Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
I haven't yet heard Biden's speech, but the BBC radio news headlines have just summarised it as "Americans should not be fighting a war Afghans are unwilling to fight". I find it hard to disagree.
 
The decision was made by by civilian leadership. That decision was made a year ago.

I use to work as a personal assistant to a CEO to a sizable company. He told me right up front that my job wasn't just to do what he asked but to anticipate what he needed to get done and do that.

The military leaders had two decades to plan an orderly exit. They were also ordered to withdraw a year ago. WTH have they been doing? How can anyone possibly argue that this wasn't a military failure?

It wasn't a military failure, the got out in an orderly fashion with no casualties during the withdrawal.
 
I haven't yet heard Biden's speech, but the BBC radio news headlines have just summarised it as "Americans should not be fighting a war Afghans are unwilling to fight". I find it hard to disagree.

Something we should have learned from Vietnam- fighting their war for our purposes is fighting a war we'll never win.
 
How many times do I have to say this: The issue is not withdrawal, but that the withdrewal was very badly executed.
CNN is critical of Biden statement this afternoon and I have to agree;his whole pointing fingers at anybody but himself is not a good look.

With "planning" the takeover of Kabul would have been delayed a few weeks, with American casualties. After all Americans and foreigners there had left, Kabul would have been taken. The situation would have been exactly the same for Afghan civilians. You can't prevent the course of events for 30 million with a few thousand troops.
 
This was a planned, orderly handover of power. The Trump admin negotiated it with the Taliban. Not the Afghan government, the Taliban. The Taliban negotiated it with local forces. We moved out, they moved in. Easy peasy, completely peaceful, except that the people we're handing power to are repressive dickbags who are going to rape and murder their country back into the 18th century, which is why it's still being sold as a retreat and not a treaty.
 
Why not the Afghan gov't? Well, the corruption in the gov't did not lead to any loyalty. As soon as the US left, the ones in the military and army fled, dressed as civilians. This country is a s-hole.
 
Nobody knows and no.

WaPo came out with the Afghanistan papers and revealed as much. Nobody in charge had any idea what the mission was, much less how to accomplish it. It was a zombie war, dead but undead.

I hear a lot about "the lessons of Vietnam" in the last couple of days.

However, the lessons of Vietnam were not about how not to abandon to the city. They were about how not to actually get caught up in the mess in the first place. We failed to heed the "lessons of Vietnam" more than 15 years ago. The events on Sunday were just a consequences of that.
 
Something we should have learned from Vietnam- fighting their war for our purposes is fighting a war we'll never win.

Exactly.

THAT was the lesson of Vietnam.

It wasn't about abandoning the city. That is a consequence of the mess.
 
It is strange seeing major publications, including several liberal ones, taking such a critical stance on the decision to withdraw.

Pulling the cord on this multi-decade mistake may be one of the greatest decisions of Biden's long political career. It takes a lot of guts for a politician to admit that we lost a war.
 
How many times do I have to say this: The issue is not withdrawal, but that the withdrewal was very badly executed.
CNN is critical of Biden statement this afternoon and I have to agree;his whole pointing fingers at anybody but himself is not a good look.

It is strange seeing major publications, including several liberal ones, taking such a critical stance on the decision to withdraw.

Pulling the cord on this multi-decade mistake may be one of the greatest decisions of Biden's long political career. It takes a lot of guts for a politician to admit that we lost a war.

We lost this war years ago to a more effective Propaganda Machine than we had, Trump's Incompetence just helped speed that process up by a few months.
 
I'm arguing that such statements as "they had 20 years to plan" and "the decision was made last year" aren't remotely definitive.

The top brass could have "anticipated" all they want, if they were given orders otherwise, that is the end of it.

As Zinni discussed in his book, they did wargames and strategic anticipation of an invasion (and occupation) of Iraq. They included cultural, economic, social, and religious factors. They already knew well in advance there would be a drive for regional Kurdish autonomy. They knew a sectarian feud would occur, they knew the western provinces would become a hotbed of insurgency.

They dutifully reported all of these things and presented plans to address these issues.

The Kurds pushed for autonomy. The sectarian strife did occur. The provinces did become a guerrilla war zone.

Does that mean "the military" blundered?

In contrast to some people's belief, the general staff is not comprised of cowboy jar-heads. A great deal of logical, methodical, and rational consideration can be found at the highest levels of operational command.

You'll much more likely find that "we'll march in with our overwhelming force and achieve victory with brute force" in the civilian side of things.

Biden is CnC. He could have reversed course (or changed the priorities of what objectives were to be reached). Naturally, one might raise the objection that Congress would then have to appropriate funds or the government in Kabul would have balked or any number of other political considerations led him not to do so.
But we don't nearly have enough insight to declare outright where the fault lies.

He could have reversed course? If it couldn't be done in twenty years, what makes you think it could be done in 21? I agree with you the military generals are not a bunch of cowboys. Nevertheless they had two decades to plan an exit strategy.

This failure was baked in the cake. My guess is the generals knew twenty years ago that this is the way this would end.

Blaming Biden is kind of absurd even though as CINC he's ultimately responsible. Sure Biden could have reversed course and left the troops in Afghanistan for the next eight years and we could blame the next POTUS.

1. This was either an impossible mission.
or
2. The military/civilian leadership for two decades failed.

I see this like I see America's approach to the homeless. A total lack of will to address the problem. What the US did in Afghanistan for two decades was manage the situation but did nothing to address solving the situation.
 
It is strange seeing major publications, including several liberal ones, taking such a critical stance on the decision to withdraw.

Pulling the cord on this multi-decade mistake may be one of the greatest decisions of Biden's long political career. It takes a lot of guts for a politician to admit that we lost a war.

Yes what a graceful exit President Biden will be remembered by. "It's their fault for not fighting hard enough while we are abandoning them to their enemy." That is basically Biden's rationale even-though Afghan soldiers and police fatalities count 27-to-1 with American ones, not to mention the hundreds of thousands wounded and maimed.
 
Last edited:
It is strange seeing major publications, including several liberal ones, taking such a critical stance on the decision to withdraw.

Pulling the cord on this multi-decade mistake may be one of the greatest decisions of Biden's long political career. It takes a lot of guts for a politician to admit that we lost a war.

I'm seeing very little in the way of critical stances on the decision to withdraw - and lots of criticism on the execution. In his speech I think Biden tried to draw focus away from the execution and onto the question of whether or not it was time to withdraw, but almost all the criticism I'm seeing is of how the withdrawal was handled.
 
I'm seeing very little in the way of critical stances on the decision to withdraw - and lots of criticism on the execution. In his speech I think Biden tried to draw focus away from the execution and onto the question of whether or not it was time to withdraw, but almost all the criticism I'm seeing is of how the withdrawal was handled.

That in my mind is a failure of the military leadership. POTUS doesn't tell them how to withdraw. Only to get it done.
 
It might not be polite, but it is accurate.

2,448 American soldiers have died. Over 66,000 Afghan soldiers and police have died. (this does not include non-government militia and informal local forces).

Maybe the problem wasn't that Afghans weren't willing to fight. Maybe it was the Americans who were too afraid, only venturing out when the risk was low enough to avoid casualties and using Afghans as expendable cannon fodder. Think of all those disability payments one maimed American soldier costs!
 
Last edited:
2,448 American soldiers have died. Over 66,000 Afghan soldiers and police have died. (this does not include non-government militia and informal local forces).

Maybe the problem wasn't that Afghans weren't willing to fight. Maybe it was the Americans who were too afraid, only venturing out when the risk was low enough to avoid casualties and using Afghans as expendable cannon fodder. Think of all those disability payments one maimed American soldier costs!

That's why the Afghans disarmed as soon as the small number of Americans left?
 
Stacyhs said:
Will you please provide links to anyone who has said that Biden is 'above any blame' in this debacle?
Not in so many words, of course, but the way that some people bristle at the mere thought that Biden might have made mistakes there.
The problem is not in the idea of withdrawal, but in the execution of it which was way too quick. Another couple of months could have resulted in amore orderly withdrawal and allowed us to get those who worked with US Troops out of Afghansitan.
Of course I fully expect some to say that that those left behind in Afghanistan have it coming, given I am already seeing on many internet sites what amounts to apologetics for the Taliaban.
Please share more insightful musings of the voices in your head!
 
Last edited:
2,448 American soldiers have died. Over 66,000 Afghan soldiers and police have died. (this does not include non-government militia and informal local forces).

Maybe the problem wasn't that Afghans weren't willing to fight. Maybe it was the Americans who were too afraid, only venturing out when the risk was low enough to avoid casualties and using Afghans as expendable cannon fodder.

Maybe the problem is that you have a very misinformed and distorted view of the facts.

So you think that more Americans than Afghans should have died in a CIVIL war taking place in AFGHANISTAN? You do understand the Taliban are overwhelmingly Afghans who were fighting their own government? But more Americans should have died? That is one weird way of looking at things.

Think of all those disability payments one maimed American soldier costs!

I can't even think of anything to say about statement that wouldn't involve me getting a yellow card. :mad:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom