Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
The thread's original mention of what happened to the news crew:
CNN news crew attacked by Taliban in Kabul.
BUt the evacuation plan is going great........
The word "assault" isn't even in there. Why the obsession with it since then? Surely the fact that it apparently presents an opportunity for equivocation can't have anything to do with it, right?
 
The thread's original mention of what happened to the news crew:The word "assault" isn't even in there. Why the obsession with it since then? Surely the fact that it apparently presents an opportunity for equivocation can't have anything to do with it, right?

I don't think that was the original intent. It was exaggeration in order to make it appear worse than it was.
Edited by xjx388: 
<SNIP> Rule 12
 
Last edited by a moderator:
So yea, that is two countries that think their country did a bad job.

That's not two countries. That's some MPs that are members of a party of that is the equivalent of the GOP. But even if they were members of the more liberal party they don't speak for an entire nation.

FYI, I'm not going to respond to your next post.
 
What the actual ****? I'm not assuming negative results from the chaos, everyone can SEE negative results from the chaos. That's just a fact. And it was largely avoidable by taking steps that were obvious beforehand, it really isn't a matter of hindsight.

And I'm not talking about the occupation of Afghanistan in total because this thread isn't about that. There are other threads in which to evaluate that and assign whatever blame you want for it.

Jesus Christ on a stick.

No, you're seeing the chaos. Let's talk about it in a month or when the evacuation is complete.
 
If you could get a good government out of it, that would be supported by the population, with a loyal military, that would be a good deal I would think.

I think I see your problem: you think that is possible within our lifetimes. It demonstrates a general lack of understanding that this has never happened in Afghanistan. Most 'soldiers' are illiterate, country peasants who will fight for whomever is paying them which is one reason they melted away when the US military withdrew.

In practice, however, Afghan governments have never succeeded in extending their rule very deeply at the local level. This reality has meant that local influentials and power brokers would not challenge the state, and the state, in turn, would refrain from trying to interfere with them. Whatever the regime in power, a high degree of autonomy has allowed local areas to pursue economic activities and to follow tribal and localized law and customs. To administer the government’s few extractive and allocative powers, the country was divided administratively into provinces, each headed by a centrally appointed governor. The provinces were further subdivided into districts and subdistricts headed by appointed officials.

In the absence of an effective central government, Afghan communities have their own social norms, but none so elaborate as Pashtun tribal law, known as Pashtunwali. With the advent of the Taliban, Islamic courts and an Islamic administration of justice through interpretation of the law by clergy (ʿulamāʾ) assumed greater prominence. These changes have widely replaced the authority once exercised by traditional local leaders, or khans.

The most far-reaching and ultimately disastrous attempt to expand the penetration of the Kabul government occurred during the early years of communist rule that began in 1978 and eventually led to civil war and chaos.
https://www.britannica.com/place/Afghanistan/Political-process

The concept of a 'nation' made up of differing tribes/cultures seeing themselves as 'Afghans' first and not Pushtun, Tajiks, Hazaras, Turkmen, Durranis, etc , simply is not part of their history.
 
That's not two countries. That's some MPs that are members of a party of that is the equivalent of the GOP. But even if they were members of the more liberal party they don't speak for an entire nation.

FYI, I'm not going to respond to your next post.

The equivalent to the GOP party is the one in charge....it would be like Trump screwing up the evacuation and the GOP complaining about him.
 
I think I see your problem: you think that is possible within our lifetimes. It demonstrates a general lack of understanding that this has never happened in Afghanistan. Most 'soldiers' are illiterate, country peasants who will fight for whomever is paying them which is one reason they melted away when the US military withdrew.


https://www.britannica.com/place/Afghanistan/Political-process

The concept of a 'nation' made up of differing tribes/cultures seeing themselves as 'Afghans' first and not Pushtun, Tajiks, Hazaras, Turkmen, Durranis, etc , simply is not part of their history.

This. :thumbsup:
 
It is not all Biden's fault by any means.
But he bears his share of the blame for the botched Withdrawal.
Whataboutsim and Deflect, Deflect,Deflect are no better coming from the Liberal aide then it does from the Right side.
If you dare to criticize Biden you seem to think that makes you a Trump Supporter

How did he botch it? Wasn't he given a deadline of Aug 31st or else there would be combat because of a deal Trump made? I guess he could've sent in more soldiers to push the withdrawal out further so that more soldiers could die in the name of..what? He was given a crappy hand, I think he's done the best that he could with it.
 
I see the anti-immigration brigade is at it as predicted when it comes to our Afghan allies who helped us for 20 years:
From former Trump adviser Steve Cortes:
Steve Cortes
@CortesSteve
·
Aug 17
Raise your hand if you want this plane landing in your town?

America paid unimaginable costs in Afghanistan because of uniparty globalists who dominated the Bush & Obama administrations.

No more…


Steve Cortes
@CortesSteve
·
20h
No Afghan migrants

“Is this the country you want for your wife, your sister, your daughter?…I welcome the scorn of the credentialed ruling class…I stand for working-class citizens and take unpopular stands in defense of the Deplorables”



Because, as we know, they're sending us rapists, murderers......Hide your daughters!! :rolleyes:


Rep. Tom Tiffany
@RepTiffany
·
Aug 17
Disturbing reports that 5000 Afghans per day are headed to the US – including Fort McCoy in Wisconsin.

Afghanistan is a dangerous country that is home to many dangerous people

Tucker Carlson:
First we invade and then we're invaded.

Charlie Kirk:
Biden wants a couple hundred thousand more Ilhan Omars to come into America to change the body politic permanently


Some GOP, like Romney, Ducey, Kemp, Ernst, and Hogan, are standing up and doing the right thing saying they'll take in Afghan refugees .
 
What European countries like Italy have in common with each other, the US, Australia, and Japan, but not with Afghanistan, is that they are either post-monarchial or still have a monarchy. Afghanis have never centralized control into a single figure like that. Every attempt to explain to Afghanis how life could be with a centralized governing system is going to fall into that fundamental divide, of how people can be commanded by people who aren't anywhere near and likely never will be.
 
What European countries like Italy have in common with each other, the US, Australia, and Japan, but not with Afghanistan, is that they are either post-monarchial or still have a monarchy. Afghanis have never centralized control into a single figure like that. Every attempt to explain to Afghanis how life could be with a centralized governing system is going to fall into that fundamental divide, of how people can be commanded by people who aren't anywhere near and likely never will be.

They actually did have a central monarchy but it was, like so many, rife with corruption, coup d'etats, and unstable.
 
Yes, I got to see that nice history lesson in the other thread, so I was wrong. They probably even faced things like tax collectors coming around, I was imagining that each little settlement was mostly self-governing and didn't get much contact with the outside. It was notable though that each of the empires that ruled it were not members of the local tribe, so they wouldn't feel any kind of 'ownership' like "my King that I hear from those who had a king.
 
I think I see your problem: you think that is possible within our lifetimes. It demonstrates a general lack of understanding that this has never happened in Afghanistan. Most 'soldiers' are illiterate, country peasants who will fight for whomever is paying them which is one reason they melted away when the US military withdrew.

https://www.britannica.com/place/Afghanistan/Political-process

The concept of a 'nation' made up of differing tribes/cultures seeing themselves as 'Afghans' first and not Pushtun, Tajiks, Hazaras, Turkmen, Durranis, etc , simply is not part of their history.

I'm fully aware of that. This is why I used the word "if".

It's never going to happen, but that also means what was the point of arming "350,000 soldiers" which most of us know were ghost soldiers, with such amazing equipment if it was clear to people in charge what was going on?
 
It has been the case for a while that the screening process disqualifies a significant portion of the potential refugees for reasons connected to the very assistance they gave us.

These people are targeted by the forces opposed to us to "make an example of." Failing to assassinate them directly, the Taliban forces will settle for abducting a family member and demanding ransom. For entirely understandable reasons, the targeted individual will comply to secure the release of their loved one.

Viola, they are now technically guilty of "material support of a terrorist organization."

Also, it's a civil war. Some 2nd cousin by marriage inevitably is on the "wrong side" from our perspective and that can be enough to fail their background check.
 
Last edited:
Keep living in fantasy land, guy.
Explain why BIden is taking so much fire from the Dems in congress if everything is working out so great.
And, yes, the American people don't pay much attention to foreign affairs until they get hit over the head by them, but foreign affairs can be decisive in domestic politics.
And what you said about the Taliaban is rational, problem is I donlt think the Taliaban is very rational, or that it can control all it's "soldiers.".

It will be forgotten in a month.
 
So now intimidating news crews is no big deal?
If this had happened under Trump,you would be outraged.
Trying to let the Taliban off the hook will not help Biden much, if that is whay you are trying to do.

It did happen under Trump, news crews were assaulted by cops in DC to clear a way for him to wave a Bible.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom