Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes, silly journalists, documenting and reporting on things in a dangerous situation.

Surely if anything happens to them, it's their own fault?

I mean, dang, she was wearing a non face-covering garment. Almost like asking for it.

Get used to it. Lots of people are going to went to ignore the situation in Afghanistan .
 
I guess the values we espouse can take a back seat when there's a president of our preferred party to stand in solidarity with.

ETA: this kind of fair-weather adherence to our own stated beliefs gives fuel to the claim that it is all naught but virtue signalling.

THIS. Not much difference between the die Hard Trumpers and the Die Hard Biden Supporters.
I am not saying that Biden and Trump are the same:BIden is a 1000 times better. But he botched the withdrawal.and a lot of his die hard supporters are in denail he messed up.
But our leader must be blinded supported at all costs....
 
Watch Chris Wallace call out Pompeo for his "it's all Biden's fault" crap.


It is not all Biden's fault by any means.
But he bears his share of the blame for the botched Withdrawal.
Whataboutsim and Deflect, Deflect,Deflect are no better coming from the Liberal aide then it does from the Right side.
If you dare to criticize Biden you seem to think that makes you a Trump Supporter
 
You mean like they have for the last two decades?

ANy what is your freaking point?
You know, I think if the left keeps on this almost complete disreagard for what is happening to the Afghan people, it is going to lose a lot of their moral advantage over the right. and it going to look like it'sphony, is just a mask for a hunger for power no different then what we see from the right.
 
Last edited:
But clearly I made a mistake, since now I'm being fired at from two different directions.

No, you didn't. Efficient communication requires all parties understanding how the words they are using are defined. I was about to post what an "assault" means, but only didn't when you stepped in. You should be thanked and not "fired at".
 
I know what some posters are up to:
They think that any criticism of Biden helps the GOP,therefore Biden should not be criticised.
problem is that tactic NEVER works.
 
THIS. Not much difference between the die Hard Trumpers and the Die Hard Biden Supporters.
I am not saying that Biden and Trump are the same:BIden is a 1000 times better. But he botched the withdrawal.and a lot of his die hard supporters are in denail he messed up.
But our leader must be blinded supported at all costs....

It's not denial. The Biden administration made some mistakes. Okay? Satisfied?

But this is where you and I differ. I'm not sure I believe this could have ended differently unless we maintained a military presence in Afghanistan for another 40 years. And even then I think we would have failed.

Afghanistan to me is a demonstration that the US never learned the lessons from Vietnam.
 
BULLOCKS!

And you're saying Trump, Bush, Obama and the military complex knew what they were doing?

I said nothing of the sort.

But Bush, for example, has abso-*******-lutely NOTHING to do with how this withdrawal was handled. That's on Biden, first and foremost.

And no, the blame doesn't stop there either. Milley needs to be fired, for example.
 
ANy what is your freaking point?
You know, I think if the left keeps on this almost complete disreagard for what is happening to the Afghan people, it is going to lose a lot of their moral advantage over the right. and it going to look like it'sphony, is just a mask for a hunger for power no different then what we see from the right.

Moral advantage? You can't be serious? Was it morals that kept the US in Afghanistan for 20 years? You don't actually believe that?

You're right. They botched the withdrawal. I cannot do anything about that. I feel bad for the Afghans left to live under the Taliban the same way I feel bad for women in Saudi Arabia and the US hasn't given a damn about that for 70 years.
 
It's not denial. The Biden administration made some mistakes.

Some mistakes?

This was a colossal **** up.

But this is where you and I differ. I'm not sure I believe this could have ended differently unless we maintained a military presence in Afghanistan for another 40 years.

Then you're clueless. Again, this isn't just about the Taliban taking over. Yes, that was inevitable given that we were leaving. It was NOT inevitable that so many US citizens would be stranded. It was NOT inevitable that our biometric database would get captured. It was NOT inevitable that our rapid response capability would be dismantled shortly before we needed it.
 
It is not all Biden's fault by any means.
But he bears his share of the blame for the botched Withdrawal.
Whataboutsim and Deflect, Deflect,Deflect are no better coming from the Liberal aide then it does from the Right side.
If you dare to criticize Biden you seem to think that makes you a Trump Supporter

I see most Biden supporters around here saying he bears quite a bit of responsibility for the botched evacuation, including me. You've said something similar before and I asked you:

Will you please provide links to anyone who has said that Biden is 'above any blame' in this debacle?

You never provided any.

By the way, that's another example of the hyperbole I was talking about earlier.
 
God, I hate definition arguments. I can see how two different people might use these terms differently. But I also believe people can hide behind that vagueness. It should be noted that I also said I agreed with you that Dud was being hyperbolic in his description.

But clearly I made a mistake, since now I'm being fired at from two different directions.

I responded to you before I had read your second post.

There's a ten minute difference between our two posts. You had written and posted while I was still doing some research and writing mine.
 
Last edited:
I said nothing of the sort.

But Bush, for example, has abso-*******-lutely NOTHING to do with how this withdrawal was handled. That's on Biden, first and foremost.

And no, the blame doesn't stop there either. Milley needs to be fired, for example.

BOLLOCKS! This demonstrates a misunderstanding that if you don't build a solid foundation the building will eventually collapse.

George W. Bush set up a corrupt government that the Afghans themselves did not support and would not fight for. There's a reason that the moment Trump announced a peace deal with the Taliban and US withdrawal that the Taliban negotiated deals with those leaders and why the Taliban basically took over the entire country without a shot.

Now Biden could have reversed course. But what would have happened then? Probably a hell of a lot of bloodshed and the US maintaining a military force there for another decade. Is that the outcome we wanted? A delay of this for another ten years?
 
Yeah, it's s**tshow, ,and Biden heserves to be criticised for his part in it, but Trump Bad Dwal with the Taliban is just as big, if not bigger part of the S**tshow.

Trump Bad Dwal would be an excellent name for a pub rock band performing a **** show.
 
BOLLOCKS! This demonstrates a misunderstanding that if you don't build a solid foundation the building will eventually collapse.

George W. Bush set up a corrupt government that the Afghans themselves did not support and would not fight for. There's a reason that the moment Trump announced a peace deal with the Taliban and US withdrawal that the Taliban negotiated deals with those leaders and why the Taliban basically took over the entire country without a shot.

Now Biden could have reversed course. But what would have happened then? Probably a hell of a lot of bloodshed and the US maintaining a military force there for another decade. Is that the outcome we wanted? A delay of this for another ten years?

If you could get a good government out of it, that would be supported by the population, with a loyal military, that would be a good deal I would think.
 
Some mistakes?

This was a colossal **** up.

Then you're clueless. Again, this isn't just about the Taliban taking over. Yes, that was inevitable given that we were leaving. It was NOT inevitable that so many US citizens would be stranded. It was NOT inevitable that our biometric database would get captured. It was NOT inevitable that our rapid response capability would be dismantled shortly before we needed it.

No, you're clueless. Two decades and a few hundred billion dollars and two thousand American lives and a half a million Afghani lives.

You are looking at this entirely with hindsight and partisan lens. Also, you're viewing the chaos of the moment and assuming total negative results.
 
Last edited:
No, you're clueless. Two decades and a few hundred billion dollars and two thousand American lives and a half a million Afghani lives.

You are looking at this entirely with hindsight and partisan lens. Also, you're viewing the chaos of the moment and assuming total negative results.

What the actual ****? I'm not assuming negative results from the chaos, everyone can SEE negative results from the chaos. That's just a fact. And it was largely avoidable by taking steps that were obvious beforehand, it really isn't a matter of hindsight.

And I'm not talking about the occupation of Afghanistan in total because this thread isn't about that. There are other threads in which to evaluate that and assign whatever blame you want for it.

Jesus Christ on a stick.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom