Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
You are living in a left wing echo chamber.
If it becomes a hostage crisis, the COngress will go red in 2022. No debate.
Even without the Afghan crisis, the Dems would have had a uphill fight to hold on.
I know the US being totally humiliated is not a big deal to you and your fellow hard left buddies, but it is to most Americans.Which is why the Dems in congress are turning up the heat on Biden not to mess this up.

Why do you feel so humiliated? I don't.

Did you ever read the Pentagon Papers, or are you at least familiar with them? We stayed in Vietnam for a couple decades because the various administrations didn't want the US to look bad if we left.

Fifty thousand plus US deaths just because a few POTUSes didn't want the US to look bad. Biden had a son in the military before Beau died of cancer. I trust that of anyone, Biden understands what is at stake when we stay in a failed war.

You are clearly one of the more upset forum posters here. Now that you know 20 years of trying to train the Afghanis to defend themselves had gone nowhere: What were our options? Just keep things going to save face? Do you think we had an achievable goal there?

Think Trump's actions might have been a bit of a setup before he left office?

Anyway, it is what it is. Biden's decisions made sense, has has articulated them well, IMO. There are some loose ends we shouldn't leave undone like helping out the Afghanis who worked with and for us. I'm going to wait and see before jumping on the anti-Biden bandwagon.
 
Last edited:
They were assaulted, but they were not battered (put in credible fear of bodily harm). They withdrew and were therefore unable to conduct the activity of documenting the goings-on as they had intended, so they were intimidated.

It seems quite strange to object in such strong terms about phrasing and criticize the person saying it, yet not share any equally strong opinion about the situation itself.

Can you produce some verbiage of at least equal capacity in that regard?
It was his goalpost shifting that was the issue and now here you are with the straw man claims that go with it.
 
I've encountered speculations that Biden was given bad information by his advisors, either because they wanted to set him up to make him look bad, or because they expected to be able to push/manipulate him into staying like they had with previous Presidents.

On the latter point, I'm impressed by Biden sticking to his guns on this. He didn't previously seem to have the spine for that.

I heard a commentator saying a few hours ago that new polls in just the last couple of days have found support for the withdrawal finally going under 50%. They didn't quote the wording of the question, so I don't know whether it separated the principle of getting out from how the withdrawal is currently going, or pulled other polling stunts like including a "despite what a disaster it's been" clause in the "question".

I wouldn't be surprised by a temporary dip, given how hard the media and most other politicians are pushing against it on both sides, but it would recover with time, for two reasons. One is that it would eventually sink in that it's actually not disastrous but just tense and panic-inducing, and the other is that it eventually wouldn't even matter how bad the process of getting out was anyway; the bottom line that anybody cares about will eventually just be "he finally got us out". (People use the Vietnam/Saigon analogy to paint this as a disaster, but the evacuation of Saigon was not why people hated the Vietnam War; it was just the way we got out of it, which everybody agrees was better to do than not do, and which boosted the popularity of the President who did it.)

That's actually amusing coming from somebody who echoes so much.

That's already pretty likely anyway, but for other reasons. Getting out of Afghanistan is one of the biggest things that could have happened to avoid that.

"humiliated!... humiliated!... humiliated!... humiliated!..."

I think I hear an echo!

Too bad the rererererererepetition is apparently drowning out whatever the original voice might have had to say to actually justify that claim.

Since when you you seriously actually treat Democrat politicians' behavior as an indicator of what's happening in reality? Using arguments that depend on ideas you don't even believe yourself (such as, in this case, that Democrats reliably assess reality accurately and act correctly based on that assessment) is not a good rhetorical trick.

But the "question" is answerable anyway...

1. Most of them are paid by the same donors who pay the Republicans.
2. They've all been inundated in the same pro-war, anti-withdrawal propaganda everywhere they turn, and the whole point of inundating people with propaganda is that it really can sink in.

3. Many of them, like you, perpetually operate under ideas of how to win elections that are exactly backward from reality.
4. The imagery of the situation looks worse than the facts behind it. The panicking crowd looks like they're fleeing from a huge battle, but there's actually no huge battle. That realization can be made in an instant by somebody who looks into it calmly & rationally, but, for those whose immediate reaction to seeing the panicked crowd is to join them in the panic, the realization can take more time to sink in.
And speaking of donors who support both sides: the military industrial complex almost certainly favors the US staying in forever wars. I'd like to see the news media pay a bit more attention to that side of things.
 
I think any poll at this moment is worthless. People don't know what is happening and they are mostly hearing bad because that is what the news media does. Let's see how people feel in two months.
 
I served in the US Military, and the accusation that the American soldiers were Cowards is one I truly,truly, resent. Of course the US military has some cowards..every military does. But this blanket accusation is truly outrageous.

What is truly outrageous is that ******* Biden calling the Afghan military cowards when they and their people have suffered far more than any American have. Acting like the Americans have been fighting this war for them and that they are to be blamed for not "fighting hard enough" is disgusting.

I'm fairly certain that is how he sees it too: American soldiers are dying fighting a war while Afghan people are just doing enough to pull their own weight, when in reality the Afghans have done most of the fighting and borne the brunt of the damage even though they have been severely handicapped by decades of civil war, incompetence and corruption.

He didn't have to say that. No one forced his mouth. He could just have ended it with the costs being too high. Instead he trivialized the sacrifices of millions of people who have suffered from this war while acting as if Americans have suffered far more.
 
“So, was it 30 days from withdrawal to collapse? 60? 18 months? Actually, it was all of the above, the projections aligning with the various ‘what ifs’,” London wrote.

“Ultimately, it was assessed, Afghan forces might capitulate within days under the circumstances we witnessed, in projections highlighted to Trump officials and future Biden officials alike.”

The former counter-terrorism chief said that both Donald Trump and Biden had made decisions to leave for political and ideological reasons and were ultimately impervious to intelligence briefings on possible outcomes.

“The decision*Trump made, and Biden ratified, to rapidly withdraw US forces came despite warnings projecting the outcome we’re now witnessing. And it was a path to which Trump and Biden allowed themselves to be held captive owing to the ‘ending Forever Wars’ slogan they both embraced,” London argued.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/aug/18/massive-policy-fail-cia-warned-taliban-takeover

It had to happen this way. Not because there were no other options or because no one could have foreseen these events. It had happen this way because Biden wanted it to happen this way. He could have delayed Americas withdrawal but he refused, even for a day. He thought that the sooner they left the quicker he could wash his hands off of the events which would follow, but now he's made a mess and he regrets nothing.
 
Last edited:
While Seth Meyer's A Closer Look is not always this relevant, tonight it was. Well worth the 14 minutes reminding people about so called 'experts' being trotted out on the news who were actually part of past debacles. He also points out that in 2019 a WA Po OpED noted the military industrial complex was pushing 'just a little more time' and we can turn this failure around.



Dudalb this one is especially for you.
 
SO, if Americans are trapped in Afghanistan we just write them off?
If you think that will sell politically, you are indeed in a fantasy land.

What incentive does the Taliban have to stop Americans from leaving?

That's kinda been the whole point of their operation these last two decades, to get us to leave. Seems more likely to me that they will celebrate every plane load of Americans that leaves the country.

Is there any reason to believe that the Taliban are planning to take American hostages?

Seems to me you're just wishcasting some scenario that would justify a return of American military presence.
 
Last edited:
Why are you so adverse to the reasons for the Afghanistan Fiasco being investigated?

What is a realistic result that looks better than this. When should we have started mass evacuations of Afghans and where should they have gone? Should we also have mass evacuated the Kurds when we left them high and dry?

I think these kind of situations were inevitable as the US even if it did a good job evacuating everyone who had worked for US forces would have been at best half those now trying to evacuate.

I don't fault Biden much because I see this as inevitable, no one was ever going to take every afghan who wanted out, so you would get these kinds of photos and calls no matter what.
 
What is a realistic result that looks better than this. When should we have started mass evacuations of Afghans and where should they have gone? Should we also have mass evacuated the Kurds when we left them high and dry?

I think these kind of situations were inevitable as the US even if it did a good job evacuating everyone who had worked for US forces would have been at best half those now trying to evacuate.

I don't fault Biden much because I see this as inevitable, no one was ever going to take every afghan who wanted out, so you would get these kinds of photos and calls no matter what.

If someone can point to a country that we should have emulated in getting people out of Afghanistan, I would like someone to say so. Every NATO country seems to be unhappy with their own effort right now.
 
CNN news crew attacked by Taliban in Kabul.
BUt the evacuation plan is going great........

And this is the fault of western new agencies thinking they can stay neutral and cover the story instead of evacuating when they should have.
 
What is a realistic result that looks better than this.

Why the holy **** did we close Bagram when we still had so many people in country? Why wasn't Bagram one of the last places we left? Why can't the US military even evacuate all its own citizens? Why was the embassy cut off from the airport? Why are we sending a bunch of troops back now, when everything is going to ****, rather than having the required forces in place to protect the withdrawl ahead of time? Why are our biometric databases falling into the hands of the enemy?

And why did we not even talk to our NATO allies about coordinating all of this?

Even leaving aside the question of Afghan refugees, the logistics of this have been a complete **** show.
 
Last edited:
Why the holy **** did we close Bagram when we still had so many people in country? Why wasn't Bagram one of the last places we left? Why can't the US military even evacuate all its own citizens? Why was the embassy cut off from the airport? Why are we sending a bunch of troops back now, when everything is going to ****, rather than having the required forces in place to protect the withdrawl ahead of time? Why are our biometric databases falling into the hands of the enemy?

Even leaving aside the question of Afghan refugees, the logistics of this have been a complete **** show.

Why were they planning on staying after the troops left? Who is responsible to force them to leave? The time line has been clear, why are they still there?
 
Why were they planning on staying after the troops left? Who is responsible to force them to leave? The time line has been clear, why are they still there?

Biden announced in April that US troop withdrawl deadline was September 11th. We're still weeks away. There are people who cannot leave now, who are trapped because the Taliban took Kabul in days when Biden said it would be months, who never intended to stay past our withdrawl date.
 
Gosh it's nice to have competency in government again where the best thing people can do is nitpick the details.
 
Gosh it's nice to have competency in government again where the best thing people can do is nitpick the details.

b277d5e4b3997f1861cc64b53f1906564c8303d9d8e37d821db02098b3551f8f.jpg
 
The bad planning outcome for the withdrawal from Afghanistan owes to the fact that Democrats listen to Rosy Scenario as much as Republicans do, each hearing what they so dearly wish to hear. Beyond that, invasions don't work for changing hearts and minds. Besides, withdrawal is a deadly sin no matter which side does it; purely partisan, nothing to do with the country known as Afghanistan.
***
Meanwhile, gerrymandering alone will now flip the House in 2022, which is highly likely to greet it's new, unelected Speaker, Donald Trump; a position he may very well roost in as a safe pulpit for years to come. Much better than President, he will find; shielded, unaccountable, never facing election, able to do maximum harm, endless accolades and interviews on the front steps several times a day. The WH will barely have a media voice. That is, if Donnie Boy doesn't go for broke, impeaching both the P and VP, then taking office and instituting the GOP pogrom so many White boys have a hard on for.

Biden will be out on his ass, dizzy, by mid 2023. The coming Buttlick USA is both party's fault; damn the noodle spine on both sides of the aisle.
 
Last edited:
Why the holy **** did we close Bagram when we still had so many people in country? Why wasn't Bagram one of the last places we left? Why can't the US military even evacuate all its own citizens? Why was the embassy cut off from the airport? Why are we sending a bunch of troops back now, when everything is going to ****, rather than having the required forces in place to protect the withdrawl ahead of time? Why are our biometric databases falling into the hands of the enemy?

And why did we not even talk to our NATO allies about coordinating all of this?

Even leaving aside the question of Afghan refugees, the logistics of this have been a complete **** show.

Why does every other country have a lot of similar problems?
 
Why does every other country have a lot of similar problems?

Every country doesn't have similar problems. For example, British paratroopers are rescuing British citizens in Kabul. We aren't. Why? Because the White House hasn't ******* authorized it!

This is a **** show. Everyone with half a brain can see this is a **** show. And it didn't need to be this way. Seriously, there are just so many obvious steps that could have been taken to make our withdrawal go more smoothly than this, it's hard to imagine how it could have been done any worse. This is epic mismanagement.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom