gnome
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Aug 5, 2001
- Messages
- 14,914
I think it is important we find out what went wrong with the withdrawal from Afghanistan.
I know you think the whole thing is unimportant, I could not disagree more and find your desire to sweep this under the rug not a good idea.
We need to find out who borched up the on the ground withdrawal/evacuation and get rid of them.
I think it is worth finding out, but we do need a good idea of what would have been preferable and attainable.
My gut says an intelligence failure underestimating Afghani government forces' ability and willingness to slow the Taliban's advance--that we planned around them buying us some time and successfully holding a portion of the country. But I'll wait for more information to emerge, and I do think we should seek it, learn lessons from it. Honestly I want that more than I want to find scapegoats.
When was the last time one of our "wars" closed in anything but a deadly mess? Speaking from the US, we're not good at this and we should be more reluctant to get into these things in the first place.
Last edited: