Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
I remember how awful it was when they blew up the Kingdome. Those awful Seattleites actually gathered round and watched and cheered when it came down.

God, if you don'/t see the difference between the Kingdome and the Buddhist statues, you are really hopeless.
I guess destroying thousand of years old cultural landmarks is no big thing in your book.
 
I give up. SOme people here are intent on putting a good face on the Taliban because somehow they think it will help BIden. That's the bottom line.

Yet more hyperbole not based on the facts.

The insitence at the destruction of the Buddhist statues was not an act of violence was the straw that broke the camel's back. You can's reason with somebody who buys something are silly as that. It's a stupid semantic game, frankly.
Np defination of Violence I have seen restricts the definition to acts against other people.

Then please explain to me how it was any more 'violent' than bringing down a condemned building.

I detest the Taliban and everything it stands for. I don't trust them at all. You're accusation that I'm 'putting a good face on the Taliban' is ludicrous and offensive.

If you can't see that habitually using exaggeration/hyperbole that inaccurately describes a situation is a very bad habit that lowers your credibility, then you are the one who isn't using reason.
 
If you don't see the difference between bringing down a thousands year olf cultural monument and blowing up a 60 year old building you are really really ignorant.
I guess blowing up Notre Dame in Paris would be ok in your book...
 
Biden is making the kind of speech he should have made a couple of days ago. He is putting heavy emphises about the US keeping it's promise to the Afghansh whe helped us. it's the first really effective damage control he had done.
But is till cannot buy into the No serious mistakes were made and Biden should not be criticised attitude I am seeing here. And "Whataboutism" and "Deflection" is no better coming from the left then the right.

I’m simply wondering how you get from almost all posters here saying it’s been a **** show to “Biden should not be criticized.”

I’m a far left ( for the US) person. I agree that Biden ****** up. I also can hold an opinion that others ****** up too.

Not everything is one or the other.
Also, still waiting for the civil war you predicted five years ago.
 
God, if you don'/t see the difference between the Kingdome and the Buddhist statues, you are really hopeless.
I guess destroying thousand of years old cultural landmarks is no big thing in your book.

Yet another example of gross misrepresentation. AC was being sarcastic with his reference to the Kingdome. He has never said, or implied, that he thought the destruction of the statues was 'no big thing'. The issue was whether or not it was an example of Taliban 'violence'.
 
The US Administration's haste in leaving Afghanistan before ensuring the safety of all those Afghanis who aided them and were promised security in exchange maddens me. It's very much a case where none shall be left behind. Abandonment of any of these people is tantamount to leaving US troops behind, in my books.

The treacherous betrayal of the Kurds will never be forgotten by me, either.
Allies in war are as worthy as one's own citizens.
They you would be part of a tiny minority in the USA.
 
If you don't see the difference between bringing down a thousands year olf cultural monument and blowing up a 60 year old building you are really really ignorant.

You just can't stop, can you? The issue was if it was VIOLENT, not whether it was a good thing or not.

I guess blowing up Notre Dame in Paris would be ok in your book...

No, as a matter of fact I was devastated when Notre Dame was nearly destroyed by fire a few years ago. Do you have any other offensive and false accusations to make now?
 
I’m simply wondering how you get from almost all posters here saying it’s been a **** show to “Biden should not be criticized.”

I’m a far left ( for the US) person. I agree that Biden ****** up. I also can hold an opinion that others ****** up too.

Not everything is one or the other.
Also, still waiting for the civil war you predicted five years ago.

:thumbsup:

Well, the revolution is coming according to the guy they just arrested in DC for threatening to blow up his truck by the Capitol.
 
Last edited:
I thought we should have gotten out of Afghanistan a long time ago, but I was never under the illusion about what would happen once we pulled out.
I also note your tirade has nothing to do with my statement.
You are now just writing political platitudes regardless of the topic.


I think this is awful. I despise religious zealotry and misogynistic violence. It's absolutely disgusting that women all over the world are treated as second class citizens. It's even more horrible that misogyny turns to violence against women. This is especially so in the Islamic world.

But i also think there are limits to what we can accomplish militarily. And while i respect the front line soldiers that serve, I believe our foreign policy is corrupted by the military industrial complex.

A complex where some to many Generals and other high level officers do things not for the country's best interests, but for military contractors and future jobs. Eisenhower warned us about this and yet we still haven't learned.

I look at this moment as probably inevitable. It's unfortunate. (Probably a massive understatement)

But what do we do now? Sure, we can look back at it with hindsight and say "if only we had done this differently." Trying to blame those who didn't have that luxury of hindsight. Not that I don't think we shouldn't examine it.

But I know one thing for sure, I am not interested in reviewing it through the lens of the Neocons who got us into this mess.
 
Last edited:
I'm reserving judgement on whether or not the evacuation was a disaster or not. So far despite the challenges and uncertainty, they've been successfully pulling out Americans and thousands of Afghan nationals alike without any major causalities or violent incidents. That's not nothing.

The biggest obstacle to the withdrawal was the immediate and complete collapse of the government. As soon as the withdrawal began, they were done, and I'm not sure that's something more time or planning can fix. I'm also not sure a troop surge necessary to secure the entire country from the Taliban until the withdrawal is complete looks very pretty either at this point.
 
If you don't see the difference between bringing down a thousands year olf cultural monument and blowing up a 60 year old building you are really really ignorant.
I guess blowing up Notre Dame in Paris would be ok in your book...

I wish the Kingdome was a 60 year old building when they imploded it. More like 24. Also that was a joke.

As for the Notre Dame, If the French government or Catholic Church demolished it say after the fire I wouldn't necessarily see that as exactly violence.
 
I wish the Kingdome was a 60 year old building when they imploded it. More like 24. Also that was a joke.

As for the Notre Dame, If the French government or Catholic Church demolished it say after the fire I wouldn't necessarily see that as exactly violence.

You don't have much respect for cultural monuments, I see.
 
You don't have much respect for cultural monuments, I see.

Oh dear. Will you please just stop with this kind of hyperbolic nonsense? What ac said was in no way a lack of respect for cultural monuments.

If Notre Dame had been damaged to the point that they felt it needed to be demolished...which is the ONLY scenario under which that would have happened...it would not have been an act of violence. Which was ac's point.
 
ON the Bamyan statutes:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buddhas_of_Bamiyan

But their destruction is just peachy keen to some people here.
And how dare the internatinal community have branded this an outrage.

Jesus Christ on a pogo stick! Just stop with the gross exaggerations!!

Please quote anyone here supporting the destruction of the statues or claiming it was just 'peachy keen' in any way. We've actually said the opposite. I said this several posts ago: " They were, sadly, destroyed, but to call it 'violence' is exaggeration."

I'm not an apologist for the Taliban. I'm just not going to be a Debbie Downer about an unknown future.

I think it's awful they blew up those ancient sculptures. But c'mon, that's not violence.
 
Last edited:
:thumbsup: But that's not how dudalb was meaning it. Pedantry would be more accurate. He thinks I'm being pedantic by calling him out on his habitual use of hyperbole that misrepresents things.
No it's exactly how he was meaning it. He meant that little lilt you had in your voice when you needed to italicize "accurately."
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom