Stacyhs
Penultimate Amazing
The point is that Islamic scholars often come to various different conclusions about what is and is not permitted. You can find a quote from Omar that the statues should be preserved and also that they should be destroyed.
I know: I'm the one who first presented both those quotes.
The same goes for Islamic interpretations of staying indoors or going out to get educated.
You said: "They are extreme Islamic fundamentalists, and they claim that what is against the Koran or against the Hadiths are haram and must be punished."
Did I disagree that the fundamentalists would claim that? No. I just pointed out that some of those things are not in the Koran or in hadiths as many moderate Muslims point out. People tend to interpret things according to already existing biases. We see it here in this very thread with some making unfounded accusations because of how they erroneously interpret what someone said.
The Taliban will see their actions as consistent with Islam not just with Pashtunwali. And it is a red herring to say that some codes of conduct predate Islam.
I didn't say they would but you cannot deny Pashtunwali directly affects how they interpret things as it is a very fundamental part of their culture and has been for over a thousand years.
No, it is not a red herring at all: it directly affected/affects the reason why some traditions/rules of Islam are different in different places. You want to separate pre-existing culture from that influence which cannot be done. For example, you can't separate a lot of Christian beliefs/traditions from the pre-existing Jewish culture that influenced them and, in some cases, pre-existing pagan cultures. Many Christian holidays are actually celebrated on what were pagan holidays due to that influence. Christmas is celebrated on what was Sol Invictus.
Islamic fundamentalists often look to what Muhammad did in life and act according to how they perceive what he did as interpreted through writings of his time (the hadiths) and try to live in accordance with them. So if the Taliban say “I think women did not go to school or walk around by themselves uncovered in Muhammad’s time” then they will extrapolate from that about what women should do today. There is little point in any of us saying they got the theology wrong.
Not only Islamic fundamentalists look to what Muhammed did in life. Sunnah, the sayings and practices of Muhammed, is a basis for all Muslims.
But you have still not identified anything I said that was not true. And you are still implying in your last sentence that there is a debate here on whether they 'got the theology wrong'.