Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well, let’s face it: some of the statements made by Biden were stupid, but I am rethinking this a bit and concluding that there were no good options for him. Trump left a steaming pile on his desk when he left. Do you take all the professional people with you from Afghanistan and make a Taliban takeover inevitable? Or do you hope the country can stand on its own two feet as you might imagine twenty years of support should allow it to. Moving the deadline by another two months or so only moves the needle one way or the other between the two ends of either saving everyone or dooming then country with a brain drain.
 
A few more months would probably have allowed a lot more Afghanis to have gotten out.
But your contempt for the Militaryis noted,
And that is a major reason I am not a "Progressive". They seem to have a total contempt for the militray, equaled only by an ignorance about it.

Biden messed up badly here, and the people trying to ignore this fact are begining to sound like the Trumpers denying that Donnie every made a mistake.

The military work with the demands dropped on them as best they can. They have no control over the demands, only how they might deal with such demands.

Sarajevo is a classic example. Go in and keep things peaceful but you are not allowed to use your weapons. Once the insurgents in whichever theatre realise that troops are not allowed to shoot back, they do not care anymore.
 
I nominate dudalb.

I nominate dudalb for the following post:
A few more months would probably have allowed a lot more Afghanis to have gotten out.
But your contempt for the Militaryis noted,
And that is a major reason I am not a "Progressive". They seem to have a total contempt for the militray, equaled only by an ignorance about it.

Biden messed up badly here, and the people trying to ignore this fact are begining to sound like the Trumpers denying that Donnie every made a mistake.

Where in the ever loving **** do you constantly grab “contempt for the military” out of your ass every time anyone suggests that the US might be making mistakes and should not expose its military to stupid dangers?”

ETA, just commenting on the noted phrase
 
Last edited:
The issue here is not withdrawal, which was probably inevitable, but the way it was carried out..which was horribly.
 
The issue here is not withdrawal, which was probably inevitable, but the way it was carried out..which was horribly.

The military had an entire year to plan for this. Actually twenty. Which leads to the question, was this the fault of Biden or the incompetence of the military leaders?
 
The military had an entire year to plan for this. Actually twenty. Which leads to the question, was this the fault of Biden or the incompetence of the military leaders?

I don't think any of them, including Biden, are free of blame. It's a matter of degree of responsibility.
 
Trump 6-26-2021:

"I started the process. All the troops are coming back home. They couldn't stop the process. 21 years is enough. Don't we think? 21 years. Biden admin couldn't stop the process. They wanted to, but it was very tough to stop."
 
I don't think any of them, including Biden, are free of blame. It's a matter of degree of responsibility.

Biden is CINC so he is ultimately responsible. But this is something I agree with Trump on. 21 years is enough.
 
There's no reason why it should take years. As some commentators are observing, the U.S. has biometric databases of everybody who worked for us, and the Taliban is using that captured information to look for those people. It would have been easy for the U.S. to say "If we can identify you in our database, we'll take you and your family to Guam and process your visa there."

Things like that take congressional Approval. I think it was only last year Congress approved that third party countries could host them while visas were processed.
 
The military had an entire year to plan for this. Actually twenty. Which leads to the question, was this the fault of Biden or the incompetence of the military leaders?

Biden was just following orders.

This was just a game of musical chairs, and ol' Joe got caught out. From the perspective of self-centered Americans, this was not a huge propaganda win for the Taliban as much as it was a huge propaganda win for the Republican Party. They're going to say Democrats "lost it for us" in Afghanistan when Biden executed a policy in place by Trump, itself a response to a mostly hopeless situation. Biden apologists are now desperately trying to blame Trump (see above) for a policy Biden executed (and made assurances that what's happening was not going to happen). The optics of the 20th anniversary of 9/11 will not good for Democrats, and this will be another symbolic issue for Republicans to hammer.
 
Things like that take congressional Approval. I think it was only last year Congress approved that third party countries could host them while visas were processed.

Guam is part of the United States, and it was used to process Vietnamese refugees in the '70s. That's why it was proposed.
 
I earlier said that a lot of people won't like the idea of thousands of Muslims being allowed to settle in the US. Stephen Miller tweeted:

Stephen Miller
@StephenM
·
21h
It is becoming increasingly clear that Biden & his radical deputies will use their catastrophic debacle in Afghanistan as a pretext for doing to America what Angela Merkel did to Germany & Europe.


Stephen Miller
@StephenM
·
21h
See below. The Biden team wants to grow this number far beyond this initial group and into the many hundreds of thousands.
Quote Tweet
Mai El-Sadany
@maitelsadany
· Aug 15
DMV Friends: 2,500 Afghans are expected to arrive and be resettled in the next few weeks. Lutheran Social Services (National Capital Area) has put out a call for those willing to assist in resettlement with their time, donations, and efforts.
Stephen Miller
@StephenM
·
19h
Humane refugee policy emphasizes relocation as close to home as possible, maximizing finite resources & enabling possible return when conditions allow. Those rejecting regional resettlement strategies in favor of mass US resettlement have a political, not humanitarian, objective.
 
The military had an entire year to plan for this. Actually twenty. Which leads to the question, was this the fault of Biden or the incompetence of the military leaders?

I think a better question is what could have been done by delaying even longer that wasn't done since the May 1 delay.
 
And so me, Like Biden, state they don't think the law allows them to do that anymore.


Not everyone agrees.
Facts First: Biden's "the law doesn't allow that to happen" claim is dubious. According to multiple experts in immigration law, there is a law that allows the Biden administration to bring Afghans who worked with American troops to the US before their visas are finalized. Specifically, these experts say, the Department of Homeland Security has the legal authority to grant these Afghans immigration "parole," under which they could enter the US while their applications are still being assessed. The US already has parole programs for designated population groups from other countries.

Federal parole law says that the Secretary of Homeland Security has the authority to grant parole for "urgent humanitarian reasons or significant public benefit" to "any individual applying for admission to the United States," though "only on a case-by-case basis."
https://www.cnn.com/2021/07/14/poli...hanistan-siv-visas-law-parole-guam/index.html
 
Surely Stephen Miller doesn't speak for most Americans. And why are you focusing on Muslims? Over three million Muslims already live in the U.S., including veterans of the U.S. armed forces and members of Congress.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islam_in_the_United_States

One, I didn't say he spoke for most Americans. Two, his tweets are an example of the anti-Muslim sentiment many in this country harbor. He was referring to Muslims when he mentioned Angela Merkel and Germany. Three, there are millions of Black and Hispanic people in this country, many of them veterans of the U. S. Armed Forces and members of Congress and look at the racism directed toward them. Look at the boldness of the white supremacists here. They don't even try to hide it.
A cache of documents obtained and published by the investigative research organization Documented appears to show anti-Muslim hate group leaders such as Brigitte Gabriel, Frank Gaffney and others who have stoked Islamophobia are involved with the Council for National Policy, or CNP. The documents also reveal that the coalition has promoted policies championed by the broader anti-Muslim network.
https://www.splcenter.org/hatewatch...amophobic-figures-policies-presents-challenge

Across the United States, mosques are vandalized, local government officials denounce Islam, and state legislatures debate anti-Muslim laws. Such anti-Muslim activities have increased markedly since late 2015. This project documents that increase by cataloguing 763 separate incidents from 2012 to 2018. The incidents, sorted into six categories (listed below), are compiled in an interactive graph and in maps showing their geographic distribution in absolute numbers as well as per capita. They are also collated in a searchable database.
https://www.newamerica.org/in-depth/anti-muslim-activity/
 
One, I didn't say he spoke for most Americans. Two, his tweets are an example of the anti-Muslim sentiment many in this country harbor. He was referring to Muslims when he mentioned Angela Merkel and Germany. Three, there are millions of Black and Hispanic people in this country, many of them veterans of the U. S. Armed Forces and members of Congress and look at the racism directed toward them. Look at the boldness of the white supremacists here. They don't even try to hide it.
....

What racist extremists want can't be the basis for national policy.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom