Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think it is important we find out what went wrong with the withdrawal from Afghanistan.
I know you think the whole thing is unimportant, I could not disagree more and find your desire to sweep this under the rug not a good idea.
We need to find out who borched up the on the ground withdrawal/evacuation and get rid of them.

I think it is worth finding out, but we do need a good idea of what would have been preferable and attainable.

My gut says an intelligence failure underestimating Afghani government forces' ability and willingness to slow the Taliban's advance--that we planned around them buying us some time and successfully holding a portion of the country. But I'll wait for more information to emerge, and I do think we should seek it, learn lessons from it. Honestly I want that more than I want to find scapegoats.

When was the last time one of our "wars" closed in anything but a deadly mess? Speaking from the US, we're not good at this and we should be more reluctant to get into these things in the first place.
 
Last edited:
Last POTUS who was qualified to command Ground Troops in a operation was Eisenhower.
Biden ..and most recent presidnets have had little if any military experience. They have to listen to the pros.
In fact, I maintain the when the POTUS tries to play soldier, bad things happen. The White House micromanging military operations has never turned out well. I give you LBJ as a prime example.

I agree.

But I maintain that LBJ got bad advice from Westmoreland. In fact I'm convinced that Westmoreland flat out lied to LBJ. Not sure who I despise more, Westmoreland or McNamara.
 
They will just do something on the order of running an ad where Biden says no Vietnam style helicopter evac, then show the helicopter taking off form our embassy. Whose mind will that change? The low information voters. Most of which will vote GOP anyways. But as we all know, Trump/GOP candidate doesn't need to pick up several million vote, they need a few thousand in a few key states.

The odds of Trump winning in 2024 just got a bit higher. (I just puked in my mouth a bit)... OTOH had Biden reneged and the shooting started again, they'd run ads on how the dems are the real warmongers.
A little blib in Biden popularity. Afghanistan is forgotten by 2024. Biden was unpatriotic to Trump voters no matter what, so no change there. Independents on the other hand...
 
I think it is important we find out what went wrong with the withdrawal from Afghanistan.
I know you think the whole thing is unimportant, I could not disagree more and find your desire to sweep this under the rug not a good idea.
We need to find out who borched up the on the ground withdrawal/evacuation and get rid of them.

It's not even over yet. Other than the optics on the news and per the GOP (expected per usual), do you know what could have been done better?

Someone on the news today said we should take in a million Afghan refugees. No way that's going to happen.

I'm still waiting to see what happens.
 
He could have reversed course? If it couldn't be done in twenty years, what makes you think it could be done in 21? I agree with you the military generals are not a bunch of cowboys. Nevertheless they had two decades to plan an exit strategy.

This failure was baked in the cake. My guess is the generals knew twenty years ago that this is the way this would end.

Blaming Biden is kind of absurd even though as CINC he's ultimately responsible. Sure Biden could have reversed course and left the troops in Afghanistan for the next eight years and we could blame the next POTUS.

1. This was either an impossible mission.
or
2. The military/civilian leadership for two decades failed.

I see this like I see America's approach to the homeless. A total lack of will to address the problem. What the US did in Afghanistan for two decades was manage the situation but did nothing to address solving the situation.

As far as the military are concerned the pull out was a complete success. They got out with no casualties.
 
That in my mind is a failure of the military leadership. POTUS doesn't tell them how to withdraw. Only to get it done.

As far ad they will be concerned they got out with no casualties. What happens next is up to the politicians.
 
It's not even over yet. Other than the optics on the news and per the GOP (expected per usual), do you know what could have been done better?

Someone on the news today said we should take in a million Afghan refugees. No way that's going to happen.

I'm still waiting to see what happens.

FOr the record, Democratic congressman are also asking some pretty tough questions.
 
There would have been numerous, probably very long discussions about this in the Oval and/or situation room.

If the President had no more input to offer than "just get it done" that's an even more enormous failure than I had already envisioned.

In one of the Trump threads, the difference between a "boss" and a "leader" was discussed. Your version makes Biden sound like a "boss", totally disinterested in the how and why of it.

I agree. Biden didn't just say 'get it down'. Nothing about him indicates that mindset.
 
As far as the military are concerned the pull out was a complete success. They got out with no casualties.

A. They are not out yet, and won't be for a while.
B. Then there are the Afghans who worked with US Troops and whom Biden promised would be gotten out.
I know the idea of a nations promise does not mean much to you, given your attitude that the UK should just turn over the Falklands to Argentina regardless of what the occupants want but it means something to me.
 
C'mon, Presidents aren't Generals with military expertise. The idea that they know how to withdraw from a military engagement is like suggesting they know how to battle a virus. The President does have meetings on these subjects, it still is always up to others on how to do it and execute that plan.

Which they would have discussed with Biden. Just as the medical experts discuss things with him about Covid. That's why they're called advisors.
 
Last POTUS who was qualified to command Ground Troops in a operation was Eisenhower.
Biden ..and most recent presidnets have had little if any military experience. They have to listen to the pros.
In fact, I maintain the when the POTUS tries to play soldier, bad things happen. The White House micromanging military operations has never turned out well. I give you LBJ as a prime example.

No one is suggesting that he micromanaged them, but to think he was not advised on what the plans were and that he didn't have questions about and input to them is just not realistic.
 
Last POTUS who was qualified to command Ground Troops in a operation was Eisenhower.

Biden ..and most recent presidnets have had little if any military experience. They have to listen to the pros.

In fact, I maintain the when the POTUS tries to play soldier, bad things happen. The White House micromanging military operations has never turned out well. I give you LBJ as a prime example.

One of the major reasons he was picked as VP to Obama was precisely for his foreign policy credentials. He was Chair or ranking member of the U.S. Senate Foreign Relations Committee for 12 years.

He is described as having a "leading role" in the withdrawal from Iraq.

This attempt to go the "plausible deniability" route is a total farce.

Uh, I hate to break it to you but...this hasn't turned out well. You've kinda sunk your own battleship with that one.
 
Last edited:
No one is suggesting that he micromanaged them, but to think he was not advised on what the plans were and that he didn't have questions about and input to them is just not realistic.

Biden or LBJ? LBJ certainly micromanged operations from the White House.
 
Biden or LBJ? LBJ certainly micromanged operations from the White House.

Did he?

You never addressed my comments about General Westmoreland who ran Vietnam operations from 1964 to 1968. His war of attrition and pressure to expand operations to Laos and Cambodia were a human rights and military disaster.

And by the way, Nixon was just as involved.
 
Last edited:
FOr one thing, find out about the huge intelligence failure concering the speed with which the Taliaban won. There is no excuse for that.
And had it taken longer more refugees could have gotten out I presume?

Do they have any country to go to?


Personally I'd like to see more of the people in danger getting out, especially more women. It looks like a sea of men at the airport. Should those men let women and children leave first?


And when we bring thousands into this country, you know the GOP are going to complain very loudly.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom