Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
Live on air

What part of the word "why" did you not understand?

Let's review your claim for a moment:

It did happen under Trump, news crews were assaulted by cops in DC to clear a way for him to wave a Bible.

See that hilighted part? That's your claim of motivation. That's what I disputed. Proving the what doesn't do anything to support your claim of why.
 
It has been the case for a while that the screening process disqualifies a significant portion of the potential refugees for reasons connected to the very assistance they gave us.

These people are targeted by the forces opposed to us to "make an example of." Failing to assassinate them directly, the Taliban forces will settle for abducting a family member and demanding ransom. For entirely understandable reasons, the targeted individual will comply to secure the release of their loved one.

Viola, they are now technically guilty of "material support of a terrorist organization."

Also, it's a civil war. Some 2nd cousin by marriage inevitably is on the "wrong side" from our perspective and that can be enough to fail their background check.

Why do you assume they will do such things? They might. But the Taliban leadership now has a country to organize and govern. They won. What makes you think they are going to get all vengeful?
 
Why do you assume they will do such things? They might. But the Taliban leadership now has a country to organize and govern. They won. What makes you think they are going to get all vengeful?

Well, first off I said this has been going on for a while. The kinds of situations described (and there are many more kinds of ways to run afoul of the checks than the two I mentioned) already occurred and can't be undone.

Second, forming a government doesn't necessarily mean forming a just and fair government. Plenty of governments engage in terrible reprisals against their political opposition or other classes, whether they be citizens or not.

Additionally I doubt that even if a central cabal were to adopt a more conciliatory tone going forward that it would necessarily be adhered to out in the provinces. Taliban forces even in the heart of Kabul don't seem to be conducting themselves with what I would describe as professional, disciplined behavior.

ETA: It isn't the government in Kabul that would deny their asylum request. The U.S. government has been doing that for years now.
 
Last edited:
Why do you assume they will do such things? They might. But the Taliban leadership now has a country to organize and govern. They won. What makes you think they are going to get all vengeful?

Why does the scorpion sting the frog?
 
What part of the word "why" did you not understand?

Let's review your claim for a moment:



See that hilighted part? That's your claim of motivation. That's what I disputed. Proving the what doesn't do anything to support your claim of why.

News teams were assaulted by US cops in Washington DC.

Your claim was "If this had happened under Trump, you would be outraged."


It did happen under trump, right there in the USA.

Trump's waving of the bible is secondary
 
How much do you really know about the Taliban? I know very little despite reading a lot.

I think I know enough to know that they're intrinsically violent and brutal, that it isn't simply a tactic they adopt out of necessity.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom