Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
A thoughtful essay on the U.S. role in Afghanistan.
The Afghan people know who they are and more than that, they know who they have always been, and they are just as proud as we are. I once sat down in a family compound behind 20-foot mud brick walls with a farmer and his sons who were descended from the family that had farmed that land and lived on it in mud brick compounds exactly like that one for more than 1000 years. When I used the word "Taliban" with the father, it meant "religious people" to him, not enemy. He took me outside and pointed down the road to a nearby farm. "Taliban," he said. He pointed further to another farm. "No Taliban," he said. Both farms were his neighbors. What he couldn't point to was the presence of anyone or anything having to do with the Afghan government, because in the remote region where his farm was along the border with Pakistan, there was no Afghan government.
https://www.salon.com/2021/08/17/la...afghanistan--we-are-finally-leaving-it-alone/
 
https://www.cfr.org/in-brief/how-afghan-army-collapsed-under-talibans-pressure

I've read several articles to this effect over the last few days. Basically, when the US announced it's withdrawal the corrupt government officials, who had already been skimming payroll and selling weapons, began to make plans to cooperate with the Taliban instead of defending from them.

It seems to me the biggest mistake of the withdrawal so far was putting any faith in the Afghan government and forces they had supplied and trained.
Nothing on how, why or under what circumstances said fatalities occurred, only that it was over the 20 year period. Could some of those fatalities have been when we invaded in the first place?

I don't disagree with the mistaken faith part of your post.
 
Exactly right. Afghanistan has always been about family, tribal life, warlords, and loyalty to them. A centralized government leading a 'nation' is a myth. It's never really existed.

Agreed, American (and we aren't alone on this, it's a thing with most Western Nations) foreign policy does not have a good track record when we have to deal with any group not organized within a traditional Nation State. We just don't "get it."

There is no "Afghanistan" in the way we see it.
 
Last edited:
Agreed, American (and we aren't alone on this, it's a thing with most Western Nations) foreign policy does not have a good track record when we have to deal with any group not organized within a traditional Nation State. We just don't "get it."

There is no "Afghanistan" in the way we see it.

The underlying problem is that many Americans seem to think that everybody everywhere is just like us, or would be if only they had the chance.
 
I think we were justified in the intial invasion of Afghanistan, going after the Al Qaida there,and the Taliban becuse they were supporting Al Qaida (apparently they were using Al Qaida as hired goons...doing some of the Taliaban's dirty work in exchange for asylum) but we NEVER should have gotten heavily involved with Nation Building.
I got a feeling we will probaly have to make raids into Afghanistan if terrorist groups do set up operations there..which from all I have read is pretty much a given..but other then that, and getting the Afghans who serve with us out...just leave them to fight it out.
 
I think we were justified in the intial invasion of Afghanistan, going after the Al Qaida there,and the Taliban becuse they were supporting Al Qaida (apparently they were using Al Qaida as hired goons...doing some of the Taliaban's dirty work in exchange for asylum) but we NEVER should have gotten heavily involved with Nation Building.
I got a feeling we will probaly have to make raids into Afghanistan if terrorist groups do set up operations there..which from all I have read is pretty much a given..but other then that, and getting the Afghans who serve with us out...just leave them to fight it out.

Considering the way Bin Laden was actually killed, a special forces raid into a country with no invasion, it seems like begging the question that a ground war was a necessary condition for pursuing Bin Laden and other leaders. OBL and Al Qaeda leaders did not care much for national borders, so a long, slow moving invasion was not a great way to pursue them anyway because they would just hide elsewhere, such as Pakistan.

The fact that the US pursued many other objectives unrelated to crushing Al Qaeda during our two decade invasion, including staying well after OBL and Al Qaeda had been eliminated, shows that invasion was not merely a means to that end but a goal in itself.
 
Last edited:
Considering the way Bin Laden was actually killed, a special forces raid into a country with no invasion, it seems like begging the question that a ground war was a necessary condition for pursuing Bin Laden and other leaders. OBL and Al Qaeda leaders did not care much for national borders, so a long, slow moving invasion was not a great way to pursue them anyway because they would just hide elsewhere, such as Pakistan.

The fact that the US pursued many other objectives unrelated to crushing Al Qaeda during our two decade invasion, including staying well after OBL and Al Qaeda had been eliminated, shows that invasion was not merely a means to that end but a goal in itself.

You had to take out the AL Qaida infrastucture in Afghanistan.
 
Exactly right. Afghanistan has always been about family, tribal life, warlords, and loyalty to them. A centralized government leading a 'nation' is a myth. It's never really existed.

Many of the modern troubles in the Middle East can be traced back to lines on the map drawn by colonial powers that don't make much sense locally.
 
There is bipartisan support for hearings on the whole mess of the Afghan withdrawal. A number of Democrats are asking some pretty tough questions.
I hope they leave aside the partisan bickering for a little bit, long enough to find out exactly what happened,particulary in the horrible intelligence failure, and then get rid of the people responsible.
 
There is bipartisan support for hearings on the whole mess of the Afghan withdrawal. A number of Democrats are asking some pretty tough questions.
I hope they leave aside the partisan bickering for a little bit, long enough to find out exactly what happened,particulary in the horrible intelligence failure, and then get rid of the people responsible.

If only they could do that on something far more important to American democracy.
 
That in my mind is a failure of the military leadership. POTUS doesn't tell them how to withdraw. Only to get it done.
And as others have said, they did it without further casualties. It was a political failure, not a military one. The military were told to get out and they did.

2,448 American soldiers have died. Over 66,000 Afghan soldiers and police have died. (this does not include non-government militia and informal local forces).

Maybe the problem wasn't that Afghans weren't willing to fight. Maybe it was the Americans who were too afraid, only venturing out when the risk was low enough to avoid casualties and using Afghans as expendable cannon fodder. Think of all those disability payments one maimed American soldier costs!

I served in the US Military, and the accusation that the American soldiers were Cowards is one I truly,truly, resent. Of course the US military has some cowards..every military does. But this blanket accusation is truly outrageous.

It wasn't the soldiers who were cowards, but civilian leadership. This goes right back to the start, with the Bush administration preferring to employ unreliable militias to go after Bin Laden, when we knew where he was, rather than risk US casualties. As a result, he got away.
 
That in my mind is a failure of the military leadership. POTUS doesn't tell them how to withdraw. Only to get it done.
There would have been numerous, probably very long discussions about this in the Oval and/or situation room.

If the President had no more input to offer than "just get it done" that's an even more enormous failure than I had already envisioned.

In one of the Trump threads, the difference between a "boss" and a "leader" was discussed. Your version makes Biden sound like a "boss", totally disinterested in the how and why of it.
 
Last edited:
2,448 American soldiers have died. Over 66,000 Afghan soldiers and police have died. (this does not include non-government militia and informal local forces).

Maybe the problem wasn't that Afghans weren't willing to fight. Maybe it was the Americans who were too afraid, only venturing out when the risk was low enough to avoid casualties and using Afghans as expendable cannon fodder. Think of all those disability payments one maimed American soldier costs!

When my son was stationed in Afghanistan they went out on missions into dangerous villages frequently. Although maybe his unit that was stationed far from the main cities was an outlier.
 
There would have been numerous, probably very long discussions about this in the Oval and/or situation room.

If the President had no more input to offer than "just get it done" that's an even more enormous failure than I had already envisioned.

In one of the Trump threads, the difference between a "boss" and a "leader" was discussed. Your version makes Biden sound like a "boss", totally disinterested in the how and why of it.

C'mon, Presidents aren't Generals with military expertise. The idea that they know how to withdraw from a military engagement is like suggesting they know how to battle a virus. The President does have meetings on these subjects, it still is always up to others on how to do it and execute that plan.
 
If only they could do that on something far more important to American democracy.

I think it is important we find out what went wrong with the withdrawal from Afghanistan.
I know you think the whole thing is unimportant, I could not disagree more and find your desire to sweep this under the rug not a good idea.
We need to find out who borched up the on the ground withdrawal/evacuation and get rid of them.
 
Last edited:
There would have been numerous, probably very long discussions about this in the Oval and/or situation room.

If the President had no more input to offer than "just get it done" that's an even more enormous failure than I had already envisioned.

In one of the Trump threads, the difference between a "boss" and a "leader" was discussed. Your version makes Biden sound like a "boss", totally disinterested in the how and why of it.


Last POTUS who was qualified to command Ground Troops in a operation was Eisenhower.
Biden ..and most recent presidnets have had little if any military experience. They have to listen to the pros.
In fact, I maintain the when the POTUS tries to play soldier, bad things happen. The White House micromanging military operations has never turned out well. I give you LBJ as a prime example.
 
I think it is important we find out what went wrong with the withdrawal from Afghanistan.
I know you think the whole thing is unimportant, I could not disagree more and find your desire to sweep this under the rug not a good idea.
We need to find out who borched up the on the ground withdrawal/evacuation and get rid of them.

You misunderstood me. I'm in favor of them looking into it.

My comment was just that we should be able to do that on Trump's coup attempt.
 
There is bipartisan support for hearings on the whole mess of the Afghan withdrawal. A number of Democrats are asking some pretty tough questions.
I hope they leave aside the partisan bickering for a little bit, long enough to find out exactly what happened,particulary in the horrible intelligence failure, and then get rid of the people responsible.

What would you like to see accomplished with said hearings?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom