Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'd bet $100 that 75% of Americans think a Kurd is something that Miss Muffet was eating while she sat on her tuffet.
Surely ignorant opinions of people who care nothing for the plight of others not like themselves should be the basis of our ethical reasoning.
 
They you would be part of a tiny minority in the USA.

I suppose that I'd also be part of that "tiny minority," then. I will freely admit that it is not a major issue when it comes to who I choose to vote for, but that betrayal was and is hard to stomach.
 
It most certainly does matter as the claim was that the TALIBAN destroyed them as an"'arbitrary and capricious act of violence". It was the Taliban leader who wanted to save them initially. Yes, Omar ended up ordering them destroyed under AL QAEDA's suspected influence. This goal shifting is obvious.

The quote is not from me, so claiming there is some goal shifting is false. I am claiming they blew them up because they were haram.
 
The US Administration's haste in leaving Afghanistan before ensuring the safety of all those Afghanis who aided them and were promised security in exchange maddens me. It's very much a case where none shall be left behind. Abandonment of any of these people is tantamount to leaving US troops behind, in my books.

The treacherous betrayal of the Kurds will never be forgotten by me, either.
Allies in war are as worthy as one's own citizens.

They you would be part of a tiny minority in the USA.

I'd bet $100 that 75% of Americans think a Kurd is something that Miss Muffet was eating while she sat on her tuffet.

Surely ignorant opinions of people who care nothing for the plight of others not like themselves should be the basis of our ethical reasoning.

Has anyone said, or even implied, that it should be?
 
Has anyone said, or even implied, that it should be?
Then why even make such an argumentum ad populum at all?

Very well. Your non sequitur will be given the credence it deserves.

Our behavior on the world stage is quite nakedly apparent to all. Our domestic attitude of nonchalance about it, if anything, just makes it that much more shameful.
 
Some of these attempts to put a gloss on the Taliban are pretty fatuous. No, I’m not going to accuse anyone of being apologists for them, but don’t get in the game of trying to minimize what they are. They are extreme Islamic fundamentalists, and they claim that what is against the Koran or against the Hadiths are haram and must be punished. That is of course why they blew up the statues at Bamiyan and why they stone women for adultery in front of crowds and cut off the hands of thieves or lash them in the square and parcel off women to the Taliban fighters in forced marriages, ban education for girls and women, close schools, ban publications, prevent women from most forms of employment and don’t allow women to leave the house uncovered and without a male chaperone.
>snip<

The worship of idols is haram, not their actual existence if no one is worshipping them. Which is what Mullah Omar first declared when he forbade the statues' destruction. I remember seeing the beautiful Byzantine mosaics of Mary and Jesus in the Hagia Sophia in Istanbul that were discovered under the plaster on the walls. These were allowed to remain uncovered because it was no longer a church or a mosque but a museum.

The education of women is not forbidden in the Koran or in the hadiths. Nor do the Koran or hadiths require women to wear any form of veiling or forbid them to leave the house without a male chaperone. Those restrictions were for the wives of Muhammed only. That is why the majority of Muslim women do not wear a veil, a burka, or even an abaya. Most wear a simple head scarf or hijab, if anything, and are free to go out without a male chaperone. Veiling and restrictions on women's freedom were already a cultural aspect of several pre-Islamic cultures, such as in Saudi Arabia, Christian Byzantium, and among India's Moguls. These customs were kept after converting to Islam. Pashtunwali, the strict code of the majority Pushtuns in Afghanistan, is also pre-Islamic.
 
Then why even make such an argumentum ad populum at all?

I didn't. I was making the point that most Americans are ignorant of the Kurds and their situation. You are the one assigning a fallacious meaning to it.

Very well. Your non sequitur will be given the credence it deserves.

My post was not a non sequitur. It was directly related to the topic: remembering Trump's abandonment of the Kurds. Now, your accusation that my post was an argumentum ad populum? That is a non sequitur.

Our behavior on the world stage is quite nakedly apparent to all. Our domestic attitude of nonchalance about it, if anything, just makes it that much more shameful.

Further proof that you missed my point as it had nothing to do with being 'nonchalant' about the situation. In fact, it was a negative commentary on the ignorance of most Americans about what happened to the Kurds.
 
Some of these attempts to put a gloss on the Taliban are pretty fatuous. No, I’m not going to accuse anyone of being apologists for them, but don’t get in the game of trying to minimize what they are. They are extreme Islamic fundamentalists,
And they have been able to propagate their extreme beliefs under the guise of defending against foreign invaders - us. We gave them the excuse they needed.

destroy statues (Lol! They mean the confederate statues - because we know that is exactly the same thing, right!)... and then we have a list of ways in which the person saying it wants the point to be taken seriously.
Which it should be. Confederate statues were works of art of great cultural significance to many. Yet we deemed them inappropriate and therefore legitimate targets for destruction. It is hypercritical to not allow other cultures to do the same. In the case of the Buddha statues, the Taliban's stated reason for removing them was:-
I did not want to destroy the Bamiyan Buddha. In fact, some foreigners came to me and said they would like to conduct the repair work of the Bamiyan Buddha that had been slightly damaged due to rains. This shocked me. I thought, these callous people have no regard for thousands of living human beings—the Afghans who are dying of hunger, but they are so concerned about non-living objects like the Buddha. This was extremely deplorable. That is why I ordered its destruction. Had they come for humanitarian work, I would have never ordered the Buddha's destruction.
And sure enough, westerners who didn't give a **** about the plight of Afghans wrung their hands about the state of a bit of old rock.

the more I think about this the more I think it was a massive error to pull out from Afghanistan at all.
It was a massive mistake to go into Afghanistan at all. Everything we did since then has built on that error, and what we see today is just the inevitable conclusion.

I can’t help thinking it is a big waste.
A big waste for sure, but anything we did there was bound to be. The only way to avoid it would be to have not been there.
 
Last edited:
And they have been able to propagate their extreme beliefs under the guise of defending against foreign invaders - us. We gave them the excuse they needed.

Which it should be. Confederate statues were works of art of great cultural significance to many. Yet we deemed them inappropriate and therefore legitimate targets for destruction. It is hypercritical to not allow other cultures to do the same. In the case of the Buddha statues, the Taliban's stated reason for removing them was:-
And sure enough, westerners who didn't give a **** about the plight of Afghans wrung their hands about the state of a bit of old rock.

It was a massive mistake to go into Afghanistan at all. Everything we did since then has built on that error, and what we see today is just the inevitable conclusion.

A big waste for sure, but anything we did there was bound to be. The only way to avoid it would be to have not been there.

Confederate statues were constructed and placed where they were specifically as a form of intimidation and not all that terribly long ago. But we've been over that issue repeatedly in other threads.

Bamiyan Buddha statues were carved into the cliff face at a religious site Buddhism had long-since already spread to along the Silk Road. That occurred much more organically over centuries.

Omar also said:

"The government considers the Bamiyan statues as an example of a potential major source of income for Afghanistan from international visitors. The Taliban states that Bamiyan shall not be destroyed but protected."

And also:

"Muslims should be proud of smashing idols. It has given praise to Allah that we have destroyed them."

Those quotes are from the same link you used and right nearby, so nice quote mining.

I like the bit about "slightly damaged due to rains" but not mentioning the multiple prior attempts at their destruction by artillery and cannon fire.

Also numerous overtures to purchase or pay for access to them were made, from which starving children they made such a show of wringing their hands over could have been provided for, but all were spurned. Pardon me for being dubious that they were "thinking of the children."

Congratulations, you've endorsed and propagated two different kinds of blatant lying to excuse away cultural aggression in one go.
 
Was it though? My understanding is that there had been improvements in terms of infrastructure, schools, healthcare and a number of other things, whereas when the Taliban were last in charge there was almost no electricity and almost nothing there worked.


When they were last in charge they were working with what the Russians had left them.

All it took to fix that was twenty years and couple trillion dollars of somebody else's money.

Remember the initial premise of The Mouse That Roared?
 
Last edited:
Biden pulls out: Trumpsters blame him for humanity stuff, deny visas to interpreters.
If Trump had been president: "We don't care, they are foreigners. But get the Americans out. At least if they are not Muslim."
 
The worship of idols is haram, not their actual existence if no one is worshipping them. Which is what Mullah Omar first declared when he forbade the statues' destruction. I remember seeing the beautiful Byzantine mosaics of Mary and Jesus in the Hagia Sophia in Istanbul that were discovered under the plaster on the walls. These were allowed to remain uncovered because it was no longer a church or a mosque but a museum.

The education of women is not forbidden in the Koran or in the hadiths. Nor do the Koran or hadiths require women to wear any form of veiling or forbid them to leave the house without a male chaperone. Those restrictions were for the wives of Muhammed only. That is why the majority of Muslim women do not wear a veil, a burka, or even an abaya. Most wear a simple head scarf or hijab, if anything, and are free to go out without a male chaperone. Veiling and restrictions on women's freedom were already a cultural aspect of several pre-Islamic cultures, such as in Saudi Arabia, Christian Byzantium, and among India's Moguls. These customs were kept after converting to Islam. Pashtunwali, the strict code of the majority Pushtuns in Afghanistan, is also pre-Islamic.

Nope. I think you don't get it. There is no point debating Islam with a fundamentalist. When you try to argue that you know best what Islam says, you are going to lose.

the Taliban's stated reason for removing them was:-
And sure enough, westerners who didn't give a **** about the plight of Afghans wrung their hands about the state of a bit of old rock.

That's one of their many passive aggressive excuses.

Indeed. We don't have to care about the statues as much as we should care about the people living there now. However, if there is something that many isolationists have in common with the Taliban it's that they don't give a ****.
 
Biden pulls out: Trumpsters blame him for humanity stuff, deny visas to interpreters.
If Trump had been president: "We don't care, they are foreigners. But get the Americans out. At least if they are not Muslim."
Not quite whataboutism, but sort of a whatifism.

While I'm among the first to say that words do matter, especially from leaders, it was quite apparent to me that Biden used direct phrasing and firm, almost staccato cadence for assurances we'll get Americans out and softer, casual platitudes about doing our best and trying real hard for our Afghan allies.

The asylum process is written in statutory law. That law has not changed nor does it appear it will. It has barred many of them already over the years.

So we'll continue to hear "they can apply for.../make request to..." statements that carefully avoid making a real commitment.

And while words matter, appeasing hollow promises (lies) aren't that much better. Same result for those who will suffer, but we can pat ourselves on the back for delivering the same callous policy in real terms.
 
Biden pulls out: Trumpsters blame him for humanity stuff, deny visas to interpreters.
If Trump had been president: "We don't care, they are foreigners. But get the Americans out. At least if they are not Muslim."

Odd as it might sound, Trump may not be the most relevant person to focus on there. Stephen Miller probably is. With Stephen Miller leading the way, our Afghan allies were pretty well betrayed at the visa level. The Trump Administration had years to prepare for a withdrawal that they tried to plan, all while also working to screw over those who were helping to keep Americans alive and well in Afghanistan.

Looks like Biden's Administration may just now be ramping up working to correct that situation somewhat, but that's cold comfort when it comes to the situation at hand. I want to criticize them for taking so long, but... then I remember how bad the sabotage and backlog in general was after Trump's Administration.
 
Last edited:
Biden pulls out: Trumpsters blame him for humanity stuff, deny visas to interpreters.
If Trump had been president: "We don't care, they are foreigners. But get the Americans out. At least if they are not Muslim."

Not only did the Trump admin not try to get out the Afghani people who assisted us, they actively blocked their removal.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tc35eiFjk98
 
Odd as it might sound, Trump may not be the most relevant person to focus on there. Stephen Miller probably is. With Stephen Miller leading the way, our Afghan allies were pretty well betrayed at the visa level. The Trump Administration had years to prepare for a withdrawal that they tried to plan, all while also working to screw over those who were helping to keep Americans alive and well in Afghanistan.

Looks like Biden's Administration may just now be ramping up working to correct that situation somewhat, but that's cold comfort when it comes to the situation at hand. I want to criticize them for taking so long, but... then I remember how bad the sabotage and backlog in general was after Trump's Administration.

Shocked to hear that Trump wasn’t involved in the details but then again presidents are still responsible for things that happen on their watch as the buck stops with them. The same will be true of Biden of course is the chaos turns to widespread bloodshed.
 
Originally Posted by Stacyhs View Post
The worship of idols is haram, not their actual existence if no one is worshipping them. Which is what Mullah Omar first declared when he forbade the statues' destruction. I remember seeing the beautiful Byzantine mosaics of Mary and Jesus in the Hagia Sophia in Istanbul that were discovered under the plaster on the walls. These were allowed to remain uncovered because it was no longer a church or a mosque but a museum.

The education of women is not forbidden in the Koran or in the hadiths. Nor do the Koran or hadiths require women to wear any form of veiling or forbid them to leave the house without a male chaperone. Those restrictions were for the wives of Muhammed only. That is why the majority of Muslim women do not wear a veil, a burka, or even an abaya. Most wear a simple head scarf or hijab, if anything, and are free to go out without a male chaperone. Veiling and restrictions on women's freedom were already a cultural aspect of several pre-Islamic cultures, such as in Saudi Arabia, Christian Byzantium, and among India's Moguls. These customs were kept after converting to Islam. Pashtunwali, the strict code of the majority Pushtuns in Afghanistan, is also pre-Islamic
.

Nope. I think you don't get it. There is no point debating Islam with a fundamentalist. When you try to argue that you know best what Islam says, you are going to lose.

"Nope" what? Is there anything I wrote that is not true?

Did I deny that fundamentalist interpret many things differently than more moderate Muslims? Nope.

You're right about one thing: I don't get what your 'debating Islam with a fundamentalist' comes from as I wasn't debating Islam at all. I was stating historical and current facts. Can you identify anything that I wrote that is not true?
 
.



"Nope" what? Is there anything I wrote that is not true?

Did I deny that fundamentalist interpret many things differently than more moderate Muslims? Nope.

You're right about one thing: I don't get what your 'debating Islam with a fundamentalist' comes from as I wasn't debating Islam at all. I was stating historical and current facts. Can you identify anything that I wrote that is not true?

The point is that Islamic scholars often come to various different conclusions about what is and is not permitted. You can find a quote from Omar that the statues should be preserved and also that they should be destroyed.

The same goes for Islamic interpretations of staying indoors or going out to get educated. The Taliban will see their actions as consistent with Islam not just with Pashtunwali. And it is a red herring to say that some codes of conduct predate Islam. Islamic fundamentalists often look to what Muhammad did in life and act according to how they perceive what he did as interpreted through writings of his time (the hadiths) and try to live in accordance with them. So if the Taliban say “I think women did not go to school or walk around by themselves uncovered in Muhammad’s time” then they will extrapolate from that about what women should do today. There is little point in any of us saying they got the theology wrong.
 
Odd as it might sound, Trump may not be the most relevant person to focus on there. Stephen Miller probably is. With Stephen Miller leading the way, our Afghan allies were pretty well betrayed at the visa level. The Trump Administration had years to prepare for a withdrawal that they tried to plan, all while also working to screw over those who were helping to keep Americans alive and well in Afghanistan.

Looks like Biden's Administration may just now be ramping up working to correct that situation somewhat, but that's cold comfort when it comes to the situation at hand. I want to criticize them for taking so long, but... then I remember how bad the sabotage and backlog in general was after Trump's Administration.

Stephen Miller is just evil. He is well known for being a racist and a bigot. That a Trump would have him as part of his administration, much less a senior advisor on policy, is telling.

As Olivia Troye said:

"There were cabinet mtgs about this during the Trump Admin where Stephen Miller would peddle his racist hysteria about Iraq & Afghanistan. He & his enablers across gov't would undermine anyone who worked on solving the SIV issue by devastating the system at DHS & State," Troye wrote.


I tracked this issue personally in my role during my WH tenure. Pence was fully aware of the problem. We got nowhere on it because Trump/S. Miller had watchdogs in place at DOJ, DHS, State & security agencies that made an already cumbersome SIV process even more challenging.(2/7)

I met w/ numerous external organizations during my White House tenure who advocated for refugees & pleaded for help in getting US allies through the process. I got the phone calls & letters as the homeland security & CT advisor to Pence…(3/7)

The fear of people across the Trump Admin to counter these enablers was palpable. There were numerous behind closed door meetings held-strategizing how to navigate this issue. The Trump Admin had FOUR years…(5/7)

..Trump had FOUR years-while putting this plan in place-to evacuate these Afghan allies who were the lifelines for many of us who spent time in Afghanistan. They’d been waiting a long time. The process slowed to a trickle for reviews/other “priorities”-then came to a halt.(6/7)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom