Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
Maybe the problem is that you have a very misinformed and distorted view of the facts.

So you think that more Americans than Afghans should have died in a CIVIL war taking place in AFGHANISTAN? You do understand the Taliban are overwhelmingly Afghans who were fighting their own government? But more Americans should have died? That is one weird way of looking at things.



I can't even think of anything to say about statement that wouldn't involve me getting a yellow card. :mad:

I served in the US Military, and the accusation that the American soldiers were Cowards is one I truly,truly, resent. Of course the US military has some cowards..every military does. But this blanket accusation is truly outrageous.
 
While wringing their hands about the poor Afghans, The Fox News crew ia already screaming about Bringing Afghan refugees to the US. Usually Crap.
What a bunch of hypocritcal bigots.
Of couse we need to be careful and screen the refugees, I am sure some Islamic Militants are going to try to sneak in posing as refugees, but this is different then the crap bigotry FOxnews is pushing.
Last time I looked, bringing the SOuth Vietnamese into the US gave us some very productive citizens..more so then many Native Born Citizens.
 
Last edited:
I served in the US Military, and the accusation that the American soldiers were Cowards is one I truly,truly, resent. Of course the US military has some cowards..every military does. But this blanket accusation is truly outrageous.

I think it's a crock to say US military soldiers are cowards. I don't believe that for one second. But I do believe the loss of American boys over there would be untenable politically here at home

I remember Vietnam. I remember how unpopular that war was. I watched as my oldest brother went off to Vietnam only to come back wounded and a changed person. That war had an impact here in the states and was very unpopular. Afghanistan could have gone on for another two decades and almost no one would have noticed.
 
I think it's a crock to say US military soldiers are cowards. I don't believe that for one second. But I do believe the loss of American boys over there would be untenable politically here at home

I remember Vietnam. I remember how unpopular that war was. I watched as my oldest brother went off to Vietnam only to come back wounded and a changed person. That war had an impact here in the states and was very unpopular. Afghanistan could have gone on for another two decades and almost no one would have noticed.

The US learned a lot from the failure of the Vietnam War. Not much about democracy building through bombing, as the withdrawal from Afghanistan shows, but about PR management and how to perpetuate an unpopular war.

Unlike Vietnam, where draftees were filmed getting turned into corpses by press in the thick of the action, the Afghanistan war was fought with a small, volunteer only professional military with limited press access. It's the perfect recipe for keeping this endless quagmire out of sight and out of mind of the public. WaPo's "Afghanistan Papers" expose dropped proving that leadership had been lying about the war since the start and nobody cared.

It's a minor miracle the war is actually ending. It really could have gone on forever despite its general unpopularity, because it didn't really matter to anyone who wasn't directly involved. Biden deserves credit for ending this sham because it really could have just gone on forever, the hopeless backburner war that everyone forgot about.
 
Last edited:
The US learned a lot from the failure of the Vietnam War. Not much about democracy building through bombing, as the withdrawal from Afghanistan shows, but about PR management and how to perpetuate an unpopular war.

Unlike Vietnam, where draftees were filmed getting turned into corpses by press in the thick of the action, the Afghanistan war was fought with a small, volunteer only professional military with limited press access. It's the perfect recipe for keeping this endless quagmire out of sight and out of mind of the public. WaPo's "Afghanistan Papers" expose dropped proving that leadership had been lying about the war since the start and nobody cared.

It's a minor miracle the war is actually ending. It really could have gone on forever despite its general unpopularity, because it didn't really matter to anyone who wasn't directly involved. Biden deserves credit for ending this sham because it really could have just gone on forever, the hopeless backburner war that everyone forgot about.

It's not so much a military failure, but in the act of nation building. A task which is very hard in the best of circumstances and total folly in almost all others. Afghanistan is not Germany or Japan which were very organized societies who aided their former enemies in rebuilding their countries. South Vietnam and Afghanistan were not invested in rebuilding their countries alongside their American allies.

I feel empathy for the pawns who fought alongside our soldiers that will suffer. But I also believe this would have happened whenever America left.
 
I don't underestimate the GOP and their BS. But their problem is their POTUS negotiated a Peace deal with the Taliban. It was bragging point on the GOP website until yesterday. The page was removed.

They will just do something on the order of running an ad where Biden says no Vietnam style helicopter evac, then show the helicopter taking off form our embassy. Whose mind will that change? The low information voters. Most of which will vote GOP anyways. But as we all know, Trump/GOP candidate doesn't need to pick up several million vote, they need a few thousand in a few key states.

The odds of Trump winning in 2024 just got a bit higher. (I just puked in my mouth a bit)... OTOH had Biden reneged and the shooting started again, they'd run ads on how the dems are the real warmongers.
 
While wringing their hands about the poor Afghans, The Fox News crew ia already screaming about Bringing Afghan refugees to the US. Usually Crap.
What a bunch of hypocritcal bigots.
Of couse we need to be careful and screen the refugees, I am sure some Islamic Militants are going to try to sneak in posing as refugees, but this is different then the crap bigotry FOxnews is pushing.
Last time I looked, bringing the SOuth Vietnamese into the US gave us some very productive citizens..more so then many Native Born Citizens.

One side believes both that one should stay in their country to change it if they don't like it and should leave the country if they don't like it.
 
The odds of Trump winning in 2024 just got a bit higher. (I just puked in my mouth a bit)... OTOH had Biden reneged and the shooting started again, they'd run ads on how the dems are the real warmongers.

//Cynic in me//

Probably why Biden did in now, waaaaay early in his Presidency. This will not be on anyone's mind come 2024.
 
The military had an entire year to plan for this. Actually twenty. Which leads to the question, was this the fault of Biden or the incompetence of the military leaders?

Remember that Trump set this in motion and refused to share security, or any, intel with the new Biden admin. They had to come in and start from scratch.
 
WHat cracks me up is the GOP removing that page fools anybody but the True Believers.
Once you put something up on the Internet, it's pretty much there forever.
I think the Dems should bring this up anytime a Republican triest to shift all the blame To Biden.
 
They will just do something on the order of running an ad where Biden says no Vietnam style helicopter evac, then show the helicopter taking off form our embassy. Whose mind will that change? The low information voters. Most of which will vote GOP anyways. But as we all know, Trump/GOP candidate doesn't need to pick up several million vote, they need a few thousand in a few key states.

The odds of Trump winning in 2024 just got a bit higher. (I just puked in my mouth a bit)... OTOH had Biden reneged and the shooting started again, they'd run ads on how the dems are the real warmongers.

It Trump wins again, THe US will be in state of chaos probably not much different then Civil war.
I still think Trump will not get the 2024 nomination. One of the "Neo Trumps" will.
 
It Trump wins again, THe US will be in state of chaos probably not much different then Civil war.
I still think Trump will not get the 2024 nomination. One of the "Neo Trumps" will.

Yeah, thats why I said Trump/GOP Candidate. I know its early but, if Trump is in (by his standards) good health, and not in jail, I'd put his odds of getting the nom at about 95%.
 
Yes what a graceful exit President Biden will be remembered by. "It's their fault for not fighting hard enough while we are abandoning them to their enemy." That is basically Biden's rationale even-though Afghan soldiers and police fatalities count 27-to-1 with American ones, not to mention the hundreds of thousands wounded and maimed.

Do you have a source for this?

As for not fighting hard enough, I'm pretty sure Biden was saying not fighting at all.

20 years to train and equip an army. Tell me, are we just so superior? Does that sound just a little bit absurd to you?

Think installing and supporting a corrupt government was a good move? To my knowledge the country has never been unified. Someone correct me if I'm wrong.
 
//Cynic in me//

Probably why Biden did in now, waaaaay early in his Presidency. This will not be on anyone's mind come 2024.

That's what I was thinking, but the other cynical part of me is like "Nah, the Dems aren't capable of planning that far ahead."
 
2,448 American soldiers have died. Over 66,000 Afghan soldiers and police have died. (this does not include non-government militia and informal local forces).

[snipped hard to stomach bull **** from someone complaining from their armchair]
When and where did those casualties occur? A source would help clarify things.
 
Last edited:
WHat cracks me up is the GOP removing that page fools anybody but the True Believers.
Once you put something up on the Internet, it's pretty much there forever.I think the Dems should bring this up anytime a Republican triest to shift all the blame To Biden.

This reminds me of a scene in the TV series NewsRadio. One of the female characters finds out an ex boyfriend posted naked pictures of her on the Internet and she asks the technician if he could get the pictures off the Internet. His answer was perfect.

It's like getting pee out of a swimming pool.
 
While wringing their hands about the poor Afghans, The Fox News crew ia already screaming about Bringing Afghan refugees to the US. Usually Crap.
What a bunch of hypocritcal bigots.
Of couse we need to be careful and screen the refugees, I am sure some Islamic Militants are going to try to sneak in posing as refugees, but this is different then the crap bigotry FOxnews is pushing.
Last time I looked, bringing the SOuth Vietnamese into the US gave us some very productive citizens..more so then many Native Born Citizens.

Tucker and Laura I. are the worst:


Carlson claimed Monday night that the Biden administration’s “official position is that American lives are not more valuable than the lives of foreigners” and conflated the acceptance of Afghan war refugees to the influx of immigrants across the southern border with Mexico.

“ ‘Bring in the refugees tonight!’ they’re screaming,” Carlson said, referring to politicians like Romney who are advocating for those trapped in Afghanistan. “That’s the only lesson they’re taking from this debacle.”


Similarly, Fox News host Laura Ingraham called the withdrawal a “catastrophic failure” and questioned whether it was necessary for the United States to follow through on promises made to Afghans eligible for refugee status in America.

“Is it really our responsibility to welcome thousands of potentially unvetted refugees from Afghanistan?” she said on her Monday show. “All day, we’ve heard phrases like, ‘We’ve promised them.’ Well, who did? Did you?”

A comment from a bigot:

"This is why I voted Trump in 2016. As a gay man, I don't want a bunch of muslims in America (from Syria). So yah, same logic holds here."

https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2021/08/17/tucker-carlson-afghan-refugees/

Although they never used the word "Muslim", you know that's a large part of their problem.
Former Murdoch Executive Says He Quit Over Fox's Anti-Muslim Rhetoric
 
Do you have a source for this?

As for not fighting hard enough, I'm pretty sure Biden was saying not fighting at all.

20 years to train and equip an army. Tell me, are we just so superior? Does that sound just a little bit absurd to you?

Think installing and supporting a corrupt government was a good move? To my knowledge the country has never been unified. Someone correct me if I'm wrong.

https://www.cfr.org/in-brief/how-afghan-army-collapsed-under-talibans-pressure

I've read several articles to this effect over the last few days. Basically, when the US announced it's withdrawal the corrupt government officials, who had already been skimming payroll and selling weapons, began to make plans to cooperate with the Taliban instead of defending from them.

It seems to me the biggest mistake of the withdrawal so far was putting any faith in the Afghan government and forces they had supplied and trained.
 
Tucker and Laura I. are the worst:




https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2021/08/17/tucker-carlson-afghan-refugees/

Although they never used the word "Muslim", you know that's a large part of their problem.
Former Murdoch Executive Says He Quit Over Fox's Anti-Muslim Rhetoric

Laura Ingrham is lying though her teeth.
The whole idea it to establish temporary camps, either overseas or in the US
for the vetting process to take place to weed out the potential terrorist...and I have no doubt some will not try to sneak in posing as refugees.
Fox News is openly about White Christian Supremacy now.
As for the Gay Man who voted for Trump..assuming that is not a complete fabrication...he seems never to have heard about what the Christian Fundies ..who are one of the backbones of Trumpism..thinks about Gays:no different then the Taliban.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom