Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
The point is that Islamic scholars often come to various different conclusions about what is and is not permitted. You can find a quote from Omar that the statues should be preserved and also that they should be destroyed.

I know: I'm the one who first presented both those quotes.

The same goes for Islamic interpretations of staying indoors or going out to get educated.

You said: "They are extreme Islamic fundamentalists, and they claim that what is against the Koran or against the Hadiths are haram and must be punished."

Did I disagree that the fundamentalists would claim that? No. I just pointed out that some of those things are not in the Koran or in hadiths as many moderate Muslims point out. People tend to interpret things according to already existing biases. We see it here in this very thread with some making unfounded accusations because of how they erroneously interpret what someone said.

The Taliban will see their actions as consistent with Islam not just with Pashtunwali. And it is a red herring to say that some codes of conduct predate Islam.

I didn't say they would but you cannot deny Pashtunwali directly affects how they interpret things as it is a very fundamental part of their culture and has been for over a thousand years.

No, it is not a red herring at all: it directly affected/affects the reason why some traditions/rules of Islam are different in different places. You want to separate pre-existing culture from that influence which cannot be done. For example, you can't separate a lot of Christian beliefs/traditions from the pre-existing Jewish culture that influenced them and, in some cases, pre-existing pagan cultures. Many Christian holidays are actually celebrated on what were pagan holidays due to that influence. Christmas is celebrated on what was Sol Invictus.

Islamic fundamentalists often look to what Muhammad did in life and act according to how they perceive what he did as interpreted through writings of his time (the hadiths) and try to live in accordance with them. So if the Taliban say “I think women did not go to school or walk around by themselves uncovered in Muhammad’s time” then they will extrapolate from that about what women should do today. There is little point in any of us saying they got the theology wrong.

Not only Islamic fundamentalists look to what Muhammed did in life. Sunnah, the sayings and practices of Muhammed, is a basis for all Muslims.

But you have still not identified anything I said that was not true. And you are still implying in your last sentence that there is a debate here on whether they 'got the theology wrong'.
 
I know: I'm the one who first presented both those quotes.



You said: "They are extreme Islamic fundamentalists, and they claim that what is against the Koran or against the Hadiths are haram and must be punished."

Did I disagree that the fundamentalists would claim that? No. I just pointed out that some of those things are not in the Koran or in hadiths as many moderate Muslims point out. People tend to interpret things according to already existing biases. We see it here in this very thread with some making unfounded accusations because of how they erroneously interpret what someone said.



I didn't say they would but you cannot deny Pashtunwali directly affects how they interpret things as it is a very fundamental part of their culture and has been for over a thousand years.

No, it is not a red herring at all: it directly affected/affects the reason why some traditions/rules of Islam are different in different places. You want to separate pre-existing culture from that influence which cannot be done. For example, you can't separate a lot of Christian beliefs/traditions from the pre-existing Jewish culture that influenced them and, in some cases, pre-existing pagan cultures. Many Christian holidays are actually celebrated on what were pagan holidays due to that influence. Christmas is celebrated on what was Sol Invictus.



Not only Islamic fundamentalists look to what Muhammed did in life. Sunnah, the sayings and practices of Muhammed, is a basis for all Muslims.

But you have still not identified anything I said that was not true. And you are still implying in your last sentence that there is a debate here on whether they 'got the theology wrong'.

To be honest, at this point it is difficult to even know what you are trying to argue. Yes, sunnah is an important aspect of Islam and becomes even more important with fundamentalists. So while you argued that only Muhammad’s wives had to stay home or veiled, the point for fundamentalists practicing extreme forms of sunnah is that their wives or family members must do the same.

So are we agreed then that the Taliban are following their Wahabbi/Deobandi inspired Islamic fundamentalism and hence we can expect them to continue to act as they have always been known to? What is there to argue about then?
 
To be honest, at this point it is difficult to even know what you are trying to argue. Yes, sunnah is an important aspect of Islam and becomes even more important with fundamentalists. So while you argued that only Muhammad’s wives had to stay home or veiled, the point for fundamentalists practicing extreme forms of sunnah is that their wives or family members must do the same.

So are we agreed then that the Taliban are following their Wahabbi/Deobandi inspired Islamic fundamentalism and hence we can expect them to continue to act as they have always been known to? What is there to argue about then?

"So while you argued that only Muhammad’s wives had to stay home or veiled..."

That's the problem: I'm not arguing anything! I'm merely presenting historical and current facts. You seem to think I'm debating/arguing something.
 
"So while you argued that only Muhammad’s wives had to stay home or veiled..."

That's the problem: I'm not arguing anything! I'm merely presenting historical and current facts. You seem to think I'm debating/arguing something.

Initially this began with you misattributing a dudalb quote to me and accusing me of “goal-post shifting”

It most certainly does matter as the claim was that the TALIBAN destroyed them as an"'arbitrary and capricious act of violence". It was the Taliban leader who wanted to save them initially. Yes, Omar ended up ordering them destroyed under AL QAEDA's suspected influence. This goal shifting is obvious.

You made no acknowledgment that you got that wrong and have since appeared to attempting to school me on the Taliban’s understanding of Islam.

It would probably be better if you just acknowledged that we don’t have a disagreement in that case then we can move on.
 
Initially this began with you misattributing a dudalb quote to me and accusing me of “goal-post shifting”

I didn't misattribute the quote to you. The claim was exactly what I said. I never said you made it. And it was goal shifting from the original claim which I thought we were discussing.

This is my original post:
It most certainly does matter as the claim was that the TALIBAN destroyed them as an"'arbitrary and capricious act of violence". It was the Taliban leader who wanted to save them initially. Yes, Omar ended up ordering them destroyed under AL QAEDA's suspected influence. This goal shifting is obvious.

You made no acknowledgment that you got that wrong and have since appeared to attempting to school me on the Taliban’s understanding of Islam.

It would probably be better if you just acknowledged that we don’t have a disagreement in that case then we can move on.

I didn't acknowledge it because I never misattributed it to you.

Nope. You keep insisting that I'm arguing/debating that with you which I am not. As I've said before, I'm just posting historical and current facts. You seem to be the one who is attempting to school me on what the Taliban's understanding of Islam is. But I agree that we should just move on. I know it's become tedious for me and I suspect it has for you, too.
 
Fox News is staying as classy as usual when it comes to the subject of getting citizens out of Afghanistan.

O’NEILL: “I don’t want to be in charge, but if I was—oh, I want to get the Americans? Cool. Give me nine guys. I’m gonna walk through the streets, and I’m gonna kill everyone I see, and I’m gonna grab the Americans. It is not difficult, but we have these people who are in charge that are a disgrace. I am amazed that there hasn’t been at least 30 generals and admirals that haven’t resigned or been fired today. But we won’t because we have a commander in chief that was put there through whatever happened at 4 in the morning on election night.”

Just another bit in their constant evil peddling.
 
Last edited:
Fox News is staying as classy as usual when it comes to the subject of getting citizens out of Afghanistan.

Quote:
O’NEILL: “I don’t want to be in charge, but if I was—oh, I want to get the Americans? Cool. Give me nine guys. I’m gonna walk through the streets, and I’m gonna kill everyone I see, and I’m gonna grab the Americans. It is not difficult, but we have these people who are in charge that are a disgrace. I am amazed that there hasn’t been at least 30 generals and admirals that haven’t resigned or been fired today. But we won’t because we have a commander in chief that was put there through whatever happened at 4 in the morning on election night.”

Just another bit in their constant evil peddling.

But, but, but....FOX is where you go for REAL news, not that fake stuff like all the other channels have.

This guy was banned from Delta Airlines:

On Tuesday, O'Neill posted a photo of himself to Twitter aboard a Delta flight without a protective face mask, despite the fact that the United States is still in the middle of a major novel coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic.

The photo was accompanied with a simple message: “I'm not a p****.”

Oh, yes, Rob....you are.

The tweet was later deleted and good ol' Robbie claimed his wife deleted it. Then, when he got called out, he claimed it was all 'a joke'. Sound familiar?

Later Neil said:

“If someone felt uncomfortable, I’ll put the mask on,” O’Neill told Fox Business on Friday. “I don’t have a problem with that. I do have a problem being ordered to do it. I don’t think I violated the policy. I’d love to talk to the CEO, Mr. Bastian, about it. I’d like to help them because their image right now isn’t very good and I have a million miles on Delta.”

So, an ex-Navy Seal has problems with obeying an order he doesn't like? I'm sure his superior officers in the Navy were cool with that.

I'm not anti-mask, just pro humor."

Really? Kinda like Trump wasn't and isn't anti-mask, right? Is that why you tweeted these earlier?


Robert J. O'Neill
@mchooyah
·
Aug 16, 2020
You know that **** you’re wearing on your face is novelty, right?

and

Robert J. O'Neill
@mchooyah
“Mask” is easier to say than “Placebo”.

And then there's this one:

Robert J. O'Neill
@mchooyah
·
Jul 30, 2020
They can’t make you wear masks. They can’t make you take your temperature. They can’t make you quarantine. Wise up.

But you were just 'joking', amirite?

Now that we've established O'Neill is a liar, it seems his fellow SEALS on the bin Laden raid disagree with him about who killed the al Qaeda leader. Even his own father give a different story than his son as to why he went into the Navy in the first place.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/ar...d-three-bullets-terror-mastermind-s-head.html

So, yeah, Rob...you are a p****.
 
But, but, but....FOX is where you go for REAL news, not that fake stuff like all the other channels have.

This guy was banned from Delta Airlines:



Oh, yes, Rob....you are.

The tweet was later deleted and good ol' Robbie claimed his wife deleted it. Then, when he got called out, he claimed it was all 'a joke'. Sound familiar?

Later Neil said:



So, an ex-Navy Seal has problems with obeying an order he doesn't like? I'm sure his superior officers in the Navy were cool with that.



Really? Kinda like Trump wasn't and isn't anti-mask, right? Is that why you tweeted these earlier?




and



And then there's this one:



But you were just 'joking', amirite?

Now that we've established O'Neill is a liar, it seems his fellow SEALS on the bin Laden raid disagree with him about who killed the al Qaeda leader. Even his own father give a different story than his son as to why he went into the Navy in the first place.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/ar...d-three-bullets-terror-mastermind-s-head.html

So, yeah, Rob...you are a p****.

O Neill's getting roasted by his fellow Seals for his stupid rant.
He seems tohave forgotten everything he learned about as a Navy seal about basic tactic.
The guy has long been regarded as a braggert and a blowhard.
 
Meanwhile, a domestic-issue action of Biden's which Afghanistan is drowning out: he recently eliminated student loan debt for a certain category of debt-holders, for the third time... all while lying about not being sure he can do what he's done three times now and apparently promised during the campaign that he would do for all of us, not just three slim categories of us (although he also said he wouldn't, during the same campaign).

To me, this is obviously the behavior of somebody who just doesn't want to do the big-picture version of it. If he did, what would be the point of dilly-dallying around about it like this? To do it closer to election time so it's fresher in voters' minds when they vote?
 
Meanwhile, a domestic-issue action of Biden's which Afghanistan is drowning out: he recently eliminated student loan debt for a certain category of debt-holders, for the third time... all while lying about not being sure he can do what he's done three times now and apparently promised during the campaign that he would do for all of us, not just three slim categories of us (although he also said he wouldn't, during the same campaign).

To me, this is obviously the behavior of somebody who just doesn't want to do the big-picture version of it. If he did, what would be the point of dilly-dallying around about it like this? To do it closer to election time so it's fresher in voters' minds when they vote?

Still mad that Bernie did not win the Primary?
 
Fascists are rioting in Portland, including an attempted murder attempt and mutual gunfire in the streets resulting in a right winger being arrested.

Wonder if Biden's DOJ will prosecute this lawless rioting with the same zeal the feds protected the sacred fence during the BLM riots.

PPB is obviously not interested in policing right wing violence, but it would be trivially easy to make federal cases out of these as many of the leaders and participants are engaged in multi-state coordination.
 
For all the pundits rending their garments about Afghanistan, it's important to keep in perspective that hte public has long since stopped giving a **** about this failed campaign.

in NBC poll Afgh is literally nowhere on the list of concerns: Economy/Jobs (26%), Immig (10), covid (7), corruption +healthcare (5)... not even 1 %??

https://twitter.com/JRubinBlogger/status/1429459553276542976

The Natsec ghouls might be crying their eyes out, but nobody should care what these morons think. This kind of punditry has decades of a failed track record, Biden is wise to ignore their whining.
 
Fascists are rioting in Portland, including an attempted murder attempt and mutual gunfire in the streets resulting in a right winger being arrested.

Wonder if Biden's DOJ will prosecute this lawless rioting with the same zeal the feds protected the sacred fence during the BLM riots.

PPB is obviously not interested in policing right wing violence, but it would be trivially easy to make federal cases out of these as many of the leaders and participants are engaged in multi-state coordination.

According to OPB:
Anti-fascists and far left demonstrators gathered downtown early in the day to oppose the far right gathering. The two sides eventually clashed in Northeast Portland after remaining separate for hours, leaving a spree of violence that stretched blocks.

After the violence ended in Northeast Portland, an unidentified man fired a handgun at what appeared to be a group of anti-fascists downtown. Portland police moved in and arrested the man.

Throughout the day, members of each side exchanged words and debated each other, but no notable violence had taken place for the first few hours of the gatherings. That changed just after 4 p.m., as the Proud Boys and anti-fascists ran along 122nd Avenue, exchanging paint balls and bear mace. Some people in the crowd threw mortar fireworks near a Chevron gas station, which had to close.

Members of the antifascist crowd shouted at local journalists who were following the melee. They then sprayed chemicals and paint at the journalists, and one local freelance photographer was attacked and injured.
Portland police did not show up as the two sides clashed.

Witnesses said the violence began when a white van attempted to pull into the parking lot where the “Summer of Love” event was taking place. Members of the Proud Boys later flipped the van over.

“This van right here that’s on its side tried pulling into the parking lot, and all these Proud Boys gate security started hitting it with bats and busting the windows out,” one witness, who did not want to be identified, told OPB.

The witness said people got out of the van and started to run away as Proud Boys attacked them.

“I saw this dude beating a woman. There was like two ladies that got hit. It was a nightmare, it was ******* terrifying,” they said.

The witness said they have lived in Portland for 15 years, and had been practicing driving in a nearby lot with another person. They decried the lack of police intervention in the violence that unfolded.

During the clashes, Proud Boys were also captured on video attacking people and vehicles they believed to be with the anti-fascists. After the groups disengaged from each other, Toese and other Proud Boys continued to drive around the Parkrose neighborhood shooting paintballs at people.

This is the way FOX described it:

Antifa members throw explosives, disperse chemical spray in violent Portland riots

There were several descriptions of "Antifa" violence but virtually nothing about the right-wing violence. No mention of the gunfire directed at the left-wing protesters by the right-wing protesters.
 
"It's Only wrong when Liberals/progressives/Democrats/Antifa does it."

To quibble, that seems a bit off. That implies that the viewers are actually informed of the "wrongdoings" of all sides and are applying double standards. If the side that consistently acts in a dramatically worse way is consistently represented positively and no mention of their wrongdoings is made, while the "wrongdoings" of those who oppose them are regularly magnified and they're vilified consistently, that dodges that by virtue of controlled information to work with.

Either way, looks like Fox has also tried to pin blame for Afghanistan on Jill Biden, among others.

"Of course the media and many people are saying - you had some people on your show this week who were saying it was Susan Rice and Obama and maybe Valerie Jarrett. I'm sorry, as a political spouse, I can't help but look at Jill Biden, No one knew better his state of mind than Dr. Jill Biden. And if you ask me, the most patriotic thing Jill Biden could have done was tell her husband - to love her husband and not let him run in this mental state that he's in. I think she failed the country as well."
 
Last edited:
For all the pundits rending their garments about Afghanistan, it's important to keep in perspective that hte public has long since stopped giving a **** about this failed campaign.

Americans are apparently so poor that they are not just broke but also broken and can't even afford to pay attention.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom