Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
They were assaulted, but they were not battered (put in credible fear of bodily harm). They withdrew and were therefore unable to conduct the activity of documenting the goings-on as they had intended, so they were intimidated.

Oh, good god...they were not 'attacked' or 'assaulted' as there was no 'physical attack' as is the very definition of 'assault'. An attack/assault produces physical damage which did not happen. They were threatened and intimidated, not attacked or assaulted.


It seems quite strange to object in such strong terms about phrasing and criticize the person saying it, yet not share any equally strong opinion about the situation itself.

I was addressing dudalb's continual hyperbolic and misleading representation of what happened for the reasons I gave. Why do I have to also give an opinion on the event itself being bad? That is obvious and didn't need my additional condemnation unless you think I approve of threatening and intimidating news crews for some odd reason.

Can you produce some verbiage of at least equal capacity in that regard?

Yes: The Taliban were using threats and intimidation. This 'verbiage' accurately describes what really happened. The CNN crew was not 'attacked' or 'assaulted'.

It seems quite strange to me that you can't see the difference.
 
While Seth Meyer's A Closer Look is not always this relevant, tonight it was. Well worth the 14 minutes reminding people about so called 'experts' being trotted out on the news who were actually part of past debacles. He also points out that in 2019 a WA Po OpED noted the military industrial complex was pushing 'just a little more time' and we can turn this failure around.



Dudalb this one is especially for you.

:thumbsup:
 
Oh, good god...they were not 'attacked' or 'assaulted' as there was no 'physical attack' as is the very definition of 'assault'. An attack/assault produces physical damage which did not happen. They were threatened and intimidated, not attacked or assaulted.
Actually no Stacy.

This is the difference between the colloquial definition of assault and the original or legal meaning of assault.

Almost everyone thinks "assault" means a physical act, which is not necessarily so. Otherwise why do people often say he was "physically assaulted." If assault meant physical harm then there would be no need ever to describe a physical attack as a physical assault. They would just say "assault."

The legal definition of assault varies by jurisdiction, but is generally defined as intentionally putting another person in reasonable apprehension of an imminent harmful or offensive contact. Physical injury is not required.

If you threaten someone with physical harm and then hit them you have committed "assault and battery". If you hit someone without threatening them you have just committed battery.
 
Last edited:
When you resort to semantics it's generaly a sign you don't have a good argument.

Like Intimidating and Threatning Journalists" is so much better then Physiclaly Attacking them.
 
Last edited:
Every country doesn't have similar problems. For example, British paratroopers are rescuing British citizens in Kabul. We aren't. Why? Because the White House hasn't ******* authorized it!

This is a **** show. Everyone with half a brain can see this is a **** show. And it didn't need to be this way. Seriously, there are just so many obvious steps that could have been taken to make our withdrawal go more smoothly than this, it's hard to imagine how it could have been done any worse. This is epic mismanagement.

You may not be aware, but the UK seems to think the government has done a poor job getting people out of Afghanistan.
 
When you resort to semantics it's generaly a sign you don't have a good argument.


I pointed out the semantics so everyone can be on the same page and for no other reason.

The CNN crew was assaulted. They just weren't physically assaulted.

I tend to agree with Stacy in that while you may have been accurate, you have been hyperbolic in your descriptions.
 
Every country doesn't have similar problems. For example, British paratroopers are rescuing British citizens in Kabul. We aren't. Why? Because the White House hasn't ******* authorized it!

This is a **** show. Everyone with half a brain can see this is a **** show. And it didn't need to be this way. Seriously, there are just so many obvious steps that could have been taken to make our withdrawal go more smoothly than this, it's hard to imagine how it could have been done any worse. This is epic mismanagement.

Yeah, it's ********, ,and Biden heserves to be criticised for his part in it, but Trump Bad Dwal with the Taliban is just as big, if not bigger part of the ********.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Yeah, it's ********, ,and Biden heserves to be criticised for his part in it, but Trump Bad Dwal with the Taliban is just as big, if not bigger part of the ********.

Why just blame them? Why not blame the military industrial complex for 2 decades of failure in Afghanistan?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Actually no Stacy.

This is the difference between the colloquial definition of assault and the original or legal meaning of assault.

Almost everyone thinks "assault" means a physical act, which is not necessarily so. Otherwise why do people often say he was "physically assaulted." If assault meant physical harm then there would be no need ever to describe a physical attack as a physical assault. They would just say "assault."

The legal definition of assault varies by jurisdiction, but is generally defined as intentionally putting another person in reasonable apprehension of an imminent harmful or offensive contact. Physical injury is not required.
If you threaten someone with physical harm and then hit them you have committed "assault and battery". If you hit someone without threatening them you have just committed battery.


If you're going to C&P please cite as such.


Yes, you are correct that the legal definition of assault does not necessarily contain physical harm in some states even if most people use it to mean a physical attack. When we say someone was assaulted, the common usage is that they were physically attacked. Otherwise, we use 'threatened" or "intimidated" outside of a courtroom.

Regardless, the word dudalb used was "attacked" not "assaulted". This implied something which did not happen. I called him out on it and then Delphic Oracle said "They were assaulted, but they were not battered (put in credible fear of bodily harm)." What was the purpose in bringing up that bit of legal detail as dudalb had not used the word 'assault'?

In no way was the news crew 'attacked' or 'assaulted' in the common usage of the words. And since dubalb is not a lawyer, why would he, or anyone, interpret it in a legal sense?

In this pedantry over whether 'assault'(a word not even used in his claim) legally needs to include physical harm , the reason for my response to him has been pushed aside. That was to call out his habitual use of misleading hyperbole of which his post was a classic example.
 
Yeah, it's ********, ,and Biden heserves to be criticised for his part in it, but Trump Bad Dwal with the Taliban is just as big, if not bigger part of the ********.

Nothing forced Biden to abide by Trump's deal. It was never ratified by Congress. I know the instinct of 90% of the membership here is to try to figure out how to blame everything on Trump, but this is Biden's disaster. He wanted this, he owns it.

And the fact that he thinks this was inevitable, that he didn't do anything wrong and that no mistakes were made, should be a huge ******* wake up call that he doesn't know what the **** he's doing.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
If you're going to C&P please cite as such.


Yes, you are correct that the legal definition of assault does not necessarily contain physical harm in some states even if most people use it to mean a physical attack. When we say someone was assaulted, the common usage is that they were physically attacked. Otherwise, we use 'threatened" or "intimidated" outside of a courtroom.

Regardless, the word dudalb used was "attacked" not "assaulted". This implied something which did not happen. I called him out on it and then Delphic Oracle said "They were assaulted, but they were not battered (put in credible fear of bodily harm)." What was the purpose in bringing up that bit of legal detail as dudalb had not used the word 'assault'?

In no way was the news crew 'attacked' or 'assaulted' in the common usage of the words. And since dubalb is not a lawyer, why would he, or anyone, interpret it in a legal sense?

In this pedantry over whether 'assault'(a word not even used in his claim) legally needs to include physical harm , the reason for my response to him has been pushed aside. That was to call out his habitual use of misleading hyperbole of which his post was a classic example.

God, I hate definition arguments. I can see how two different people might use these terms differently. But I also believe people can hide behind that vagueness. It should be noted that I also said I agreed with you that Dud was being hyperbolic in his description.

But clearly I made a mistake, since now I'm being fired at from two different directions.
 
Last edited:
When you resort to semantics it's generaly a sign you don't have a good argument.

Accurate reporting is not 'semantics'. Using words that give a misleading account of something is dishonest. Which is what you were doing. It's what you do: you exaggerate to make things seem worse than they are to fit your agenda.

Like Intimidating and Threatning Journalists" is so much better then Physiclaly Attacking them.

Why, yes...yes, it is. Which do you think the news crew would rather have been? Threatened and intimidated by having the butt of the guns raised to them or having been actually struck with them? And before you accuse me of saying otherwise, that does not mean either is acceptable.

When you have to resort to gross hyperbole, it's generally a sign you're being dishonest.
 
Nothing forced Biden to abide by Trump's deal. It was never ratified by Congress. I know the instinct of 90% of the membership here is to try to figure out how to blame everything on Trump, but this is Biden's disaster. He wanted this, he owns it.

And the fact that he thinks this was inevitable, that he didn't do anything wrong and that no mistakes were made, should be a huge ******* wake up call that he doesn't know what the **** he's doing.

BULLOCKS!

And you're saying Trump, Bush, Obama and the military complex knew what they were doing?

This wasn't just a 2021 debacle, it was 21st century debacle.
 
It's all Biden's fault because that's what Ziggy and other Trumpublicans want people to believe.
 
Oh, good god...they were not 'attacked' or 'assaulted' as there was no 'physical attack' as is the very definition of 'assault'. An attack/assault produces physical damage which did not happen. They were threatened and intimidated, not attacked or assaulted.


Assault, by the legal definition is:

intentionally putting another person in reasonable apprehension of an imminent harmful or offensive contact.

No physical injury, wounds, or scars are required.

This is a widespread misconception. In similar vein to "domestic abuse" not requiring a spouse to have literally physically harmed the other. Emotional pain is real and being intimidated into actions against one's will (or, conversely, to refrain from an act they had desired to engage in).

It is minimization to scoff at it.
 
And this is the fault of western new agencies thinking they can stay neutral and cover the story instead of evacuating when they should have.
Yes, silly journalists, documenting and reporting on things in a dangerous situation.

Surely if anything happens to them, it's their own fault?

I mean, dang, she was wearing a non face-covering garment. Almost like asking for it.
 
I guess the values we espouse can take a back seat when there's a president of our preferred party to stand in solidarity with.

ETA: this kind of fair-weather adherence to our own stated beliefs gives fuel to the claim that it is all naught but virtue signalling.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom