Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
Biden was just following orders.

This was just a game of musical chairs, and ol' Joe got caught out. From the perspective of self-centered Americans, this was not a huge propaganda win for the Taliban as much as it was a huge propaganda win for the Republican Party. They're going to say Democrats "lost it for us" in Afghanistan when Biden executed a policy in place by Trump, itself a response to a mostly hopeless situation. Biden apologists are now desperately trying to blame Trump (see above) for a policy Biden executed (and made assurances that what's happening was not going to happen). The optics of the 20th anniversary of 9/11 will not good for Democrats, and this will be another symbolic issue for Republicans to hammer.

I'm sure the GOP will spin it that way.


I still stand by my argument. The voters DON'T CARE. This is worth a tenth of a point at most.
 
Biden is CINC so he is ultimately responsible. But this is something I agree with Trump on. 21 years is enough.

How many times do I have to say this: The issue is not withdrawal, but that the withdrewal was very badly executed.
CNN is critical of Biden statement this afternoon and I have to agree;his whole pointing fingers at anybody but himself is not a good look.
 
How many times do I have to say this: The issue is not withdrawal, but that the withdrewal was very badly executed.

CNN is critical of Biden statement this afternoon and I have to agree;his whole pointing fingers at anybody but himself is not a good look.
But, but, but he even said "the buck stops with me."

Surely he wasn't trying to have it both ways.
 
What racist extremists want can't be the basis for national policy.

Did I say it was?! I said that there are a lot of people who will not like thousands of Afghan muslims coming here. That is a fact. From that you infer I think what bigots think should be our national policy? :confused: :boggled:
 
How many times do I have to say this: The issue is not withdrawal, but that the withdrewal was very badly executed.
CNN is critical of Biden statement this afternoon and I have to agree;his whole pointing fingers at anybody but himself is not a good look.

I dunno. Maybe another 100 times?
 
How many times do I have to say this: The issue is not withdrawal, but that the withdrewal was very badly executed.
CNN is critical of Biden statement this afternoon and I have to agree;his whole pointing fingers at anybody but himself is not a good look.

I understand your point.

But isn't it the military's responsibility to plan that withdrawal? Isn't 21 years enough time to plan it? Why did they fail?
 
Last edited:
I see we have Biden is above any blame and criticism cult building here.
I know what the thinking is, any criticism of Biden helps the GOP, so Biden should not be criticised.
SOrry, but the actual withdrawal was messed up and it happened on BIden's watch.
Not that there are lots of people to blame....including Trump of course...but please;only members of the Personaity Cult will buy that Biden has no responsiblity for this.
Just because not everyone here agrees with you doesn't mean none of us thinks Biden has any responsibility.


Here's my 2 cents: First, we should have gone after BinLaden and not invaded Iraq. A no brainer.

Second, we should have strengthened the coalition when everyone was on our side after 9-11.

Third, the US should have invested heavily in understanding the culture, made sure our troops did as well, not chosen corrupt leaders to install, invested in education and health care if we really wanted the Afghan people on our side.... stuff like that.

The endeavor was doomed from the start because Bush/Cheney were ******** from the start.
 
Did I say it was?! I said that there are a lot of people who will not like thousands of Afghan muslims coming here. That is a fact. From that you infer I think what bigots think should be our national policy? :confused: :boggled:

I think the question is what is your point of saying that “many people won’t like it”? If you are saying the racists won’t like it, well who cares about racists? Does it mean that there should be any consideration of their views?
 
I think the question is what is your point of saying that “many people won’t like it”? If you are saying the racists won’t like it, well who cares about racists? Does it mean that there should be any consideration of their views?

The point is that "many people won't like it". I was stating a fact. What is hard to understand about that? Stop trying to give it some other broader meaning.
 
The voters DON'T CARE. This is worth a tenth of a point at most.

Voters shouldn't care, but I'm not so confident that they won't. It also depends on what happens; if there's any kind of terrorist attack, it will be "explained" by Biden's actions and used as a cudgel. Never underestimate the Greed Over People's Party ability to gin up controversy. Even if it does not directly translate into support, it can be good for fundraising and base mobilizing. Every day this year some Republican has at some point angrily mentioned Operation Fast and Furious. What this means for the Republican Party's coalition, activating national security voters, remains, at least to me, unclear. It will also be a data point for framing Biden as a Mr. Magoo.
 
I understand your point.

But isn't it the military's responsibility to plan that withdrawal? Isn't 21 years enough time to plan it? Why did they fail?
If it is anything like what Gen. Tiny Zinni describes in "Before the First Shots Are Fired" (about Iraq), they probably had a plan. They probably had several plans.

But the decision is ultimately made by the civilian leadership.

For someone so upset about "progressives" villifying the military, it seems you've got your new marching orders and have done quite an about face (multiple puns intended).[/hilite]

ETA: Wrong target, my mistake :9.
 
Last edited:
I see we have Biden is above any blame and criticism cult building here.I know what the thinking is, any criticism of Biden helps the GOP, so Biden should not be criticised.
SOrry, but the actual withdrawal was messed up and it happened on BIden's watch.
Not that there are lots of people to blame....including Trump of course...but please;only members of the Personaity Cult will buy that Biden has no responsiblity for this.

That's so odd, back during the election threads, we were all purists who never met a Biden criticism we didn't like.
 
Voters shouldn't care, but I'm not so confident that they won't. It also depends on what happens; if there's any kind of terrorist attack, it will be "explained" by Biden's actions and used as a cudgel. Never underestimate the Greed Over People's Party ability to gin up controversy. Even if it does not directly translate into support, it can be good for fundraising and base mobilizing. Every day this year some Republican has at some point angrily mentioned Operation Fast and Furious. What this means for the Republican Party's coalition, activating national security voters, remains, at least to me, unclear. It will also be a data point for framing Biden as a Mr. Magoo.

I don't underestimate the GOP and their BS. But their problem is their POTUS negotiated a Peace deal with the Taliban. It was bragging point on the GOP website until yesterday. The page was removed.
 
If it is anything like what Gen. Tiny Zinni describes in "Before the First Shots Are Fired" (about Iraq), they probably had a plan. They probably had several plans.

But the decision is ultimately made by the civilian leadership.

For someone so upset about "progressives" villifying the military, it seems you've got your new marching orders and have done quite an about face (multiple puns intended).[/hilite]

ETA: Wrong target, my mistake :9.


The decision was made by by civilian leadership. That decision was made a year ago.

I use to work as a personal assistant to a CEO to a sizable company. He told me right up front that my job wasn't just to do what he asked but to anticipate what he needed to get done and do that.

The military leaders had two decades to plan an orderly exit. They were also ordered to withdraw a year ago. WTH have they been doing? How can anyone possibly argue that this wasn't a military failure?
 
The decision was made by by civilian leadership. That decision was made a year ago.



I use to work as a personal assistant to a CEO to a sizable company. He told me right up front that my job wasn't just to do what he asked but to anticipate what he needed to get done and do that.



The military leaders had two decades to plan an orderly exit. They were also ordered to withdraw a year ago. WTH have they been doing? How can anyone possibly argue that this wasn't a military failure?

I'm arguing that such statements as "they had 20 years to plan" and "the decision was made last year" aren't remotely definitive.

The top brass could have "anticipated" all they want, if they were given orders otherwise, that is the end of it.

As Zinni discussed in his book, they did wargames and strategic anticipation of an invasion (and occupation) of Iraq. They included cultural, economic, social, and religious factors. They already knew well in advance there would be a drive for regional Kurdish autonomy. They knew a sectarian feud would occur, they knew the western provinces would become a hotbed of insurgency.

They dutifully reported all of these things and presented plans to address these issues.

The Kurds pushed for autonomy. The sectarian strife did occur. The provinces did become a guerrilla war zone.

Does that mean "the military" blundered?

In contrast to some people's belief, the general staff is not comprised of cowboy jar-heads. A great deal of logical, methodical, and rational consideration can be found at the highest levels of operational command.

You'll much more likely find that "we'll march in with our overwhelming force and achieve victory with brute force" in the civilian side of things.

Biden is CnC. He could have reversed course (or changed the priorities of what objectives were to be reached). Naturally, one might raise the objection that Congress would then have to appropriate funds or the government in Kabul would have balked or any number of other political considerations led him not to do so.

But we don't nearly have enough insight to declare outright where the fault lies.
 
Last edited:
I don't underestimate the GOP and their BS. But their problem is their POTUS negotiated a Peace deal with the Taliban. It was bragging point on the GOP website until yesterday. The page was removed.

Yep. But let's face it, has it ever caused the GOP problems in the past to be shameless liars?

I mean, how does it play out, "Ah! You said Biden lost Afghanistan but it was Trump who..."

GOP: "Biden lost Afghanistan! He hates Murrrrica!"

Trump: "I love Murrrica! Watch me hump the flag!"
 
How many times do I have to say this: The issue is not withdrawal, but that the withdrewal was very badly executed.
CNN is critical of Biden statement this afternoon and I have to agree;his whole pointing fingers at anybody but himself is not a good look.

There is of course the possibility that in the original withdrawal plan it was assumed the Afghan army would actually resist the Taliban.
Did anyone know they'd all surrender without a fight?
If so, I agree, it was badly handled. But if the complete capitulation came as a surprise that at least explains part of the mess.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom