Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
What part of the word "why" did you not understand?

Let's review your claim for a moment:



See that hilighted part? That's your claim of motivation. That's what I disputed. Proving the what doesn't do anything to support your claim of why.

What part of photo op do you not believe? Care to list the other possibilities? And of course it was to wave a Bible, again what are your other possible reasons?
 
I see the anti-immigration brigade is at it as predicted when it comes to our Afghan allies who helped us for 20 years:
From former Trump adviser Steve Cortes:







Because, as we know, they're sending us rapists, murderers......Hide your daughters!! :rolleyes:


Rep. Tom Tiffany


Tucker Carlson:

Charlie Kirk:


Some GOP, like Romney, Ducey, Kemp, Ernst, and Hogan, are standing up and doing the right thing saying they'll take in Afghan refugees .

You also have to include the Governor of Utah, who issued a letter welcoming Afghan refugees into his state.
As for Cortes, I would call the man a pig, except that is very unfair to pigs.
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure what I could tell you that would convince you, if their history hasn't already led you to that conclusion.

Are they sexist misogynistic, male dominated and religiously backwards? Yes.

Are they arbitrarily and capriciously violent? I don't buy that. To many of the Afghans, Taliban means religious.
 
Last edited:
What part of photo op do you not believe? Care to list the other possibilities? And of course it was to wave a Bible, again what are your other possible reasons?

You aren't paying attention. I'm not talking about why Trump had a photo op. I'm talking about why the park police cleared protesters and journalists from the area. That had nothing to do with the photo op. And the other possible reasons, also known as the actual reasons, are given in the link I provided.
 
Biden is making the kind of speech he should have made a couple of days ago. He is putting heavy emphises about the US keeping it's promise to the Afghansh whe helped us. it's the first really effective damage control he had done.
But is till cannot buy into the No serious mistakes were made and Biden should not be criticised attitude I am seeing here. And "Whataboutism" and "Deflection" is no better coming from the left then the right.
 
Are they sexist misogynistic, male dominated and religiously backwards? Yes.

Are they arbitrarily capriciously violent? I don't buy that. To many of the Afghans, Taliban means religious.

You don't know much about the Taliban do you?
Remember the blowing up of the Buddhist statues?
Sorry, but I think you are trying to make the Taliban look better then the religous thugs they are because you think somehow that will make Biden look better.
The Taliban are bunch of violent, relgious thugs, period. Just look at the record.
The US withdrawal from Afghanstian meant putting a bunch of thugs in charge. I think we should have withdrawn because it was a hopeless military situationg, but I was under no illusion about what that meant.
And if the "Progressives" are going to go into the business of making excuses for Islamic Militants, it will not end well politcally for them.
You wanted a withdrawal, now you got it. You need to face up to the consequences. And trying to white wash the Taliban in not doing that.
 
Last edited:
Keep in mind Trump made this decision. Biden didn't reverse course.
The Trump regime also effectively destroyed any confidence in the 'Afgan government' by excluding them at Doha, and conceding the country to the Taliban.
 
Are they sexist misogynistic, male dominated and religiously backwards? Yes.

Are they arbitrarily capriciously violent? I don't buy that. To many of the Afghans, Taliban means religious.

Given their brand of religion, I don't see that as contradicting my characterization.

You don't know much about the Taliban do you?
Remember the blowing up of the Buddhist statues?

The statues were the least of it. Remember the soccer fields used for public executions and amputations?
 
The choice wasn't to stay forever or leave now no matter what. The U.S. could have taken the time to extract the tens of thousands of Afghans who have helped the U.S. and who are now in danger of immediate execution, and made clear that Taliban interference would delay our departure.
Firstly the US was never going to evacuate "tens of thousands"; it's been busy obstructing any chance of them entering the US for several years.
Secondly once that started the 'Afghan government' would have collapsed.

Remember why Germany collapsed in 1918; no-one wants to be the last to die in a losing war.

There's also an argument to be made that U.S. troops are and should be stationed wherever it serves our interests. U.S. troops have been deployed throughout Europe and the Pacific since the end of WWII, and in Korea since the end of the Korean War. There are 600+ U.S. military installations abroad of one kind or another. I'm not sure keeping 2500 troops in Afghanistan indefinitely to prevent a Taliban takeover would have been a bad investment.
How would keeping US forces in Afghanistan, against the will of the populace, serve your interests?
 
Gen. Wesley Clark outlined why the Taliban could take over so quickly. It mostly boils down to the corruption of the government and the failure of leadership. He said that there is a culture of the government officials 'from the top down' to 'line their own pockets'. He added that there were "years and years of mismanagement and corruption and people who were half-heartedly committed in order to get a paycheck and leaders who took pay from them and didn't provide the logistics." He also said there was "no real support from the citizenry of the government and no loyalty up and down the chain of command."
This. There never was an 'Afghan government' outside of neocon fantasies. Afghanistan is a tribal state, there is no loyalty to a central government, and little basis for a national identity. The US never seemed to learn/accept this fact.

I note that Ghani managed to take at least a couple of hundred million in cash an valuables with him. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
You don't know much about the Taliban do you?
Remember the blowing up of the Buddhist statues?
Sorry, but I think you are trying to make the Taliban look better then the religous thugs they are because you think somehow that will make Biden look better.
The Taliban are bunch of violent, relgious thugs, period. Just look at the record.
The US withdrawal from Afghanstian meant putting a bunch of thugs in charge. I think we should have withdrawn because it was a hopeless military situationg, but I was under no illusion about what that meant.
And if the "Progressives" are going to go into the business of making excuses for Islamic Militants, it will not end well politcally for them.
You wanted a withdrawal, now you got it. You need to face up to the consequences. And trying to white wash the Taliban in not doing that.

How exactly is blowing up the Buddhist statues violent? Seriously, how?
 
I don't trust the Taliban. Period. Their claims of being less violent and of allowing women to be educated etc. are empty promises made to placate the US for now. Once our and NATO's presence is completely out, they will revert to what they are and always have been: Mostly Pushtun extremist authoritarians. Pushtunwali is the medieval and extremely patriarchal code that guides them. To understand it:
https://www.thefridaytimes.com/pashtun-women-and-the-national-question-i/


Taliban fighters hunting a journalist from Deutsche Welle have shot dead one member of his family and severely injured another, the German public broadcaster said, adding that three more of its journalists had had their homes raided.
Deutsche Welle (DW) said the Taliban had been doing a house-to-house search to find the journalist, who it said was now working in Germany and did not name. Other relatives were able to flee and are on the run now, it said.
Deutsche Welle said the Taliban had raided the homes of at least three of its journalists.
https://www.reuters.com/business/me...y-taliban-german-broadcaster-says-2021-08-20/
 
Firstly the US was never going to evacuate "tens of thousands"; it's been busy obstructing any chance of them entering the US for several years.

Biden said that the count evacuated is around 14,000, with thousands more evacuated by charters, for what that's worth. So tens of thousands actually is looking reasonably likely.
 
How exactly is blowing up the Buddhist statues violent? Seriously, how?


You have got to be kidding?
..
Serioualy, you are making a huge mistake in becoming an apologist for the Taliban..which is whay you seem on the verge of becomng.
 
I don't trust the Taliban. Period. Their claims of being less violent and of allowing women to be educated etc. are empty promises made to placate the US for now. Once our and NATO's presence is completely out, they will revert to what they are and always have been: Mostly Pushtun extremist authoritarians. Pushtunwali is the medieval and extremely patriarchal code that guides them. To understand it:

I don't think they will be anything different than that either. But I don't believe that they be arbitrarily violent to say Foreigners leaving or to everyone that opposed them. I also don't know if we can assume that the Taliban leadership of 2021 is going to be exactly like it was in 2001.

I'm just not willing to predict the future. But the reality is the Taliban was going rule the moment we left whether that be under Trump or Biden.
 
I don't think they will be anything different than that either. But I don't believe that they be arbitrarily violent to say Foreigners leaving or to everyone that opposed them.

Why not? They're willing to kill women for wearing the wrong clothes.
 
You have got to be kidding?
..
Serioualy, you are making a huge mistake in becoming an apologist for the Taliban..which is whay you seem on the verge of becomng.

I'm not an apologist for the Taliban. I'm just not going to be a Debbie Downer about an unknown future.

. I think it's awful they blew up those ancient sculptures. But c'mon, that's not violence.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom