservatives didn't want to end the war because we just needed n+1 more year to achieve our goals. Liberals didn't want to end the war because putting it on the backburner carried less political risk than being the person that publicly called it a failure. It's no wonder this failure dragged on for 20 years.

It's a minor miracle that someone finally pulled the cord on this.
 
Last edited:
That was always the problem. Conservatives didn't want to end the war because we just needed n+1 more year to achieve our goals. Liberals didn't want to end the war because putting it on the backburner carried less political risk than being the person that publicly called it a failure. It's no wonder this failure dragged on for 20 years.

It's a minor miracle that someone finally pulled the cord on this.

Exactly. That was two decades of tossing good money after bad.
 
You aren't paying attention. I'm not talking about why Trump had a photo op. I'm talking about why the park police cleared protesters and journalists from the area. That had nothing to do with the photo op. And the other possible reasons, also known as the actual reasons, are given in the link I provided.

Well you have no evidence of your hypothesis while the rest of us saw it with our own eyes. They cleared the square, Dump walked out with his entourage and held up a Bible for a photo op.

There is zero evidence of another reason the square was violently cleared ahead of the designated curfew.
 
Exactly. That was two decades of tossing good money after bad.

Was it though? My understanding is that there had been improvements in terms of infrastructure, schools, healthcare and a number of other things, whereas when the Taliban were last in charge there was almost no electricity and almost nothing there worked.
 
Was it though? My understanding is that there had been improvements in terms of infrastructure, schools, healthcare and a number of other things, whereas when the Taliban were last in charge there was almost no electricity and almost nothing there worked.

I'm sure some of that is true. But it still was a disaster. Two decades isn't enough? How much longer should we stay there? How many more billions of dollars should we spend?

We could easily have had Universal Healthcare for all Americans for the money we spent in Iraq and Afghanistan. We had money for roads and bridges over there but not for them here at home?
 
You and I see to define violence in a different way. You seem to think Violence must involve an attack on other human beings. I think the criminal destruction of property ia a acto of violence, and I am betting that the standard dictionary defination wuld support me.And the internatinal community considered the destruction of the Banyan Bamiyan Statues to be a criminal acto of destruction.

Yes, we do. We also disagree on what an attack is. Wanna bet that the vast majority of people would interpret your sentence that the "news crew was attacked" as meaning they were physically attacked as in hit, kicked, and/or otherwise touched in a violent, physical way?

Violence according to the Violence Prevention Alliance:

VPA addresses the problem of violence as defined in the World report on violence and health (WRVH), namely:

"the intentional use of physical force or power, threatened or actual, against oneself, another person, or against a group or community, that either results in or has a high likelihood of resulting in injury, death, psychological harm, maldevelopment, or deprivation."
https://www.who.int/violenceprevention/approach/definition/en/

If we go by Merriam Webster:

Violence: "the use of physical force so as to injure, abuse, damage, or destroy."

So if I use physical force to tear open an envelope rendering it damaged and/or destroyed, I'm committing a violent act?

I agree that the blowing up of the Bamiyan statues was an act of destruction but that was never the point of disagreement. To remind you of the actual topic:

Are they sexist misogynistic, male dominated and religiously backwards? Yes.

Are they arbitrarily and capriciously violent? I don't buy that. To many of the Afghans, Taliban means religious.

You don't know much about the Taliban do you? Remember the blowing up of the Buddhist statues?Sorry, but I think you are trying to make the Taliban look better then the religous thugs they are because you think somehow that will make Biden look better.
The Taliban are bunch of violent, relgious thugs, period. Just look at the record.
The US withdrawal from Afghanstian meant putting a bunch of thugs in charge. I think we should have withdrawn because it was a hopeless military situationg, but I was under no illusion about what that meant.
And if the "Progressives" are going to go into the business of making excuses for Islamic Militants, it will not end well politcally for them.
You wanted a withdrawal, now you got it. You need to face up to the consequences. And trying to white wash the Taliban in not doing that.

I do think you're right that they will not be 'arbitrarily or capriciously' violent: it will have a reason for them although it will often seem unjust according to our views. For example, beating a woman because she's not covered to their standards, executing those whom they view as collaborators, stoning women who committed/are suspected of adultery, etc.

Blowing up the Buddhist statues isn't what I would call 'violent' any more than demolishing an old building is violent. It was done on the orders of the Taliban leader because they were 'idols' which is against Islam. It wasn't like blowing up a church or government building with people in or nearby in order to hurt people.

You gave destroying the statues as an example of an 'arbitrary and capricious act of violence. It was not. I explained and quoted Mullah Omar reasoning for doing so. And before you twist that into an accusation that I am supporting that, agree with, or approve of it, just don't.
 
I'm sure some of that is true. But it still was a disaster. Two decades isn't enough? How much longer should we stay there? How many more billions of dollars should we spend?

We could easily have had Universal Healthcare for all Americans for the money we spent in Iraq and Afghanistan. We had money for roads and bridges over there but not for them here at home?

:thumbsup:
 
I'm sure some of that is true. But it still was a disaster. Two decades isn't enough? How much longer should we stay there? How many more billions of dollars should we spend?

We could easily have had Universal Healthcare for all Americans for the money we spent in Iraq and Afghanistan. We had money for roads and bridges over there but not for them here at home?

What the pundits are bemoaning is the end of a de-facto occupation. The war was sold to the public as a war, but it ceased being a military operation pretty quickly and turned into a permanent police action. Even the hawks quietly accepted that any kind of decisive victory was impossible and that a permanent presence was going to be required.

There were no goals beyond remaining and continuing the status quo. Permanent occupation is what they wanted. Troops had to remain and we had to keep propping up the puppet Afghanistan government.
 
Last edited:
Some of these attempts to put a gloss on the Taliban are pretty fatuous. No, I’m not going to accuse anyone of being apologists for them, but don’t get in the game of trying to minimize what they are.

And yet you contradict your first sentence with your second. I got whiplash with that one.

They are extreme Islamic fundamentalists, and they claim that what is against the Koran or against the Hadiths are haram and must be punished. That is of course why they blew up the statues at Bamiyan and why they stone women for adultery in front of crowds and cut off the hands of thieves or lash them in the square and parcel off women to the Taliban fighters in forced marriages, ban education for girls and women, close schools, ban publications, prevent women from most forms of employment and don’t allow women to leave the house uncovered and without a male chaperone.

I agree with all of that except for this sentence:

That is of course why they blew up the statues at Bamiyan

As I explained earlier, Mullah Omar at first prohibited the destruction of the statues, ordered them protected, and even sought to have work done that would prevent further damage. It was only after Bin Laden, who was not Taliban but al Queda, became influential that Omar ordered their destruction as 'idols'.
 
I agree with all of that except for this sentence:



As I explained earlier, Mullah Omar at first prohibited the destruction of the statues, ordered them protected, and even sought to have work done that would prevent further damage. It was only after Bin Laden, who was not Taliban but al Queda, became influential that Omar ordered their destruction as 'idols'.

It makes no difference whose idea it was first. The basis is still because of an interpretation of Islamic fundamentalism. Indeed, Saudi-inspired Wahabbism made their interpretation even more extreme (I seem to recall that similar reasoning also led to the destruction of shrines and graves for fighters who had defeated the Russians), but it was still the Taliban's call to make.
 
It makes no difference whose idea it was first. The basis is still because of an interpretation of Islamic fundamentalism. Indeed, Saudi-inspired Wahabbism made their interpretation even more extreme (I seem to recall that similar reasoning also led to the destruction of shrines and graves for fighters who had defeated the Russians), but it was still the Taliban's call to make.

It most certainly does matter as the claim was that the TALIBAN destroyed them as an"'arbitrary and capricious act of violence". It was the Taliban leader who wanted to save them initially. Yes, Omar ended up ordering them destroyed under AL QAEDA's suspected influence. This goal shifting is obvious.
 
Well you have no evidence of your hypothesis while the rest of us saw it with our own eyes. They cleared the square, Dump walked out with his entourage and held up a Bible for a photo op.

There is zero evidence of another reason the square was violently cleared ahead of the designated curfew.
Somewhere around here there's another whole thread on this. One of the news outlets interviewed some of the people who were involved in that and apparently were consistently told that it was done to give workers some room to work on something, I think an upgrade to the fence around the White House, and that it had been planned for a while before that day, and that they didn't even know Trump was going to take his stroll through that area until he did. One could, of course, say they're all lying, but the starting point which that would seem to be based on amounts to just a post-hoc-ergo-propter-hoc itself.

And whether Trump's religious pandering was the cause of that attack or not is really beside the point. Yes, somebody did make that assertion, but the point that person was really making still works fine without it. The point was that, in the USA, cops frequently attack people they've identified as left-wingers. That's what they did in that case regardless of why they did it, and it's what we've all seen happening in plenty of other cases even if we completely ignore that one. So the point was correct, just badly stated.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom