Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
I don't think they will be anything different than that either. But I don't believe that they be arbitrarily violent to say Foreigners leaving or to everyone that opposed them. I also don't know if we can assume that the Taliban leadership of 2021 is going to be exactly like it was in 2001.

I'm just not willing to predict the future. But the reality is the Taliban was going rule the moment we left whether that be under Trump or Biden.

Yes, but let's not have any illusions about what we have done in letting Taliban take control.
And once again, I have to at your statement that blowing up BUddhist statues is not violent. Last time I looked, destruction of property was considered violent.
 
And once again, I have to at your statement that blowing up BUddhist statues is not violent. Last time I looked, destruction of property was considered violent.

That fight isn't worth having, given the countless direct murders and mutilations the Taliban committed.
 
I don't think they will be anything different than that either. But I don't believe that they be arbitrarily violent to say Foreigners leaving or to everyone that opposed them. I also don't know if we can assume that the Taliban leadership of 2021 is going to be exactly like it was in 2001.

I'm just not willing to predict the future. But the reality is the Taliban was going rule the moment we left whether that be under Trump or Biden.

I do think you're right that they will not be 'arbitrarily or capriciously' violent: it will have a reason for them although it will often seem unjust according to our views. For example, beating a woman because she's not covered to their standards, executing those whom they view as collaborators, stoning women who committed/are suspected of adultery, etc.

Blowing up the Buddhist statues isn't what I would call 'violent' any more than demolishing an old building is violent. It was done on the orders of the Taliban leader because they were 'idols' which is against Islam. It wasn't like blowing up a church or government building with people in or nearby in order to hurt people.
 
Yes, but let's not have any illusions about what we have done in letting Taliban take control.
And once again, I have to at your statement that blowing up BUddhist statues is not violent. Last time I looked, destruction of property was considered violent.

You mean like taking down statues of Robert E. Lee?

If i destroy my own property, does that constitute violence?
 
I do think you're right that they will not be 'arbitrarily or capriciously' violent: it will have a reason for them although it will often seem unjust according to our views. For example, beating a woman because she's not covered to their standards, executing those whom they view as collaborators, stoning women who committed/are suspected of adultery, etc. Blowing up the Buddhist statues isn't what I would call 'violent' any more than demolishing an old building is violent. It was done on the orders of the Taliban leader because they were 'idols' which is against Islam. It wasn't like blowing up a church or government building with people in or nearby in order to hurt people.

I'd just like to point out that they do this in Riyadh.
 
Yes, but let's not have any illusions about what we have done in letting Taliban take control.
And once again, I have to at your statement that blowing up BUddhist statues is not violent. Last time I looked, destruction of property was considered violent.

Exaggeration again, dudalb. Do you consider blowing up a condemned building 'violent'? Destroying the Buddhists statues, as the Taliban saw them, was a planned and controlled act of what they considered were on their own land. Remember that the Taliban controlled that area at the time. In fact, the Taliban leader, Mullah Omar, had ordered the statues not be destroyed and even took step to keep them from being further damaged. However, this changed later and it's been speculated that this was due to Bin Laden's influence.

I did not want to destroy the Bamiyan Buddha. In fact, some foreigners came to me and said they would like to conduct the repair work of the Bamiyan Buddha that had been slightly damaged due to rains. This shocked me. I thought, these callous people have no regard for thousands of living human beings—the Afghans who are dying of hunger, but they are so concerned about non-living objects like the Buddha. This was extremely deplorable. That is why I ordered its destruction. Had they come for humanitarian work, I would have never ordered the Buddha's destruction.

Omar also changed his view that the statues were not idols because they were not being worshipped since Afghanistan had no Buddhists. Again, under speculation that this change was due to Bin Laden's influence, he said
"Muslims should be proud of smashing idols. It has given praise to Allah that we have destroyed them."

They were, sadly, destroyed, but to call it 'violence' is exaggeration.
 
I'm not an apologist for the Taliban. I'm just not going to be a Debbie Downer about an unknown future.

. I think it's awful they blew up those ancient sculptures. But c'mon, that's not violence.
It is " cultural violence" and much in line with other numerous examples of fundamentalist Islamic groups such as ISIS.
 
I'd just like to point out that they do this in Riyadh.

Absolutely. The treatment of women, especially in rural areas, in Saudi Arabia can be harsh. When my sister worked in Riyadh back in the 1980's, she said she saw women hit by the bands of roving "morals police". However, these roving bands have been pretty much stripped of their power as S. A. moves to a more moderate view. For example, they now allow women to drive which gives them much more freedom.
 
You mean like taking down statues of Robert E. Lee?



If i destroy my own property, does that constitute violence?
Some statues are placed to reinforce racial/cultural superiority.

Some statues are destroyed to reinforce racial/cultural superiority.

Superficial similarities don't tell the whole story.
 
Exaggeration again, dudalb. Do you consider blowing up a condemned building 'violent'? Destroying the Buddhists statues, as the Taliban saw them, was a planned and controlled act of what they considered were on their own land. Remember that the Taliban controlled that area at the time. In fact, the Taliban leader, Mullah Omar, had ordered the statues not be destroyed and even took step to keep them from being further damaged. However, this changed later and it's been speculated that this was due to Bin Laden's influence.



Omar also changed his view that the statues were not idols because they were not being worshipped since Afghanistan had no Buddhists. Again, under speculation that this change was due to Bin Laden's influence, he said


They were, sadly, destroyed, but to call it 'violence' is exaggeration.

What semantic BS.
 
I give up. SOme people here are intent on putting a good face on the Taliban because somehow they think it will help BIden. That's the bottom line.
The insitence at the destruction of the Buddhist statues was not an act of violence was the straw that broke the camel's back. You can's reason with somebody who buys something are silly as that. It's a stupid semantic game, frankly.
Np defination of Violence I have seen restricts the definition to acts against other people.
 
Last edited:
I give up. SOme people here are intent on putting a good face on the Taliban because somehow they think it will help BIden. That's the bottom line.
The insitence at the destruction of the Buddhist statues was not an act of violence was the straw that broke the camel's back. You can's reason with somebody who buys something are silly as that. It's a stupid semantic game, frankly.
Np defination of Violence I have seen restricts the definition to acts against other people.

BOLLOCKS.

Do you think the US was succeeding in Afghanistan before we decided to withdraw 16 months ago?

What I'm not willing to do is assume this could have turned out differently just because the Neocons said so.
 
It is " cultural violence" and much in line with other numerous examples of fundamentalist Islamic groups such as ISIS.

I'm not sure I agree that this is even cultural violence which is defined as:

`Cultural violence' is defined here as any aspect of a culture that can be used to legitimize violence in its direct or structural form.'

For example, it was OK to kidnap people from Africa and enslave them because they were inferior to white people, subhuman, and non-Christian. Another example is 'honor killings' where killing a girl/woman who has 'dishonored' the family is culturally acceptable.

I suppose there is room for debate about this but dudalb was not using 'violence' in that respect anyway.
 
What semantic BS.

And there you go again. It's not semantics, dudalb: it's using words that accurately describe something.

Is blowing up a building that is not committed as an illegal/terroristic act 'violent'?
Your penchant for exaggeration in order to support your view is noted yet again.

And would you care to refute anything I said that was not factual with evidence?
 
Last edited:
And there you go again. It's not semantics, dudalb: it's using words that accurately describe something.

Is blowing up a building that is not committed as an illegal/terroristic act 'violent'?
Your penchant for exaggeration in order to support your view is noted yet again.

And would you care to refute anything I said that was not factual with evidence?

I remember how awful it was when they blew up the Kingdome. Those awful Seattleites actually gathered round and watched and cheered when it came down.
 

BOLLOCKS.

Do you think the US was succeeding in Afghanistan before we decided to withdraw 16 months ago?

What I'm not willing to do is assume this could have turned out differently just because the Neocons said so.

I thought we should have gotten out of Afghanistan a long time ago, but I was never under the illusion about what would happen once we pulled out.
I also note your tirade has nothing to do with my statement.
You are now just writing political platitudes regardless of the topic.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom